That the studios and networks have been twisting the truth about the WGA strike to suit their own purposes looks to be standard operating procedure during this strike. That happens on the other side of this labor dispute, too. But no company seems to be doing this more than Disney/ABC. For instance, all comments (not just some) that are even mildly friendly to the WGA are quickly deleted from ABC.com. Here is one striking writer’s experience on Tuesday: “I was on ABC.com today when I saw the Leno story and that there were comments where writers were being bashed and scabs promoted. I defended writers and less than two minutes later the comments were deleted. I tried again and, once again, my comments were deleted. Talk about ABC/Disney censorship.”
The above wouldn’t seem as scary if Disney didn’t own an international news operation, ABC, which is supposed to report accurately and consider both sides of an issue.
But it gets worse.
ABC recently held a ”Strike Educational Seminar”. Its purpose was described thusly: “With each day of the WGA strike, more articles and opinions circulate in the media. Now is your chance to hear the real issues in question. Please join Mark Pedowitz and Marc Sandman for a brief discussion of the strike and its challenges.” According to an account of the seminar from a Disney/ABC employee who wishes to remain nameless but whose identity I have confirmed, very little about this presentation was truthful.
[But, first, a personal note: I'm told during the seminar I was called "Tokyo Rose" -- a reference to the English-speaking female broadcasters used by Japan to disseminate anti-American propaganda during World War II. This is not merely a garden variety insult. This is an odious comparison with all its implications to use against anyone, much less a journalist.]
Here is the account given me of the ABC strike seminar:
“I went for selfish reasons, hoping to get the answer to the question, Will I lose my job? But I also wanted to hear what these folks had to say, and I was shocked. Sandman, a labor lawyer here, did not refrain from editorializing every chance he got. Rather than discuss what this meant for the studio in a pragmatic sense (2008 pilots, jobs, bonuses, etc.), he totally BASHED the WGA at every turn. These were some of the salient points this little blowhard spread to no less than 150 employees:
“1. The Guild wanted to strike way back in July. The AMPTP was ready to bargain then, but the WGA refused.
“2. They never spend more than 3 hours at the table, and this is the Guild’s fault. Basically, says he, Verrone and Young are novices who’ve never done this before and as such read from a script at the table, then leave. When talks broke off the last time it was because the WGA handed the AMPTP their proposals, then left. According to him, the AMPTP was ready to work things out.
“3. The main issues for the WGA, which the AMPTP considers unacceptable are: 1) sympathy strikes; 2) reality and animation; and 3) the issue of distribution, which says that the WGA is insisting on a provision whereby no network or studio can acquire a product unless the writer(s) of that product are complying with WGA rules. This is what he had the audacity to say. He also said that in terms of streaming and downloads, the AMPTP has a proposal that is absolutely workable.
“4. The DGA is a much more responsible, reasonable union. The DGA had one tiny strike in the last 40 years, while the WGA strikes every chance it gets.
“5. The main reason the WGA is striking is political. The main reason the Guild wants to unionize reality and animation is to create more revenue stream through dues. (!!!!!!) It has nothing to do with caring about writers. And, he said, because Patric Verrone used to write for animation, he has a particular beef with that.
“6. He referred to the strikes as a “traveling circus”.
“The thing that killed me is that people in the audience were buying it. During the Q&A, questions such as “What can we do to to help the studio’s cause?” were asked. I almost lost it, and my cheeks were so red I felt like I suddenly had a 104 fever. The way this information was presented — in addition to being complete bullshit — was absolutely unacceptable and irresponsible. This asshole was given a theater to act out his own personal vendetta against the WGA to an audience that doesn’t know any better. It was awful.
“Feel free to spread this far and wide, to Writeraction and Nikke Finke (who he referred to as “Tokyo Rose”).”
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.


Why is it bad that ABC/ Disney is censoring posts on their website, but you (Nikki) do it ALL the time? Many posts that are pro-AMPTP aren’t posted…the few that do get through are bashed by the writers as “posted by shills”. Isn’t it possible that there are other voices out there that want to be heard? Nikki, you should stop censoring and post the voices of your readers. Let the public make up their mind on who is right in this fight.
Nikke, you are like ABC.com in the sense you post only Postive WGA comments and refrain from posting postive AMPTP comments.
Good to know that even in the Iger era, Disney has remained the over-the-top evil corporation that Eisner made it. Any chance we could get Roy Disney to leave a flaming bag of poop on that lawyer’s doorstep?
Tokio Rose – I like it.
It is rare to see such biased reporting as you manage to turn out every day.
The WGA really should fine Disney for this. 10% more than any other studio/network when the individual deals are struck (and they will be). If they ask why, the answer is “for Tokyo Rose.”
This, to me, is the real crux of this who issue.
There is a side in this battle that is very willing to fight dirty. Really dirty. Much of the tactics probably got them the wealth and power they enjoy, and they have no problem lying, cheating, stealing, anything they have to do to stay in power. They have done it before, and they will do it now.
Because they honestly believe they deserve the power they have. They honestly believe they are the good guys, and that the world falls apart if they lose their power. They honestly believe they are smarter, more worthy, and more talented…otherwise, why would they have all their money and power at all? They earned it.
If this sounds familiar, look to the White House for the prime example.
The writers are still clinging to the idea that the truth will win this battle. It should. But will it? Is it more powerful than the lies wrapped in money?
Or will they be roped into the same practices of lying and deceit themselves? Will this really turn into a political campaign of mudslinging where no one has any idea what is really true anymore?
Will it brew apathy? The best friend of those already in power?
Hmmm….
“Tokyo Rose”?
I fully expect the propaganda, the ‘stretching’ of truth and credulity and the ‘fuzzy’ accounting to be used by both sides during this strike. I even expect and tolerate some name calling but to use a term like ‘Tokyo Rose’ in a situation such as this is repugnant.
I am not a writer, I am not a studio person. I am an actor who is sitting in his house waiting for his show to re-start…. or not.
Whether you agree or not with what Miss Finke reports, whether you agree or not that she has unbiased journalistic integrity should not bring you to use terms such as this.
For me it diminishes the valiant and brave work of our fighting men and women not only in World War 2 but also in the conflicts of today.
It is an abhorrent comparison and even though it was made without press and cameras present it should be addressed and a statement of explanation should be forthcoming along with an apology. Not only to Miss Finke but to the people that a comment such as this offends, which should be us all.
Let us hope that “Tokyo Rose” is not the thin edge of the wedge and that we are about to embark down the road of hysterical historical comparisons. That never ends well. I would hate to see someone lob a Goerbles grenade over the fence.
Hey Mark, I’m one of those writers you want to get along with and like you.
I have a very long memory.
Disney/ABC is dispicable. I honestly feel sick after reading this shit.
To be called Tokyo Rose by the writers or by some impartial entity might be an insult but to be personally vilified by the heavy-handed propagandists at Disney is a high honor few can aspire to achieve.
Think how heavy your heart would be now if Disney had labeled you “Disney sympathizer Nikki Finke” or “AMPTP-friendly Nikki Finke” or worse, “Honorary Cast Member Nikki Finke”, (Disneyland doesn’t have employees, they have cast members.) You’d demand a retraction.
None of this should surprise you. This is how Corporate America operates (or any powerful entity for that matter). They will only present their side of the story, not all sides. Remember these are suits, not journalists, and they have every right to do and say what they’re doing. I’m not saying it’s right or wrong, but that’s how they are. I admire the person for speaking out and revealing this inside tidbit. In the grand scheme of things, unfortunately, it won’t matter much. This is a small part of a larger counter-campaign to discredit the WGA. The hiring of a combative PR firm, the ads in the trades, the seminars… they’re meant to do one thing: take back public opinion. What concerns me is the longer the strike is, the more it works in the “Company’s” favor PR-wise, UNLESS the WGA has an ace up its sleeve. Just remember: don’t believe everything you read — believe everything you know for a fact.
I’ve said it before… Now that the WGA is willing to negotiate individually, they simply offer the first taker the best deal on the internet. Every studio/network after that will pay incrementally higher rates. If the moguls are afraid to be the first one, this structure will give them the ability to say, “Hey, we got the best deal and our competitors are paying a higher rate.” Do you really think shareholders of the other companies would stand for losing more of their profit margin to a shittier deal? I think not. This is the way to break the ‘alliance.’
I guess this just reinforces the general thoughts among the membership that the AMPTP isn’t interested in negotiations, but, instead is actuality interested in busting the union. And they’ll do anything, say anything, and use anyone, to achieve their ends.
And apparently, Mr Sandman has mistakenly remembered history, Tokyo Rose was on the side of the enemy, she was not a journalist doing her job…
Welcome to the AMPTPs smear campaign, Nikki, they don’t care who they paint with their brush.
I wonder if Disney consulted with their PR hacks before they put on this little presentation–cuz if this is the advice they’re getting, Iger should demand his money back.
Is it just me, or does the AMPTP actually WANT to make their members look sleazy?
I’m trying to be sympathetic to the cause, but Verrone and Young are novices compaired to the DGA’s team.
The WGA didn’t do enough research into this either. The DGA spent the past year figuring out what real numbers would be lost/gained where as the writers waited until it was too late.
You rip people who are one sided, but you are guilty of that yourself. If you were a “company man” you would be presenting your side of that arguement.
Of course you are Tokyo Rose to Bob Iger and the people at Disney. They know WWII and Intellectual property very well. They know these things because the founder of the company was such a strong Nazi Sympathizer who built his company on the stolen ideas of Ub Iwerks. Iger and crew still have the tapes of Rose and listen to them during the holidays when they are feeling Nostalgic for the Fascist “Old Times”.
A college friend of mine works there. She says the employees refer to Disney Corporate Headquarters as “The unhappiest place on earth.” Now I see why.
I would like to see the WGA refute (with facts) those points made by Disney.
Don’t think you can expect to have it both ways, Nikki. You are a very accomplished journalist, but you’ve totally shown a bias for the writers (which is completely your right as you are now a blogger). But with headlines like this “AMPTP Statement Recycles Same Old Shit” if the shoe fits…
I feel sick reading this and knowing I’ve been in business with these liars. How will we ever go back to work for these people again after the lies they tell? That’s the real question. I don’t know Sandman, but Pedowitz, you, sir, are a scumbag.
It looks like the trolls were just waiting for you to post this, Nikki, so they could be first with their responses.
It’s not just ABC covering up the truth. It’s NBC, too. We had that 5000 member march on Ave. of The Stars and there was not one NBC news story about it all day long. Not one. What else are we not seeing on our news? This isn’t just writer versus producer, this is about Free Speech and Censorship. This is also a moral issue: How much is enough ENRON? Our gas has tripled. The cost of a house has tripled. Has anyone’s salary tripled? We’re asking for a lousy 3% a year. Hardly a “fair deal” for writers, yet entirely doable by the producers who are making 10% more a year. Heck, just pay us what The Golden Compass cost to make. We’d make 4% a year!
Yo Mr. Grimes and UltraV, and the two Marcs at the session, you do Ms. Finke much honor by comparing her blog to the entire news apparatus of Disney/ABC. She has her point of view and is advocating it. Disney/ABC better make up their mind as to what they are advocating before we the general public make it for you. Ya’ll are a bushel of schmucks.
Well, well, back to the USSR, or at least Putin-like tactics to suppress the truth and spead lies…
To keep a grip on to Power.
It’s the old Political game, lie enough, over and over and maybe the sheep/public opinion will accept it as the truth.
Only this is NOT Putin’s Russia, but the AMPTP’s Demagogues trying to become an Oligarchy with their push to further consolidate and become a Monopoly. They are doing it right now with their latest efforts to “Buy”/Lobby for an FCC Rules/Regs reversal. I recommend everyone who doesn’t adhere to these tactics to contact Diane Feinstein’s Office ASAP. She is trying to block it and there is an ongoing petition drive you can check out at unitedhollywood.com.
I have friends who work for Businesses loyal to, dependant on and beholden to “The Companies” and you would not believe how brainwashed they are. I have to correct the facts and argue the truth with them, over and over and over. They are definitely being told only what the companies want them to believe and it is a shameless, if not illegal practice.
And who do the Companies choose to Rep them in this PR battle? A Political PR Firm specializing in smear tactics, lies, disinformation campaigns, opposition research ( i.e. politics of personal destruction) and now, it seems, Corporate Brainwashing… maybe that is why you see more and more of this going on now.
The truth will win out here, there is no control over information in THIS Country… or world for that matter. At least not the last time I looked.
Tell me Ugly Betty is technically owned by someone other than these assholes. I want my show back. How did they get all the good progreams? Damn them, damn them, damn them.
I took the trouble to forward this piece to Boxer, Feinstein and Waxman. I hope they see it.