About 300 people showed up for the protest on the other side of the street from where Saturday’s “The Night Before” fundraiser for the Motion Picture & Television Fund was being held at the Beverly Hills hotel. While Jeffrey Katzenberg and Michael Douglas gave TV interviews at the hotel with a pre-arranged list of talking points (below), celebs like Lea Thompson, David Carradine, and David Lander picketed alongside family of patients as well as caregivers at the MPTF’s acute care hospital and long-term care nursing home facing closure. (more below video)
A few networks like ABC were there to film statements by Lilly Tomlin (who was late) and the other celeb protesters. Then Katzenberg’s press conference time was suddenly pushed up, and all of the camera crews ran inside to hear what he and Michael Douglas had to say. The camera crews only returned later to film the protesters marching in the dark and grab some quick sound bytes from David Carradine and those celebs still available. The police demanded that the amplified portion of the protest — heard by the party guests gathered poolside — end at 8 PM even though the organizers had paid for the proper Beverly Hills permit to use amplification equipment and a time to stop wasn’t specified. Many of the limos pulling into the party rolled down windows to give the picketers the thumbs up. “I am hopeful there is an awareness growing for the tragedy that is taking place at the MPTF,” one of the protest’s organizers told me.
Katzenberg’s “The Night Before” Oscars party raised $6 million for the MPTF, which equaled last year’s total despite the economic crisis. So by those standards it was a great night for the financial troubled MPTF facilites.
I’ve obtained the list of talking points given to Jeff Katzenberg and Michael Douglas to say before the cameras:
MPTF CHARITY AND SERVICES
Over $15 million in residential subsidy for the 215 residents living on the Wasserman Campus in independent/assisted living and memory care.
Over $ 2 million dollars in financial assistance to 1100 industry workers impacted in 2008 by the WGA strike and general economy.
Over 5000 people supported by social services including crisis counseling and Elder Connection services helping their aging parents.
Financial support for Tuition Assistance at the Samuel Goldwyn Children’s Center.
Community Care Teams to assist seniors and their families in providing support for their ongoing care needs.
In addition, MPTF continues to provide outpatient health care at six health centers in Southern California. And MPTF services include outpatient surgery, lab, radiology, GI lab, physical and occupational therapy and pharmacy.
The Saban Health & Wellness Center is serving over 500 industry veterans and campus residents in proving their quality of life both physically and mentally.
In other news, Los Angeles journalist Andrew Gumbel who also has been following the MPTF story is reporting that the Motion Picture and Television Fund may have spent $20 million a year on what it describes as “professional fees”. His article is quite speculative, and I can’t vouch for its accuracy. He claims “some of that money — about $5.5 million according to the Fund’s tax returns — goes to pay the hundreds of doctors within the MPTF network who are not direct employees. But what about the $1.1 million listed in the 2007 tax return as ‘consulting fees’? Or the stunning $13.7 million listed as ‘management fees’?” He also quotes sources that “at least some of that money went to the Camden Group, the private medical consultancy whose reports paved the way for the decision to close the nursing home and hospital.”
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.


Michael! Let’s hear that Gordon Gekko “Greed is good!” speech again. It’s so goddamned appropriate here!
Thank you for posting this, Nikki.
Keep it in the news so these guys continue to feel the pressure.
It becomes more evident with every revelation that there are members of the board who are unaware of the truth that lies behind Katzenberg’s smokescreen. There’s no way that some of these very good people would ratify a decision to close the Long Term Care Center had they known the truth.
Where is that board member who has the balls to stand up against Katzenberg and Mancuso? When are they going to speak out?
Why did Michael Douglas look like a deer in the headlights when asked to verify some new facts about expenditures – and why did Katzenberg answer for him repeatedly?
Why wasn’t Jody Foster shown that her money could have been better spent supporting the Long Term Care facility when she was given ‘the list’ of things the MPTF needed.
It’s clear that the Board are amateurs when it comes to running a healthcare facility in these challenging times.
It’s time that these guys went back to making movies, and putting in a board of healthcare specialists.
Thanks for the continuing coverage Nikki. The story, and the number of protestors, is growing. Those who came before us created the MPTF to “take care of our own”. But the surprise plan to eliminate the nursing home part of the facility means not taking care of those who need it most!
While there is debate over income and costs for the Home, no one should be debating the need to continue this most essential program. If the board had the kinds of personal relationships with the residents that the volunteers and nursing staff had, they could never bring themselves to kick them out. These are human beings that are sweet and gracious in spite of their aggravating ailments and frailty. The MPTF has given them security and dignity. Do we really want to end that? What will become of us when we reach that stage?
An appropriate response from the MPTF’s board cannot be closure. Instead it should be a cry for help and a forthright campaign to involve all of Hollywood more fully in sustaining this asset. Not just the A-listers, but the Guilds, the studios, the leading vendors. I wanted my guild to get more involved, but it became clear that without an appeal by the board, no one is going to step forward.
We would never have gotten this far without the hard work of the film processors, gaffers, makeup artists, and character actors I have met at the Home. Losing the Long Term Care unit means losing the specialness of the MPTF and the industry at large. I’m not ready to let it die just yet.
A Film Worker and MPTF Volunteer
Get this to our Attorney General immediately and LOUDLY before a “Fixer” is sent in to sweep it under the proverbial rug! This whole thing stinks to high heaven and has to be investigated from top to bottom, along with EVERYONE connected with it!
A poignant report from the Motion Picture Hospital: Long term care residents watched news reports from the gala & protest on Saturday night. When they heard Michael Douglas saying nothing could be done, they wept. Shame on Michael Douglas. According to someone close to the late Jack Brodsky, the Romancing the Stone producer would not be pleased with Mr. Douglas’ role in this MPTF debacle.
MPTF Watch
re: Toss comment
It was Tillman and the health care specialists who worked for four or more years at setting the Board up for the final act. Tillman sought national recognition for his vision of the future, and he sure found it, didn’t he? We don’t need any more of him or his regime around. Next time, hire a CEO who is truly compassionate and give her/him a mandate to save the Fund’s legacy, not to destroy it.
What I love about this story is that when thousands upon thousands of Americans have had their entire retirement medical benefits eradicated by corporate decison-makers, more interest and publicity is given to these 130 ex-actors, actresses, etc. Why don’t actors, producers, directors, writers, etc. “take care of their own?” Lord knows they’ve got money; however,
LaLa land is such a place of wonderment and craziness, but disconnected from the rest of the U.S.A. and to a degree reality.
Although it’s understandable to say things like “…it’s time that these guys went back to making movies, and putting in a board of healthcare specialists…” I respectfully would like to add, “Not so fast!” Much too easy a solution for what is going on here. There actually may have been a history of collusion going on that should be investigated immediately! How were the “charitable” contributions managed? Where are the complete, unadulterated records of the investments and the paid in – paid outs? If these and a slew of other questions are answered and all rules were followed to the letter, then – and only then – will the above mentioned solution work. This is a “get tough” situation. Get tough and take back our MPTF!
An inside source just told me that management has told employees that they should not read the sites because of all of the negative press. They should focus on their jobs. They also stated to employees that no amount of negative press and outside pressure is going to change their minds – they are still moving forward with their plans to close LTC and the hospital!
I have several questions:
- Where is the law firm that is representing the families of those being evicted?
- Where are the film and television stars and why are they not speaking out? Does Katzenberg wield that much power that they are all afraid of him? Please, he is almost a has been and if he loses his quest in closing LTC he clearly will be (a has been with the stigma of the damage he caused).
- Who is organizing groups to counter this disaster? We have seen rallies but it is unclear who the organizers are. Clearly Katzenberg and Tillman are aware of this. So how do we organize? I see a lot of compassionate people on the blogs but no where to sign up and take action. Enough is enough – it is time to move. Actors, guilds, unions, studios stand up NOW!
- And this one is for Michael Douglas. Have you no shame? Your father is one step from being a patient at MPTF and if he was there and needed further help, he would be ousted. Is this what you want for him as well as for the others? Talk to Catherine – maybe she has some compassion. How could you turn on your brothers and sisters? I guess “Greed IS good”. (Ps. You looked like an ass on television)
Lastly, I ask that everyone go on the MPTF site and read the history of how the MPTF came about. It involved caring people who were able to involve all industry people in an organized and methodical plan. And the times were no different then than now (1920 and 30”s vs. today – if anything, times were tougher then). That is why the damage these 4 men (Katzenberg, Mancuso, Tillman and Ellis) have done is so contrary to what was achieved in the beginning days of MPTF.
What the MPTF Board and Administration is actively putting the Residents of Long Term Care and all other campus Residents through is despicable.
It’s Elder abuse. The MPTF decision heads will be held accountable I’m certain.
MPTF CEO David Tillman along with Seth Ellis promised everyone attending the Residents Family meetings on January 21st and 23rd, that no action to vacate would be taken by the Fund for at least 60 days.
They LIED!
MPTF Social Workers are hustling, not by the Residents initiative, to get Residents to quit and vacate NOW.
Several sources have already come forward to confirm it being true.
I am telling everyone to please hold your ground until you get a written notice with a firm date to vacate. Then lets see where legal takes it. Our case is growing stronger everyday. MPTF is counting on us to give up. If we force their hand they will be going to court.
Then lets see what dirty BIG secrets get uncovered.
Clooney’s efforts on behalf of Darfur – A Noble Effort…
Pitt’s efforts on behalf of Katrina victims – A Noble Effort…
DiCaprio’s efforts to save the planet – A Noble Effort…
Jolie’s efforts on behalf of the UN Refugee Agency – A Noble Effort…
Spielberg’s efforts on behalf of Shoah – A Noble Effort…
Clooney’s, Pitt’s, DiCaprio’s, Jolie’s, Spielberg’s efforts on behalf of MPTF? – Not so Noble…
(At least publicly)
Of course the list of “Noble Efforts” is much, much longer, and the list of “Not So Noble” efforts even longer, but you get the point…
As insiders striving for justice for all concerned, we urge everyone to HANG IN THERE and be patient because the Wheels of Justice are turning! It would be inappropriate to discuss strategy on this site, but most importantly, know that great efforts are being made to secure our goals of keeping the MPTF Long-Term Care facility open, insuring the future of the MPTF Long-Term Care facility, and restoring MPTF’s commitment to its historic Mission – Taking Care of Our Own.
Meaning no disrespect…What exactly does “insiders striving for justice” mean? Just the reference to “Insiders” sends up a red flag. Is there a law firm involved? Is there an attorney involved? Are there court papers being prepared to file? Will we be seeing any “Perp Walks” anytime soon?
MPTF hasn’t had any communication with it’s employees in over a month. The other day an email was sent that there will be meetings in the future to discuss any questions employees have.
The transistion for some of the residents who have been moved has not been easy. They want to know when they can come ‘home’. Those still at MPTF ask why this is happening, and are in a state of disbelief that this could be going on.
There is no compassion among the executives, especially Seth Ellis. If you saw him on the news a few weeks ago, you can see he has no feelings at all.
Dr Tillman said on MPTF’s channel 22 that no amount of money will keep the Long Term open. There is another agenda here and no one knows but the board and executives.
As far as the millions spent on consulting and management fees- Some executives are not qualified for their jobs and outside help is needed. Some consultants and management fees are outright frauds. Someone else is pocketing money and hopefully someone on the outside is looking into all this. There is so much waste.
The Fitness center and Jodie Foster pool are the one positive at MPTF. Both have helped the residents and those in the industry. It is the only bright spot on this horrible event.
Dr Tillman, Seth Ellis and Ken Scherer should resign. The board should be brought down. We need an independent outsider to come unravel this mess that they have caused.
jimmy b. – michael douglas doesn’t have to worry. the unit HIS family donated wil remain open. Isn’t it ironic that its the only LTC unit, the oldest building btw, that will remain open. It will house 30 patients. this is why mikee doesn’t care. his family project will go untouched. coincindence??
Anonymous commenter-there are no “perp walks”-your comment was disrespectful, like it or not – those walks are done by people who care. be it employees, or families and friends. they care about those patients. you may not agree with it, but be respectful of the love they have for the patients. we have adopted many of those patients, some of them have no one but us on a daily basis. they see us, not social workers or ceo’s. we cry when they die, we smile with them, we hold their hands, not you.
I just visted the home today, to go to the doctor. It surely is a sad shame — why is this corruption allowed to continue?
I say yes, the attorney general needs to be involved. This is elder abuse. Those sweet elderly actors deserve better than this.
May God put his hand on this situation – and hopefully some outspoken A-lister can help to hire the proper investigative people to get involved.
Again, the producers are behind this, they are phasing out all health care very soon, mark my words. They truly are rotten to the core, bottom line is all that matters.