Today, Dirty Sexy Money, Eli Stone, and Pushing Daisies were all cancelled after posting season lows among adults 18-49 this week. But ABC did order five more episodes of its new series (based on the British drama) Life On Mars. All the axed shows were marginal at best, and two were interrupted by the writers strike. Warner Bros’ Pushing Daisies was an expensive experiment. It began airing with big buzz but also had early budget and production problems from trying to sandwich 70 to 170 visual effects into every episode — so many that people considered it an unsustainable show. ABC Entertainment prez Steve McPherson called Bryan Fuller with the news: “We gave it the best shot we could.” This was also the show that ABC decided not to preempt for Barack Obama’s half-hour campaign commercial which every other major network aired. Dirty Sexy Money (ABC Studios/Berlanti) should have been put out of its misery last season. It’s been a major primetime headache for ABC, especially the showrunner musical chairs. First, Josh Reims left last year. Then Dexter’s Daniel Cerone sealed an overall deal with ABC Studios last fall and joined Dirty Sexy Money as showrunner right after the end of the writers’ strike in February. Then, in June, Cerone’s 3 already-shot episodes for the 2008-2009 season were thrown out (talk about an expensive decision), and he was replaced by Jon Harmon Feldman (whose Big Shots didn’t last very long on ABC but who had worked with Dirty Sexy Money‘s exec producer Greg Berlanti on Dawson’s Creek). So that was 3 showrunners in the show’s short lifetime. As for Eli Stone, it was also from ABC Studios/Berlanti, and it was unwatchable.
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.


A thousand tears for a thousands years for Pushing Daisies. All my meals shall now be in pie form.
What a shame. DSM and PD were good shows. I hear technically the shows have not been cancelled, but no back order given, that way the network gets to hold the actors until June and try to prevent them from getting work on other shows.
So sad to See Daisies and Eli Stone get canceled! Loved those two shows so much!
Figures. The shit rises to the top again.
Unbelievable. The best 2 shows on right now (Eli & Pushing Daisies) and they cancel them! Like I want to watch that dreadful “Dancing with the has-beens” show – gimme a break. I guess fresh ideas & good story are too expensive so they had to cut back. Talk about lame. Just for this, I am no longer going to watch Lost when it comes back in Jan. Not like anyone else was either I guess…
RIP Pushing Daisies! You will be missed!
This is one of the most creative shows on television. Another network should definitely pick it up.
Can somebody please tell me what the hell is going on over at ABC? First, they have a gay panic by getting rid of Brooke Smith of “Grey’s Anatomy” and then getting rid of Melissa George’s bi-sexual character’s story. They downgrade Rebecca Romjin’s post-op transgender character into a recurring role and they wrote out a transgender character on “Sexy Dirty Money”. Now they cancel SDM (a guilty pleasure that reminds me of the good old sadistic days of “Dynasty”) plus these other two shows. Who is running this ridiculous network? Are they going to program Dancing with the Stars every day of the week? This is why network TV is dying – idiots who don’t know what they’re doing. I’m just going to stop watching ABC. Why bother watch a show if they’re going to just cancel it? I was into “Life on Mars” but I’m going to stop watching as I’m sure that’s the next to go.
About time! It’s funny how NBC won’t cancel their crap shows that in clearly in the gutter. Why is NBC still trying to save face (same guy’s face that’s usually in a pile of snow, wink wink).
Nooo! What am I going to do with all these pies I was gonna send to ABC?
I keep hoping that having Pushing Daisies on the list is a mistake. Sure fanciful design and actual witty banter can be too much for some people, but what did they expect from another Bryan Fuller creation.
Eli Stone “unwatchable.” Wow Nikki you really have no taste when it comes to TV do ya. That or you really just have beef with Greg Berlanti. Granted Dirty Sexy Money is pretty blah but Eli Stone was decent and had a good critical following.
ABC also axed one of the mid-season shows w/ Alyssa Milano, Single With Parents, too… before it even got on the air.
Does ABC have anything left to show anymore?
Happy Holidays, Below the Liners!
Why so quick to bash everything, Nikki? I thought Eli Stone was interesting from the few episodes I caught. None of these ABC shows were appointment television, but my guess is they’ll be as good as whatever they get replaced with…
The second season premier of Eli Stone was as good as it gets on TV. I’m sorry to hear about the cancellation. As for Nicki, well, she’s still analog in her TV tastes. I bet she watches Gunsmoke reruns.
No big losses there
Sad about Pushing Daisies. Bryan Fuller just has no luck when it come to TV shows. PD, Wonderfalls and Dead Like Me were all great shows that were cancelled too soon.
Also, what the hell is going on with TV lately? Rating are pretty down across the board for most shows. What is everyone watching, or doing instead?
This is why I don’t bother with staying loyal to American network tv. Give me Dr. Who, Spooks or Merlin and I’ll manage just fine. HBO has True Blood and thats keeping me American as well as Fringe. These three shows-never heard of them. Torchwood I’ll wait for you-can’t wait for new episodes.
Do any of the dorks at the networks even want to know what people are downloading? Get a clue.
ELI STONE WAS UNWATCHABLE!! I agree w Nikki for the first time ever. Come on, people it was terrible. You people must’ve worked on it or something. you didn’t watch the same show i was watching. the Katie Holmes episode?!?! ugh…
PD was at least innovative. If NBC has any brains they will snap up Bryan Fuller and offer him whatever it takes to come back and put Heroes back on par with its first season.
Nikki,
I have followed you and your unbelievably great access to information for quite some time but saying that “Eli Stone” was unwatchable makes me think that you were already asleep at 10pm like most of the audience that would have watched and enjoyed the show had it been aired at an earlier time. Perhaps you have a limited imagination.
DSM was terrible I agree. Worst script on television !
What I find unbelievable are all these PD and DSM fans whining about how they “can’t believe” their shows were canceled.
Because it was pretty clear they would be canceled just by looking at the ratings — no one was watching those shows! Of COURSE they were going to get canceled. How does this surprise anyone at all? Both shows were lucky to get a second season.
Nikki….have you ever watched Eli Stone? It was one of the best shows on TV. Unwatchable? Seriously? Thats your commentary? I expected more from you than that.