A screenwriting and television writing professor at Emerson College tells me that the strike is giving film school students ”much food for thought”. Sounds more like E-coli to me. That’s because “as every day passes, many of them are quite cognizant of the creative and economic opportunities the strike might afford them personally,” the instuctor says. ”My students have asked me questions ranging from ‘How do I cross the picket line when my internship requires me to be at work but my sympathies are with the writers?’ to ‘How do I get my material read so I can get hired while the writers are on strike?’” I’m also told by other sources that the USC film writing students are warned by professors not to scab or use pickets for networking. Yet many opportunistic students are attempting both (“luckily, not the talented ones”). All I can say is, What little shits.
Sounds Like They Need A Class In Ethics
By NIKKI FINKE | Friday November 9, 2007 @ 1:58am PSTTags: Writers, Writers Strike
This article was printed from http://www.deadline.com/2007/11/maybe-they-need-a-class-in-ethics/
COMMENTS (48)
-
SUBSCRIBE TO DEADLINE NEWS
-
Marketplace
-
Two Weeks of Posts Comments 1 Paula Abdul Won’t Return To ‘X Factor’ In 273 2 RECORD-BREAKING WEEKEND! 4 Films Open $20+M: ‘The 176 3 Why Actors Hate Agents At Pilot Season… 161 4 ‘Chronicle’ Tackles ‘Woman In Black’ For 121 5 SAG-AFTRA: Exclusive Post-Merger Details 120 ‘New Girl’ Music Video
News/Opinion Poll
Loading ...By The Numbers
Title Studio Gross 1 Chronicle FOX $22.0M 2 The Woman In Black CBS $20.9M 3 The Grey OPRD $9.3M 4 Big Miracle UNI $7.8M 5 Underworld: Awake... SNY $5.5M 6 One For The Money LGF $5.2M 7 Red Tails FOX $4.7M 8 The Descendants FSL $4.6M 9 Man On A Ledge SMT $4.4M 10 Extremely Loud & WB $3.8M 11 Contraband UNI $3.4M 12 The Artist TWC $2.6M 13 Beauty And The Beast DIS $2.6M 14 Hugo PAR $2.3M 15 The Iron Lady TWC $1.9M 16 Mission: Impossible - PAR $1.7M 17 Joyful Noise WB $1.5M 18 Haywire REL $1.2M 19 Alvin And The FOX $1.0M 20 Sherlock Holmes: A WB $1.0M SOURCE: RENTRAKBox Office Poll
Loading ...Archives
- December 2011
- November 2011
- October 2011
- September 2011
- August 2011
- July 2011
- June 2011
- May 2011
- April 2011
- March 2011
- February 2011
- January 2011
- December 2010
- November 2010
- October 2010
- September 2010
- August 2010
- July 2010
- June 2010
- May 2010
- April 2010
- March 2010
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008
- February 2008
- January 2008
- December 2007
- November 2007
- October 2007
- September 2007
- August 2007
- July 2007
- June 2007
- May 2007
- April 2007
- March 2007
- February 2007
- January 2007
- December 2006
- November 2006
- October 2006
- September 2006
- August 2006
- July 2006
- June 2006
- May 2006
- April 2006
- March 2006

- Whitney Houston Interview: Talks 'Sparkle,' Aaliyah's Death And More In One Of Her Final Interviews
- BAFTA Awards 2012 Red Carpet: Michelle Williams, Viola Davis Meryl Streep And More (PHOTOS)
- BAFTA Rising Star Award: Hayley Atwell On Lack Of Female Nominees
- 'The Vow' Wins Box Office: Beats Out 'Safe House' And 'Star Wars' With $41.7 Million
- Whitney Houston Dies: Remembering Her Finest Onscreen Moment In 'The Bodyguard'


- Artist, Meryl Streep Win Big at BAFTA Awards
- Berlinale Dispatch: The Taviani Brothers — Who? — Return with a Great Shakespeare-in-Prison Movie
- Berlinale Dispatch: Greetings from the Baked Potato of Film Festivals, 62nd Edition!
- Summit and Lionsgate Hoping for Sixth Twilight Movie, Of Course
- REVIEW: Star Wars: Ep. I - The Phantom Menace Adds Stunning Third Dimension of Meh



And the magazine Creative Screenwriting is actively encouraging writers to write during the strike. The UCLA profs have it right, scabbing yourself is no way to break into a collaborative career in film or TV production.
Agreed. But the students do bring up a good point re: internships. I’m studying film/tv at NYU and I’m relying on internships for learning and work experience. With the strike going on, how else can I go about getting experience?
Well, Kenny, if you’re relying on internships for learning and work experience, I’m relying on work for paying the bills and advancing my career. Right now, you can’t get experience. I can’t get work. Welcome to the labor movement. We’re all hurting — you’re out some experience, and I’m out a mortgage payment.
“With the strike going on, how else can I go about getting experience?”
Uhm, Kenny, with a talent strike on, YOU DON’T.
I would have thought that the “food for thought” from the strike would have been this: if you want to be a writer, don’t bother with Hollywood, cuz you ain’t valued here. That seems to be the overall lesson.
I’m WGAE and a few of my writer friends have been giving me praise for standing up against the AMPTP, sticking it to the man, going for our fair share, etc… then, shockingly, the next words out of their mouth are, “do you think I can get a job more easily now that you guys are all on strike?” It devastates me that they actually have the balls to ask someone who is guild this question and not realize how horrific it is.
Putting it simply, scabs make Baby Jesus cry.
I fully agree about scabbing, but I don’t see the problem with going out to join the picket line. The writers’ strike is for the future of the industry. People who hope to be part of that future should help out too, in my opinion. How is that mercenary?
Scabbing for a guild you hope to be a part of one day is shameful and short-sighted. But I see no reason not to join the cause and support your favorite writers (or your least favorite writers). They are all more than happy to talk to anyone who joins them on the picket lines.
I teach film writing at USC and have gotten these same questions. I have told my students that they should go to their internships, but should make a point of stopping to explain to the strikers on the line why they’re entering the studio/network, maybe go early or stay late and walk the line, bring those ubiquitous baked goods, and otherwise show their support.
(Believe me, those of us on the line do realize that hundreds of people need to cross the line to go to work and we sympathize with them. We wish we could go into the studio to work too, and we will do so the minute the companies have presented an offer fair enough for us to agree to.)
I have also told my class that any of my students who scab (proved) gets an F for the semester.
““With the strike going on, how else can I go about getting experience?”
Uhm, Kenny, with a talent strike on, YOU DON’T.
Comment by WrteStufLA — November 9, 2007 @ 3:06 am
”
Oh my God, you killed Kenny! You Bastards!
Sounds to me like that professor should be out of a job, because if he advises his students to take advantage of this strike, then he is teaching them how to ruin their future careers. Not the kind of thing you should be teaching your students.
In answer to Walk the Line up above, there is nothing wrong with encouraging developing writers to keep writing. The strike does not prohibit people from writing. I know plenty of WGA writers who will continue writing specs during the strike. It simply prohibits people from submitting those scripts to struck companies, or working on projects for them.
As an Emerson graduate I am disgusted. I can only hope this represents the minority of students.
I posted this point elsewhere but I’ll say it again:
If you complain about non-union scab writers taking your jobs during this strike (and you should), then you’d better not be applying for ‘story producer’ jobs on all the non-Guild reality shows that’ll be cropping up soon.
I’ve worked on three reality show in the past six years and EVERY one had WGA members working on them for the same lousy pay I got.
As an Emerson College graduate, I am disgusted and I have just one thing to say: Don’t look to me, Kid, to donate the money I earn writing to your scholarship fund. Maybe when you have to work for your money you’ll understand why this is so important.
I’m a film student and an aspiring screenwriter who supports the strike 100%. I’m astonished there are students out there failing to grasp why the strike is happening and how it affects them. As far as I’m concerned, writers, fans and future-writers are all as one. My only regret is I’m in London so I can’t join the picket lines.
has anyone else has been approached by a studio executive in regards to going on a strike breaker list? i got a call a few weeks before the strike about going on the list. i refused, but i wonder if there really is a list.
As someone who’s already been asked — in a roundabout way — to scab (and yes, I turned them down), the idea that film students and kids new to LA and NYC are going to be courted by unscrupulous producers is an easy one to grasp. I am sure that few of them are aware of the possible repercussions and are naive enough to take producers at their word. The WGA needs to talk to the heads of all the local schools — at least in LA (USC, UCLA, LMU, AFI, etc.) — and make sure that the word gets out that this could really come back to bite them in the ass. If these students are as naive as I was when I first moved to LA — and as arrogant — they’re easy pickin’s for the predatory.
Here’s how the youngsters can respect the strike and still build their careers – join the picket line. It’s a great opportunity to shmooze potential future employers/mentors and make valuable connections for when the strike is over.
It’s nice to know that my alma mater’s late leaning towards annoying money-laden kids is going to just really help my resume a ton after this is all over. Thanks, you opportunistic jerks.
Scab writers are to the WGA as mob doctors are to the AMA.
Scab writers seek opportunities during strikes, because they can’t compete based on their ABILITY. Their only talent is their availABILITY.
It’s bizarre that the same people who call themselves conservatives or supporters of the free market and claim a union protects its members from having to compete based on quality are also the same people that would encourage scab writers who can’t compete based on quality when there isn’t a strike.
I’m a recent USC grad, not yet a Guild member, who went to the picket lines for one reason – to support the collective of writers that I hope to be a part of someday. I wasn’t asking for business cards, or even last names for that matter. The mood on the picket line seemed to be that everyone is equal and fighting for the same ideas.
So I don’t want people to get the idea from this blog that USC students going to support the picket lines are necessarily “opportunistic” or “little shits.” We’re fighting for our futures, too.
@ Kenny -
As long as your internship doesn’t require you writing scripts (or working with Scab writers) keep going. You aren’t in a union and you’re not undermining them by answering phones or whatever your internship has you doing.
A lot of us who work in Development are very sympathetic and supportive of the writers, but would get fired very quickly if we refused to show for work as a show of solidarity. (There’s no develompent guild to protect us).
Wish them luck, buy them some donuts, and go to your internship. It’s part of your education.
>>>”What little shits”<<<<
Seriously? Seriously????
Tisk…tisk, Nikki!
In my opinion, those “little shits” are going to save this damn industry. We know it, and the reason we want “in” (aka scab) is because some folks in H-town think they’re doing a good job. As a recent Emerson grad, I’ve seen this Hollywood catastrophe on the horizon for the past 5 years! Why do you think I’m here now!? Why do you think all of my friends are here NOW in force!? Why do all of you millionaire writers, directors, producer, think you’re so smart? Well, stop and think! Isn’t this the obvious channel for new blood to enter Hollywood.
I bet the thought never occurred to ask those “little shits”, who btw were posting videos on youtube before they knew to sell us out to Google, what the New Deal is? Have we not grown up with Internet and new media our entire lives?
But noooo, you stick us in little cramp offices, you pay us shit, and then steal our ideas right from under us (then, feed us the line: “It’s all about paying your dues, kid.”) Yeah, that’s really fair! Everyone wants “fair”, but no one is willing to point the finger at themselves first. When this Internet/new media battle hits the fan, and us poor little scabs with no mortgages, private school bills, or hummers… seem to be doing alright with the strike….
Yeah, I feel really bad.
You know some of us want to do this the right way. But I guess in the eyes of others it easier to look at something new and call it shit. You know, I can hear you writers out side the studio now.
P.S. We don’t want to scab, we want to work.
Flame away —
Gen Y – Wannabe
I’m wondering how does the average person who is watching/reading this and lives in the LA area and understands that this is a bigger concern in the entire labor movement, how to help and support the writer’s efforts. If you look to the recent labor negotitations in the LA area alone: supermarket workers, public enforcement, Longshoremen, hotel workers et al., then you have to look to how the “trickling effect” is not working and this is a sign of the times and of things to come and thus a fight all should likewise be concerned.
I’m a screenwriting student at USC. It’s a tiny program, and I know not a single student who has expressed interest in scab writing. I do however, know of many trips planned in the coming week to join the picket line with snacks, etc. As for internships, especially the paid ones: if the WGA strike fund is going to pay my rent and school fees during the strike, then I’d be happy to quit. Give me a break.