THURSDAY AM UPDATE: Estimates now are that the Hugh Jackman film, the 4th in the X-Men franchise for 20th Century Fox, was downloaded hundreds of thousands of times from file sharing websites on Tuesday. This is a huge blow to the studio’s major summer blockbuster if those viewers don’t go to a theater to see the film. Meanwhile, the web piracy has created a lot of buzz around the pic, both positive and negative. The Internet is now filled with fanboy comments about whether Wolverine is any good. Despite the added publicity, this is a nightmare scenario for Fox.
2ND UPDATE: I’ve just been given this statement by 20th Century Fox:
“Last night, a stolen, incomplete and early version of X-Men Origins: Wolverine was posted illegally on a website. It was without many effects, had missing and unedited scenes and temporary sound and music. We immediately contacted the appropriate legal authorities and had it removed. We forensically mark our content so we can identify sources that make it available or download it. The source of the initial leak and any subsequent postings will be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law – the courts have handed down significant criminal sentences for such acts in the past. The FBI and the MPAA also are actively investigating this crime. We are encouraged by the support of fansites condemning this illegal posting and pointing out that such theft undermines the enormous efforts of the filmmakers and actors, and above all, hurts the fans of the film.”
8:50 AM UPDATE: This is no April Fool’s joke. Instead, Fox executives are describing it to me as one of the worst piracy scandals they can recall, since it involves a major studio and major movie. The studio is understandably in a panic. With the film opening on May 1st, this leak could cause incalculable damage to the box office of the latest in the valuable X-Men franchise. The studio must find out who did this and punish him/her/them to the full extent of the law. Meanwhile, the Internet is on fire about this DVD-quality work print of Wolverine being leaked online yesterday. Twentieth Century Fox stresses it’s an old rough cut without FX, music, etc — so that may mitigate the damage because isn’t that why you see the movie in a theater anyway? The execs say it may contain a virus. But even if the studio claims that viewers of the pirated copy will age 20 years overnight, that isn’t going to solve the problem. Toughness will. And it looks as if that’s exactly what 20th Century Fox is doing to combat this piracy.
Coincidentally, this comes just days before U.S. Congressman Howard Berman, chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, will hold a field hearing in Van Nuys on April 6th to assess the financial impact of global intellectual property piracy. On April 30 the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative is scheduled to release its annual report on intellectual property policies and practices in other countries. Last year’s report placed nine major offenders on the USTR’s Priority Watch List, including China, Russia, Thailand, and Argentina. A RAND study released earlier this month alleges that organized crime is increasingly active in film piracy. Just one problem – that study was funded by the MPAA.
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.







While I haven’t seen the pirated copy, I agree with Richard and Mizzela. The people who would download the rough copy would still see it in the theater BUT the early footage/trailers look like an utter disaster and this copy could lead to some terrible word of mouth.
At least the people at Fox will have a scapegoat if this film does indeed disappoint at the box office.
This is unfortunate, but FOX deserves it. They muscled their way to get rights to Watchmen, and this is their payback.
There is such a difference between the finished product and a rough working copy, it’s painfully obvious.
Even given the opportunity, I wouldn’t watch a rough cut. I’d much rather get the finished product with all the shiny bells and whistles.
I hope they catch the people responsible for this, and yes, I agree with another poster that it’s probably an inside job.
It’s hard to predict what, if any, damage this will cause.
It’s possible to imagine, even, that fanboys who would have stayed away from a stinker like this or “Catwoman” will now be motivated to go in order to see what changes were made and feel insider-y.
They used to release soundtrack albums to musicals months ahead of the film to familiarize the audience with the songs. I get that this isn’t the identical situation, but a similar concept could conceivably goose attendance here too.
No sane company would intentionally perform this kind of experiment to find out, but now that one is upon us it’s helpful to keep in mind that doom is only one of the possible outcomes.
Minella,
Way to be proud of being a thief!
Why should we care what your opinion is of the film? You’re a douche.
Whoever leaked this is a scumbag of the highest order.
This leak came from Post Production right on the Fox Lot. Start the witch hunt there. There will be blood.
I love the “organized crime” scare tactic. Yes, when it comes to DVD priacy, sure. But not torrents. That’s laughable — there’s no money in them!
Best as I can tell, toughness should begin with FOX’s own internal security protocols. They were lax in keeping this from happening. This doesn’t excuse the blatantly illegal activites of the person who stole this material, but do we shed a tear for the person who leaves large piles of money on their front lawn and then screams in shock when someone walks away with it? No. FOX got a pretty harsh lesson taught to them today. Wake up, Hollywood.
Hey Helen of Hill
This happened at post, Probably some intern who got their chance to work on editing this. Damn, some post house is GOING TO LOSE a multimillion dollar contract ($$$), and some dufuss FUBAR is GOING TO SEE some prison time…
Dumb, just dumb.
Bad press is good press.
This is free advertisement.
We will never know the truth for how this “leak” occurred. Perhaps it was to give the production more money and more time to spend on FX, if the studio did not want to spend more money someone may have released it early to make a point and force the budget increase.
We will never know the whole truth. Meanwhile someone will be arrested and will serve as a fall guy. Reality is that few people would not have copied or uploaded a DVD left around with a copy of the movie on it. Perhaps it was “thrown out” accidentally. Who knows.
Rough cuts are distributed on DVD by the dozens to the filmmakers, producers, and execs. These can end up lost or tossed (or easily stolen). No doubt this was one copy that got astray and was uploaded by someone not associated with the movie at all.
This is really sad cos like someone else said above, it hurts everyone involved in making the movie
What are they worried about? Don’t they know that internet streaming is still in its infancy and can’t possibly cut into traditional media?
Or maybe they just don’t like having their stuff on the internet without getting paid for it…
That’s right my FBI boys will find the criminals who did this. But don’t we have much more important things to investigate like finding and stopping terrorists? Guess not. That’s Jack Bauer’s job. Of course if somebody ever put an episode of 24 on the web before air date we’d send our own Jack Bauer to catch him and torture him.
Video piracy is obviously a very serious matter. And anyone who does this is as guilty of stealing as Bernie Madoff (and should get the cell next to his while they wait for Federal sentencing).
Given the sophistication of the audience, I doubt a grainy, f/x-less, extremely low-rez version of a partial film on a tiny YouTube-like screen will really cause “incalculable” damage to the box office. (The fans know the franchise and know the incredibly high quality of the finished product, so a viewing of some crappy footage will not make them say: “I’ve seen the film so I don’t need to pay for it.” More likely: “I can’t wait to see the pristine, finished product on an 80 foot wide digital screen.”)
Wait a minute….could this actually be part of a brilliant Fox marketing campaign? I think we may be on to something.
This film has been a disaster from the get-go. First, there was little to no acknowledgement that fans didn’t like X-Men 3. Then it was announced as a “prequel” which just seems like a boring idea. Then they cast Liev Schrieber as Sabertooth which is completely inexplicable. Then there were all these rumors about re-shoots and story problems. Then they released the trailer only in theaters so 80% saw bootleg versions of it on youtube: that ridiculous shot of Wolvie flying through the air towards a helicopter made us watching in the office laugh hysterically. Then all sorts of issues have been talked about regarding other characters like Deadpool and Gambit — characters people love reduced to afterthought intros on-screen in this movie. Then Hugh Jackman, “tough guy” Wolverine, sang and danced his way through a terrible Oscar night. And now, finally, this.
I really appreciate that Marvel is excited about their characters but I really, really wish they would be more thoughtful about their films instead of rushing them into production like a cash cow machine. When Warner Brothers gave Christopher Nolan the freedom, resources and time to pursue a vision, it paid off. It brought a lot of excitment to the genre. It elevated people’s expectations of what these movies could be like and raised the quality bar for comic book movies: the old hokey formulas aren’t going to cut it anymore. I think Marvel and Fox are about to learn a painful and financially difficult message from all of this. Do something cool instead of trying to do a two-hour toy commercial.
There is only one thief and that would be the Fox insider who stole it and placed it out in the public domain for anyone to pick up like finding a penny on the sidewalk.
It happened in post?! Oh shit…
Well, I guess those things happen when you let go/drive away those with expertise and let burger salesmen run the place…
Still, feel bad for all who worked on the film. It’s not right…
methinks the unspeakably cringe-worthy trailer was the far more destructive leak.
hate to say this as i don’t condone piracy, but if this movie’s as bad as people say, then maybe the pirates will force studios to actually focus on making good films without the safety net of knowing they can bombard the public with enough TV ads to force shitty sequels down aud’s throats. (or maybe they’ll just blame it on torrent and not the dearth of creativity.)
We will never know the truth for how this “leak” occurred. Perhaps it was to give the production more money and more time to spend on FX…
Heh. Nothing, and I do mean nothing, would surprise me. But, there are many, more probable causes.
As for the truth about IP and piracy – you are correct, we will never know all of it, but here’s a good start:
Me thinks it was Dr. Doom who took the tape…
payback for so many bad X-Men movies…
Hollywood’s biggest problem isn’t that new tech somehow stole their movie. It’s that customers end up paying $14 to sit and be tortured by their features. That’s why the new tech, ad supported free media will soon take the studios down.
Everything comes around. This is just that after that crap they pulled with Warner Brothers on Watchmen.