The Los Angeles City Council’s Housing, Community, and Economic Development Committee held a hearing on the economic impact of the Writers Guild of America strike on the local and regional economy, but the AMPTP declined to attend. ”We asked them to testify, and they said they would consider it. But then last night they said no,” an LA City Council source told me. ”We were very disappointed.” Instead, on the AMPTP’s behalf, the Motion Picture Association of America inserted a statement into the record.
I asked why the negotiators for the studios and networks didn’t show (a fact which Variety buried in the 3rd paragraph of its account of the hearing). “MPAA got involved because they rep us before the City Council, and because it was their area of expertise – economic impact,” an insider told me. “The MPAA represents the companies before all levels of government throughout the world. MPAA also provides economic data and information on the motion picture and television business to the public, on behalf of our members. But you are right that no individual from MPAA or AMPTP took part in the actual hearing.”
The WGA, which showed up in force for the 7:30 AM hearing despite pouring rain, issued a statement that the AMPTP’s “refusal shows a callous disregard for the people of Los Angeles. First these companies walked away from the bargaining table, and today they chose to ignore the economic hardship their actions have caused. The WGA would like to solve this problem and get everyone back to work, but that can’t be done until the other side comes back to the table.”
The Los Angeles City Council approved a resolution today urging the two sides to return to the bargaining table.
On the subject of the strike’s financial impact, the government panel was told by one economist that the LA County economy could take a $380 million hit if the writers’ strike continues as long as the 1988 labor action, which last 22 weeks. But that figure is 1/10 of 1% of the LA economy, so the overall impact was said to be “very modest”. But that was strongly disputed by other number crunchers who told the committee that the strike was already having a major impact on the city, including a significant drop in sales tax revenues. One WGA strike captain who attended the hearing emailed me: ”The $300 million impact was presented by an economist shill for the moguls whose basic premise was that as people left television they would go to other jobs that would help LA’s economy. This was quickly rebuked by the objective Film LA and another representative of the city’s accounting office who both asserted that a prolonged strike could cripple LA’s already teetering economy. John Bowman estimated that a prolonged strike could ultimately cost upwards of 2 billion unrecoverable dollars.”
John Bowman, chairman of the WGA’s negotiating committee, testified with hundreds of Guild members in attendance. (Photos above by Jim Stevenson.) He said the strike is about “fighting to maintain the livelihoods of Los Angeles’ middle-class writers working in the entertainment industry. The typical WGA member makes about $62,000 a year. It’s a strike we believe we were forced into and one that is now being prolonged by the AMPTP.”
Testifying with her baby in her arms (photo left by Jim Stevenson), Betsy Thomas, writer and producer of the TBS show My Boys, said WGA writers are not living extravagant lifestyles and deserve to benefit from new technologies that are making money for the studios. ”My writers drive Hondas and Toyotas, and we’re middle class. It makes me sick that my crew will be out of work and that these writers will be out of work. I feel such a responsibility for the people who work for me, and I just hope that the studios will feel the same.”
The MPAA submitted a statement to the committee that said “the economic consequences of the strike cannot be measured solely by wages. In addition to lost wages are the costs from the lack of sales of goods and services that go into production, which is an estimated additional $300 million. It also means that scores of other businesses from prop houses to caterers that serve production daily in Los Angeles have also had to lay off
numerous employees.” (Below, press conference with Eric Garcetti. Photo by Jim Stevenson.)
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.







Everyone needs to calm down, take a deep breath, the strike will end, someday. Maybe in a month, maybe two, the studios/networks have this all planned out. Everyone knew this was comimg six months ago, it should be no suprise that the writers would go on strike.
I do like that photo there though – it really does look like a church in there, doesn’t it?
I used to drive a Ford Taurus, which I sold during week three of the strike to pay expenses after turning away non-union writing work offered to me. I’m a non-union writer, in full support of the guild, and have stopped all writing because one day I WILL be in the WGA. We’re all feeling a huge financial pinch — especially the technicians and crew who make each film and TV show possible. Our sacrifices now will be worth it one day, no matter which guild gets the deal.
just checking said… The WGA is on strike, right? They are the reason I lost my BTL job, right?
No. The reason you lost your BTL job is because the AMPTP refuses to negotiate, not just fairly, AT. ALL. The AMPTP walked away from the negotiating table, TWICE. Clear?
Good.
At least the writer’s are wearing their red & black unity shirts. Makes it easier to spot from long distance.
Justin — third paragraph is ‘buried’ because the fact that the AMPTP didn’t bother to show up should have been the headline. Don’t you think if the WGA had blown off the city council it would have been?
The Companies care just as much about Los Angeles as bush does about New Orleans.
Can we please get a few one day sympathy strikes from our sister unions!
Where are our City leaders in this situation? What, if anything is our Mayor doing to move along or stimulate the continuation of talks? What is Arnold doing? In any case, I find the UCLA guy’s comments ridiculous, at best. He is completely out of touch with reality. What did he base his conclusions on, biased guesswork? Wow, what an idiot!!
The Mayor – doing nothing.
The Governor – doing nothing.
City Council – doing nothing.
CEOs – doing nothing.
Sad
Comment by informed public — December 19, 2007
“As far as we’re concerned, writers are more essential than anyone.”
This statement really says it all. It is the underlying attitude of the WGA and most of it’s members. It is why you cannot have negotiations. It is the reason the WGA thinks it is ok to sacrafice BTL for their cause. I create cg animation for your scripted television and I would really like to see your “drama” without my creation included. I don’t feel entitled to anything more than my self negotiated salary. You people get over yourself.
Nikki,
is it wrong to feel,well, fatigue from all this animosity between the AMPTP and the WGA? I support the fact writers need a better deal.
Shouldn’t the viewers get to have an opinion?
$62,000 a year? the Avg WGA member? Last time I checked on the numbers the AVG writer made $202,000 wtf? I think that the numbers should be posted in the LA times to prove the legit numbers. I dont believe the avg writer makes less than the avg. Grip. If so that is only because there are more out of work writers ( their own fault ) than trashman
“I used to drive a Ford Taurus, which I sold during week three of the strike to pay expenses after turning away non-union writing work offered to me. I’m a non-union writer, in full support of the guild…”
Comment by A Comment — December 19, 2007 @ 8:54 pm
You’re a fool. I’m a member of WGA and I am working feverishly on a spec script. This strike is a major opportunity for writers in the middle-to-lower rungs to get a leg-up on the established caste in the WGA membership — who, by the way, are quietly working on their own projects. The 1988 strike killed hundreds of careers yet birthed just as many new ones. I know which category I want to be in…
“I suggest you revist Melrose Avenue between Gower and Van Ness. There is street parking and metered parking that, since the strike, has been filled with expensive cars.”
Hey, “Anonymous”, we’re all parking on Clinton, Windsor, Norton and every other street WITH FREE, UNLIMITED PARKING south of Paramount. Becasue we have to be there for 3-4 hours a day. (Memo to the outside world – park at a meter in L.A. at your own peril. You will end up paying an idiot tax.)
Feel free to do an inventory of our cars once we return in January. We’re easy to spot: Most of us are still dressing like we did in college.
And those “expensive cars” on Melrose? Complain to the owners of Lucy’s and that weird button shop at Windsor – tell ‘em that their wealthy clients are ruining the neighborhood.
My god…
The AMPTP doesn’t show up at the negotiating table, the AMPTP doesn’t show up at City Council… are we sure that the AMPTP even exists?
Patrick Meighan
Culver City, CA
“e”:
You lost your paycheck because of the companies in the AMPTP – period. Read up on this, and you’ll be enlightened. In a nutshell, the WGA needed to work out the internet payments, since the internet suddenly became a major broadcasting tool. We did not choose the timing of it. It’s just the situation. The studios are not negotiating. We have items we’re willing to remove if they just negotiate in good faith, which they have not yet done. Sorry if you don’t understand this. And I’m really, sincerely sorry you’re out of work. Do you want Peter Chernin’s number to complain about it?
If this is the kind of hysteria the WGA brings to the negotiation table, it’s going to be a long strike. “OMG! Disney is saying bad things about us–to their own employeees! How dare the AMPTP not show up to a dog and pony show city council meeting! They must hate Los Angeles! They are the evilest people in the whole wide world!”
Give me a break. This is business and not some kind of high school pep rally. The WGA can hold rallies all day long and spin their side to their members, but god forbid Disney tell their side to their employees. Everyone knows the City Council can pass resolutions up the ying yang, and it will mean nothing. They can’t force the parties to make a deal. Maybe the AMPTP should’ve sent their own rep (for publicity sake) but they sent the MPAA on their behalf. Big deal. It’s not a crime. The world is not going to come to an end.
OKay, yes the AMPTP are greedy selfish jerks. Having said that, the WGA putting in demands they no will never have a chance in hell of being accepted isn’t helping either. I’m sorry but if this drags out till June, public support will NOT be on the writer’s side, sad but true.
Look at all those red shirts…I LOVE seeing that. Way to support the cause WGA-W! I’m sure the AMPTP didn’t bother showing because they don’t have a leg left to stand on — and they know it! Chicken sh*ts…
On a personal note, yey for Betsy Thomas testifying! My Boys is my summer TV-crack (and I desperately need to know who PJ runs into on the plane to Italy; though, now, it seems I may have to wait an entire year to find out. Damn you, AMPTP!).
So it’s an election year in ten days and the entire LA infrastructure is at stake because a few moguls think money-pinching a few cents by screwing a union is worth it?
So where exactly is the political pressure to get the AMPTP back to the table?
Wouldn’t it be funny if the result of this hearing was ultimately that the L.A. city and county government gave the AMPTP companies BIGGER tax breaks and other incentives to keep their production in L.A.? I mean, given the dependence of the L.A. economy on the industry, that would only make sense.
Yep, that’d be a regular laugh riot.
“Give me a break. This is business and not some kind of high school pep rally. The WGA can hold rallies all day long and spin their side to their members, but god forbid Disney tell their side to their employees. Everyone knows the City Council can pass resolutions up the ying yang, and it will mean nothing. They can’t force the parties to make a deal. Maybe the AMPTP should’ve sent their own rep (for publicity sake) but they sent the MPAA on their behalf. Big deal. It’s not a crime. The world is not going to come to an end.”
Nick, I thought you were on vacation.
to k3d at 3:25:
WE ARE NOT WRITERS
OUR NAME SAYS IT – “INFORMED PUBLIC” – WE ARE JUST OBSERVERS
IF YOU HAD ANY READING COMPREHENSION SKILLS, PERHAPS YOU’D BE MORE SUCCESSFUL IN LIFE THAN YOU ARE IN YOUR “CAREER”, OR “SHILLING” AS THEY SAY
On the whole writer’s cars arguements: Yes, writers at the top make more than enough money. The writers whose scripts win Oscars (Paul Haggis), or whose films have been topping the box office (Jud Apatow), or who are showrunners on hit shows on major networks (say Tim Kring, Marc Cherry, or Carleton Cuse), are in no way working class stiffs. However, most writers are not any of these people. If you are a guy who sold a script or two, or who was a staff writer on on a single season of a show, you are in the $62,000 per year category. A friend of mine sold one script, quit his job, and now lives a very frugal lifestyle while writing and hoping someone will buy another script of his. And as for a cars, who’s to say a writer didn’t buy a BMW with the cash from one script sale, and they haven’t sold anything since? Or they could be an idiot who lives well beyond their means. Fact is, you don’t know who the car belongs to, the circumstances of the purchase, or if they are able to continue making those kinds of purchases. So to sum it all up, stop talking out of your a$$.
The executive parking lot is filled with Bentleys, limousines, etc belonging to AMPTP.
AMPTP flies on private jets, wears $500 shoes, dines on filet mignon – while the rest of you can’t pay your electric bill.
While WGA freezes on the picket line, AMPTP stormed away from the negotiation table to nice vacations, sipping margaritas on yachts.
C’mon, folks, they manufactured outrage on a Friday night during holiday season so they could get to their private jets on time.
Leaving all of you out of work, clobbered by bills
Why aren’t workers rioting against AMPTP – historically, this kind of divide between haves and have nots would be the igniter of revolution.
Remember how your government abandoned you at election time. Schwarzenegger is in AMPTP’s pocket – how hypocritical as SAG helped build his empire. Villaraigosa – an ineffectual slimy joke who should hang up his hat now, and who has betrayed his people. And on and on.