EXCLUSIVE: I’m told that Peter Gabriel just pulled out of performing at the Academy Awards show. In a letter to the Academy Of Motion Picture Arts And Sciences, the co-writer and performer of Wall-E‘s “Down To Earth” says he doesn’t think the nominated songs, and their writers and performers, are getting enough respect during this year’s Oscars telecast. That’s because the show’s producers, Larry Mark and Bill Condon, have reduced the song segment to a medley of the three songs nominated for “achievement in music written for motion pictures (Original Song)” — “Down to Earth” from WALL-E (Walt Disney), with music by Gabriel and Thomas Newman and lyric by Gabriel; “Jai Ho” from Slumdog Millionaire (Fox Searchlight) with music by A.R. Rahman nd lyric by Gulzar; and “O Saya” from Slumdog Millionaire (Fox Searchlight) with music and lyric by A.R. Rahman and Maya Arulpragasam. I’m told the producers have slotted 90 seconds in the medley for each song sung by its original performer. But Gabriel said in his letter that he was only being offered 65 seconds for his song. “I don’t feel that is sufficient time to do the song justice, and I have decided to withdraw from performing,” Gabriel informed AMPAS. “I fully respect and look forward to the producers’ right to revamp the show. Even though song writers are small players in the filmmmaking process, they are just as committed and work just as hard as the rest of the team, and I regret that this new version of the ceremony is being created in part at their expense.” I’m told that the medley is the brainchild of the producers in their attempt to get the Oscar show’s running time down to 3 hours — which, frankly, would be a miracle given that it usually runs more than 4 hours. No word yet on whom the producers will choose to sing in place of Gabriel.
UPDATE: Here is the text of Peter Gabriel’s letter:
“I was delighted when “Down to Earth” was nominated for an Oscar. I was also pleased to have been asked to perform the song in the Oscar ceremony. However, in recent discussions with the Producers, it became clear that despite there being only three nominees, only 60-65 seconds was being offered, and that was also in a medley of the three songs. I don’t feel that is sufficient time to do the song justice, and have decided to withdraw from performing.
I fully respect and look forward to the Producers’ right to revamp the show. Even though song writers are small players in the film making process, they are just as committed and work just as hard as the rest of the team and I regret that this new version of the ceremony is being created, in part, at their expense.”
I still very much look forward to attending the ceremony.”






Amen Peter!
As if Peter Gabriel weren’t already cool enough (his music, the Witness project, his support for Amnesty International), he once again does the right thing, gracefully.
Sucks that he won’t be singing there, but Hugh Jackman should have plenty of singing and dancing! Can’t wait for 4 hours of that!
There’s not enough respect for animated films, period. Films like “Waltz with Bashir” and “Persepolis” could have been easily nominated for Best Aninated Feature, despite being in foreign languages. Doing that would have increase mores respect and competition for the category. But no, the Academy board won’t do that.
Hence, how can anyone take that category seriously when “BOLT” and “KUNG FU PANDA” are nominated? Seriously.
and the Bruce Springsteen song from The Wrestler should have gotten a nod, too, but nope.
The Oscars has become a JOKE. Good for Gabriel for refusing to perform.
The producers were gifted the biggest selling film composer in history, one of the hottest rappers alive, and a respected veteran with a large fan base, and they want to stuff them into a 270 second montage? Insanity.
They’re messing with the songs now? As in, one of the few parts of the telecast worth watching?
Simple solution for the Oscars: make a rule that in order to be nominated, a film must have been released WIDE by the end of the year. This year the nominees were announced a day before Frost/Nixon, Milk & The Reader opened wide. Maybe people would tune in if they’d actually seen some of the movies nominated.
Way to go Peter! I can’t believe the producers would try such a rude nonsensical ploy to get the show run time down. This year the songs are great and I was really looking forward to seeing them performed. This Oscar cast has disaster written all over it.
I agree with “College Student” that the songs were one of the more interesting oscar segments to watch.
Watch, they’ll get Phil Collins.
Dammit! WTF are you thinking Bill and Larry? Down to Earth is one of the best songs from a movie in years, and the Slumdog songs have a lot of show potential. Cutting three songs from the show into a silly medley is not at all going to cut the show time down. Get your heads out of your asses.
Quick! Get Phil Collins on the phone! And they wonder why the Oscar® ceremony has become such a joke.
Bill Condon and Larry Mark are “Music Guys”—perhaps it’s ABC-TV executives who are telling them to cut this year’s music because the ABC executives feel that the music nominations this year will bring down ratings ? But- hey- the second that Hugh Jackman bolts out into song and dance is the second that I turn off the broadcast and is also the second that I refuse to purchase a ticket to his new Wolverine movie.
Here are some suggestions for the bozos to get higher ratings for the Oscars.
1. Of the currently televised Oscar categories, here are the ones that need to be televised.
2. Of the current categories from sections 1-5 in the televised list, I would break it down to three divisions: Best Dramatic Picture, Best Comedtic Picture, Best Action Picture. As it now stands, they are slighting too many movies. As of now, Heath Ledger deserves his Oscar for his performance in The Dark Knight, but Dark Knight deserves Best Picture in the Action category though Iron Man may have something to say about that. And lets not forget Robert Downey Jr. for his performance in Iron Man. Yes you will not please everyone, but the Oscars need reinvention and fast.
3. Move the ceremony from February to May while the list of elegible films would include everything that premiered in theaters from March 1st of the elegible year to February 28 or 29 of the next year though more films would be elegible this year (2010 Oscars) due to the date change. The new date would be for the first Sunday of May and this would help to clear a busy February which has so many special events that the new Sweeps months could likely be mid October to mid November, January, and May.
Part of the reason why the Oscars could have scored lower last year is because FOX’s NASCAR coverage was delayed into primetime and past it. A Rain delay with a promise of a race to come was enough to keep viewers away from the Oscars. This year, FOX will likely keep viewers away from the Oscars by running an actual race. To make matters worse, the WWE has scheduled its “No Way Out” Pay Per View for the same time as the Oscars. I am pretty much guessing that Wrestling Fans will either order the PPV or follow it over the internet. They wouldn’t care less what happens to Mickey Rourke at the ceremony. They care more about his appearance at WrestleMania 25.
4. The Ceremony needs a comic host, but not even that will help the Oscars. I am maybe guessing that this years producers went after Jay Leno for hosting, but I am guessing that the WGA rebuffed their efforts. With that said, I would have given David Letterman every single incentive, and even beg Dave, on the Late Show itself, to host this year’s Oscars. Plan C would have been for Rosie O’Donnell to host. Even an unconventional host such as Oprah would have been better than Hugh Jackman.
5. As for any category that I didn’t mention that happens to be in the main telecast, that should be moved to the technical ceremony.
You’re exaggerating, it does not run over 4 hours. Some years it does approach four – the show itself, don’t include the :30 minute red carpet show before – but the awards usually runs 3.5 hrs, give or take. Granted, that’s still too long. But cut them some slack, they can’t please everyone, and everyone’s got a different solution to make the show better.
I had such high hopes for the new producers’ approach, but this stupid decision of theirs really hurts the show.
I absolutely support Peter and really hope other performers will walk away from this travesty too.
It’s easy to bag on Phil Collins, but I think I remember back in 1985 that he wasn’t even allowed to sing “Against All Odds” on the broadcast. Congrats to Peter Gabriel for taking a stand and to the producers for providing an obvious toilet break for viewers with this ill-fated medley.
Wow, that’s ridiculous. I completely agree with Pete and can’t believe they’re cutting it down to just 65-90 seconds. I was only 10 in 1998, but I can still remember Celine Dion singing “My Heart Will Go On” (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bEyB8YSfo9g) and Robin Williams singing “Blame Canada” in 2000 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gc0JveFySB4).
Of the currently televised Oscar categories, here are the ones that need to be televised.
Sniff. The Oscars are not the TMZ Awards, and if you wanna limit the awards to the marquee names, that’s what you’re getting.
Signed- Sound Designer and his DP Girlfriend.
MEMO : To Regional Corporate Manager
Dear Mr. Lincoln :
Huge lifetime fans of Springsteen here. Way back to the end of our “historic” campaign at least if not even WEEKS before.
But the ongoing complaints about “The Wrestler” song “One Trick Pony?”
Very effective at the movie’s “Sopranos”-like closing blank screen…
but thematically substitute rock star as show biz profession for wrestler…and you get Paul Simon’s “One Trick Pony” from the movie soundtrack of the same name.
Could it be the Boss is getting a little lazy Abe?
His Grammy?
“Girls in Their Summer Clothes?”
Nice song…but the original was Irwin Shaw’s short story “Girls in Their Summer Dresses.”
The song’s Blessing Avenue was Fifth Avenue in the story.
He’s always had literary influence and homage (which I’ve always liked – rock n’ roll is always about that which came before almost by definition) but these “homage(s)” seem(s) teetering on the brink of glaring.
Make sure that Bruce re-stocks those shelves. Makes them pretty. We got a Doorbuster scheduled for Presidents’ Day and we wanna get some people trampled to get at unbelievably low prices of American made durable goods that they don’t really need.
Now let’s sell this stimulus with our only recent EXCLUSIVE print interview designed to send an EXCLUSIVE message to “our kind” about its myriad of possible applications.
Thanks for the campaign appearances. You really know how to draw people together in ways that we will never be able to do. Not even close.
Sincerely,
Barack H. and Michele Obama
c.c. F.D.R.
J.F.K.
Jackie O.
Lincoln
b.c.c. Gwen Ifill
Oprah Winfrey
Andrew Leon Talley, Vogue
Black Enterprise
David Axelrod
90 seconds? 65 seconds? 10 seconds? Who cares? Until today I was not aware anybody even paid attention to the songs. And for the record, they all suck
can anyone even hum a line from this song? I think we will live.
do you all really care? when was the last time some one above the line played nice with you. Peter should be given a atta boy pat on the back for not bowing down to the Oscar Gods, Hats off to you!!
Non-Union Wal Mart Shift Supervisor,
Please go back to Drudge where you belong.
Peter Gabriel remains the same – performance , oscar or not – he is A LEGEND !!!