
MONDAY 12:30PM UPDATE : I’ve learned that writer’s assistant-turned-staff writer, Robin Veith, quit Mad Men before she could be let go by Matthew Weiner.
A source tells me: “It was at the very worst mutual. She needed to move on and see how she would do after leaving the nest. Matt is a genius, and he gave lots of people an opportunity, but never let’s anyone forget it. I’m sure he’d never tell anyone she quit, because that is a rejection of him. Anyway, they are friends and made a mutual decision.”
A show insider replies, “There are staffing changes every season. It is the nature of television shows to fine tune. Why is it news this season?” Because the show won two best drama Emmy’s in a row, and with success comes attention. Deal with it.
UPDATE: A prominent female writer (she asked not to be identified) knows both Kater Gordon and Matthew Weiner and sets the record straight for me: “As a female writer who has worked with many strong showrunners, I have to say that any ‘Letterman’ talk on today’s thread about Kater Gordon really disgusts me. The same kind of talk followed me and my success. So you see, you can’t win. If you’re young and female, you’ll always be suspect. Success or failure, it can’t be because you’ve actually got the goods. I feel compelled to come to both Kater and Matt’s defense on this one. Kater was a fantastic writer’s assistant, the best. She totally got the show and deserved the break she got. There was NOTHING illicit in her relationship with Matt. I believe Kater will go on to great success, if she so desires, and their parting of the ways was amicable.”
EXCLUSIVE: Well, this is a big surprise. As recently as September 20th, Kater Gordon won the drama-writing Emmy with Matthew Weiner for the Mad Men episode ”Meditations In An Emergency”. Now that Season 3 has wrapped, Gordon is off the Lionsgate show that airs on AMC. Here’s what I’ve learned: Matt originally hired Kater as his personal assistant. She was soon promoted to be his writer’s assistant, and by the end of that same season, Matt offered her the opportunity to co-write the season finale – a particularly important show for him as Weiner also directs the final episode of each season. Then, without requiring Kater to generate any other spec material on her own (usually required for a writer’s advancement), Matt promoted her to be a full-time staff writer for this past season. (Mad Men has a predominantly female writing staff…)
So what happened? A show insider emails me this explanation: ”One of the great things about Mad Men is the tradition that Matt has established of offering higher-level opportunities to staff, writers and artists in all of the various departments. From the beginning, Matt has fought to get people approved by the studio which almost always lobbied for him to hire more experienced people instead. In every season thus far, relatively new actors have been cast for significant roles, aspiring writers have been given opportunities to write scripts, and first-time directors have been offered their first chance to direct.
“We think [Kater's] done a great job, particularly for someone whose career has progressed so quickly. Now, however, Matt has reluctantly decided that their relationship has reached its full potential. She’ll be missed, but the series has consistently benefited from the influx of new writer talent, and there’s absolutely no doubt that Kater will continue to have unprecedented success in her career as she spreads her wings. She leaves Mad Men with our love and respect and a well-deserved Emmy.”
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.


I’d bet money on the real truth being that SHE opted not to come back next season. “Fired” is a very vague term in TV writing.
I do not know the details behind this. What I do know is that Kater’s shows have been the strongest this season. Her voice is clear because Matthew co-writes so many other scripts that do not come across like Kater’s episodes come across. This past Sunday’s show is a prime example. She has a gift. Obviously, Matthew’s influence has had a tremendous impact on her. She is a true talent. I will miss her voice on MAD MEN. I will be watching her wherever she goes. Whoever lands her is very lucky. I’ve worked in TV for over a decade. I’ve seen this kind of thing happen over and over again. Every situation is different. The truth will surface when we see Kater’s future work. I look forward to this.
Something tells me in 50 years we will have a cable show about the writing room of Mad Men.
There was a really weird moment during the acceptance where Matt kind of ‘snatched’ the Emmy from her. Can someone post a Youtube of it? The photo gets at it but I remember it being uncomfortable to watch.
I always trhought they worked with these relatively inexperienced people on this show primarily for financial reasons. Allows them to put as much money as possible up on the screen.
Aside: The episode they won for, the Season 2 finale, was obviously not the best one of last season. It was actually a real come-down from the brilliant penultimate episode, which featured Don’s side-trip in California. “Meditations on an Emergency” was a bit more “regular” by comparison.
Please – the episode of Don’s California trip was the weakest of the scripts. I thought they let the real writers go on vacation and got a crew of subs to write that script. You can’t tell me that we needed all those weird characters to be injected into the story when we have a whole cadre of wonderful characters that could be richly utilized to advance the series.
I think we all know having your name on a tv script doesn’t mean you had a lot to do with the episode necessarily. Maybe she just wasn’t that good. Although why are you posting a random staff writer firing, Nikki? Happens all the time. Maybe not for such an acclaimed show, but that’s just a matter of numbers.
kudos to matt
keepin it fresh
lol the scene with Don barking at Peggy takes on new significance
Anyone who believes this horseshit is completely naïve. Matt Weiner is the lowest of the low in our business. He is a egomaniac and the likelihood is that he was incensed that he had to share credit and let alone an Emmy with her. A lowly former writer’s assistant. As far as he is concerned, he is solely responsible for the success of this show and no other writer, producer, director, actor, key grip have done anything to contribute to the show’s success. For Pete’s sake, he didn’t even let Kater Gordon say a word when they got up on stage. It was her moment as well but Weiner made it ALL about him. I don’t recall him even acknowledging her. It is most likely he fired her from the show because she had the misfortune of having her name on HIS script. He is a disgusting human being.
I’ve met her, she’s a wonderful person to be around. Someone should pick her up quickly.
thank you, Nikki for the revelation. What you are effectively telling us is that a nobody, without a modicum of talent, can be hired at “Mad Men”, while other experienced talented writers CAN’T BE HIRED, CANNOT WORK at AMC-regardless if they are men or women, because they don’t have a relationship with Weiner. The predominantly female staff is nothing to cheer about. It’s an anachronistic BS feminism throwback.
I think that the show awfully sucks, and personally puts me to sleep…
“…Matt has reluctantly decided that their relationship has reached its full potential. She’ll be missed…”
To use an old expression, ‘Something’s rotten in Denmark.’ Nikki, that explanation emailed you by the “show insider” smells bad from the first word. There’s no way that’s the real reason, and it’s fairly clear she was fired – there’s no other word for it. I hope you find out what REALLY happened, Nikki, and report it.
Myself, I’d bet that Weiner’s inflated ego resented sharing credit & an Emmy with Kater Gordon and wanted her out of the way. I could be wrong, but that email reeks of the kind of shit flacks send out. And this one is a damn fool; he just put in writing something that any lawyer would have a field day with. Not to mention the California Labor Commission (and I hope they’re listening).
I’d like to add that I love MAD MEN. And for me, this reprehensible behavior on Weiner’s part now gives it a bad taste. He’s shown the world that he is a very talented guy, as well as a back-stabbing, double-dealing bastard.
BTW, is this the new grounds for terminating someone… when “their relationship has reached its full potential”, as that insider wrote? If that’s true, then 9/10′s of the suits in the executive suites should have been fired long ago.
Hey JBN,
It’s not an old expression, it’s a quote from Hamlet: There is something rotten in the state of Denmark.
That answer doesn’t explain anything, it just sucks up to Weiner.
If it’s a ” a predominantly female writing staff”, where is the story here? It’s not like she was the only female writer?
The only episode she wrote by herself was “The Fog” and it was terrible. Looks like Matt got too excited and promoted her too quickly…
I agree, “The Fog” had some horribly on the nose dialogue, although we did get a couple gems like from Gene: “You’re a housecat: you’re very important and you have little to do.”
My review tore up Kater Gordon, so I was surprised to see her win an emmy and now even more surprised to see her gone…
http://tinyurl.com/yff9a6g
p.s. I always assumed Weiner was gay, no?
OK, so what is the real story?
So which AMC or Lionsgate flack was that “insider email” written by? If that isn’t press release material, I don’t know what is…
Ummm, that “show insider” should go work in D.C. because that was an incredible amount of words used to say absolutely nothing.
Something very definitely does not add up here. I think that the key is their phrase that Weiner’s and Gordon’s “relationship has reached its full potential.” That sounds like she was hit with some sort of adverse action. I hope that we can hear from Kater to get her side of the story. Also, is this something that the WGA can look into?
that’s a cruel thing for him to do
Impossible to know how much Kater actually contributed to the Emmy winning script. 5%? 50% 90%. What has she done on her own? Why would a talented writer get bounced from the show?
What was his arrogance at the emmy’s? I missed that. He seemed pretty gracious. The woman is a staff writer and I think she was freelance last season…
MW: “I am the only one in this room who has full creative control.”
[I paraphrase, but that's the gist of it.]
This dismissal message sounds like something Roger would have said….
Only one person was able to make an acceptance speech at the Emmys, so why not him? It is HIS show. I’m sure she was relieved. And I recall he gave props on her behalf to her fiance. She may have been just lucky – like Jill Franklyn getting a credit on Peter Mehlman’s Emmy-winning Yada-Yada script for “Seinfeld”
After reading all this one thing becomes apparent. When nobody knows the facts they’ll make ‘em up to fit their own shortcomings and bias’.
Much ado about NOTHING.
Fine he fired her. Writers get fired all the time. But he did punk her this year at the Emmys and last year when she was nominated and he called her his assistant. Mathew please get that there is enough to go around for everyone. One thing David Chase never did was punk those publicly who worked for him. He let you guys all shine. You have a hit, can’t you help other people without diminishing them.
The irony is if Peggy is shown the door in the same manner.
I worked with Kater Gordon on Mad Men and with people that have known her for years. She was the friendliest and sweetest person I met while working there. Saying she had some sort of affair to get her position is the most irresponsible and reckless thing a person could possibly say. Everyone knows that Matt Weiner is the most talented prick in Hollywood.
Look at how shocked and annoyed Matt W is when this question is not directed to him. And look how he holds his Emmys too, in case we didn’t know he won twice.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Pkcw4A0TI8&feature=player_embedded#
ouch…he does look pissy. thanks for the link.
Wow, this video’s pretty telling. This guy’s a douche