After days and days of silence from the studios’ and networks’ side of the strike, I just received this somewhat cryptic statement from AMPTP President Nick Counter: “The WGA is using fear and intimidation to control its membership. Asking members to inform on each other and creating a blacklist of those who question the tactics of the WGA leadership is as unacceptable today as it was when the WGA opposed these tactics in the 1950s.”
Let me explain. The Alliance representing studios and networks and other entertainment owners is upset over what it sees as a “rat squad” operating under WGA auspicies to “inform on members breaking strike rules and to snitch on anyone who works as a scab,” as a source explains to me. Finally, after some bumbling, the AMPTP issued an addendum to explain the issue more fully through — what else? — a Variety story.
Actually, the AMPTP is days late reacting to the WGA’s strike rules as well as to the news release that the guild was setting up a WGAW Strike Rules Compliance Committee (SRCC) comprised of 12 WGAW members whose “mission is to discourage violations of the Guild’s Strike Rules by investigating allegations that writers are undermining our strike efforts by engaging in strike-breaking activities or scab writing and, in appropriate instances, by recommending action against such writers. By doing so, we hope first and foremost to discourage such writers from breaking the Strike Rules.”
UPDATE: The WGAW responded to the AMPTP today with the following statement: “Mr. Counter’s charge is as offensive as it is untrue. To accuse the Writers Guild of America of blacklisting, when it was we who suffered the most from it in the past, is simply Mr. Counter’s desperate attempt to divert attention from the fact that it was he who walked out of the negotiations, and it is he who refuses every day to return to the table. The WGA has an offer on the table and is ready and willing to meet with the AMPTP any day, anywhere.”
Of course, the great irony here given AMPTP’s ire is that, according to the guild’s website, the WGA’s online strike-breaking form “is currently unavailable” so to report an incident of strike breaking or scab writing for investigation, members have to call ”the WGAW strike tip hotline”.
I certainly heard complaints from various TV showrunners right after the walkout started how unnerving it was to have the strike captains on their staffs watching them closely with an eye to informing on any strike rule-breaking activity. On the other hand, I’ve got to say it’s rather naive of the AMPTP to think that the WGA would not try to enforce strike discipline. That’s just Labor 101.
And it is also hilarious that the AMPTP is using a Variety story about the “Compliance Committee” to make its case for it. Between all the paid ads that the AMPTP is placing in the trades, and all the free publicity it’s giving them, The Alliance is the best friend that Reed Business and Nielsen publications could have now, just when the trades’ credibility during this strike is being scrutinized and questioned by media critics on both coasts.
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.



You dont need to explain what’s going on in a minute, nikki, Nick Counter is a bonafide loon, no need to elaborate on something we already know.
Yeah. Like we need Nick Counter looking out for us.
If we want your opinion, Nick, we’ll squeeze your head. Stay in your little box until the mogul cabal pulls you out, puts their collective hand up your butt and makes your mouth move.
Oh wait…
Well, there’s one way to change the subject from the You Tube vid that’s going viral. Good luck, Nick.
I guess this less than positive message from the AMPTP means that the agencies didn’t make much progress bringing both sides back to the negotiating room?
“a blacklist of those who question the tactics of the WGA leadership is as unacceptable today as it was when the WGA opposed these tactics in the 1950s.”
Oh, I can’t wait! Let’s see, which blacklist did the WGA oppose in the 50′s? Oh, right! The one that was CREATED BY THE STUDIO BOSSES!
I’ll explain… It’s the AMPTP accusing us of using tactics that they themselves have employed.
- The AMPTP are refusing to negotiate.
- The AMPTP have put everyone out of work for the holidays, laying off crew and studio employees while they suspend overall deals and wait to force majeure those contracts.
- The AMPTP leaks rumors of a nine month strike to local news outlets, who then report that as news, so as to create financial fear among writers and all the other unions as well.
If you didn’t know already, or after seeing the moguls report on all the money they’re making in new media, how can anyone believe anything these guys say?
Yeah, Counter is REALLY worried about the WGA membership.
I’m sure he’s losing sleep.
The AMPTP… sad, little, old men.
Question for Nick Counter: Who is your audience? If you were a writer this would be one of the first questions you’d ask yourself before shining a light on what are in fact your own tactics of fear and intimidation. Lawsuits against showrunners, co-eps, and supervising producers? We are united and that means no one who claims the protections of that unity can break the rules. That’s not intimidation, that’s what we signed up for.
I’m a writer. The more I look at the video clip claims by the studio heads, the more I realize this will be a long haul because they have plenty to hide here – it’s a gold mine and they know it. There’s going to be a correlation between how long they let the strike go on without offering a fair deal and how badly they want to keep the writers from seeing how much money there truly is in internet. The studios are parking a beat up old car on top of an oil well they claim may or may not be flush with oil. Well, we know there’s oil and we can see the well. And WE WILL wait them out.
Really, Nick Counter? That’s what you’ve come up with? A 1950′s blacklist conspiracy? That’s the best you’ve got? Wow, you really do need the writers.
No need to explain, Nikki. I think we all know that Nick Counter is just trying to spin union policy his way. WGA members are being asked to let the leadership know if anyone is scabbing. This is not at all unusual during a strike by any union.
The idea that Counter is trying to compare Guild leadership to McCarthy shows how low he is willing to go, and how out of touch he is with reality.
Wah!
Sounds like Counter and his cronies are getting desperate. Clearly they are losing the PR war and are now resorting to this nonsense. I’ve been on the picket line every day since last Monday and the members on the line have been nothing but supportive of each other and the cause. The picketers are energized. Everyone believes this strike is important. There is no — repeat, no — sense of fear and intimidation among the members I’ve walked with. There is a wonderful feeling that we’re all in this together to the bitter end.
The WGA like any union has strike rules for a reason. Nick Counter is trying to find a story where there is none. The last time I saw this behavior was during Jr. high.
As a WGA writer, I fully support the SRCC and would use it if I thought someone was scabbing.
If you have to do it, go fi-core and have some balls about it. So then I can scowl at you and know I would never hire/ work with you.
There are way too many people making big sacrifices (writers and btl peeps), for some self serving pigs to slip work in under the radar…you don’t get to enjoy the benefits of guild membership if you’re going to undermine it.
The AMPTP trying to turn it into a SCANDAL is hilarious and only highlights how desperate they are.
Are you serious? That’s where this guy’s head is? Please, AMPTP — get Counter the hell out of there.
Could this be another ploy by the AMPTP to weaken the WGA’s resolve? Stepping out in defense of scabs leaves the impression that there are actual scabs they are trying to protect. Or are they sending the message to would-be scabs that the moguls will protect them? Laughable.
I’m so glad that Nick Counter is focusing on the internal politics of the WGA because that should really be his first priority. Meanwhile, he still has not addressed the real issues at hand…for instance, WHY WE ARE STRIKING IN THE FIRST PLACE!!! He is like Dorothy in ‘The Wizard of Oz’. He thinks if he just keeps banging his slippers together and wishing he could go home, he will be magically transported back to a place where none of these scary beasts exist. So transparent and annoying. Stop trying to distract people and face the music, Nick.
A solution does not appear imminent. Counter redefines the term “tool”.
For Counter to conflate a union’s enforcement of its own strike rules with the days of the Communist witch hunt when artists turned in their fellow artists merely for exercising their Constitutional right to political association, is beyond disingenuous, it’s disgusting. And transparently manipulative. I’m glad you didn’t buy it for a second. Labor 101, indeed.
Okay, I get it, Nick, you don’t like the WGA. Now quit dodging the real issues and get back to the bargaining table.
Give us our fair share (I mean, a bigger unfair share) and you won’t have to deal with us again for three years.
Mike Scully
Meanwhile, the networks have forced their daytime soap writers to go fi-core if they don’t want to be fired.
http://www.variety.com/article/VR1117975855.html?categoryId=14
Is it just me or is the AMPTP seeming more and more pathetic with each passing day?
They clearly have not adjusted to this thing known as the “Information superhighway,” aka, “The Interweb.” Every stale attempt to undermine the union is met with mocking on blogs and scorn from members.
Maybe this crap working in 1988 when we didn’t have access to websites, blogs and online videos, but those days are gone. The AMPTP does not seem to be able to adjust to the new world.
Huh. I’m not sure what “blacklist of those who question the tactics of the WGA leadership” Mr.Counter is referring to. Writers are an opinionated bunch of individuals with widely different opinions. Some mind that the leadership took DVDs off the table, others think it was wise. Some question the timing of the strike, others think it’s brilliant. I haven’t seen anybody being reprimanded for expressing an opinion. Oh, and the one thing everyone I’ve talked to is in agreement on is that they will stay on strike as long as necessary to get a fair deal from Mr. Counter. So please, can he stop wasting time trying to divide writers and just get back to the negotiating table already so the companies he works for can go back to making huge profits and the writers can get their crumbs of the pie and go back to work? That makes everyone happy.
Oh, poor Nicholas, the whiner.
Now that the the AMPTP has been exposed as the duplicitous greed mongers they and the entire World agrees, he has the temerity to launch a petty grenade which only exemplifies that the WGA is united.
Hey Nick, how about getting your ass to the Negtable and doing something worthwhile, like putting an end to this ridiculous charade.