
UPDATE: I’ve learned that Marvel Studios and director Joe Johnston are testing candidates for The First Avenger: Captain America which Paramount will distribute on July 22, 2011. I’ve scooped their wish list: most but by no means all of the contenders are young hunks who come from both movies and television — Chace Crawford (CW’s Gossip Girl), John Krasinski (NBC’s The Office), Scott Porter (NBC’s Friday Night Lights), Mike Vogel (Cloverfield), Michael Cassidy (CW’s Privileged), Patrick Flueger (Brothers). They also wanted Garrett Hedlund (Tron Legacy), but he so far hasn’t made a test deal. The studio yesterday tested several candidates from this list. It’s not surprising that the roster contains so many little known actors: Marvel after all cast a complete unknown as Thor, Chris Hemsworth. The role is enticing, but Marvel is known for driving hard bargains on its superhero deals. There’s a salary scale, but if you’re not a known quantity like Crawford or Krasinski, the offer is around $300,000 for the first film. And whoever gets the role will have to sign for another nine options for future films that include sequels, Avengers movies, or anything else Marvel decides. In fact, I’m told reliably that Captain America director Johnston recently reached an impasse with Marvel and briefly walked off the film when Marvel informed him the budget was too high and he’d have to take a pay cut.
They found common ground and he returned to the fold, but it reinforces Marvel’s reputation for hard bargaining, something that all the Iron Man 2 participants discovered. For those not in the know, Captain America is Steve Rogers, a military service washout who volunteers for a top secret research project that turns him into the superhero dedicated to defending America’s ideals. The sickly young man is enhanced to the peak of human potential by an experimental serum: he’s known for using his signature vibranium-steel allow shield as a multipurpose weapon.


the first thing they should do is rethink director choice. what tired, generic director. this will be a big budget programmer with joe johnston most likely serving as marvel’s bitch.
mj
You’re all crazy….
On Monday, I heard from someone in the industry that John Krasinsky was a more-than-legit candidate to play Captain America and, admittedly, I had to let the idea sink in.
I really like Krasinski. He’s a great-looking guy and has a lot of charisma, but I have only seen him do comedic work so far. But the more I thought about it, the more I liked the idea. In fact, I have started to love it.
Should look to josh holloway from lost
Krasinski? Is that a joke? Guy is totally soft.
Should be Ryan Reynolds. Or at least someone who isn’t a candy-ass.
Ryan Reynolds? Deadpool? Green Lantern? And Captain America? I dunno if that would work.
Ryan Reynolds is a Canadian. If they cast a Canadian as Captain America, something is seriously wrong in the world.
Reynolds? Are you kidding me???? He’s a girl’s guy. Just romantic movies.
TIM OLYPHANT.
A rare american male actor with balls.
Scott Porter is the only name on that list that doesn’t make me cringe for this film. I understand the logic in casting young, but give us a face that can actually instill great confidence in a goddamn army of men fighting for the fate of the world! Most of these guys look like backstreet boys!
I don’t think any of those guys on their wish list are good enough to be Capt America. They aren’t skilled actors who could pull it off. Someone like Josh Hartnett would be alot better.
John Krasinski?! What a joke!!!
This is the funniest thing John Krasinski has done all season!
Chace Crawford??? Captain West Hollywood?
Funny!
HOMOPHOBIC POST
I can only assume the inclusion of the name John Krasinski is a goddamn joke.
Ahh man! Nooooooooooooo! Noooooooo! Cap needs a real actor, not these walking talking clearasil ads!
Josh Lucas! Patrick Wilson! Chris Pine! McConaghey! Those should be your candidates! Another comic book movie bites the dust!
Actually, after seeing Reign of Fire…McConaghey should be at the top of that list… Plus he can hold an event film… He’s got the sparks for it.
Patrick Wilson would be good too.
No to Josh Lucas, no to Chris Pine.
Mac and Wilson would both be PRIMO.
Did you see Sahara? Mr. Abs could not help that film.
Jeremy Renner has proven he can be a non conventional soldier. I don’t want to try and type cast the guy, but having seen him act in a war movie I think he would be ideal. Scrawny Steve Rogers can be done with the right photography/fx combo, but he looks the part of a soldier and can certainly act.
Scott Porter would be perfect. His work on Friday Night Lights was excellent and I can buy him in the role.
Jim from the Office feels weird, unless they are making Captain America snarky in the script.
Chace Crawford is a void and the other actors don’t even register with me.
Porter is somewhat established, but still under the radar enough to be a refreshing choice here.
Hopefully, that Lautner kid doesn’t get involved. Can’t wait to see the studios all eat it on the megadeals he’s gotten off being a supporting character in a tween chick flick.
I actually think Zach Efron would be a great Captain America, but he’s probably too well known, i.e. expensive for Marvel.
Efron would also be a good Spider Man.
I was thumbing through some old issues of Spiderman drawn by “jazzy’ John Romita and y’know, you hit the nail right on the proverbial head! Zac Efron indeed looks a hell of a lot like John Romita’s Peter Parker!! He’s got the physique, he’s a great actor and would be spot on as good old Pete Parker/Spiderman!Quick–Sign’im up!
do you people work in hollywood? efron is signing an overdeal with warner. there is no chance in HELL he is playing a marvel superhero. none.
No. No. No no no no no. No. Don’t.
Efron is too cute to be Spidey. P. Parker was a total dork geek.
JOHN KRASINSKI?!!!!
Are you kidding me? I don’t know any of the other people on the “wish list”, but I hope they come up with something better than John Krasinski! And I do like Krasinski on The Office, but he’s not right for Captain America. It sounds even worse than when Tim Burton wanted Nicolas Cage as Superman!
And really Marvel, look at what a top star did for Iron Man! Without Robert Downey Jr. Iron Man wouldn’t have made more than $200 million!
I say, go after a great actor that will make you that extra $100 million.
Ok, I know it didn’t work for The Incredible Hulk with Edward Norton, but still, a good actor can make the $100 million difference.
Have they thought of maybe casting Robert Downey Jr. as Captain America? Hahaha…Just a joke.
I’d argue that Robert Downey Jr. was just as famous as John Krasinski prior to Iron Man’s opening. He was far more experienced, yes, but he’d never opened a blockbuster like he can now. Iron Man was a huge win for Marvel’s marketing, though Downey Jr.’s charm definitely plays into it in that they got to display that charm in all their trailers and commercials. He did a great job, but he wasn’t a famous name who could have half-assed it and still have had the movie open near as big as it did.
In summary… let Krasinski work out and give him a chance, I guess? It’s not like it’s physically impossible for him to abandon the sarcasm and smirk.
what is with the people who post on this site. downey jr was nominated for an OSCAR. krasinski in on a tv show critics like and no one watches. and his ability to open a film is zero.
RobM,
The thing is that everyone just knew Robert Downey Jr. was a great choice for Iron Man. We all know that Krasinski is a bad choice.
I remember before Iron Man opened, people were talking about how perfect Robert Downey Jr. was for the role of Iron Man. It certainly helped the opening and the great hold for the movie.
Even people that don’t usually go to “Comic Book Movies” went to see Iron Man because of Robert Downey Jr.
Now, I have to say that whoever they cast as Captain America, the movie will still do well. But why settle for “well” when you can get a great actor that would make the movie a major hit like Iron Man?
Just as famous? Is this putz really considered MORE famous than RDJ? Sad. BTW-it’s official, he has been cast as Captain America according to IMDB.
They should have brought back Matt Salinger. Kids will want to see the original Captain America.
Chace Crawford, John Krasinski and that guy from Cloverfield?
If they’re the best American actors Marvel could find to play CA I wish the had gone with foreign actors.
Totally unimpressive list.
What a terrible list. Might as well throw Michael Cera on the list if we’re going to disregard Captain America’s character to hire someone young and appealing.
dear god, not Krasinski.
Oh god, ALL of those potentials are awful, awful choices.
Yes, the article was about casting but so often the writers are never mentioned. The script was written by Markus and McFeely and I’ve heard they did a terrific job!
The reason the focus is on the actors not the writers is that the best writing in the world can’t save a production if you don’t get the right person for the role.
Consider:
Hamlet, starring Rip Taylor
Conan the Barbarian, starring Paul Reubens
Cleopatra, starring Rosie O’Donnell
Heard from who? I’ve read it. Basic. Just like their previous work on THE CHRONICLES OF NARNIA: PRINCE CASPIAN. Didn’t know there was a bomb of a sequel to the first NARNIA flick? Exactly.
Chace Crawford? Really Marvel? They should go with a real actor like Ryan Gosling. He is 6’1 and can get into the shape required for the role. He can act and he isn’t too pretty.
Captain America needs to have a presence. Don’t see that with any of the people mentioned. I mean if you are going to go CW, at least get someone bigger like Jared Padalecki. In Friday The 13th, he was nearly taller than Jason.
I’m all for Marvel giving someone a shot at a blockbuster role. That’s the beauty of America and couldn’t be more appropriate for “Captain America”. Scott Porter would nail this role! The guy has range, experienced and is already in shape.
Let go of the old formula everyone and welcome the new. Hollywood is changing, deal with it.
The problem with Cap casting is that he’s actually a pretty smart fellow, dynamic leader, etc., so going “hunky” won’t be the way to go. I don’t think Kras would be right for it. I’m sure they’ll mess it up because that’s the Marvel Way. They can thank Favreau and Jr. for Iron Man, and look how Marvel almost destroyed that sequel.
I think I like the idea of Garret Hedlund been Captain America. All other actors on the list are just whatever.
the true real life captain america can be found here
http://www.imdb.com/name/nm2227414/
nice!
Shameless. Go back to your acting class in Ohio superstar.
at least he has a decent looking jaw. My first choice has always been Casper van Dien he has the perfect Captain America jawline, hands down.
I agree, he would be perfect for the part.
Please. Van Dien is like 5’8″. Who’s he gonna defend America against, the Lollipop Guild?
Perfect under the radar candidate – Ryan McPartlin, currently on the show “Chuck”:
http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0574131/
6’3″, right age, and former Big 10 football player.
…but honestly, which studio doesn’t drive hard bargains for their tentpole movies? It’s the basic Disney Channel formula: we’ll pay you relatively little (and I say “relatively,” because I’m sure there are many people who would consider $300k for about 3 months’ work to be a pretty great payday) money, but in return, we’ll give you a huge platform from which to catapult your career.
Besides, it’s not like the actors won’t make tons of money from the sequels (unless you’re Terrence Howard and you foolishly think you can’t be replaced by Don Cheadle in a heartbeat).
And really, no one goes to see these films because they star Tobey Maguire, or Michael Keaton, or Ben Affleck, or Robert Downey – they’re going to see the films because of the concept, effects and story (and probably in that order).
Why is Captain A’s package, as it were, on this drawing so prodigious?
Would you want your country represented by someone who wasn’t packin’?
None of these Hollywood pretty boys will work. Look at who was a hit as a superhero: a mature Christian Bale and Robert Downey Jr. The latter, more impressive in my view (lacking “gritty” theatrics for the character).
The essence of Captain America is leadership. He’s the guy (like Superman in the DC universe) that the other superheros look up to and want to emulate, and who commands respect and authority.
The actor has to project toughness, determination, decency, and leadership. Gym toned six pack abs and blow dried hair does not make toughness. The very idea of Chace Crawford is a bad joke, for any role outside a tween and their moms fanbase.
Look at how badly Brandon Routh stunk up the Superman film. Having a sculpted body is not a substitute for a leading man presence.
This is Hollywood’s Achilles heel — they have no “young” versions of Kirk Douglas or Burt Lancaster.
dude. you’ve totally nailed it.
you mean like the draper actor from madman?
Amen. All we’ve got today are girly-boys. Where’s the next Bruce Willis, Stallone, or Eastwood? Men used to be cast for male positions. Now it’s Abercrombie models.
Who to play Captain America? That’s easy: CHUCK NORRIS!
I can’t believe I’m saying this….I agree with Whiskey (for once).
Don’t send a boy to do a man’s job.
American ideals? You mean like waterboarding, imperial warmongering, war profiteering, predatory capitalism, Congress in the pockets of lobbyists and special interests, and the Supreme Court saying it’s okay for corporations to buy elections? Are those things really worth fighting for? Maybe the plot of the movie could be that Captain America takes all that down and restores us to the rule of law.
Maybe you should write a super hero movie called “private progressive”…a self-loathing American who thinks every part of our history is a lie and is never ever happy and drives the bad guys crazy with his constant bitching and complaining about everything around you!In the end the bad guys kill themselves to stop the pain of listening to it!
That’s perfect actually.
So which part of the above posting was a lie by Captain Fun? Please do tell, Anon.
Perhaps Cap can also fight for the original spirit of the Constitution which limited who could vote in elections, said 5 black men were equal to 3 white men when determining representation, and turn a blind eye to the displacement of Native Americans.
The “American Way” has a not too pretty underbelly if you study history.
yeah unlike every other virtuous nation with a spotless past which you just forgot to mention…how odd
go on feeling sorry for yourself though, 90% of this tear-filled sentiment is always because the rest of the country doesn’t support the speaker’s dogmatic politics
Shut up u whiny bitch boy, if you don’t like it go to some other country and don’t knock mine. I’d rather have gray areas than be incinerated by terrorists. How bout China? I’m sure you could have tons of freedom of speech to post comments on blogs there.
Anyway… back on topic.
Chace Crawford could go Marvel one of these days if he mans up a bit more.
My pick for Captain America out of this list would def be John Krasinski. He’s in line with the off kilter Michael Keaton – Robert Downey – Tobey McGuire picks that have paid off well.
I wouldn’t think of this as right wing propaganda- Cap has OFTEN butted head with conservative views in the comics. (For a while after Watergate, he renounced his identity and called himself “Nomad”- and that recent kerfuffle about Cap and his sidekick dissing “teabaggers” is not without basis).Think of him as a JFK era Democrat- an ass-kicking war hero with socially moderate views.If done this way, the movie could really strike a chord with today’s audiences…
JFK would be rolling over in his grave about Democrats today and “progressives” should stop claiming him.
He’s what non-Bible belt, socially moderate, fiscally conservative, Republicans are today.
Nikke: PLEASE delete this clown. Can’t we save DH for the entertainment industry and not left wing, right wing or whatever wing – spewing politic-ism?
Since we’re on “politics”, I think our country should stop water boarding and start posting beheadings on jihadist websites. No one could criticize us for THAT!
You started the politicizing. I’d rather be wire tapped or water boarded then have my country bankrupted.
How about Ben McKenzie from “Southland?”