Today, Dirty Sexy Money, Eli Stone, and Pushing Daisies were all cancelled after posting season lows among adults 18-49 this week. But ABC did order five more episodes of its new series (based on the British drama) Life On Mars. All the axed shows were marginal at best, and two were interrupted by the writers strike. Warner Bros’ Pushing Daisies was an expensive experiment. It began airing with big buzz but also had early budget and production problems from trying to sandwich 70 to 170 visual effects into every episode — so many that people considered it an unsustainable show. ABC Entertainment prez Steve McPherson called Bryan Fuller with the news: “We gave it the best shot we could.” This was also the show that ABC decided not to preempt for Barack Obama’s half-hour campaign commercial which every other major network aired. Dirty Sexy Money (ABC Studios/Berlanti) should have been put out of its misery last season. It’s been a major primetime headache for ABC, especially the showrunner musical chairs. First, Josh Reims left last year. Then Dexter’s Daniel Cerone sealed an overall deal with ABC Studios last fall and joined Dirty Sexy Money as showrunner right after the end of the writers’ strike in February. Then, in June, Cerone’s 3 already-shot episodes for the 2008-2009 season were thrown out (talk about an expensive decision), and he was replaced by Jon Harmon Feldman (whose Big Shots didn’t last very long on ABC but who had worked with Dirty Sexy Money‘s exec producer Greg Berlanti on Dawson’s Creek). So that was 3 showrunners in the show’s short lifetime. As for Eli Stone, it was also from ABC Studios/Berlanti, and it was unwatchable.
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.







Bryan Fuller is a genius. I love Berlanti too. Sad day for scripted programming.
Great. Now we can all watch “Knight Rider” or some such shit.
I was also surprised to hear you call Eli Stone unwatchable. Despite the derivative law office milieu, I thought it had some thought-provoking concepts at play that aren’t being explored elsewhere ad nauseum.
I’m very sad to hear this. I enjoyed all three shows. Pushing Daises has to be in my list of all time favorites. For what it’s worth it got a vote from me for the latest WGA awards.
“Eli Stone” unwatchable? Are you kidding? The first season’s shows were excellent. Johnny Lee Miller was very good. Did you only tune in for the Katie Holmes episode? “Pushing Daisies” was a favorite too. I totally agree about “Dirty Sexy Money” though. I watched several episodes, trying to give it a chance, but that show just never clicked.
As far as I’m concerned, anything Bryan Fuller creates is appointment television. I loved each and every minute of Pushing Daisies. I hope he tries to find another network. If not, I’m looking forward to whatever you come up with next, Bryan!
The facts are these…
I loved PD and will miss it. Hopefully Fuller gets to make the feature film version!
How can TV-writers work under those ridiculous conditions, the axe over their heads at all times? How can they come up with great multiple-episodes storylines when they don’t know if/when they’re told to “wrap things up neatly”?
More importantly: in the age of Tivo, DVRs and the internet, networks still believe in the hypothetical that is ratings and make ridiculous decisions based on them.
I would like to know: how do overseas sales and DVD sales figure into those network decisions? It boggles the mind to see that series like Stone and PD find audiences overseas and then they learn – just about into season one – that there isn’t much more to come. Do these overseas TV stations pay in apple and oranges for the rights/licenses? What gives?
BTW, Eli Stone unwatchable? I politely disagree. And yes, DSM is a guilty pleasure that grew on me as well.
Nikki!
Whoa!
“Eli Stone” is (was) one of the best shows on TV! How could you call it unwatchable?! That’s just crazy-talk, woman! I’d be curious to hear what you consider “watchable”. Warn me first though, I get the feeling I may spit-take.
I also will politely disagree about Eli Stone being unwatchable. I knew it was on borrowed time, but enjoyed just about every minute of the show (Katie Holmes big song and dance not so much).
Part of the reason I knew it was not long for this world is that I got that Grey’s Anatomy was all about pretty people who were so annoying and neurotic that you wouldn’t spend a minute with them in real life during the first season. I saw that talented actors were doing their best with shoddy hastily written scripts on Private Practice. And to scoot over to a popular CBS show that Criminal Minds was more interested in showing tortured and murdered women’s bodies then telling a story for their first season (I must admit I haven’t watched it since Mantegna joined.)
IOW, my taste and the taste of the nielsen audience that actually sits and watches live rarely cross paths.
RIP Eli, Pushing Daisies. I see Brilliant but Cancelled in your futures…
Maybe the hero of Pushing Daisies could do something for Life on Mars?
Thank you Nikki for publishing the information. I am very happy to hear Life on Mars is surviving and given additional episodes. A really fun, entertaining show to watch.
In fairness, I think ABC gave Daisies and Stone plenty of time to catch on and promoted Daisies with fervor.
Just the same, I hate to see another Bryan Fuller series go away. Steve McP, can you at least send us off with a great finale?
I am surprised at all the support for “Eli Stone.” I only watched the first couple shows last season and I agree with Nikki – unwatchable. And painfully so. Cringe-worthy in fact. I never watched another. Maybe it got much better. I’d say I’ll check it out, but, of course ABC has done away with that.
“Dirty Sexy Money” on the other hand at least was silly fun and I will miss it.
“DAISIES” HAS COME TO AN END.
A TERRIBLE AND ARTISTIC SIN.
WHILE WE TEARFULLY MOURN YOU,
I WISH I COULD TOUCH YOU
AND BRING YOU TO LIFE ONCE AGAIN.
You will notice the circle jerk of dumbassery going on as hacks hire other hacks to save hackneyed shows.
The nepotism, bias and racism in the business is sinking it everyday. Good writers like Bryan Fuller are being pulled down by the arrogant untalented “friends of the affluent.” There a time when you could nurture a show like Daisies because there were so many good shows on to help it.
The facts are these:
Pushing Daisies is one of the most brilliant shows ever to grace TV. Witty, romantic and thrilling it would do anything to please.
Dirty Sexy Money was a fantastic pilot which was ruined by McPherson who tried to turn it into the fluff that he sells every other night.
“Eli Stone” was innovative and hugely entertaining. ABC just didn’t know how to sell it and so they didn’t.
“Life On Mars” is a piece of shit but ABC is sure it will be a hit because it has already played somewhere else.
It’s amazing how people who have different taste can’t see what other people like or dislike. I like strawberry and my wife likes blueberry, but I don’t tell her she is an idiot for not liking my flavor. It’s TV and subject to everyone’s personal preference.
If you liked the show you are sad it’s gone and I’m sure you wished other people watched it because that is the reason they are going away. It’s a business and if shows don’t perform they go away. If you didn’t like the show it’s no loss to you, but you don’t have to slam the people who liked it.
Sometimes posters get a little crazy. Bring it back down to earth people.
I have NEVER met anyone (or ever heard of someone who knows someone) with a Nielsen box. Who in the world are these mysterious people who watch and have their ratings recorded??? Is it one family in Kansas or something? And why are they the only people who count? I have never thought the ratings system made sense (and it seems like it can be so easily manipulated). And do the networks take in to account DVRs? Because I think way more people are watching an enjoying these shows than are reflected in the “ratings”.
ABC!! Don’t cancel Pushing Daisies!! Cancel that atrocious, unwatchable and utterly irrelevant piece of low rated shit called Jimmy Kimmel Live and use that money to “30 Rock” Daisies. It’s a great, clever, unique show. People will find it, eventually. HOW/WHY IS KIMMEL STILL ON THE AIR!!!!?????
Nikki: “As for Eli Stone, it was also from ABC Studios/Berlanti, and it was unwatchable.”
Once, it was only figuratively unwatchable – with the ratings to prove it.
Now, it is literally unwatchable – with cancellation to ensure it.
I am intrigued by “Life on Mars” and look forward to each episode. Thanks ABC, for giving this one a chance.
Nikki, I love your reporting, but could do without your editorializing based on your own personal taste. From your constant bashing of horror films, to your bizarre characterization of “Pushing Daisies” as “marginal at best” (PD marginal? Really? Were you one of those that celebrated when “Twin Peaks” got canceled too?), you seem to be unable to interject your personal hate and snark — and in a way that doesn’t help the stories you are writing.
Expensive experiment? Sure. Didn’t connect with audiences? Yep. Mediocre? Please. It’s the cancellation of shows like “Pushing Daisies” that let the moguls you so constantly rail against maintain their status quo of corporate crap.
You want those moguls to wake up and take the talent of the industry seriously? Then support the few times that filmmakers with real voices are given a shot.
ABC = Absolutely Broken Creatively
This is really sad news for creative television. I can’t think of a single show I’ll watch on ABC now, except for Lost.
What’s happening to network television?
Network television is done. Any writer who wants to have their ideas put on screen without fear of some idiot dumbing it down is going, or has already left. Cable is the future of Dramatic television.
RIP ABC, NBC, CBS and FOX