I’m receiving a lot of reports of TV showrunners and hyphenates choosing not to work on their shows during the WGA strike. I’ll update this post with names as I receive them. But here is an email sent around this morning by Shawn Ryan, the showrunner of The Shield, The Unit, and The Oaks and also a member of the WGA Negotiating Committee, explaining to fellow showrunners and TV writers what decision he’s reached and why:
“As you all know by now, we are on Strike. It’s sad that we have arrived here and I don’t know each and every one of your opinions, but I wanted to share my personal plans for what I intend to do until we have a fair contract.
I am currently quoted in today’s Hollywood Reporter as saying that I will do some producing work, but won’t do any editing as I consider that to be writing. While I said something similar to that earlier last week (I’ve learned you can’t trust a word of what these trades report), that was before I went to the Showrunners Meeting yesterday and became very crystalized in what I need to do. Like many of you I have spent the last week contemplating what to do in case of a strike. What are my responsibilities to my writers, my cast, my crew, my network and my contract? How do I balance these various concerns?
At the Showrunners Meeting it became very clear to me that the only thing I can do as a showrunner is to do nothing. I obviously will not write on my shows. But I also will not edit, I will not cast, I will not look at location photos, I will not get on the phone with the network and studio, I will not prep directors, I will not review mixes. These are all acts that are about the writing of the show or protecting the writing of the show, and as such, I will not participate in them. I will also not ask any of my writer/producers to do any of these things for me, so that they get done, but I can save face.
I will not go into the office and I will not do any work at home. I will be on the picket line or I will be working with the Negotiating Committee. I will not have an avid sent to my house, or to a new office so that I can do work on my show and act as if it is all right because I’m not crossing any picket lines.
I truly believe that the best and fastest way to a good contract is to hit these companies early, to hit them hard and to deprive them of ALL the work we do on their behalf.
How do we ask our staff writers to go out on strike as we continue collecting producer checks? How do we ask the Teamsters to respect our picket lines if we won’t ourselves or if we’re sneaking around to do the work off-site?
Just so you all know what I am prepared to give up….
Tomorrow, we begin to film the Series Finale of The Shield. I think it’s the best script our writing staff has ever written. This is the show that made me. This is the show that is my baby. If the strike goes on longer than two weeks, I won’t be able to step on set for the final episode of the show. I won’t have a writer on set, as I have had on every episode since the fourth episode. I won’t be able to edit this final culminating episode. I won’t go to the wrap party that Fox TV and FX are paying for. You can’t tell me that any episode of television is more important than this one is to me, and I am ready to forego all those things in order to strengthen my union.
Tomorrow, we begin filming a new pilot, The Oaks, that I am Executive Producing. It’s an amazing script that David Schulner wrote and I signed up to help him make this show. Until we have a fair deal I cannot do that now and it kills me.
We are currently filming Season 3 of The Unit, a show that does fairly well, but against House and Dancing With The Stars, usually finishes in 3rd place. We have no guarantee that we will back for a 4th season. I just gave a director friend of mine his first TV directing gig. I’d like to see him succeed. He’ll have to finish the show on his own now without a writer on set, or my help in the editing room.
Some people have made the argument that if they don’t do this producing work or this editing, that someone else will do it, and this act won’t hurt the companies. I respectfully disagree. If we ALL stop ALL work tomorrow, the impact of this strike will be felt much more quickly, much more acutely and it most likely will end sooner, putting our writers, our cast and our crews back to work sooner!
I spent nearly 12 hours today in the Negotiation Room with the companies. I watched our side desperately try to make a deal. We gave up our request to increase revenue on DVD’s, something that was very painful to give up, but something we felt we had to in order to get a deal made in new media, which is our future.
I watched as the company’s representatives treated us horrendously, disrespectfully, and then walked out on us at 9:30 and then lied to the trades, claiming we had broken off negotiations.
I can’t in good conscience fight these bastards with one hand, while operating an avid with the other. I am on strike and I am not working for them. PERIOD.
You will use your own instincts and consciences to decide your own actions. But if you would like to follow in my footsteps (and those of many, many others who made this pledge at the showrunner’s meating on Saturday), I encourage you to sign the trade ad that the WGA will be putting out on Tuesday by the dozens and dozens of showrunners who will simply not work at all beginning in the morning.”






How awesome is this guy and the others doing the same? I was really disappointed to hear that the dvd residuals element was given up, but it certainly shows how the guild is doing everything it can to make a deal. There is no way for the studios to defend themselves as they try to horde revenues from new media. They wanted a strike. It’s plain to see. The studios have a master plan here. Their strategy: Squeeze and wait, then squeeze and wait some more.
Shawn, there are showrunners with far, far less to lose still shooting their shows this morning. I applaud your courage in showing those hypocrites and pussies how to take a stand. It’s sickening knowing they are crossing the picket line to cash more producer checks when so many of us, as well as actors and teamsters are standing there with signs in our hands. Let’s picket THESE GUYS. WGA, list the active set locations and let us look these showrunners in the eye. They are cowards and company men.
That so many are willing to risk so much should show everyone just what’s at stake.
Big business will not give the worker that which they cannot take. That’s why this strike is so important.
I think he is breaking his contract and dishonoring the other people that work with him. I understand striking on the writing parts but to not fufill the rest of his contract is wrong
He’s a cool dude.
I wish the media would start quoting him and stop quoting that blowhard Mazin, who’s doing the cause more harm than good with his infighting and whining about how rich he is.
Mr. Ryan didn’t mention whether he’ll lose his house. My crew friends on his various shows have not been talked to by him about how long they’re working–or not.
I am an actor on The Unit and I stand behind Shawn Ryan and The WGA.
SCOTT FOLEY
Julius Fort– that argument is getting so tired. There’s no job security in production. Ever. Your show gets canceled, moves to Vancouver, whatever. It’s really disingenuous to act as though people working in production, no matter their job title, have corporate-America-style job security, whether their showrunner is on strike or not.
Julius, your crew friends wouldn’t have jobs at all if it wasn’t for Mr. Ryan and his commitment to produce his shows in L.A.
No he isn’t. This is called resisting temptation because it is too easy to edit something and make it into the final cut than to simply sit on the sidelines. All the showrunners that are working today should be considered scabs and they should be stripped of WGA membership ASAP.
Wow, big talk tough guy, fight the “bastards” that have made you a rich man who’ll never need to work another day in his life…while working Hollywood will be hurt and hurt hard. I’ll remember your pain as I’m evicted from my apartment. How people fall for this “let’s fight the bastards” mentality, as if these were coal miners in Appalachia fighting for a living wage, is beyond me. Both sides are wealthy, powerful, selfish & greedy and simply (and ruthlessly) protecting their own interests and f*** any collateral damage…nothing more, nothing less.
Actually crew members do have everything to lose, as they won’t get residuals while they are out like us. True there is no job security per se, but there is always another job, another show, whatever.
Now there will be nothing.
Please, don’t start talking like this won’t affect the people who work so hard on “your” shows for an hourly wage.
As for corporate style job security, my Father’s company laid him off when he was 55. There is no job security, anywhere, just new jobs.
Wait there aren’t ANY jobs now are there? Unless you are thinking very very hard while you are walking the line.
Mr. Ryan wouldn’t be able to produce his shows without a studio giving him millions and millions of dollers.
While hes not making his wrap party, i’m not gonna be making my rent.
Who gave anyone the right to ditch the DVD residual demand so early? You don’t give into a bully.
This is why I was worried when I heard John Welles had entered the scene.
It truly hurts my heart to see how this impacts everyone. Yes, I’m worried about paying my bills and keeping my clients working. And I can’t stand the idea that production may shut down even sooner if showrunners really do not cross picket lines and render their so-called producing services. But Shawn Ryan has expressed the pain of watching something he created come to an end without him in such a way that, among other things, reminds me of why certain individuals become writers in the first place —
I want to stand firm, and I want to be supportive. So I ask the WGA to please go back to the table, kicking and screaming if necessary, and find a way to make this end quickly.
And, lest I forget, thank you to all the writers and artists who bring the rest of us a way to be a part of this business which means so much to us.
Awesome letter. Awesome leadership.
John Bowman made his position clear at last Thursday’s meeting.
Shawn Ryan does so today.
Now we must demand other showrunners to do the same — particularly those in the WGA leadership.
To “support” the union and the strike when the WGA membership is watching while privately kowtowing to the studio by producing and editing off-site or at home is hypocrisy. Showrunners who do this will divide the WGA and undermine our efforts to extend the residual system to the internet and other new media.
Showrunners are generals in this battle, particularly those in guild leadership. If they are not willing to follow the example set by Bowman and Ryan and, soon, many others, they should state this openly and cross their own union’s picket lines to provide those services they believe they owe.
I don’t think it’s enough to follow your conscience. It’s time to state publicly where your conscience leads you and become an example to the Teamsters, SAG members and less privileged WGA members whom you are asking to stand with you in this fight.
Shawn rules: This is the only way to be effective.
Kudos, man. Hopefully, ALL others will follow. My showrunner is doing the same… and picketing with the rest of us today.
Way to go, Shawn.
They’d have children working in coalmines if they thought they could get away with it.
By the way, I stand behind the crews that make my movies. Comments that somehow describe “doing the right thing” and “caring about the people a strike puts at risk” as mutually exclusive are respectfully, mistaken. This anger is misplaced.
Ask the studios to be transparent with their accounting. They’ve been cooking the books for generations. Know anyone who has EVER received net profits?? I don’t.
We appreciate our crewmembers support. All the people this affects across country are the backbone of our power. We as WGA members understand this completely. We have to live with this pressure and responsibility in addition to not working.
The producers have clearly forced this strike. Refusing to negotiate is well, not negotiating. That is a defacto strike; it’s a lock out.
It is as simple as this: The Internet is the new delivery system of our work. It’s no different than VHS was twenty years ago and broadcast television 30 years before that.
The intellectual property has not changed nor unfortunately the appetite to exploit it.
Best,
Todd Robinson
in support of Julius – sure, production jobs are fickle. but if your show gets canceled, you move on to ANOTHER one. what if there is not another show to move onto? the argument is not tired.
while i am in full support of writers getting what they deserve in DVD and New Media – the studios are a bunch of A-holes for trying to cut them out of that. but the studios should start cutting above the line costs in the first place to save money. above the line costs can be around a third of a TV show’s 3 million dollar budget. do we REALLY need 10-12 writers writing 22 episodes? if you’re a writer/producer(as almost all are), you write what?? two episodes a year? and for the rest of the episodes you ‘break stories’ and ‘cut for time?’ is that really worth your enormous producer fee? what do you produce?
here’s what should happen. the studios should say sure, you can have your four cents on DVD and new media. but, showrunners… pick your five best writers. cause now it’s you and them. sure, those five writers will still get their producer fees. AND they will be writing more like FOUR episodes year… getting paid MORE for writing MORE scripts, AND making MORE on residuals. plus, they will actually put some hours in and WORK. picketing four days a week for four hours a day?? how will they be able to handle that? WGA, are they getting OT for that?
of course, this puts writers out of work. but to have 10-12 writers on a show that MAYBE makes 22 episodes a year is ridiculous. i also can’t help to think that only having 5 or 6 writers on a series will make the storylines more cohesive and engaging– as opposed to throwing away story arcs and characters like parking tickets.
Shawn Ryan is my hero!
rock on. I’m in awe of his clarity.
I just spent the morning on the line… Im taking a break and going back out there. He’s exactly the kind of man who will help resolve this quickly! Any showrunner who does his post is hurting people rather than helping.
Just a question – SAG and DGA contracts aren’t up for renegotiation yet but the WGA strike is going to impact everyone and i don’t know many actors or directors who oppose the writers strike, so why don’t actors and directors as well as writers and teamsters strike together?
It may help alleviate some of the arrogance of the companies and bring the strike to an end sooner. It may also help foster creative integrity as the companies will see who’s in control when they loose all their talent.
sorry if this is overly simplistic or ignorant or both. i just don’t understand.
I hope the studios will sue his a** for not doing the job(s) he is contracted for. It’s alright for the WRITERS to strike but what they really try to do is to sabotage all parts of the show creating process. Maybe because the WRITING alone isn’t as important as they try to make us believe.
Off topic for the article but on topic for the comments:
The reason giving up the DVD residual increase was a good idea for the WGA is that it forced the AMPTP to hold fast on Internet distribution, whereas previously the AMPTP had pretended it earned needed revenue from DVD’s and didn’t make anything from Internet distribution. The reality is that DVD’s will be replaced by streaming media faster than has been predicted, and that ad revenue from streaming media will increase by leaps and bounds.
Wow!! The Shield (22 Episodes), The Unit ( 22 Episode) at a Minimum of $30K per episode for producing, that’s $1.32mil. Add maybe 10 script fees at $30K + 5 directing fees at $30K, that’s another $450K. I’m sure he would give it all up in order to regain creative control of his final episode. Sure he would.
First off, I support the writers and the strike and believe that Mr. Ryan has the right to voice his opinion. While it is his right to take the stance he has chosen, the WGA does not govern the entire business and if a writer wants to also be a producer, than they should have the option to continue their producing duties without fear of retribution or intimidation from the WGA. This strike is currently just a writers strike; yes it is implications for most of us that work in the business and for the other unions that will soon be in the same position, but for now it is just the writers that have walked out. The WGA has a very difficult battle ahead of them and to attempt to shut down all aspects of production for the sake of one union and make it not an individual choice of the writer/producer but a flagrant demand is wreckless and selfish and will hit the rest of the business hard, not the intended studios. These are not the studios of 1988. These are multi-billion dollar corporations and conglomerates. They will not be “hit hard and fast” as Mr. Ryan hopes. They have content stockpiled and they do not care about the quality of the programming they fill the timeslots with in the interim. These studios are no longer creative forces, they are just forces and they currently hold the power. While I have heard that many writer/producers are choosing to walk the picket line and not cross it, there are others that see fit to walk the picket line and continue to do the other duties that they signed on for. Producers, editors, grips, production staff and all of the people writers rely on to make their words come to life are not currently on strike. While they may support the strike and the writers, they should not be forced to put their tools down arbitrarily while there is still work to be done.
Technically Mr. Ryan is correct that for scripted productions, writing is tied every aspect of production, from the stage or location shoot to the final audio layback and delivery of the show. But technically speaking, the writers (not producers) job is done when shooting is wrapped. Then the show/film falls into the hands of the other people that make up this business, including those that signed contracts to write and produce. Yes, our showrunners may “protect” the script while in the edit bay, but what they are doing is editing, not writing. When they are on a mix stage they are creating sound and enhancing their scripts, but still not writing. I understand that inevitably everything goes back to the script in some way, but to use this as an excuse to force all writer/producers to stop ALL duties is a tactic that is not fair to the business as a whole.
Even if the DGA and SAG decided to throw down and preemptively strike, which would obviously be a huge statement, that doesn’t necessitate the whole business locking its collective door immediately. The business is bigger than one union.
I hope in the end they get back to the table and the studios are forced to capitulate to at least some of the guild’s demands. In the meantime I hope that the non-writing members of the business are able to work as long as possible since this is not their strike and many of them are not in unions and will only suffer from the ramifications of this disaster.