UPDATES Tillman Exits Controversy-Plagued MPTF
Sources associated with the Motion Picture and Television Fund have confirmed to me that president/CEO Dr. David Tillman was pushed to exit because of the public relations nightmare over the closing of the acute care hospital and long-term elderly care facilities. “He left because of the process and how it was handled. Life is about execution. So if you can’t execute something well, it doesn’t matter how good the plan is. He resigned because that was the appropriate way to handle it,” an MPTF insider explained to me late last night. Nor, I’m told, was the $600,000-a-year Tillman — at one point named by MSNBC’s Keith Olbermann ”World’s Worse” person because of the closures — surprised to hear that board members were dissatisfied.
I also learned that Jeffrey Katzenberg, who’s been on the receiving end of the criticism for the closures, was not directly involved in Tillman’s removal because the DreamWorks Animation CEO doesn’t sit on that board subcommittee which made the decision. But “it’s safe to assume that nothing there is going to happen unless Jeffrey is OK with it,” the MPTF assured me.
Tillman’s exit came yesterday just a few weeks before Katzenberg hosts his major MPTF fundraiser, “The Night Before” party held annually on the eve of the Oscar broadcast. Last year’s limousines arriving for the Saturday fete were greeted outside the Beverly Hills Hotel venue by 250 caregivers, entertainment industry figures, and family members of the facility’s elderly residents protesting the MPTF-ordered closures.
It’s widely felt that exiting Tillman is a first step in the board trying to bring the Hollywood community, and especially members who’ve been most vocal on this issue, back together in its decades-old support of the MPTF. “I hope they see improved operations from our end of the table,” the MPTF insider told me.
But reconciliation can only occur when the bigshots behind the MPTF remember that it’s been kept going by generations of movie and television workers for some 90 years. And that more effort must be made to reach out to the Hollywood community ahead of time whenever big decisions like the closures are about to made or even considered. In turn, the Hollywood community must figure out a way to better support the MPTF through payroll deductions, union-organized tithing, something. Or else the fatcats who give the big donations will always have the final say in what happens there.
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.


There’s no doubt that Tillman’s ‘resignation’ is just a condition of his termination agreement. He leaves tarnished. As one of the architects of the plan to evict the remaining residents, he should turn in his ‘doctor card’ and renounce the Hippocratic Oath that he took. I remember during one of the first family meetings asking him how, as a doctor, he could be on the board’s side, and not on the side of the family.
I think that’s when David Carradine strode up the aisle and took the microphone from a bewildered Tillman to launch into a 20 minute diatribe against the closure. David must be smiling down at us right now.
Let’s not forget that Bob Beitcher is not necessarily a friend of ‘ours’. He is yet to prove himself, and his rhetoric up to this point has been one of closure. My recommendation is that he reach out to the residents, families, and industry that demand that the LTC doors remain open.
Beitcher claimed on a blog that the MPTF’s ‘business model accelerated its demise’. Ask Tillman if it was the business model that accelerated his demise. He might want to own up to the truth to salvage his career. It’s never been about money.
Coop wheeled him out.
This “departure” should not stop a FULL SCALE INVESTIGATION into the financial shenanigans and payouts over the years. In other words, no one involved should be allowed to get away with this!
as a former employee, we used to get anonymous letters disclosing the fact that the top people were lining their pockets. its no suprise to anyone working there. they should all be held accountable. they stole from the hardworking people that work behind the scenes, and from those in front as well.
The closure decision is based on the MP&TF Board position that the Fund is losing $10 million a year or more on the Nursing Home’s 189 residents. Over the past year the Board churned out press releases telling this to the world and many journalists who should know better repeated this as a fact with no basis to support it.
Here are some facts you can check out: MediCal pays the MP&TF $10,500 per resident bed per month [offset by social security payments], and this amount is paid directly by those who pay privately. If you do the math you will find the Fund can receive about $26 million per year for the 189 residents at the Home.
Add to this the fact that the Fund owns outright the buildings and land. The Fund has charitable tax status for the Home and pays no taxes. The Fund bills each resident separately for medical tests and medications. The Fund received big donations each year directed to the Home. Just add the $26 million to the $10 million the Fund says it is losing. Do you believe it costs the Fund $36 million plus or $26 million plus each year to care for 189 residents? You would have to be [excuse the expression] a village idiot to believe this.
Regardless, the Fund/Home was set up to be a charity, yes a charity, to take care of those in our Industry who needed care in their later years or those who wanted to live out their last years/days amongst their peers. It wasn’t set out to be a business running health clinics with superficial care, or a place to fill a prescription, or to offer up a spectacular health and fitness center for $25 dollars per month. If you want to run these businesses be my guest, but it should have nothing to do with the “charity” side.
It’s all either utter bullshit or gross mismanagement or something else. Like maybe an “AGENDA” that sick old handicapped people aren’t worth spending money on, aren’t worth wasting resources on. Pretty disgusting huh? Especially coming from a Board that consists only of multi-millionaires and billionaires.
Tillman’s resignation is one small step in the right direction – but it’s far from over, especially when multi-trillionaire Board Member Frank Mancuso announces that he told the interim head to make it his priority to get rid of the sick old people remaining in the Nursing Home. What a man, what a man.
This is nothing more than an attempted smokescreen to divert attention away from Kazenberg and the others who are deeply involved in every move the Board makes and then Li’l Jeffy can point to his “The Night Before” party – excuse me – “find-raiser” and show everyone what a nice, wholesome, benevolent, honorable guy he is…
Don’t let the door hit you in the ass on the way out Dr. Tillman. Five years ago he walked into a conference room at the Samuel Goldwyn Foundation Childrens Center and told us parents that the MPTF was not in the childcare business and pawned us off on a corporation to maintain the center. He told us that there would not be any increases in costs or major changes to teacher ratios, etc. – total lie. He also told us in August, so we had no chance of getting our kids into a new pre-school and he was so rude and inconsiderate in the way he made his announcement. A few parents almost reached over the table to ring his neck. In their advertisements the MPTF still uses the children to raise money and there are some amazing people who earmark their donations for the children every year, but the children are long forgotten. I truly hope that the finances are investigated and that at least that MPTF members are aware of how awfully we were treated. I am glad that the elderly do have a voice that the children did not.
We hear Mr. Katzenberg has managed to distance himself from committees and votes involved in this tragic situation. That should tell all the board members something. The good doctor had his strengths and weaknesses, and it’s obvious he’ll have to lawyer up now that he is no longer under the protection of the invisible mogul. Maybe the rest of the board members will want to do the same before they join the doctor under the bus.
Dear A-List Stars and Corporate Leaders:
The Motion Picture Fund and it’s leadership are doing everything they can to close the Motion Picture Nursing Home and throw out the most sick, handicapped and needy seniors in our Industry. They have absolutely refused to allow donations to be made to keep the Nursing Home open, they refuse to undertake fundraising for the Nursing Home. No reasonable person believes it is a financial situation. Their Agenda seems clear, don’t waste resources on sick, old handicapped people. . There is no room for sick, handicapped old people at the Motion Picture Fund. The COO Seth Ellis told Nursing Home Magazine in a 2007 interview “Nobody wants to see sickness on [the MPTF] Campus…we want to see successful aging.”
Please consider not lending your good name to the Motion Picture & Television Funds upcoming pre-Academy Awards Party, the “Night Before Gala.” Please do not attend this year. Funds raised will deliberately not be used for the Nursing Home and it’s residents. Stand-up and protest the grotesque treatment of the most sick and needy in our Industry who live at the Nursing Home and who are threatened with eviction by the Board leadership who insist on closing the Nursing Home permanently. Charlie Chaplin, Mary Pickford and Douglas Fairbanks had a dream and they worked hard with others in the Industry to make it come true in the form of a Nursing Home. “We Take Care Of Our Own – that was the historical motto.” Help stop the madness.
Thank you.
i can appreciate the need to close the hospital, and perhaps not let anyone else in at this time to long term care, but the residents who currently live on campus should be allowed to stay until they pass away. i hope that mptf gets slapped with a class action suit from all whose family members have endured the stress of moving, or perhaps died from it. as the individual in previous post stated, if you do the math they can recieve 26 million a year for the remaining 189 patients. why would you kick them out? something stinks. I think they already stole the money.
There will be no improved operations at MPTF’s end of the table until they reinstate the hospital & long term care. Ken Scherer is saying all things to all people, so are the others in his dept. People are stopping their donations and changing their wills, feeling they’ve been victims of the bait-and-switch.
The sooner Katzenberg tells his legal team to make a deal, the better. This isn’t about ego, it’s about humanity.
The industry has weighed in. We want, and will support, an MPTF that includes smart and compassionate people like some in Saving the Lives of Our Own.
“In turn, the Hollywood community must figure out a way to better support the MPTF through payroll deductions, union-organized tithing, something.”
Ha
“Or else the fatcats who give the big donations will always have the final say in what happens there.”
Well, duh!
Where have you been under a rock?! I have been contributing to the MPTF through payroll deductions since I got my SAG card in 1960! And, I would almost guarantee that nearly everyone in SAG, as well as all the other guilds and unions, does the same! Where has the money gone?! Where the f#*k is the accounting?! Where is the transparency?! This is not someone’s f#*king personal cookie jar!
its in the pockets of tillman, katzenberg, the lead dr in the health center im sure, and anyone else at the top. my father in law worked in this industry since 1930s for 45 years and my husband has put 45 years into this industry since the 1960s. Ive watched this place decline, and its so sad. i used to think of it in such a loving manner, and decided i wanted to work here. i got the job. wow, what a major mistake. i used to come when only beverly and ardeth ran the health center. they are loyal employees who have in recent years been railroaded and treated badly. I found out the hard way that they dont want industry family members to be hired at the hospital. My supervisor was fired for hiring me, and i was ousted in the most decietful bate and switch scheme that nearly killed me. That should turn the light on in your heads that they have much to hide. They say they take care of their own, but we all now know that they have only been taking care of their own “selves”.
Reconciliation can only occur when long term care is reinstated into the continuum of care on campus. The Hollywood community can be brought together when that occurs. Trying to get the Hollywood community to buy into the sacrifice of MPTF’s historical mission, and a few good residents, for the promise of closer future ties and the greater good of an HMO is a another miscalculation that will only increase the likelihood of litigation. If MPTF truly wants reconciliation, Mr. Katzenberg knows who to call at Girardi Keese.
If MPTF is seeking a mandate from industry to go forward with closure plans, guilds should run as far away from MPTF as other nursing homes have done. Who wants to be dragged down with MPTF?
The final episode in this saga is not yet written by the fatcats. I don’t believe for a minute that closing the nursing home is a fait accompli.