My commenters and emailers are pointing out whom AMPAS failed to honor this year. (Please let me know if there are more names.) There’s outrage over missing Patrick McGoohan, so good in Braveheart. Also Eartha Kitt. I think my pals Bernie Brillstein and Guy McElwaine weren’t included. Don LaFontaine, THE voiceover artist on most film promotion, was omitted even though he was also the voice of the Oscars. Not included was George Carlin. And it’s inexplicable why Irv Brecher, one of the movies’ greatest writers and actually nominated for an Oscar (Meet Me in St. Louis) was left off the list. I’m told Irv’s widow was devastated that he wasn’t shown onscreen. After all, he was the only writer to receive sole credit for a Marx Bros movie (At the Circus and Go West.) He also wrote the screenplay for Bye, Bye, Birdie and Dubarry Was A Lady — not to mention directed Ernie Kovacs in his last movie, and Robert Wagner in his first. How could they not have paid tribute to him? Because he starred in a YouTube video that was instrumental to keeping morale high during last year’s writers strike? And, one of my commenters points out, “It’s interesting that they included film critic Manny Farber this year, although in 1999 they refused to include Gene Siskel despite much lobbying from Roger Ebert. I think at the time they said film critics were not part of the Academy, so it wasn’t appropriate to include him. Was this a one-time exception, or will the ‘In Memoriam’ montage include critics from now on?” (Heath Ledger was prominent in last year’s.)
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.






Didn’t see Brad Renfro…again.
I thought Patrick McGoohan died in January, which according to my quick unofficial survey of several calenderical experts, was in 2009.
Patrick McGoohan died in January 13, 2009.
They didn’t include Brad Renfro for last year’s memorium, either because they said he wasn’t a member of the Academy or whatever. so maybe George Carlin wasn’t a member, either?
Donald Westlake
Dec. 31, 2008
Guy McElwaine died last year and wasn’t mentioned. Major agent and studio exec.
Nikki,
Perhaps you can learn of the Academy selection process. I know for a fact that all those names were considered, yet for some reason chosen not to be included. Through the years, outsiders (like family members or fan clubs) have campaigned the Academy to insure that certain indivduals would not be left out – with very little success.
What is the mysterious process? How does the Academy choose Robert Doqui over Patrick McGoohan? I’m not suggesting that one is more deserving over another. But when the Academy chooses to omit the likes of Patrick McGoohan and Bernie Brillstein in favor of others, they are certainly making that suggestion.
They also forgot Guy M, who certainly should have been mentioned.
They didn’t include Joaquin Phoenix, but I guess it was too late, and “in memoriam” is about lives not careers.
The tribute section is always an embarrassment, but frankly, this year’s was by far the worst (and not just because of Queen Latifah’s awful song). Because of the half-assed choice of not showing the deceased and their name up on the TV screen — as opposed to the monitors at the Kodak Theater — it was impossible to tell who was or wasn’t eulogized. I literally blinked and missed Ricardo Montalban; it wasn’t until now that I realized the great Patrick McGoohan — who died on the exact same day as Montalban — was omitted. The weird dutch angles and focus on the side monitors (showing clips on the side) prevented you from getting a good look at things. In a show that was largely an embarrassment, this section — already under fire for missing Brad Renfro the year before — sticks out like a sore thumb.
Eartha Kitt.
Eartha Kitt?
The In Memoriam segment was poorly done. We got shots of TV screens with photos/names from afar while the camera tried to capture Queen Latifah singing (bad taste/lame). I personally had a hard time even reading most of the names and we heard no audience reaction throughout.
I also heard they left out Estelle Getty?
It’s interesting that they included film critic Manny Farber this year, although in 1999 they refused to include Gene Siskel despite much lobbying from Roger Ebert. I think at the time they said film critics were not part of the Academy, so it wasn’t appropriate to include him. Was this a one-time exception, or will the “In Memoriam” montage include critics from now on?
Am I wrong or do you need to have been an Academy member to be included?
A few years ago, many of us lobbied–very hard– for our friend the late Adrienne Shelley to be included and were told that because she wasn’t a member of the Academy that she could not be memorialized.
Short-sighted at best; obnoxious at worst.
This addenda is hardly complete, and not all of these people were exclusively in movies, but many made at least one mark on the silver screen in addition to those on the cathode ray iteration: Barry Morse, John Phillip Law, director Joseph Pevney, Harvey Korman, Mel Ferrer, Fred Crane (the other Tarleton Twin), Edie Adams, director Milton Katselas, Paul Benedict, Robert Prosky, Sam Bottoms. Writers are especially ignored: Sir Arthur C. Clarke, Gregory Mcdonald, William Gibson (the “Miracle Worker” Gibson, not the cyber Gibson), Tad Mosel, Forrest J. Ackerman. Also, Brad Renfro and Suzanne Pleshette (or were they in last year’s necrology?).
What about Anita Page, who died in September of 2008? She was widely touted as the “last star of the silents” before her death. She had a famous turn in “Our Dancing Daughters” with Joan Crawford, but the film that made her a legend, “The Broadway Melody,” was the first sound film to win an Oscar. Incidentally, she was also probably the last living person to have attended the first Academy Awards.
What about Anita Page, who died in September of 2008? She was widely touted as the “last star of the silents” before her death. She had a famous turn with Joan Crawford in “Our Dancing Daughters,” but her status as an icon was secured by her starring role in “The Broadway Melody,” the first sound film to win an Oscar. Incidentally, she was probably the last living person to have attended the first Academy Awards.
FYI, here’s a list of the people they *did* honor, in the honor they mentioned them:
Cyd Charisse
Bernie Mac
Bud Stone (executive)
Ollie Johnston (animator)
Van Johnson
J. Paul Huntsman (sound editor)
Michael Crichton (producer writer director)
Nina Foch
Pat Hingle
Harold Pinter (writer)
Charles H. Joffe (producer)
Kon Ichikawa (director)
Charles H. Schneer (producer)
Abby Mann (screenwriter)
Roy Scheider
David Watkin (director of photography)
Robert Mulligan (director)
Evelyn Keyes
Richard Widmark
Claude Berri (director)
Maila Nurmi (“Vampira”)
Isaac Hayes (actor musician)
Leonard Rosenman (composer)
Ricardo Montalban
Manny Farber (film critic)
Robert DoQui
Jules Dassin (director)
Paul Scofield
John Michael Hayes (screenwriter)
Warren Cowan (publicist)
Joseph M. Caracciolo (producer)
Stan Winston (special effects)
Ned Tanen (producer executive)
James Whitmore
Charlton Heston
Anthony Minghella (director producer)
Sydney Pollack (director producer actor)
Paul Newman
In the past, the Academy has set a time limit on including names, so I’m almost certain they mean to have McGoohan (who died in January) or Kitt (who died on Christmas Day) on next year’s list (and maybe even Brecher who died in November). Otherwise, with all due respect to Robert DoQui and Vampira, how can they justify the omissions?
And why didn’t they include Heath Ledger?
Thank you so much for this post Nikki… I may be the commenter who originally brought up the McGoohan omission… I was and am a huge fan of his work and I almost wonder if the fact he was somewhat anti-authority (see the Prisoner) made some decisionmaker mix him… The man turned down James Bond for pete’s sake!
The ceremony included a tribute to the “Hollywood Musical!” but “In Memoriam” left out the screenwriter for “Meet Me in St. Louis” and “Bye Bye Birdie.” That’s a disgrace.
who cares! the pettiness of who was and wasn’t showcased. it’s soooo high school. but then again this whole industry is!
Suzanne Pleshette was in last year’s ‘In Memoriam’ clipshow. Where was Renfro, Anita Page, Patrick McGoohan, Eartha Kitt, Harvey Korman, Edie Adams, Mel Ferrer (Audrey Hepburn’s first hubby), Susanna Foster?
I was perplexed years ago when Stanley Kramer didn’t make the cut. His films were nominated for 85 Oscars and he was one of the rare producers to get the Academy’s Irving G. Thalberg award. Was a glaring omission that I never understood. At least Sidney Poiter mentioned him during an acceptance or presenting speech but really not the same. Hmm….
I have to mention that Patrick McGoohan starred in one of the coolest jazz movies ever called “All Night Long”, a British film from 1962. He was the scheming JOHNNY COUSIN, an ambitious drummer trying to start his own jazz band. Inter-racial couples, spliff smoking, the film was pretty daring for its time, loosely based on Othello. Plus, performances by Gerry Mulligan, Charles Mingus and more. And of course Eartha Kitt.
Forrest J Ackerman
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forrest_J_Ackerman
An ICON in the Science Fiction/Fantasy community. Even created the term “Sci-Fi”. Had cameos in over 200 movies. Led tours for fans of his legendary memorabilia collection at his home in Los Angeles for 50+ years.
His Bacon number was 2, so there.
Forry is FAR more important than 98% of the list that made it into the show, and second only to Heston and Newman.