Interesting how the same Hollywood moguls who say the necessary millions can’t be raised for the expansion and modernization of the Motion Picture & Television Fund’s acute care hospital and longterm care nursing home are instead meeting lofty fundraising goals for the expansion and modernization of the USC School Of Cinematic Arts. But then we know the reason for that: one institution is producing tomorrow’s talent whom the studios and networks can then exploit for years to come. And the other simply houses yesteryear’s old and sick and used-up workers.
Don’t get me wrong. Supporting institutions of higher learning is a wonderful thing. Especially when they’re already well-funded private schools like USC. A news release just issued on the occasion of SCA’s 80th anniversary and the opening of its new campus lavishes praise on the Fox Entertainment Group, The Walt Disney Studios, Warner Bros, the Fran and Ray Stark Foundation, the Dana and Albert R. “Cubby” Broccoli Foundation, and Marilyn and Jeffrey Katzenberg, among many other prominent individuals and foundations who have contributed significantly to SCA’s fundraising goals.
Interesting, too, how Hollywood moguls have clammed up about the MPTF despite so many journalists’ requests. But on March 29, SCA will open its doors to the media when the school’s long-time supporters George Lucas, Steven Spielberg and Jeffrey Katzenberg join USC in a press conference presenting the all-new complex.
In 2006, SCA broke ground and kicked off the current campaign to construct and equip a new state-of-the-art campus. Since that time, the school worked with Industry leaders and others to raise nearly $125 million, but continues to try to raise the additional $50 million needed to complete the project in 2010.
Said Dean Elizabeth Daley: “We are incredibly proud of our close and valued ties to the entertainment industry. For decades, the generosity of our industry colleagues has been vital for our continued growth and renewal. We believe, as do our colleagues, that their contributions are investments in the future of cinema, and toward the progress and achievement of our mutual goals.”
Interesting as well how the Hollywood moguls said that a new state-of-the-art acute care MPTF hospital was too ambitious a project to undertake. Yet SCA’s new campus represents the most ambitious cinema school project in the U.S., anchored by a 137,000-square-foot main complex, which includes a massive courtyard/gathering space, eight screening rooms, 19 conference rooms, three sound mixing rooms, six picture editorial labs and ample exhibition space. Under construction are the 38,000-square-foot Animation and Digital Arts building, four sound stages with a combined actual production space of over 7,000 square feet, and a production equipment center. Also planned for the future is the Cinematic Arts Park, usable for exterior location filming.
Interesting that I tried, and failed, to get the MPTF to tell me which Hollywood studios and individuals and foundations had contributed to the MPTF and how much. But the USC press release is proud to detail what groups and individuals are forking over:
– Fox Entertainment Group has contributed funds to build and outfit the Fox Sound Stage, one of four sound stages currently under construction adjacent to the main complex. Fox Entertainment Group is also establishing the Fox Fellowship Endowment Fund. The program will support third-year students enrolled in the school’s Interactive Media Division.
– The Walt Disney Studios has funded the construction and outfitting of The Walt Disney Studios Screening Room, a state-of-the-art student facility in the main administrative/instructional complex.
– Warner Bros has funded the construction and outfitting of the Warner Bros Screening Room.
– The Stark Foundation has contributed to the construction and outfitting of two screening theatres: the Stark Family Theatre and the Fanny Brice Theatre.
– Marilyn and Jeffrey Katzenberg’s recent contributions will be directed toward instructional/production structures adjacent to the main complex.
– The Broccoli Foundation is funding a screening room, The Broccoli Family Theatre.
– THX sound system creator Tomlinson Holman is overseeing the installation of all screening room and theatre sound systems.
– Recently pledged contributions of support include notable alums John August, Ashley and David Kramer, Peter Segal, Stacey Sher, and Jana and Stephen Sommers, as well as The Jack Oakie and Victoria Horne Oakie Charitable Foundation, Salon Films Ltd and Spike TV.
– Industry contributions and pledges previously announced include the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, the Alma and Alfred Hitchcock Foundation, the Dana and Albert R. “Cubby” Broccoli Foundation, the Hugh M. Hefner Foundation, the Lucasfilm Foundation, and Entertainment Partners.
– “Together, these groups and individuals have named rooms and community spaces within the buildings, making the complex truly supported by a large community of alumni and friends,” the USC press release concludes.
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.


Sick to the bones!
Between these fools supporting a fraud for “President” and crap like this, no wonder the rest of the world laughs at Hollywood people. This is pathetic and embarrassing.
It could be that many, like me, don’t see any value to an industry specific hospital or long term care facility. The same $ value would likely be much better targeted at supporting those retirees’ expenses at regular facilities. Best medical practice is focusing on expert hospitals that do sufficient numbers of a given procedure to keep surgeons at the forefront of the field and well versed in the issues of a given procedure.
This issue is just tired unionist crap, just part of the ongoing smear campaign against studio execs. They do more than enough actually vile things, no need to gin up a fake controversy.
I went to film school & all I got was 120,000 in debt and a few friends who immediately quit the business. I would have been better off just giving my money to USC like these other clowns.
KATZENBERG AGAIN!! The little hypocrite!
Why can’t we orgaize a picket line to embarrass these sons of bitches on their big day? The media would LOVE to report this – and just think – we could ask: What’s more important? Saving LIVES or having a building NAMED after you?
I’m so sick of this, I cannot tell you. These men & women HAVE to be hung out to dry in the media.
(maybe that will lead them to wisdom, as they say)
Maybe the President could mention the MPTF situation tonight on his Leno appearance, as he explains his stimulus package, corporate bailouts and bonuses awarded to major corporations.
Strange that Jeffrey Katzenberg, George Lucas, Steven Speilberg who are getting up there in years wouldn’t have more compassion for our old industry people. I don’t get it. Is it that they want to look “cool” to the youngins and don’t want to look in the mirror? Our industry has to remember and herald those who came before us, yet they choose to throw old artists away. I don’t understand it. Weird psychology. It’s wrong. But then again being young in Hollywood is where the work is. Being old is not – for that matter America has always put youth up on a a pedestal, whereas other countries revere old people with grace and wisdom.
I’ll play amateur psychologist here and say that maybe these old guys JK, SS and the rest of ‘em – maybe it feeds their egos and makes them feel young to do this. They wax poetic about their early days at ‘SC and want to somehow get that feeling back and funding this will get those old endorphins coursing through their old brains again.
Trouble is – they’re old too. This is just typical of the way Americans work and I am quite sure there is some return on the dollars that their giving to USC. Where MPTF is simply charity for the elderly.
There but for the grace of God go I – guys.
As someone who graduated in 2000, no sour grapes or anything, but I can’t really put my finger on exactly what the school was lacking in terms of facilities. It was a little grungy, but really no more so than the average studio lot. The real reason for the expansion was to increase the number of students they can grab $40k a year from, not only in production but now in their humungous digital interactive multimedia facilities. USC Cinema, apparently taking a page from DeVry and Full Sail and scam mail-order colleges, is teaching people “how to write the next great videogame.” Then again, this might be sour grapes… people with a USC film degree have always been a pretty exclusive club, and you generally know everyone in your class by name, and the small size made the school a great way to make connections (this aspect was probably worth more money than the actual skills education).
I’m curious what the ongoing pedagogical focus of the place is going to be as the classes become bigger; they were always hurting for good faculty, and some of their best teachers and support people have moved to LMU over the past few years. I do also wonder how all these donors justify their giving, or has it just become an ego game? Then again Ray Stark spent $50m in 1982 dollars on Annie, so maybe they don’t really have any perspective any more (don’t ask me how I’m so acquainted with Ray Stark’s resume and Columbia’s pre-Coca-cola days).
PS. NF could get in trouble buy going around claiming that Tom Holman invented THX, since Lucasfilm let him go and systematically tried to erase him from the history of the thing, and I believe the official line at this point is “George Lucas challenged a group of engineers to realize his vision,” or somesuch.
PPS. MPTF shafted how horrible. The solution is clear, we need merely to draft Dean Daley into running the MPTF.
These two posts appeared earlier and have still not been answered with any amount of transparency!
EARLIER POSTS:
#
As insiders striving for justice for all concerned, we urge everyone to HANG IN THERE and be patient because the Wheels of Justice are turning! It would be inappropriate to discuss strategy on this site, but most importantly, know that great efforts are being made to secure our goals of keeping the MPTF Long-Term Care facility open, insuring the future of the MPTF Long-Term Care facility, and restoring MPTF’s commitment to its historic Mission – Taking Care of Our Own.
Comment by Anonymous — March 2, 2009 @ 6:34 pm
#
Meaning no disrespect…What exactly does “insiders striving for justice” mean? Just the reference to “Insiders” sends up a red flag. Is there a law firm involved? Is there an attorney involved? Are there court papers being prepared to file? Will we be seeing any “Perp Walks” anytime soon?
Comment by Anonymous — March 3, 2009 @ 10:56 am
I agree, leave the studio executives alone!!!!! when will someone stand up for the executives against the evil unions that control everything?
Nikki, why are you pointing out this supposed hypocrisy when you are missing the real culprit……Obama! Somehow he’s to blame for this. That’s the story you should be working on.
Most of the people on that list are alumni of USC Cinema. Newsflash, Nikki: people donate to their alma maters.
The MPTF situation is awful, but that doesn’t mean you get to nitpick where people choose to donate their money. Ultimately it’s theirs to donate, and universities are worthy causes. If your argument was that perhaps USC should be giving that money to its students in the form of scholarships to offset the extremely high cost of tuition, that would be a different matter. Unlike the rest of USC, the cinema program is not overrun with rich kids from Orange County, and film students often graduate with only a thesis film and tens of thousands of dollars of debt to their name. Wealthy alumni could better serve current students by attaching a few strings to how their monetary gifts are spent. Cinema students need fewer state of the art buildings and more low interest loans. In fact, all students could use more low interest loans.
Tired union crap? What a crock, BB.
The hospital has been around since Charlie Chaplin started it. It’s important for the BTL workers and others who gave so much without making much at all.
You want to throw them in the Bedsore Inn to die? All because you know, “It’s tired union crap?”
Gawd, give it a rest.
These people donated to the MPTF from the dues and their own assets (Homes, Bank Accounts) with the PROMISE the MPTF would be there for them.
They are effectively being kicked to the street.
After all, which sounds better as you brag about your latest contribution? “Ah, my name is on the Dialysis Center.” Or “Ah, my name is on the USC Film School”
It’s not hard to figure how the ego for these folks works.
It is obvious to me that two of the above comments have little to do with the issue of the Industry promist to “Take Care of Our Own.” Workers give their lives, sometimes 16-18 hours a day for many months at a time so the Spielbergs and Katzenbergs of this industry can make movies and make millions doing it. They could have accomplished all of this without dedicated workers who made it possible. Throwing away people who gave much of their lives to making millions for others deserve to have a safe place to go in their last days.
Once a person is in a long term care facility and is settled in and promised that he/she will have a place until he/she dies, that promise should be kept. It is not easy to just throw them away to any other nursing home. The change kills some of them. As a matter of fact, a recent resident was removed from the home and died 1 week later because of it.
Think before you throw people away when they are old. You will one day be old too, if you live that long.
This is a strange argument. Why can’t there be care for elderly *and* young talent? The people who donated to USC SCA aren’t actively working against a hospital. It’s not like they donated to an “anti-hospital” campaign. The individuals singled out here have long histories of interaction with the School of Cinematic Arts.
Tom Holman is a tenured professor at the School of Cinematic Arts, and teaches introductory sound to every single student who passes through. He’s also an engineer, and does a ton of work with the engineers and sound department at USC. Of course he would want to oversee the construction of his own department. Where and how else is he going to have this opportunity?
And who else would USC want to have oversee the construction of their sound facilities? Some outsider when one of the industry pioneers is a member of their faculty?
Tom doesn’t deserve to be singled out and bashed. Nor do a lot of these individual alums who give a great deal of time and mentoring to young, broke, and struggling students/alums. John August and Stacy Sher in particular have given a great deal of their time.
We can debate ad infinitum about best uses of money. I’m sure many of the students, if given the choice, would have liked that money to go to financial aid rather than such a dramatic new building.
Spot on!
@ Bulging Bracket, “It could be that many, like me, don’t see any value to an industry specific hospital or long term care facility.” And it could be you’re just and Asshole/Studio/MPTF board shill. This is an “industry specific” town and requires some “industry specific” institutions. Like film schools and maybe an old folks home for those who have been bled dry by the studios, paid into the Fund their whole lives and now have now where else to go! The MPTF’s own web site lays claim to their venerability and 70 year history since started by Mary Pickford, Douglas Fairbanks, Charlie Chaplin,et. “Fake controversy”? How about, your a fake human being-
So if these entities don’t spend money on MPTF, they can’t spend money on anything? Like a university? With a department with a direct pipeline into their industry?
And private schools can’t accept donations either? Like every other school everywhere does with their successful alumni? If it was a state school, would you be bitching that a publicly-funded entity was accepting alumni or industry donations?
Wow. Get off your broom, Nikki. The MPTF situation sucks, but it’s not USC’s fault. What is it you want them to do exactly? “Oh no, we couldn’t possibly accept these badly-needed buildings and facilities updates. Please make your checks out to the MPTF instead. After all, we’re just a big charity whose first responsibility is not to our student body.” That place was already 25 years out of date 10 years ago. It’s about time they got an overhaul.
I posted this morning, but for some reason my post didn’t show up Nikki. Not sure why. Anyway, to re-cap what I said was perhaps Lucas, Katzenberg and Speilberg want to feel their youth again and giving to USC brings all of those fun feelings back…or something like that. But it’s ironic that these three legacies of Hollywood, who are all growing old wouldn’t have as much compassion for the old artists of the older artists at MPTF home. It’s shameful, but typical of not only Hollywood to concentrate on YOUTH, but in the bigger picture: typical of America’s obsession with YOUTH. We should revere and help and be empathetic to these old people who came before us. Europe reveres the elderly – why hasn’t the culture changed in America?
Between these fools supporting a fraud for “President” and crap like this, no wonder the rest of the world laughs at Hollywood people. This is pathetic and embarrassing.
Comment by OBAMA IS A FRAUD — March 19, 2009 @ 8:10 am
By the rest of the world you mean you & the 10 other racists who follow the Drudge Report & the FL junkie from your mom’s basement.
Hollywood’s foreign film & television revenue is up for the 3rd straight year.
Just so you know, President Obama’s approval rating is higher globally than it is here.
Some examples–
Canada: 80%
UK: 73%
Brazil: 84%
Republicans: 26%
That # reflects their popularity in the U.S.
PS: Can you explain why you’re erroneously labeling the POTUS a fraud?
Sweet Jesus. I wish Drudge would stop linking to your site, Nikki. The cretins that show up are embarrassing.
While it’s true that people can give their money to whatever charity they want, Jeffrey Katzenberg as a board member of MPTF should be a bit more willing to help the organization do what it was built on, ‘Taking care of our own’.
MPTF provides the best possible care and all who have lived or had to stay in the hospital can attest to that. However I think the fundamental issue here is that Seth Ellis and David Tillman have had an agenda since they started. It’s just taken a few years to evolve and now with the economy the way it is, they have used this situation to move on with their plan.
Seth Ellis has a stake in a company that MPTF outsources to. Seems to me to be a conflict of interest, but then I am nobody. The amount of money spent on consultants coul more than pay for the shortfall and has anyone asked why they need so many consultants and still have full time high compensated employees that should be able to do the job?
As a first semester grad student in production at ‘SC, and a member of the first class to enjoy the fruits of these donations, I have to show gratitude for the efforts put forth by alumni. Our facilities are amazing and the prestige the alum bring to the school is immeasurable. USC is and always will be in a class of its own when it comes to film school. That said, I was not offered a dime in financial aid, even after these donations were received. They wouldn’t even pay for my USC ID card ($15.)
A large portion of this money should have been spent aiding the students. I’m 22. In a decade or so (hopefully), I will be one of those directors working for the studios. If those that benefit from the studio system are going to donate money to my university (and no, I don’t feel this money is DUE to me,) it would be a big help to ensure that I’m not living in a cardboard box for the next 20 years while paying off loans.
And that’s not hyperbole. I mean literally a cardboard box.
Almost all of the money for the new facilities came from one donor, George Lucas.
Tom Holman is a professor at USC, but is not at all overseeing the installation of sound or projection facilities. In fact he is on sabbatical all year, and was not asked for his opinion on facilities as he and George had a falling out years ago.
Okay, so none of us on the outside of this situation really know ALL the facts and honestly, none of us probably ever will – unless of course, this whole situation is brought to court in which case skeletons will spew forth faster than an awakening of the dead. So why do you ask, am I then going to take the time to write my commentary on this article if even I do not have all the facts? Easy. Because this is a “commentary” (e.g. my comments) and I do not pretend to be reporting facts as a journalist might.
There are four observations I’d like to share:
1) In my view, Nikki’s article was restrained and fair given her obvious (and well placed) bias in the situation but then again, anyone with half a heart and mind would have to agree with her. Those who can’t even admit her observations to be level headed and truthful subscribe to a totally different set of morals and ethics that should be called into question.
2) If anyone has ever worked in the industry for any adequate length of time in a capacity where all the deals are made, we all know what the truth is; and this is not a jaded statement: it’s largely a business based on hypocrisy, fear, jealousy, greed, self-interest and loathing. It is hypocrisy that fills jobs, fear that keeps jobs, jealousy that keeps outsiders from those jobs, greed that destroys people for those jobs, self-interest that keeps the wrong people in those jobs and loathing that prevents everyone else from being truly honest. At this point, the whole wretched mess starts all over again since we’re all then forced to live a big lie in order to hopefully, make our mark in a business that we all know is the single most important business in the universe – we have myriad award shows to validate this. You all know of what I speak. What does this have to do with the article? Simple: it’s these same traits that continue to fail the same “below-the-line” people who’ve toiled in their careers to make others rich – even though these same “below-the-line” people are retired and in need. It’s nice to see how Hollywood keeps on giving. True, there are good and fair people everywhere in Hollywood and some, against all reason, even reach the pinnacle of whatever craft and profession they practice. Integrity, honesty, good values and a sense of responsible ethics are shared by a handful of us but we are few and far between. You know, “Clap when you see one!”
3) If any of us know the REAL deal points of so many of Hollywood’s top earners you’ll discover a plethora of provisions that enable “in perpetuity” as the legalese goes, the funneling of vast sums of money into already bulging pockets for really NOTHING. Chalk this up to astute lawyers and shrewd business managers for sure, but what makes this situation most reprehensible is that an industry that prides itself on projecting its humanity to the world really does so ONLY if those already accomplished individuals and successful companies get something out of it. For an industry that’s also motivated by what’s hot and sexy, a long term care facility isn’t sexy. A film school upon which the donors’ names are plastered all over the walls is sexy. It’s also a situation where these institutions will be forever indebted to those entities. The same long term effect of “scratch my back and I’ll scratch yours” doesn’t really fit with people in the final chapter of their lives. Donating, supporting, running such a facility might be needed or noble or commendable but it’s definitely not sexy. Nikki’s comment that there’s more aggrandizement to be had from financing a film school than funding a nursing home therefore, hits the nail on the head. Sorry, guys and gals, if you check your emotions and subjectivity at the door and see the BUSINESS for what it is, that’s EXACTLY what it is – a BUSINESS through and through. That’s why it’s called “Show BUSINESS” and not “Show Show.” For sure there are a few executives and actors and whomever else out there that support charities and causes of this nature and others out of sincerity but you can count them on one hand. That said, I don’t begrudge a business or professional making a business decision because the business of business is business, however…
4) Shame on Dr. Tillman and his preposterous salary of approximately $700K per year to run a NON-PROFIT organization! He truly needs to take a hard look at himself in the mirror and question his conscience. If not, he should resign and join the folks at AIG since they seem to be cut from the same cloth. How do you look an 80 year old patient in the eye after they’ve signed over all their assets to you and say, “We know we had a moral and legal agreement with you to take care of you for the rest of your life but we’ve decided the space you’re taking up would be better served as high-end condos?” Is this immanent domain in geriatric care? It takes a very special kind of “human being” to be sold cold AND make obscene amounts of money while doing it. He would have fit in quite well with historic political movements of the past – namely, one very well known party in Germany during the 1930s. I mean, why doesn’t he simply wrench the gold out of their teeth while he’s at it? (Sorry, that was indeed an unwarranted comment on my part and also an insult to a man I’ve never met but in my book of ethics there’s some pretty scary similarities.)
And as far as Katzenberg and all his gracious concern goes in not wanting to upset the residents and therefore, keeping the fund’s alleged financial woes a secret until they simply had to reach this “difficult decision” to kick everyone out is concerned, he should stick to animation. There are no living, breathing PEOPLE in animation. He can treat those characters as he pleases because life and death is simply a stroke of the pen or swipe of the eraser. He has no place in being on the Board of this hospital and neither do any of the individuals who are responsible for doing NOTHING about this situation until it was too late. But then again the question remains, how did such a group of highly successful business people become so STUPID in mismanaging funds that were supposed to last “in perpetuity?” Ahh…there’s that legalese again. On the other hand, it’s not THEIR money coming to THEM in perpetuity, it’s someone else’s money. Big difference. Oh, well, easy come, easy go. We’ll get you a bed…somewhere.
This entire situation is simply a reflection of the voracious greed, wrecked regulation, broken checks-and-balances and moral apathy that has become the greatest country the world has ever known…the United States. All hail to the mighty dollar and to hell with what’s right as long as it’s legal.