2ND UPDATE: Here is the response from “Saving The Lives Of Our Own”:
Los Angeles—In reaction to a “pre-eviction” notice released by the Motion Picture Television Fund today, residents of the MPTF long-term care facility and their families rejected the letter as an example of continued strong-arm tactics by the Fund and its administrators. In an interview, the MPTF’s Ken Scherer insists the facility will be closed by the Thanksgiving holiday.
The letter was released to the media before being delivered to the residents and their families, in the presence of security guards, in a further attempt to intimidate and frighten the elderly out of the Home they were promised would be there for them until the end of their days.
Lynn Medford, whose husband Don, 91, is a director and long-time resident of the Home says, “They gave us a letter already stating what was stated before. It’s the easy way out for them in lieu of an eviction letter. Nothing’s new.”
“The more the MPTF tries to defend its indefensible position, the more public outrage is generated in support of the 80 frail, elderly residents who are being forced out of their homes. Dr. Tillman’s letter is a blatant attempt to circumvent and deprive the elderly, including my mother, of their rights. Families will not be fooled into ‘voluntarily’ relocating their loved ones,” insists Melody Sherwood, whose mother Kay Meyer, 93, is a resident of the facility.
“When they carry me out of my home in a coffin, that’s when I’ll leave here,” states Larry Jennings, a 73-year-old resident and electrician, member of IATSE Local 40.Saving the Lives of Our Own, representing over 4000 Entertainment Industry professionals and members of the community concerned about the MPTF long-term care facility closure, is committed to keeping this historic and vital Hollywood facility open.
We are requesting:
– An immediate reversal of the decision to close the long-term care facility in acknowledgment of the commitment made to these seniors and their families
– A dedicated fundraising campaign for the purpose of keeping the facility open
– Financial transparency in the form of a comprehensive and independent audit of the MTPF and all its related entities.“Saving the Lives of Our Own” is a grass-roots coalition of Entertainment Industry workers and community members. Our mission is to keep the MPTF long-term care facility open, to stop the evictions of its elderly residents and to ensure that the MPTF promise of “Taking Care of Our Own” remains unbroken – now and for future generations.
UPDATE: A top activist opposing the closures emails me, “They are obviously trying to force the families to pull the trigger on their lawsuit, and to put them and their lawyers on the defensive. Not gonna happen.”
EXCLUSIVE: I’ve just been told that the Motion Picture & Television Fund Board Of Directors is sending preliminary notice to those affected that the long-term unit and intensive care hospital at Woodland Hills will be closed at the end of 2009 as previously announced. Sources tell me this preliminary notice is a kind of “pre-letter” to alert patients and their families and friends and other activists that they’ll be getting formal notice soon of the intent to shutter the facilities. So now the end game of this controversial MPTF action is being played out.
The MPTF tells me it’s making this move because four months of settlement talks have broken down with Los Angeles litigator Tom Girardi’s law firm Girardi & Keese which is representing the patients and their families and friends who want to keep open the facilities which are reportedly losing $1 million a month. “We’ve made all kinds of overtures, but they haven’t responded with any plan of their own,” an MPTF insider tells me. ”They want to keep the hospital and long-term care unit open for 80 people even if it bankrupts all the services used by 60,000.” The MPTF is expecting Girardi’s firm to counter with an injunction preventing the shutdowns, and a lawsuit.
This comes just as SAG and the Teamsters voted to oppose MPTF’s impending acute care closures because of lobbying by the grassroots organization, Saving The Lives Of Our Own, a 3,600-member coalition of MPTF residents, family members and friends. According to the activists, the remaining 100 or so residents live in daily fear that they will be evicted from the caring home promised them as a peaceful place to live out their days. The group keeps asking the MPTF Board of Directors to reverse their decision to close the nursing home.
Here is the MPTF letter:
August 25, 2009
Dear Patients and Families,
In our efforts to keep you abreast of developments regarding the impending closure of the long-term care facility and hospital, I am writing to give you an update. I am also writing to reiterate our commitment to working with you throughout the transition process and after you or your family member leaves the campus.
Since January when we announced our difficult decision to close the long term care facility and hospital by the end of the year, it has been our goal to help you identify appropriate options for relocation and to work with you to make the transition as comfortable as possible. We hoped that by giving our residents many months to make plans that most, if not all of you would be far along in the process by now.
We have tried to reach a mutually acceptable solution with the lawyers who are representing many of you in connection with the closure. Our outside counsel has been working with them to craft a solution that would address your transfer and relocation concerns. To that end, the parties retained a former associate California Supreme Court Justice to mediate a settlement. Regrettably, those talks have not been successful and so I urge you to move forward with your transition plans.
We must move forward with phasing out the facility and we want to remind you once again of the resources and assistance we are providing, and to urge you to take full advantage of them.
We have identified 22 high quality community nursing facilities that were screened by MPTF staff to ensure that they could and would support our residents and keep them connected to MPTF health and, or social services via our Community Care teams, if they desire. A list of these facilities is available from your social worker.
We understand that you and your family may have concerns and questions about how the transfer and relocation process actually works. In addition to talking to your social worker about the steps you need to take, we can put you in touch with the Community Care Team. They can give you first hand accounts about how MPTF staff including Dr. Humayun and Linda Healy have worked with them through the process, and in a number of cases continue to provide care where desired.
We are deeply saddened by the fact that we have to close the long term care facility. Our long term care residents will always be important members of the MPTF community and we hope you will allow us to continue serving you after you relocate.
In closing, I urge you once again to allow us to help you identify as many options for relocation as possible and to make the transition as comfortable as possible.
Sincerely,
David Tillman, MD
President / CEO
MPTF
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.


Couldn’t many of today’s big Box office stars contribute to keep the home open? If some major stars kicked in they could fend off the closing. There is still plenty of money in Hollywood.
I suggest that if a one time, “big name” film, done gratis, by everyone, from the drivers, to the grips, to the actors, to the writers, to the production company(ies) and every studio in town (which would produce and distribute it as a joint venture), this would pull the Motion Picture Home out of the red (and volunteering for a non-profit is tax deductible). In these terms $24M isn’t a lot of money considering a big name film can make that return quickly.
Sandra Bullock wrote a check for $1M for the 9/11 rescue workers. There has to be 24 people in the industry who can write the same check, and who could afford to do a free film. I’d volunteer for such a film, and others would, too.
As for sustaining the Home and its long term care and ICU facilities, a continuing fee can be imposed. Broadway tickets have a $1.50 Restoration Fee. The racing industry has a voluntary $2 starting fee for the horses’ retirement (they’re currently trying to make that mandatory). If a fee is attached to a movie ticket, and matched by the Studios (again, tax deductible), it would be a continuing flow to sustain the Home.
Using 2008 as the example, according to NATO the average 2008 movie ticket was $7.18, and the highest domestic grossing film of that year was The Dark Knight, at $533,316,061. That would be 74,780,003 tickets sold for this one film, in one year. Adding one penny to the ticket price would bring in $747,800. And, with a matching one penny, from that one studio, it would up the total to $1,495,600.
Say, for example, the Home needs $1.5M annually to sustain it (I don’t know the exact projected numbers – this is just an example), then the fees collected and donated to the MPTF, as an annual sustaining contribution, would keep the Home afloat. Also, the amount of the fees would be adjusted for COL, and take into consideration the highs and lows of a particular year’s domestic gross.
Each studio would donate annually in proportion to its gross ticket sales from the prior year. And, if a shortfall should occur for the Home, in any future year, another “donated” project would be produced, and the profits again be donated to the MPTF.
Law firms are required to do pro bono work for those who cannot pay. The studios, and everyone in the industry, should do the same for those we call mishpocheh.
Don’t you people get it yet. The MPTF Board of Directors and the studios expect that Obamacare is coming, so why should they absorb the expense. It’s all part of the bigger plan to get us to demand the government option because its better!
1. They cannot pass this public health care bill fast enough.
2. Who really wants to kill grandma?
3. The PR in this letter sounds like something from that Tarrantino movie.
“Our long term care residents will always be important members of the MPTF community”
4. When, where, and how will the hearts of the over seventy crowd break before or after they are pushed to the curb?
5.”To make the transition as comfortable as possible”
Hey grandpa how about some sleeping medicine, it worked well for MJ you won’t feel a thing just roll over.
This is the most despicable thing Hollywood has ever done. I can’t believe a bunch of millionaire and billionaire actors, producers and writers let this happen. SHAME ON YOU.
How can this bastard sleep at night…how can they all sleep!!!! Shame on them mowing over the weak & feeble….It’s a travesty that these elderly have to live their lives out in fear of being without a home!!!
If 78% SAG members aren’t willing to fight for their rights when they’re young and healthy, why should they get any better when they’re old and useless? The old-age home is a financial drain, the money can be put to much better use paying productive entertainment executives, and so that’s what the Hollywood system is doing. Go entertainment industry executives go. Take every penny for yourselves. You deserve it.
And Girardi’s lawsuit will only cause more financial harm to MPTF, leading to more patients being affected, and only serve to line the lawyers’ pockets.
What a shame.
Shame on the MPTF.
Since the beginning of this ‘move’ by the MPTF to shut down LTC and Hospital they have failed in their obligation to be forthright and truthful. Their tax returns don’t match their claims. The manner in which the elders and their families informed? Shameful. What happened to common decency? Communication? Compassion? Responsibility? And, “taking care of our own”?
Their recent tax returns in November 2008 show no $10 million losses, or any losses at all. The fund’s assets actually increased in 2006 and 2007.
And then there’s this from Jeffrey Katzenberg, “We give ourselves a failing grade. This has not been communicated well.”
Aren’t we in the communication business? Isn’t he? I would like to think we are ALL in the communication business. The ‘failing grade’ is far more than communication, it’s also about compassion and responsibility.
“Communications” can be bad or good but in this case we needed the plain and truthful variety. The thousands of donors, who gave millions and millions of dollars, and the patients and recipients of this care deserve an accounting.
I am surprised those people, including myself, who supported the MPTF with their dollars haven’t been more vocal? Where are the managers of the estates who are entrusted with donations? Where’s are the people who gave their “industry earned” dollars to The Fund? What’s the plan by the MPTF? Shouldn’t we all know?
If the injunction by Giradi and Keese is successful and this case does go to court, perhaps the truth, the book keeping and the true heroes will emerge. My heroes, as the line goes in the movies, are all about “Truth Justice and The American Way”. Is this the American way?
Well that’s my two cents.
“We are deeply saddened by the fact that we have to close the long term care facility. Our long term care residents will always be important members of the MPTF community and we hope you will allow us to continue serving you after you relocate.”
——————————————————-
There is something about this statement that sounds like B.S. Oh wait I know it is B.S.
They don’t care one bit about what they are doing to those old folks.
If they really cared they would let big name actors, directors, writers ect.. along with all us little people, put money into an account solely for the purpose of keeping the home open.
I never wanted fame but I do now just so I could stand up and do what is right, and have the influence a celebrity has to bring light to this horrific situation!
Where’s good guy Tom Hanks NOW? George Clooney?… anyone?…. anyone?
You gotta give ‘em hope.
horrible contract.
Hi? you’re old? get out.
you haven’t worked in a while. you can’t vote.
Twenty-four dollars? for 6 months? after 17 to 24 days of free reuse?
you want me to dress up as a what?
if I say no, does that mean I’m fired?
and for president of aima 2025, running, once again, unopposed, I’d like to nominate roberta reardon.
I’d like to second that and sing this song, after first cart-wheeling across the stage, tearing off my jacket, and giving roberta a bare-chested hug.
we are pleased to announce, the average income of the aima actor ROSE by 3/4ths of a percent, in 2017, to seventeen thousand dollars a year!
what pension?
tom hanks just bought belgium.
you gotta give ‘em hope!
@ ToSad
“Where’s good guy Tom Hanks NOW? George Clooney?… anyone?…. anyone?”
Haven’t u learned by now? There are no good guys…
That chirping sound you hear is the absence of A-list actors and producers giving a damn about the MPTH…
Just shows not to devote yourself and suffer so for this industry. They won’t take care of you in your old age.
FYI Anonymous,
You obviously are not a family member, nor in Long Term Care at the Home. Research the facts of what is really going on with our legal position and what the final financial outcome will be for the MPTF, before you make your accusations and predictions in regards to Girardi & Keese harming the Fund. Our legal team has been waiting, along with us family members of Residents, for the MPTF to get on the right side of this fight to preserve the historic commitment to care for our Industry Elders, but the MPTF has declined all offers for a healthy resolve. Our legal team has not billed me, nor will they bill me, ONE penny! G & K also knows our mission is NOT to bring the MPTF down, we have pledged from the very beginning, to help the Fund be stronger than it’s ever been. G & K took our case because they believe what we are fighting for, is the RIGHT thing to do, not to line their pockets. Go to their website and read.
Also get it right, our family members that LIVE at the Motion Picture & Television Home are NOT “patients”, they’re “Residents”. It’s their HOME.
Thank you Bill Smitrovich for your two cents, money well spent! Your earnest support is great comfort to all Residents at the Home. God Bless you!
Grateful to all you supporters.
I just cant believe our great industry can let this happen to our pioneers. The people who gave us our jobs. I always thought i would have a place to retire too.
That’s why i worked so long at good pay but no benefit’s. I thought that’s why we payed our dues.
I never thought Steven Spielberg would have anything in his life to be ashamed of, he does now! So does, Tom Hanks, Cruse, Cloony, Julia Roberts, Brad Gray, Zuker, Moonves, The list goes on.
What i want to know what is the REAL reason they want the property ? Is their Oil under neath it? Who is getting a kickback. We should call for an 10 year forensic audit to look at finances.
It’s losing a million a month? I don’t think donations from stars is going to go very far in covering that.
Is there any other industry where you get digs like this when you retire through age 91 and beyond?
It was a noble thing while it lasted, but it’s unrealistic to think it will continue forever.
Have the Teamsters checked in on this latest MPTF salvo?
May I ask a question here?
The 10 or so residents in the long term facility who would be moved out are not mobile/are requiring of constant care. Apparently none are what the wider world would call “famous’. They’re rank and file MPTF members, as I am.
But they were preceeded in their situation at the Home by how many hundreds of once very famous directors, writers, actors and actresses etc. who lived their last days in those same circumstances-that is, they too were bedridden and required constant care.
Once this facility and its capabilities are kaput, will that mean that anyone now living at the Home whose health fails will be ipso facto mustered out to some “longterm care”/hospice place somewhere in the greater L.A. area?
Away from everyone previously familiar to them in the years prior that they lived at the Home?
Away from and not surrounded by caretakers aware of their Industry
past and contributions, as is the case at the Home?
If so…is THAT truly “taking care of our own”?
I too wish I were wealthy. I wish to God that a Pickford were alive today to set this right as I’m certain she would. It’s great what her and others’ hard work and money has come to, isn’t it? She didn’t have to end her days at the Home-but she damn well knew others without her resources would.
Any actor or other industry professional of great means via employment in this industry who steps up now will be doing something incredibly important, and noble.
Why is that not happening?
Mr. Tillman,
May you reap what you sow someday.
What about the millions that Katzenberg raises each year at his Beverly Hills hotel event?
Its disgusting that these self-aggrandizing millionaires dont give a shit about the elderly.
No A-listers willing to step up? Do we remember when the A-listers were on our Next Generation Council? All the names have been removed now. But we had names like Whoopi, Heather Locklear. Maybe someone has the old stationary around and would like to add them to list of shame.
It has been rumored that maybe the whole facility is listed to close now. Not just LTC. That was just the first step. Be ready for more
Isn’t it ironic that the day Senator Ted Kennedy lost his battle with brain cancer that the self-centered “me the people” group who hold sway in the entertainment business would choose to jettison the very people they promised to take care of in their old age. Kennedy, theh outspoken champion of the old, inferm and sick…and who, the men who are so concerned with the length of their small dicks they spend all their energy trying to find a way to one-up each other?
SHAME on those who lack the humanity and compassion for their own. And think about this…there are MANY MANY ticket buyers who will let them know in the only way they understand…they will stop buying tickets.
Daniel,
G & K might not be billing you anything, however if this does go to court the MPTF will have to hire lawyers (if they haven’t already) and they WILL bill the MPTF!
I’m not saying your wrong for what you are doing, but recognizing that this looks like a lose-lose situation no matter how it plays out.
Have the Teamsters issued a comment on this latest MPTF attack?
I know absolutely nothing about the law firm of Girardi & Keese, except from going to their website, but I do know about, and have dealt enough with other L.A. firms, to know that many of them are used in the entertainment industry as “fixers” – the Pellicano case is a good example. So far, there has been very little hard talk about actually legally going after and exposing the MPTF Board’s financial records, which could mean that “the fix” is already in or one is being negotiated behind closed doors. One would hope that this time it will be different and heads will roll, but I just can’t get “Chinatown” out of my mind.
Kenny,
Didn’t you read Bill Smitrovitch’s post?
The recent tax returns show NO LOSSES.
Well said Bill. Good on ya.
Hopefully the lawsuit will prevail and the truth will out.