2ND UPDATE: Here is the response from “Saving The Lives Of Our Own”:
Los Angeles—In reaction to a “pre-eviction” notice released by the Motion Picture Television Fund today, residents of the MPTF long-term care facility and their families rejected the letter as an example of continued strong-arm tactics by the Fund and its administrators. In an interview, the MPTF’s Ken Scherer insists the facility will be closed by the Thanksgiving holiday.
The letter was released to the media before being delivered to the residents and their families, in the presence of security guards, in a further attempt to intimidate and frighten the elderly out of the Home they were promised would be there for them until the end of their days.
Lynn Medford, whose husband Don, 91, is a director and long-time resident of the Home says, “They gave us a letter already stating what was stated before. It’s the easy way out for them in lieu of an eviction letter. Nothing’s new.”
“The more the MPTF tries to defend its indefensible position, the more public outrage is generated in support of the 80 frail, elderly residents who are being forced out of their homes. Dr. Tillman’s letter is a blatant attempt to circumvent and deprive the elderly, including my mother, of their rights. Families will not be fooled into ‘voluntarily’ relocating their loved ones,” insists Melody Sherwood, whose mother Kay Meyer, 93, is a resident of the facility.
“When they carry me out of my home in a coffin, that’s when I’ll leave here,” states Larry Jennings, a 73-year-old resident and electrician, member of IATSE Local 40.Saving the Lives of Our Own, representing over 4000 Entertainment Industry professionals and members of the community concerned about the MPTF long-term care facility closure, is committed to keeping this historic and vital Hollywood facility open.
We are requesting:
– An immediate reversal of the decision to close the long-term care facility in acknowledgment of the commitment made to these seniors and their families
– A dedicated fundraising campaign for the purpose of keeping the facility open
– Financial transparency in the form of a comprehensive and independent audit of the MTPF and all its related entities.“Saving the Lives of Our Own” is a grass-roots coalition of Entertainment Industry workers and community members. Our mission is to keep the MPTF long-term care facility open, to stop the evictions of its elderly residents and to ensure that the MPTF promise of “Taking Care of Our Own” remains unbroken – now and for future generations.
UPDATE: A top activist opposing the closures emails me, “They are obviously trying to force the families to pull the trigger on their lawsuit, and to put them and their lawyers on the defensive. Not gonna happen.”
EXCLUSIVE: I’ve just been told that the Motion Picture & Television Fund Board Of Directors is sending preliminary notice to those affected that the long-term unit and intensive care hospital at Woodland Hills will be closed at the end of 2009 as previously announced. Sources tell me this preliminary notice is a kind of “pre-letter” to alert patients and their families and friends and other activists that they’ll be getting formal notice soon of the intent to shutter the facilities. So now the end game of this controversial MPTF action is being played out.
The MPTF tells me it’s making this move because four months of settlement talks have broken down with Los Angeles litigator Tom Girardi’s law firm Girardi & Keese which is representing the patients and their families and friends who want to keep open the facilities which are reportedly losing $1 million a month. “We’ve made all kinds of overtures, but they haven’t responded with any plan of their own,” an MPTF insider tells me. ”They want to keep the hospital and long-term care unit open for 80 people even if it bankrupts all the services used by 60,000.” The MPTF is expecting Girardi’s firm to counter with an injunction preventing the shutdowns, and a lawsuit.
This comes just as SAG and the Teamsters voted to oppose MPTF’s impending acute care closures because of lobbying by the grassroots organization, Saving The Lives Of Our Own, a 3,600-member coalition of MPTF residents, family members and friends. According to the activists, the remaining 100 or so residents live in daily fear that they will be evicted from the caring home promised them as a peaceful place to live out their days. The group keeps asking the MPTF Board of Directors to reverse their decision to close the nursing home.
Here is the MPTF letter:
August 25, 2009
Dear Patients and Families,
In our efforts to keep you abreast of developments regarding the impending closure of the long-term care facility and hospital, I am writing to give you an update. I am also writing to reiterate our commitment to working with you throughout the transition process and after you or your family member leaves the campus.
Since January when we announced our difficult decision to close the long term care facility and hospital by the end of the year, it has been our goal to help you identify appropriate options for relocation and to work with you to make the transition as comfortable as possible. We hoped that by giving our residents many months to make plans that most, if not all of you would be far along in the process by now.
We have tried to reach a mutually acceptable solution with the lawyers who are representing many of you in connection with the closure. Our outside counsel has been working with them to craft a solution that would address your transfer and relocation concerns. To that end, the parties retained a former associate California Supreme Court Justice to mediate a settlement. Regrettably, those talks have not been successful and so I urge you to move forward with your transition plans.
We must move forward with phasing out the facility and we want to remind you once again of the resources and assistance we are providing, and to urge you to take full advantage of them.
We have identified 22 high quality community nursing facilities that were screened by MPTF staff to ensure that they could and would support our residents and keep them connected to MPTF health and, or social services via our Community Care teams, if they desire. A list of these facilities is available from your social worker.
We understand that you and your family may have concerns and questions about how the transfer and relocation process actually works. In addition to talking to your social worker about the steps you need to take, we can put you in touch with the Community Care Team. They can give you first hand accounts about how MPTF staff including Dr. Humayun and Linda Healy have worked with them through the process, and in a number of cases continue to provide care where desired.
We are deeply saddened by the fact that we have to close the long term care facility. Our long term care residents will always be important members of the MPTF community and we hope you will allow us to continue serving you after you relocate.
In closing, I urge you once again to allow us to help you identify as many options for relocation as possible and to make the transition as comfortable as possible.
Sincerely,
David Tillman, MD
President / CEO
MPTF
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.







Oh I disagree with the sideliner. This is far from a lose-lose situation. When the lawyers do what they have to do, they will be fighting for the rest of all those who have worked and contributed. The MPTF seems to have set this scheme in motion several years back and we have the spoilers to thank for stopping it in its tracks. The more of us they battle, the more they are falsely emboldened. Will we see MPTF unravel? The bigger they are, the harder they fall. The Wall Street scandals are recent reminders of that. Then we can all watch from the sidelines and help to put the pieces back together again when its over.
My father died at the Motion Picture facility two years ago. I’m truly lucky that he did not live long enough to be forced out. When he broke his leg in a fall and had to be moved from the assisted living facility to the hospital there, it was traumatic to lose his room, his furniture and his mobility.
But at least he didn’t lose his friends. His former nurses and boarders from the assisted living facility still visited and made the transition easier. And taking him around the beautiful grounds still made him smile. I pity the older generation, now that they will be shipped off to die alone!
It doesn’t make sense that it would cost $1 million per month to take care of 90 people. Even the costliest, top-notch, private long term care facilites for seniors only cost $5-6k per month, per person. Which is still a rip off. So, who is getting rich here? Who wants this property sold? The “CEO”? Does he get a bonus if it makes it look suddenly “profitable” or within the budget if a multi-million dollar real estate transaction and massive layoffs of health care workers temporarily fills the MPTV fund coffers?
Or did Bernie Madoff or others run off with the funds?
Those of us who have contributed and who depend on that facility being there when we need it, have the right to know. It is beyond a failure to send out a blanket xerox telling people that the “gig” is up and the money has dried up. This is about our future, not just about the people who are there now.
Katzenberg and others on the board owe it to the film industry to find a creative solution to save this facility. They got us into this mess; they should get us out. Have a Jerry Lewis style telethon, have a “Save the Fund” music event, have $5000 per plate, star-studded fundraisers until the facility gets stable and then find a way to run the facility that is more in line with the private facilities that offer similar high quality care for half the price. It can and must be done!
NY Times August 25, 2009 – Movie Fund Set to Close Housing Unit for the Aged
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/08/26/movies/26fund.html?_r=2
“…high labor costs, stagnant or declining reimbursements from state and federal health care programs, sharply reduced investment income and declining philanthropic support resulted in a $24 million deficit in 2008. A projected shortfall averaging about $16 million over the next five years, the group said, threatens to exhaust the fund’s net investment reserves of about $68 million by 2013.
About half of a projected operating deficit of $23 million annually — only some of which is expected to be made up by donations and investments — was attributed to the long-term-care unit, making it a prime target for a cutback.
But public financial statements through 2007 actually showed growth in net assets, leading to furious criticism from residents and commentators. Those objecting were particularly galled by the disclosure that Dr. Tillman received a pay increase of about 40 percent from 2005 to 2007, raising his compensation to about $600,000 at a time when the fund’s finances were supposedly deteriorating.
“New management” is the cure recommended by Nancy Biederman, whose mother-in-law, Jane Biederman, has been a resident for nine years, and whose mother, the television writer Irma Kalish, served on two of the fund’s boards before resigning this year. Ms. Biederman said she believed the fund’s reported financial crunch was a “created crisis,” intended to help Dr. Tillman, who formerly ran the organization’s clinics, toward an expansion of clinical care.”
Let’s see…ah…Brad’s in Louisiana building new homes for the Katrina victims… Georgie touts Darfur… Stevie touts Shoah… Tommy touts the new S.A.G. contract… Good causes all… No time for their fellow industry vets though…
Let’s take a look at how the MPTF Board members are presently spending your Fund:
. Renting prop phony police cars to park at the Home to intimidate
patients and family members
. Hiring bodyguards for Dr. Tillman to accompany him everywhere he
goes
. Hiring a horde of security guards (with golf carts at their disposal) to
add more pressure on patients and family members
. Paying for private lawyers for the Jeffrey Katzenbergs of this world
Did I hear they have hired 4 lawyers so far? Billed to the Fund of
course. Shall we now talk about how they are not accepting cash donations, are not filling beds that bring into the fund $10,000/month In one hallway alone I counted 8 empty beds x $10,00 – wow – that = $80,000 a month Tillman has decided that the fund no longer needs!
Let’s open the books follow the money and we’ll have our answers.
And one more thing…….To the MPTFund decision makers….
When you called my family in July of 2008 and told us you had a room for my brother, and welcomed him as a patient in the LTC facility, did you already know you were going to close 5 months later? You accepted him with a diagnosis of early onset Alzheimer’s Disease. You knew he would be in your facility for the rest of his life and that he would never get better – only gradually succumb to his disease. 5 months later my brother’s wife received the MPTF letter saying she had 60 days to find him a new place.
My response to MPTF CEO Ken Scherer’s statement in the Wrap.com, “We didn’t want to do this. This is as painful for us as it is for the families.” is, REALLY? Then when you took my brother into your care one year ago, you had no idea that this was coming? In the 5 months that followed the entire financial structure of the Home fell apart?
What everyone of us have been asking since January 14th is WHY WEREN’T WE TOLD THERE WAS A PROBLEM – WHY WASN’T ANYONE TOLD THERE WAS A PROBLEM? It’s a very simple question Mr. Scherer – Why did you give my brother, an industry worker for nearly 30 years, a home to live out the rest of his days, and then take it away from him – and every other industry worker that had the expectation that the MPTF Home would always be there for them as promised?
If the MPTF Board made public statements that the fund was ten million in debt and the tax returns say that it’s ten million to the good, doesn’t this fall under the catigory of distributing false information to its dues paying members? And, aren’t there illeagalities involved in such actions?
It’s sad that a facility that promises to ‘Take Care Of Their Own’, is now trying to ‘farm them out’ to other care facilities. I drive by the MPTF every day and notice recent improvements: modern new buildings, landscaping and plans for future condo development?
Why not put those millions of dollars towards your residents? It’s just disgusting, and no amount of press releases from the MPTF will justify their intolerable behavior. We all know better. (So do they).
Have all the charity funds that Katzenberg raised at his big Academy Awards charity bashes been audited? How much was actually raised and how much actually made it to the MPTF?
For the rest of their lives, Tillman, Katzenberg and the others who are behind this travesty will be looked at for exactly who they are! This will be their legacy…
What really burns me is Edie Wasserman’s fatuous and patently untrue comment that the facility was never meant to offer “lifetime” care. What a lie! She should be working to keep it open, not making disingenous excuses.
If this MPTF facility is doomed, one option is the nuclear option, use a political hook to get the IRS to do an expedited audit of this non-profit. If the MPTF is spending donations in an improper way, for excessive salaries to executives, for unreasonable expenses like renting out movie prop police cars or for salaries to no-show employees who are relatives of management higher-ups, that could create problems for this organization.
The other option, way more expensive, is to hire a forensic accountant to examine the MPTF books for fraud. Embezzlement is always a problem at non-profits that are run by a few insiders. If you don’t look, you don’t find. Refer to the SEC versus Bernie Madoff.
My family received our letter from Dr. Tillman and the MPTF. The following was my reply…
Dear David Tillman, M.D.,
Thank you for your letter keeping me abreast of the developments regarding the impending closure of the long-term care facility and hospital.
You’ve obviously never met my Mother. She lives at the Motion Picture Home. Let me try and bring you up to speed on my Mom. She is among the most frail and vulnerable of the home’s residents. She has been on palliative care for a number of months and owes her very life to the exceptional care of your staff. For this, everyone in my family is exceedingly grateful… really beyond words. That being said, I feel certain that if she were moved in her present condition she would surely die. This is not an opinion I hold alone. I’m sure if you had any knowledge of my Mom, you’d concur.
In addition, my Mom suffers from dementia and has no knowledge that she’s in danger of losing the comfort and security of the surroundings that are now her home. I feel, if she were to somehow survive the physical stress and turmoil of a move, the resultant loss of that comfort and security would certainly press her into a state of depression and confusion that would bring about her death.
So David, my family and I will fight with everything we have to prevent my Mother from being moved… anything else would be unconscionable. Obviously, as a doctor, we believe you should share our position.
Best regards,
A loving Son
In addition, I would like to express my gratitude for the support of the Screen Actors Guild and the Teamsters… and to say how truely disappointed I am in my own guild, the DGA. C’mon guys, where’s your moral compass?
I believe in our lawyers. I believe that they have tried to avert a legal storm. I believe they know who and what they are dealing with.
Why are some of the guilds pro-closure? What do they have to gain? Who wants to dump the old people – call’em out now.
The true nuclear option is the lawsuit, followed by the threatened class action suits. MPTF calls it a weak case. That so? Then why the despicable intimidation tactics? It’s all about the money.