UPDATED THROUGHOUT: First it was turmoil inside NBC’s fall scripted shows like Kath & Kim and My Own Worst Enemy. Now there’s trouble inside CBS’s primetime sked. I’m told that The Ex List‘s creator/showrunner Diane Ruggiero is exiting: some say she
quit over creative differences, others say she was pushed to jump. In any case, executive producer Rick Eid will take over running the show. And CBS stock has been tumbling. Les Moonves this week told Wall Street what a lousy year it was for advertising, especially with the problems of U.S. automakers. But don’t cry for his beleaguered Big Media company yet: he predicted an ad turnaround in 2009.
Indeed, automotive marketers and movie studios are leading the way to help NBC sell out mid-80% of its 2009 Super Bowl XLIII ad inventory earlier than expected — including about a dozen or so advertisers who agreed to pay $3 million for a 30-second spot (as opposed to the $2.7 mil that Fox asked in 2008). And NBC claims to Ad Age it’ll set prices higher as the Tampa game date draws near. Talk about an obvious attempt to goose early ad buys. But here’s what I think is hilarious: NBC is using the Super Bowl to try and sell ad packages across its properties because NBC’s primetime is gonna stink up the joint this season.
Here’s why I know networks are preparing for the worst: because bosses like Les Moonves and Jeff Zucker keep telling business reporters that their companies are “so much more” than just primetime. As for CBS’ prospects, their sked looks better than NBC’s but far from great. CBS thinks I’m selling their fall line-up “a little short. The comedy Worst Week is easily the most critically acclaimed new comedy of the season; the Simon Baker drama The Mentalist, is getting good advance notices; and test audiences have been excited about Jerry Bruckheimer’s new drama Eleventh Hour, which the press will see for the first time next week.” Nice spin, but I still think the network entertainment team there is past its expiration date.
At troubled stepsister The CW, other media inexplicably haven’t fussed over the dramatic falloff of 90210‘s follow-up to its Tori Spelling-less opener — but I will. When 90210 can’t beat in its 2nd original airing what the old WB’s Gilmore Girls got in its reruns, it’s time for Moonves to fire UPN-turned-CW boss Dawn Ostroff.
And let’s not forget to look at Peter Liguori’s Fox: numbers for this week’s debut of the second season of Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles were lousy. And the network’s sitcoms got off to a slow start even against no competition. Fringe has generated some decent media reviews, but this looks like yet another fall that’s just dead air until American Idol starts up its 8th season. And two Fox midseason shows have shut down production because of script problems: Joss Whedon’s Dollhouse and Howard Gordon’s 24.
As for ABC, aside from executive roiling, and nasty Katherine Heigl, there shouldn’t be a major primetime headache because most of the new shows don’t even start until midseason. Unless you don’t count the showrunner musical chairs on ABC’s unwatchable Dirty Sexy Money. First, Josh Reims left last year. Then Dexter‘s Daniel Cerone sealed an overall deal with ABC Studios last fall and joined Dirty Sexy Money as showrunner right after the end of the writers’ strike in February. Then, in June, Cerone’s 3 already-shot episodes for the 2008-2009 season were canned (talk about an expensive decision), and he was replaced by Jon Harmon Feldman (whose Big Shots didn’t last very long on ABC but who worked with Dirty Sexy Money‘s exec producer Greg Berlanti on Dawson’s Creek). As part of the transition, Dirty Sexy Money moved up its hiatus to July, giving the show a chance to regroup. So that’s three showrunners in the show’s short lifetime. I would never have brought back the series in the first place: great cast, horrible storyline. ABC’s Anne Sweeney, Steve McPherson, and Mark Pedowitz should have put this dog out of its misery.
- MAJOR MESSY NBC SHAKEUP AHEAD
- Tori Spelling Furious At ’90210′ Spinoff For Unequal Pay With Jennie & Shannen
- Who’s Gonna Be The Boss Of ‘Gossip Girl’?
- What’s Really Going On At ABC Studios…
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.







Sheesh, Moonlight is last year’s news. The show never had 8 million fans. At times it reached 8 million viewers (not the same) who were so bored on Friday nights they tuned in. And vampires are not “in” right now. Just see what happened to True Blood. They’re hyped by massive PR, that’s all. Moonlight was one of CBS’ mistakes last year, and thank god they corrected it and canceled that lame show.
Fringe? Good word of mouth? Perhaps by people being paid to spread WoM. Among people who watched it? This sums it up:
http://mikecane2008.wordpress.com/2008/09/12/debut-episode-of-fox-tvs-fringe/
Whatever the ratings were for that, expect them to plummet for the next one.
Fringe has good word of mouth? Who have you been talking to? It was lousy. I doubt it’ll get past 8 episodes.
Maybe Abrams & Benson can have an affair with someone at CBS and then save THAT network.
I think people are watching too many Reality Shows, America got talent and American Idol!!! All Crap When will end? The Wife swapping, Nanny Problems, Stuck on some silly island or Big Brother All a bunch back stabing morons. I think this will put a lot great writers Actors & Directors out of work, even the one that are not good at it!!!! or maybe Sarah Palin will get a show and watch her run the country into ground like the last idiot did for last eight years. That’s what we get when no one want’s to think!!!!!
‘Ex list’ fell prey to being a foreign show that did well in it’s home country but doesn’t fully translate here, much like ‘In Treatment’. CBS LOVED LOVED LOVED ‘Ex List’, but they failed to allow the Israeli producers creative input. Instead, they gave control to Diane Ruggiero hoping that she cold match the tone and temperment of the Israeli original, but instead ended up putting her own emotions and stamp into it, which would be fine if CBS had known what they wanted in the first place. The production was and is a mess.
It used to be that American television could come up with its own ideas, but that is over. What happened to great comedies built around great comics? Just like there seems to be a complete lack of ideas in movies, the same has happened for TV, but the biggest problem is the only format that has really translated to American TV has been ‘The Office’. Books can be made into movies, but a network thinking that an Israeli or Australian tv show successful overseas will be successful here does not work.
I think that Fox is being smart with ‘Dollhouse’. Even if you have to spend a little money to shut down, it’s much better to shut down and make sure that a great showrunner/creator like Joss Whedon has the full opportunity to make his show everything it can be than squander one of the few opportunities to make a moneymaking show. The problem isn’t too many pilots and I don’t think the answer to TV’s problem is going straight to series. Instead, it’s getting back to developing shows properly. Thinking out strategically what the producers, creatives and network want from a show. Don’t go in half ass thinking that you can duplicate a foreign show just because you watched 5 episodes of it. Development of ideas is nearly extinct and it’s a shame.
You Moonlight deadenders need to die in a fire. Let it go. It’s never coming back. Not on CBS. Not on The CW. Not nowhere. Not no how. Nobody cares but the 20 or so of you who take every opportunity, no matter how farfetched or remotely connected to bring up a failed show and spam every forum there is about your love for the show. We get it. Now go back to your caves. You loved it, but you don’t make a show. There weren’t enough of you to matter.
Jericho and the nuts, anyone?
Yeah, I thought so.
Simon
“As to why The CW’s 90210 2nd episode had a dramatic falloff, of after its opener is quite simple. It is shot in High Def video.”
You seriously believe that? It could be shot in 65mm Imax and still no one would watch it.”
You’re right.
90210 sucked in every area. But the production values were really bad. You have to be really accomplished to make High Def look good for dramatic programs. Gossip Girl pulls it off pretty well but some shots still look really flat. Film is much more forgiving.
Network executives have to stop trying to be show runners. They micromanage everything now, and the shows are just confused, cookie cutter “products.” Of course, procedurals are easier to repeat than serialized stories, but they also appeal to network execs because procedurals are all plot, with outlines the executives can understand step by step — what happens comes out of plot and not character. It takes the creative team behind a show to find and work through character on a long term basis — but if that were allowed, the network people wouldn’t know how to insert themselves into the process. Trusting people to decide on the direction of their shows may seem risky, but how much worse could the results be than they are now? Niche programs like Mad Men or Breaking Bad (I’m not even talking pay cable here) are good because cable nets need only niche audiences to succeed — and so the creators actually decide how the stories are going to go. This doesn’t mean the network doesn’t get involved, it means they don’t micromanage every moment of every episode the way they do on CBS. NBC is just a train wreck. Sadly, they’ve got LIFE and 30 Rock and a couple of other things, but they’re so inconsistent and their schedule is such a mess that it’s hard to be bothered wading through the crap. Maybe when networks inevitably get to the point where a 2.0 is a fabulous rating — like on basic cable — they’ll leave people alone to create interesting programs.
Lucia: “Canceling Moonlight was definitely one of CBS’S more obvious mistakes. And vampires are in now!”
So, the Moonlight fans appear to shill Moonlight – even when there is no previous mention of it (which is why the Moonlight fans are so annoying).
Susan is correct that “Moonlight” is definitely old (and very tired) news.
The truth is that it never had much penetration. One can claim “8 million viewers” (which is a generous rounding of its highest number), but one can’t deny that it was incredibly expensive to produce considering the relatively small number of viewers. It never beat first-run competition in its timeslot and critics generally ignored it.
It’s only recognition was the People’s Choice Awards – perhaps the least credible of any awards show due to it allowing multiple Internet votes per person of which Moonlight fans took full advantage. It’s always hilarious when a letter writer cites the PCA for Moonlight. You wouldn’t believe all the meaningless Internet polls that Moonlight fans cite in their letters. If there was some obscure poll on some Blogspot blog that had a favorable mention of Moonlight, Moonlight fan letter writers would cite it.
In the end, no one wanted to pay for “Moonlight” anymore – including Joel Silver. It’s really that simple.
The “Twilight” movie will be an indication of mainstream penetration of a vampire-themed production and whether “vampires are in,” but despite the book sales, few are expecting a blockbuster. I look forward to the fan excuses for that in November like “They didn’t promote it enough!” “Not enough promotion” is always a fan favorite excuse.
Genuine lack of interest? Inconceivable to the fan.
Boy, these new shows sound awful! And the returning shows have not been very good either. The first new Terminator episode was actually boring, Prison Break has been reduced to a caper series, and there hasn’t been a good comedy on since Seinfeld! The best shows are on cable now.
Hey Mike Cane…Good call. very funny recap of Fringe
@Bite Me
I’m not sure that vampires can die in a fire. Direct sunlight and/or stakes through the heart are still the tried and true methods.
I agree sense when did this post turn into a “Moonlight Whinning Campaign”. Ladies listen up, CBS loves Alex O’Loughlin he will be back on another show. And just for you ladies he will be taking off his shirt and showing off his combed and groomed hairy chest.
Just be patient okay?????
“It used to be that American television could come up with its own ideas, but that is over.”
That’s right! Remember those classic all-American shows like ALL IN THE FAMILY, SANFORD AND SON and THREE’S COMPANY!
TO THE PEOPLE WHO COMMENT HERE:
God how I wish you all ran the networks and studios! You bicker, you argue, you insult and yet you have more knowledge, love for entertainment and good ideas than all the studios combined!
Keep on writing, I love it.
Why, thank you, Tart!
The problem is not execs. The problem is creative people. Most of the guys creating new shows fail, around 80% of the time. No wonder execs are looking to stuff that was proven to work elsewhere (Ex List, Life on Mars).
The problem is absolutely creative people. They don’t have a clue about what ordinary people want, because they live in an isolating bubble of wealth and fame.
Dollhouse is a good example. Dushku is cute, Whedon had some success, the concept is however absolutely stupid and no matter how well executed, likely to be a failure. There is nothing more pathetic than people who ARE THE MAN posturing AGAINST THE MAN.
I’m sure inside Hollywood people would love this, but that’s about it. I don’t see either men or women adopting this show and a quick cancellation, despite obvious talent all around involved.
That TV has approaching an 80% fail rate for new shows ought to tell you that it’s creative people have no clue whatsoever what people want to see. I don’t think the writing, acting, and directing have ever been better, technically, and the emotional core of scripted entertainment so dead and soul-less.
Reality TV is just the opportunistic infection caused by creative failure.
First of all, Josh Reims wasn’t canned. He moved over to Brothers & Sisters (the other Berlanti show), so not only is this article inaccurate and ignorant, it’s also just plain wrong: this show is one of last years’ bests, hands down! It’s crazy to see all this negativity in one forum when usually this show receives such high critical praise. I guess negativity gravitates towards negativity. Or towards Nikki Finke. Same thing.
The networks don’t have a clue what’s good and what’s not. CBS had a new HIT sitcom called “The BIGG Family” and they passed on it. It would of gave them another “Everybody Loves Raymond”. NBC passed also. now it looks like ABC who is willing to take chances is going to picking it up.
@ Rich D , your joking right??? They were series in UK before they were adopted for US TV.