UPDATED (below) with GE spokesman’s comments.
It’s a very dangerous situation when any huge multinational corporation wages war against media companies. Especially when that huge multinational corporation is General Electric, which itself owns a media company, NBC Universal, and it’s using all its power and influence and money to try to harm another media company, Nielsen, and Nielsen Business Media, and its trade publication The Hollywood Reporter. This certainly sounds like a situation which the FCC, and the FTC, and the U.S. Justice Department should be investigating. Just one problem: the controversy stems from GE/NBCU’s coverage of President Obama. Here’s what happened:
According to my sources inside and outside Nielsen Business Media, The Hollywood Reporter trade publication ran a story dated April 22nd and updated on April 24th covering the “drama” at the most recent GE shareholders meeting in Orlando. THR‘s West Coast Business Editor Paul Bond wasn’t sent to the meeting, but he interviewed about half a dozen people who’d been inside the shareholders meeting and told him what transpired (see below). Bond’s THR story focused on the attempts by stockholders and Fox News Channel and other media to find out whether or not GE Chairman/CEO Jeffrey Immelt ordered his news operations to be less critical of President Obama and his policies.
Bond’s story was immediately picked up by The Drudge Report under the headline “GE shareholders outraged over MSNBC bias; Microphone cut off.” It became a widely posted news story on conservative and liberal and media websites everywhere. That’s when, sources inside and outside Nielsen Business Media tell me, GE Chairman Jeff Immelt ordered a GE company-wide ban on all of The Hollywood Reporter‘s parent company Nielsen: advertising, editorial, the works. After a few days, the ban was reduced to GE’s NBC Universal which chief Jeff Zucker carried out against Nielsen Business Media’s The Hollywood Reporter and lasted six weeks. My NBC Universal sources believe the ban was lifted yesterday.
My reporting is the first about the ban or what led to it. “People need to know that GE is using its media arm to stifle coverage about its company, and this is coming from Immelt and Zucker,” a Nielsen Business Media insider said. I’d attempted multiple times over several weeks to speak with NBCU about this story but the company won’t discuss it.
*UPDATE: Gary Sheffer, GE’s Executive Director of Corporate Communications, emailed me: “I just read your post on GE and NBCU. Jeff Immelt had no involvement in this matter whatsover. He did not call NBC Universal or anyone else about it. In fact, he had no knowledge of The Hollywood Reporter story in question.” I stand behind my sources on this story. But I fing Sheffer’s remarks incredulous considering that the THR account of the GE shareholders’ meeting, once the story was carried by Drudge, became a major media topic. The GE spokesman didn’t deny the reprisals against Nielsen or THR, just Immelt’s direct involvement in them. Yet Sheffer admits that he himself spoke directly to The Hollywood Reporter several times about the story. The spokesman refused to talk about NBCU vs Nielsen. He also refused to reply to my question why, since GE rides herd so closely on all its personnel and especially its division managers, Immelt would let Zucker run amok and take reprisals against a media company trying to cover GE?*
Here’s what’s also interesting: the current Chairman/CEO of Nielsen is David Calhoun, who prior to joining in 2006 served as Vice Chairman of GE. After rising through GE since 1979, Calhoun had been in contention to run the conglomerate after Jack Welch retired. But Immelt got the top spot instead. As President/CEO of GE Infrastructure, the largest of six GE business units and responsible for 25% of the company’s sales, Calhoun surprised Wall Street when he became the first top exec to quit after Immelt took over in 2001.
In that THR article, Bond’s reporting revealed:
“…Attendees who spoke to The Hollywood Reporter said shareholders asked about 10 politically charged questions concerning MSNBC as well as one about CNBC.
First up was a woman asking about a reported meeting in which CEO Jeff Immelt and NBC Uni CEO Jeff Zucker supposedly told top CNBC executives and talent to be less critical of President Obama and his policies.
Immelt acknowledged a meeting took place but said no one at CNBC was told what to say or not to say about politics.
During the woman’s follow-up question, her microphone was apparently cut off. A short time later, Watters asked a question and his mic was cut, too.
“The crowd was very upset with MSNBC because of its leftward tilt,” one attendee said. “Some former employees said they were embarrassed by it.”
…But one of those questions came from Jesse Watters, a producer on [Fox News Channel's] “The O’Reilly Factor” whose criticisms were cut short when his microphone was cut off, according to several attendees. Watters apparently did not publicly identify himself as a Fox employee… Watters has built a reputation as an ambush interviewer, specializing in on-the-street confrontations. But this is arguably the boldest move by a Fox newsie to utilize the tactic inside their chief rival’s tent, as it were… When he got the floor, Watters [a producer on Fox News Channel's "The O'Reilly Factor"] focused his question about MSNBC on Olbermann’s interview of actress Janeane Garofalo, who likened conservatives to racists and spoke of “the limbic brain inside a right-winger.
“He (Watters) was complaining that Olbermann didn’t bother to challenge her,” another GE shareholder said.
Immelt told the assembled he takes a hands-off approach to what is reported on the company’s news networks, which prompted a shareholder to criticize him for not managing NBC Uni more effectively….”
In the update to the story, THR pointed out that a GE corporate spokesman later pointed out that “there was no attempt to cut anyone off who had questions or comments to make. In fact, corporate spokesman Gary Sheffer said, the meeting did not conclude until everyone who wanted to speak had a chance — and some shareholders returned to the standing microphone multiple times.”
Because of that story, sources inside and outside Nielsen Business Media tell me, GE Chairman Jeff Immelt personally issued a GE ban on all of the Nielsen company. ”Jeff Immelt severed relations between all of GE with all of Nielsen over that story. Immelt called Zucker, and Zucker took it from there. Then, after a few days, GE backtracked, and then it became NBC Universal severing relations with The Hollywood Reporter.”
According to my sources, Zucker ordered NBC Universal employees “not to talk” to THR. ”They took away passes and tickets,” says one insider. Another told me advertising was affected: it appears all or almost all advertising was stopped by NBC Universal at what was and continues to be a very important revenue time for the trade — just before the Emmy nominations. Still another told me that NBC Universal employees stopped returning THR reporters’ calls. One NBC Universal employee actually said to a THR reporter: “I’m not allowed to talk to The Hollywood Reporter.”
Only a handful of people within the publication knew about the GE/NBC Universal ban. “It was all very mysterious,” one reporter whose calls stopped being returned by NBC Universal told me. “No one told me specifically why. But I think some story really pissed them off.”.
NBC Universal also attempted to have Paul Bond fired. The company went to Nielsen/THR and complained not just about his shareholders meeting coverage, but also about the tone of that story and others he’d written about NBCU. But Bond’s bosses refused to buckle under the pressure.
“They defended him, showing a lot of courage especially in this environment where ad money is hard to come by,” a Nielsen Business Media insider told me. “It’s fairly remarkable because Jeff Immelt is a very powerful man. If that doesn’t prove THR is a real newspaper, I don’t know what does.” (Well, you still have to prove that to me. But this is a start.)
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.





You want the Justice Department to investigate this? The Obama Justice Department? From the Adminstration that’s in bed with GE and NBC, and vice versa?
How wonderfully naive of you, Nikki.
Just more proof that NBC, MSNBC, and CNBC are in the tank for Obama. Had it been a conservative leaning company doing this, it would be smeared on the front page of every liberal newspaper. Since it about a company that favors Obama, hardly a word will be spoken. We have come to this: those who tell the truth are punished for doing so. Those who hide or color the truth get their new hosts of programs promoted by the President. Is this the American way?
You want to send a real message… then boycott anything and everything NBC!
Is it just me, or is anyone else just so sick of crap like this?
Anybody watch Brian ‘Bowing” Williams tonight get a big tour of the WH as a reward for constant sucking-up to The Won and his Rahm-bunctious crew. When Brian plucked the hem of BHusseinO’s robe to ask if he watches MSNBC, Obama did show good taste by saying watching KeithO & Matthews was like WW Wrestling.
Lil’ Bri didn’t have a follow-up question on that one.
The real issue behind all of this is Immelt’s mismanagement of GE and Zucker’s mismanagement of NBC. GE’s stock price is abysmal because Immelt and his hand picked board of zombies have mismanaged a once very successful company. NBC’s ratings (and its advertising rates) have plummeted because Zucker is a gutless boot licker who has pushed NBC to the far left to satisfy the political objectives of his boss, Immelt.
GE has donated big money to Obama and the Democrats because GE wants Obama to approve them for fat government contracts to develop a national electronic medical record database. Immelt has pandered to Obama and greased the Democrat decision-making machine with lots of political money because he sees big bucks on the horizon if GE gets these government contracts. He has instructed Zucker to lay off criticizing the Obama administration because Immelt doesn’t want NBC messing up the deal.
It all comes down to money. But in spite of all of Immelt’s and Zucker’s political pandering, their businesses are still trailing the competition.
All this talk of MSNBC tilting to the left is overblown. Sure they have Olberman, but they balance him out with Maddow. Sure they have Shultz, but then they temper that with Matthews.
Hey, wait a minute…
Immelt was a major player in Obama’s campaign for president. It is my understanding that Immelt hosted fund raising evients for Obama. Also, Obama made Immelt one of his economics adivsor.
GE was promised billions in “Green Energy” contracts by Obama’s team, now they are calling in all the chips! No surprise they want to supress everything.
All hail Immelt the Antichrist!
I have provided technical support for several stockholder meetings for very large corporations over the years. They are very staged and highly controlled events. Undercover guards planted in amongst the participants, plants in the audience to ask questions that the board wanted to have asked and also these plants were used to deflect as well.
The cutting of the microphones mentioned does not surprise me one bit. Common practice.
Golly, GE is acting just like the Bush White House. But, then, so does every totalitarian cabal whether Right or Left.
Media consolidation began under Reagan when the TV networks, desperate to win deregulation so they could aggregate and expand into cable, killed or downplayed news stories that would have embarrassed the (mostly Republican, but not always) lawmakers and bureaucrats who held the investigative keys. The irony is that, no matter how much the Right wing spreads its lie that the media are Liberal, they lift limits and allow the media to grow bigger and more powerful. Face it: the Fourth Estate has become an arm of the power elite. It is neither Right nor Left, but something worse: amoral (Cue Ned Beatty’s speech from Paddy Chayefsky’s “Network”). Good reporting, Nikki, and even better analysis.
I have come to the conclusion recently that GE cannot be trusted with control of a major media outlet like NBC. They do nothing with it except to propagandize for their own benefit. (Green Week? get real.)
Boycott all Ge products and NBC programing…I have been sending emails to people to SELL all GE, Disney, and Cbs and NYTs Stock
Post a link to this story on every website and blog
You aren’t alone Scott…we’re the silent majority that is about to roar. And strike. Hard.
It’s obvious that GE/NBC are in bed with the Obama administration, what with the billions in no-bid contracts that GE will receive for health care reform as well as “green” energy initiatives. If you were angry about Halliburton contracts in the Iraq war, imagine the tax-payer money that will go to these “guilt-free” projects. If you want to see the absolutely detestable reporting in action, you merely have to turn on MSNBC on any given day. It’s simply abhorrent. Then you have Obama giving comedy routines to Conan, the comment from a white house aid about how much they love MSNBC, the recent blaming of Fox News’ Bill O’Reilly for the Tiller shooting and dozens of other details that just go to show the unabashed relationship in full public view on a daily basis. Congratulations to Nikki and to THR for further exposing this relationship and it’s dire nature. The sad thing is that the American public is so incredibly blinded by the massive amount of media corruption which is literally slobbering over the new president with a never ending foray of pointless puff piece after pointless puff piece. I’m still fairly young but I’ve never seen such unapologetic predilection. To put it frankly, disinformation purposefully injected into the public consciousness; disgusting.
Wait, aren’t we all ALREADY boycotting all NBC shows? hmm… sure seems like it.
I just find it ludicrous that any commenter can consider NBC, or any media outlet that is part of the big conglomerates, anything but conservative in nature.
What’s troubling is the censorship, regardless of being perceived as pro- or anti-Obama.
You can continue dreaming about the same Justice Dept that walked away from a slam dunk conviction of the Black Panthers intimidating voters doing anything about this.
The Obama FCC is too busy trying to figure out how to ban conservative talk radio.
What would Obama do without NBC?
There would not have been four hours of prime time Obama infomercial with Brian Williams Inside the Obama White House this week without them.
They are nothing but a PR firm for the Administration that they helped to elect.
GE stands to make tens of billions from Obama energy and health care initiatives. Of course they’re doing all they can.
Follow the money.
General Electric(GE) owns NBC, CNBC and MSNBC and GE has and will continue to profit, big time, from Obama’s socialistic policies and his giving away our and our children’s money(debt put on the country’s credit card). Basically, this Administration has it’s own TV Propoganda stations. It is sickening.
Ditto Scott. Its beyond unhealthy. It borders on scary.
1. We now know why Brian Williams of NBC was video’d as bowing to President Obama.
2. GE is a company that has accepted TARP funds to cover its lending business, thus GE/NBC Uni has become equal to PRAVDA a state owned media outlet.
3. They got rid of Dillan Rattigan on Fast Money (CNBC) because he kept questioning whether or not Geithner knew what the heck he was doing regarding taking over the banks.
4. We know that Santelli of CNBC and the Chicago bond pits was put on notice by both GE/NBC Uni as well as the Chicago political establishment because he said in an interview that he felt threatened by what had occurred after the ‘tea party’ speech that seemed to start that ball rolling.
5. GE is in line to get almost all of the major green projects once cap and trade goes into place.
6. There is a great picture of Immeult sitting next to President Obama at a recent cabinet meeting. Don’t remember his confirmation hearings being broadcast on CSpan.
7. Immeult has presided over the worst decline in GE history and all those institutional buyers of GE stock (ie – teachers union) are now hosed. How are they going to live on the cut dividends and the smaller payouts from the trust funds set up on their behalf? Its outrageous and I have to ask: does the actors union and the writer’s union have a trust fund for retirees? If so, do you know if your trust fund has invested in GE? Do you realize that only if GE gets these contracts for “green projects” do they have any growth opportunities that will raise their share price thus being helpful to the retirees in getting more in their monthly check?
8. One of the big Fox news stories against GE is that GE is still selling huge machine parts to Iran, thus helping Iran maintain and grow its civilian-easily-switched-to-military infrastructure. We all know that Iran REALLY doesn’t like 1 certain country in its midst. So, GE can be said to be helping Iran in its quest to get rid of that 1 country (in the neighborhood) it REALLY doesn’t like.
So again, I have to ask: Why the government give GE the TARP money? What financing of GE’s operations weren’t paying their bills? I believe the answer to that is the large equipment sector that built the machinery for Iran – thus we have forgiven Iran’s debts to GE with our tax money at the same time GE shareholders (the unions) get slammed.
I really really feel sorry for the union trusts that those people paid into for retirement and get a GE that is at $13 bucks with a cut dividend.
Thanks Immeult!
Since Zucker is running around kissing President Obama’s rear patootie, Zucker can kiss my ass too.
Where is the neutral journalism anymore? Fox is to the right, CNN, MSNBC, NBC, ABC, CBS are to the left.
Can we get 1 network that just tells us news that isn’t skewed to support or denigrate anyone in political office or are they now so wrapped together that there is no such animal anymore?
I proudly voted for hope and change.
I did not vote for Brian Williams to bow to the President nor did I think that tough questions would never be asked for fear of reprisals.
AKA – less automotive advertising $$$ going to what stations to keep them going in this recession.
Now stop it – all of you journalists – because you’re scaring me. Do your jobs which is report for good and bad.
The News in this country, whether it be Newspapers, MSNBC, CNN, or ABC…
IT so FULL OF SHIT, they sensor everything that the Government doesn’t want us to see or hear…
The difference between them is: What they are willing to censor….
Guess what, if they censor AT ALL, we all lose….
The news reporting agencies of this country are corrupt…
Stick with the INTERNET, and get the real deal…
Read Internet papers from ALL countries around the world…
Only THEN, do we get the true picture….
US news agencies and stations are corrupt and paid off in my opinion….
So Fox News and Newscorp owned newspapers are brazenly biased and blindly supportive of the Bush administration for 8 years and that’s perfectly fine?
But if MSNBC chooses to go with a route that is also biased with some of its broadcast personalities (while keeping them away from hard news) this is seen as illegal and worthy of a justice department investigation?
In that case let’s bring back the Fairness Doctrine that Reagan got rid of and see how well Fox fares.
Also, people say Jesse Watters is a liar and a bag of scum. People say Jess Watters likes to attack people and then cut the footage to make them look bad. People say Jesse Watters and the Fox newscasters like to use the term “people say” to throw around whatever allegation they want even if there are no sources for it.
Why is Immelt still the CEO at GE?
The stock price has gone down ever since he took over.
This is sickening. Why is it that those who most loudly claim to protect our democratic rights and free speech are the first ones to attempt to shout down criticism, belittle any who disagree and cleave so tightly to a favored politician that they knowingly infringe the very rights they purport to protect. Rarely has a precursor to fascism been so openly aggressive. Historically they are more slippery and clandestine than this. If the Congress and the FCC do not look into this and other such intimidation we will know where some very important democratic rights have gone. I mean, really, what will be next? Honestly, the only word that comes to mind is shame. Shame!
Replace GE with Haliburton and the media would have already etched the story into our skulls. NBC is the propaganda arm of the Obama admin and plan to get paid back via so-called “green” investments and health care “reform”. Both stand to hand GE millions in government contracts. Immelt had banked the entire future of GE on this pie in the sky nonsense while ignoring the parts of GE that have been legit and profitable. The share holders have every right to be upset. I doubt Obama can afford to pay Immelt back and we sure as hell can’t.