UPDATES Who Should Direct ‘Twilight’ Sequels?
Yes, he’s had tremendous success working with tweens and teens (About A Boy as director and writer, American Pie as producer and uncredited director). But Chris Weitz also did The Golden Compass (as writer and director), and my source says Summit Entertainment liked the look of that even if it didn’t heat up the domestic box office (but did better overseas). I don’t have official confirmation yet that this Twilight sequel offer has gone out to Weitz. But my insider says another reason it came down is because Weitz and Summit’s president of production Eric Feig are longtime pals. The source tells me Weitz is “still considering” the offer to helm New Moon and possibly also Eclipse if the sequel and threequel movie adaptations of Stephenie Meyer’s series of vampire books are made back-to-back. But let’s also not forget Weitz’s behavior on Golden Compass. On December 15, 2004, Weitz announced his resignation as director of the trilogy, citing the enormous technical challenges of the epic and later admitting he was worried about dissing by the book’s fans. After another helmer came on and then walked off, Weitz returned to direct saying he’d done “a lot of growing in the interim”. Despite all that, Summit seems willing to put its first valuable franchise in his hands. Not so with Twilight director Catherine Hardwicke who’s off the sequel for a whole host of reasons I reported that fall under the “difficult” category. Sexism, anyone?






um, this just sounds like a bad idea. I get that summit needs a director fast but chris weitz? seriously? he might be able to do effects but does he really get teen angst & romance. i don’t see the twilight fans taking this choice quietly or being happy with it but i could be wrong.
I don’t see how the look of Golden Compass can be siphoned off into New Moon? They should not be in the same class visually.
Is New Line’s number unlisted or something? First they hire Hardiwcke, who had to be sedated during New Line’s NATIVITY shoot and everyone there vowed to never hire her again. Now Weitz, who basically was locked out of the editing room on COMPASS because he was overwhelmed by the CG? I LOVE Summit. They need to give Tony Kaye a film next!
Come on guys, how can you just look at one film in the director’s CV. How about writing and directing About a Boy? Or producing Nick and Norah’s infinite playlist? He knows what he’s doing with teenagers. And Compass needed a lot of CG that New Moon and Eclipse wont necessarily need.
I think it’s a fine choice. Not the BEST, but it will work.
Actually, Weitz is better than I expected. I think he could do a solid job. Which is the most that can be asked I think in a rush job with weak source material.
At least they’re not offering it to Uwe Boll…but I can see Weitz being the perfect guy for this…there’s no *way* that Bigelow (or most of the others suggested by recent comments here) would be interested in this B-level franchise…
I think this is the worst idea I’ve heard so far.
I don’t think he had one single good movie as director.
Golden compass was so so, but ” About a boy” was the stupidest by far.
Now a question to Summit. Twilight was a good teen movie. Do you want to transform the rest of the books into low crap chick flicks?
I hope this is just a rumor!
B level francise r u kidding me! this movie mad 70 millon in a weekend any director would love the chance to jump on the Twilight ship. this guy seems alright I liked most of his movies, the only problem is the Twi fandom have it in there heads who should do NM and let me tell it he is not so far up the list.
It doesn’t matter who directs it. It’s going to suck anyway.
Well what I heard (cue rumor mongering) is that Chris was a disaster with TGC, having no experience with a big effects-based movie really showed, and that he was virtually locked out of the edit room as the suits took over to try and salvage something they could screen.
None of this means he’ll be a disaster on the vampire movie front and he is clearly a pretty intelligent guy, but…
Weitz sounds like a pretty good choice if he’ll take it. I loved About a Boy and Nick and Nora. I didn’t see the Golden Compass I don’t have kids. I think the reason the Golden Compass didn’t do that well here in the states was because of the grassroots efforts against it.
I’m….Not sure about him. The Golden Compass was supposedly a HORRIBLE adaptation and well, Twilight is another adaptation. I won’t judge him yet….I actually loved Twilight even WITH the cheesy special effects because the acting, intensity, and essence was all there. Twilight was preserved beautifully. Now, well, we’ll see who Summit selects. Hopefully if it is this guy, he won’t make it a movie focusing too much on special effects. -_-
Keeping New Moon alive as well as the characters is the MOST crucial part of it all. The entire story is character-driven which is one of the reasons I love the series and the first movie. Even though Kristen and Rob have unbelievable chemistry when filming, the director needs to know how to make sure they are on track because there is such a fine line between the lines coming off as obsessive, fanatical, all consuming love and cheesy, cheap, and funky.
Camera angles, too…I don’t want them to keep switching directors and have all the movies after New Moon to feel disconnected. -Sigh- Summit has a lot of work to do.
So Feig’s going to pull a Toby Emmerich and try to hire the cool kid even though he’s completely wrong for the job. Don’t get me wrong, Weitz is a good director (not great), but would be a poor fit.
HA! Uwe Boll. Wow, awesome reference! In regards to no CG effects, most of the characters are werewolves in New Moon with complete transformation and fang on fang action (brief). You have to agree the effects as well as the action were two of the weakest parts of Twilight. Why go with a director who lacks in those areas? I vote Joss Whedon. He’s got all the credentials to knock this out of the park! Plus he’s a brilliant writer that can fix the obviously rushed script that Melissa turned in for the check.
Catherine Hardwicke did like two movies before Twilight so stop saying he has no experience when she didn’t have any either.
Plus he would be really important for the special effects for the wolves. The polar bear and all the other random animals in The Golden Compass looked absolutly amazing UNLIKE those horrible/cheezy special effects in Twilight.
You fans should be happy.
Twilight was a bad movie.
Hopefully he can do a much better job with New Moon and Eclipse.
I’m still depressed that they won’t be filming the rest of the His Dark Materials trilogy. Stupid paranoid Christians.
I loved About a Boy. I say give him a shot! I am game for anyone with big movie experience right now. Someone who understand scene continuity primarily as that was severly lacking in Twilight.
If New Moon gets made into a light teenie bopper flick- I’m going to be severly dissappointed. That is not the story- that is not the SERIES at all.
I DID NOT LIKE HARWICKE’S WORK WITH TWILIGHT.
i loved about a boy and golden compass. so i’m excited!
Come on guys we have to be reasonable, Cuaron directed Harry Potter 3 after he directed ‘Y tu mamá también’, he’s a good director, so lets just hope for the best for New Moon
What??? I really hope this IS a rumor! I personally would pick someone else. I mean Weitz??? Grr.. I’m a little mad now…Please let this be a rumor!!!
I personally thought the special effects in The Golden Compass were wonderful. I also really liked the movie About A Boy and so did the critics. What we have to remember is that the Twilght hardcore fans are not going to like whoever they pick unless it’s Stephenie Meyer herself. When Rob Pattinson was cast they went psychotically angry and blogged about what a horrible choice he was. Look at him now. He did a fantastic job and now they are on his side. I don’t think Chris Weitz will actually end up directing it but I would love to see a male directors take on New Moon. We just have to remember that whoever they pick there will be a big fuss about it and eventually all the Twilight fans will come around and be supportive. They just need to get over the initial shock.
Well, just think about it this way, it could be worse. It’s not like he’s a bad director and he’s made some interesting films besides The Golden Compass. And Golden Compass gives him more of an advantage then Hardwicke had because he has experience in CGI. Her effects were horrible and looked more like something on the sci-fi channel, but I still liked the movie.
No way…He would seriously eff up Twilight. I bet he could do a good job with the special effects, but teen angst and romance? Not a chance, he’d ruin it. Crap. This sucks.
I don’t care who directs it, I just want them, whoever they are, to do a good job (which in my opinion means pretty much using the book as the script) and doesn’t trash it at all. I wasn’t too impressed with catherine’s job with twilight, so I’m keeping my fingers crossed that the sequels will be done better.