From Deadline|London editor Tim Adler: You may be upset or relieved to hear my news that Howard Stern definitely won’t be joining American Idol as the judge replacing Simon Cowell. According to my sources close to the show, the new judge will be announced at the end of the current run. Whoever gets the gig will have a sweet deal: 19 Entertainment, the London-based company which created American Idol, has a budget of $38 million to spend on Cowell’s replacement.


I’ve got it… Bill Clinton. He’s got gravitas, loves music, and isn’t afraid to voice his opinion.
Yippee…….. no Howard Stern… Can’t say I am very happy with Ellen this year either. But we have been a loyal family of viewers for years. Howard would have caused us to change the channel. No one can replace Simon……. lets hope they give it a good try anyway!
The perfect replacement for Simon would be Russell Brand. He’s funny, and basically says what he feels. He could be better than the original.
Russell Brand should stay in England. He’s not funny at all.
Agreed
I agree. Bill Clinton would be great!
Howard Stern is way, way, way to honest and normal to get near a thing like this…But He WOULD improve it. He would also overwhelm it and might not take the pay cut to $38 Million.
Yes — Bill Clinton is an excellent realistic choice…
I can’t believe you used Howard Stern and “normal” in the same sentence.
But Stern is probably the only choice I can think of who would bring me back to watch the show. The losers Simon has now on his panel have made the show unwatchable.
Stern would be a train wreck and ratings would drop big time. His act only appeals to a small portion of viewers and some of the things he’s done in the past would totally alienate people.
yeah, you’re right. He only has millions and millions of listeners who actually pay to hear him everyday. Can you name one other person in the history of broadcasting who has accomplished what he has? You must not listen to him very often; his topics of interest aren’t just penis and tit jokes.
Howard Stern is Scum. I am he wont be judging this contest. I think the show had a good run and should end after Simon leaves.
Two words. Hulk Hogan.
He is “scum?” You most likley don’t even listen to his show . I bet yo are a Rachel Maddow fan, am I right?
Yeah Bill Clinton is totally honest.
Yes, and for his unhonesty, we repented with George Bush, Jr. What a lovely exchange. Plus, Republicans have got us feeling semi-embarrassed over the only successful presidency of the last three decades, and the only successful Democratic presidency in half a century. Nice clear thinking there, Mike.
Why do you have to take this to a political level. It’s a discussion of entertainment. But then again, if you think this is a successful presidentcy and Bill Clinton has gavitas it explains why you have such opinions that ignore reality. We haven’t had a good president in two decades. What we have, on both sides of the aisle, are a bunch of people who are slowly taking away our freedoms and people like you who think what we have now is good for our country will be shocked when they wake up one morning and realize that they have lost the freedoms we once had. However, as I said before, this is about entertainment so on that point I will say that they need someone who has a professional music background, not a politician or other entertainer.
Amazing! Two in a row. First, Howard Stern is “normal” and then Bill Clinton is “honest.” What planet are you guys living on? Next you’ll be claiming George Bush is “smart” and Barack Obama is “a different kind of politician.”
Only successful Presidency of the last three decades? Leave Reagan out of the American Idol debate. Unfortunately, he’s dead. Although he’s the only one with show business experience.
So, just to get this straight, you believe Ronald Reagan was an unsuccessful president?
BTW, in keeping with the post, I believe Howard Stern would have been fantastic.
Wow someone sounds angry. Relaaaxxx.
I vote for Ricky Gervais. He would wreck havoc on the dreadful wannabees.
never watched show and never wanted to… but that being said, ricky gervais might make me do it.
Oh too bad. I really like listening and watching howard. He’s a real hero, as far as making a name for himself and buisness. I too want to make a name for myself and started a website – could you help promote http://www.myezbids.com
thanks!
i think american idol is going to be done after the next season. its good but Simon is too big a draw. When x-factor came out in the UK it squashed Pop idol(our equivilant). There is more scope for competitors as there are age, gender and group brackets. And as the judges rep one bracket each you know they’ll be blowing up the rivalry between judges.
(does anyone know who the judges for x-factor will be)
why don’t they get someone that has talent…sooooooooo glad stern is not going to be…he would want them to strip on stage, so he can see if he would approve them…
also clinton, lol
the person they need has to be full of all kinds of talent to begin with…i just dropped my mouth open when i heard ellen was going to be one…
this show is becaming a big joke…not a talent show at all.
they have loads and loads of people that go for the tryouts, that are really good…so they pick these jokesters that can tied their shoes… hey as far as i think and see it, that is discrimating about the person with the real talent…
get some judges that have talent
Howard Stern… Howard SEWAGE Stern?! Yeah, he’s the answer. Not hard to see what kind of people are voicing their opinions here, is it? Next up: Bill Clinton. Wow. How nasty are your lives to aspire for these two absolute sleazebags to be judges? Come ON!
lets drive this show into the ground by putting justin beiber in simon’s spot:P
Based on his lethal observations about Ellen Degeneres last week, I assumed the real-world possibility of this happening had passed. He would have torn the phoniness of this grotesque, sadistic karaoke MK Ultra experiment to shreds.
AMEN
Agree with you 100%
Howard would have brought nothing but white trash to the table. Howard is lucky, not talented. Anyone can get up there and get mad and throw a fit and call it radio. thats not hard, whats hard is looking at howard sterns nose for 5 minutes.
can you say anti-semite??
Frankly, I’m pissed. Howard would have not only saved a dying show, but he would have given it a new and improved shot in the arm. I’m disgusted with the twitchy likes of Ellen and the fearful retorts of Kara and wish someone would march in there and make some heads roll and Stern could’ve done it. Fuck them! Fuck them with a sharp fucking stick and die already!
I think they knew that myself and most if not all of my family and friends who watch this show regularly would have stopped watching it completely with the addition of Stern to the judges!
Howard Stern is a disgusting creature. He is vile, unattractive and just plain gross. The show would have died a hell of a lot quicker if he was the new judg. Frankly I’m amused of how angry you seem over his rejection.
It’s so very sad to hear such crude remarks from you. Don’t you know thst you were made for something MUCH better than to follow the likes of Stern and other so-called “shock” celebrities? I hope you find some good things to live for besides a TV show- your passion would be awesome for the good things.
All Cowell did was “shock” by telling the truth. If shock = truth then Stern is the only answer. Ellen and Kara have RUINED the show and a loyal fans like you and myself know this to be true. We need somebody who’s not afraid to tell the truth and doesnt like his eyes are going to pop out of his head.
Don’t be such a terd. What Howard did for entertainment was brilliant and gutsy. He tackles every issue in life with raw and witty humor. Its the most human entertainment in the mainstream media today.
I agree with this posting Howard would have been great. Right now the show is stale. Howard would have revived it.But lets be honest.
38 million is not enough money to get Howard to participate in what
is now a dying telivision franchise. F American Idol! STERN RULES
What a nasty mouth. Yea, you are such a lady
Patti seems Pissed that the Shock Jock lost out. Stern has not the class or experience in music for that slot. Now, if they were having wet t-shirt contests on Stern’s show…maybe Patti would like to enter. That’s all he is good for…trash.
Douchebag say what?
And what musical experience does Ellen have?
Hmm, funny thing is Stern has NEVER HAD a wet t-shirt contest on his show. Judge not what ye know little of.
Ellen and Kara are sinking the show, and Cowell’s departure will only hasten its demise.
My thoughts exactly.
Howard invented the format for american Idol in 1984. He had 3 record execs and him self judge amateur singers for a record contract, it was a regular part of his program in the 80′s. He also was a program director choosing what people hear on the radio. He also discovered Sugar Ray and put Staind on the map by promoting their talents in music. Plus he started with an audience of 600, 000 at sirius satellite and now has 20 million listeners that pay $16 per month to hear him talk. Nobody on the planet has that much pull. When Oprah signed on with XM radio after 2 years they didn’t have any increase in listeners. If you listen for 1 week you will see he is not just bathroom humor. He is the last honest celebrity talking about what we all think but are afraid of saying. Howard also has pull on TV his E program was the highest rated daily cable program ever and his old channel 9 show beat Saturday night live every week in ratings.
Actually, Hoo Hoo only had 8.3 million subscribers before the Sirius XM merger. XM had 9 million. Since Hoo Hoo had already been on Sirius for over 2 years by the time the merger happened, to say that 18 million people pay for Hoo Hoo is just a lie. 9 million of those people had already made their choice to have an XM subscription. Did Hoo Hoo increase subscriptions for Sirius? Most definitely. But only to 8.3 million, not 18 million. Stop believing everything that comes out of Hoo Hoo’s mouth.
“Class is music”? Is this like how the music industry is so classy with rappers shooting each other, and using misogyny, celebrating thug life or are we talking completely offensive over the top no-talents like Adam Lambert and his simulated sex or are we talking about the classy biting heads off of bats, or the classy overdoses and drug addictions? With so much “class” I’m just not sure how Howard could fit….
Amen.
Yes Patti!
Good grief Patti Harvey! What a filthy mouth! And you are the kind of fan Howard Stern attracts? We already are getting to be a moraless country. We sure don’t need him and his fans!
With the language you used in this public post, what a surprise you are for Howard Stern. The American Idol people have to maintain some semblance of decency because families watch this show together, and Howard Stern is the opposite of family friendly.
You’re right on. What a boring karaoke contest this has become. For those knuckleheads out there who trash Howard you obviously don’t listen to his show.
I HIGHLY doubt they’ll pay the new judge $38 million. Most likely, that just gives them room to aquire a well known personality.
Stern was never in the running, but don’t ask HIM that…
Obviously you don’t listen to his show so obviously you don’t know that he really didn’t even want this job. Reports came out and he just ran with them. Get YOUR facts together before posting.
How about RINGO STARR? My wife and I were actually enthused at the thought of him being on the show. He knows music, he’s honest, and he doesn’t need to impress anyone. RINGO, RINGO, RINGO!
Agree…great idea. Ringo would give the show some Graveetass. But i think Ellen would object. Her light would dim to a shadow next to a Beatle.
“Ringo Starr”??? The least talented member of the Beatles. Not even really a musician, but rather a percussionist?
Not a good choice.
you don’t have to be a great singer to know one – when you have spent close to 50 yrs in recording studios & surrounded by
excellent singers & musicians- through decades of changing musical styles. He’s not IN the competition – his musical knowledge – from all angles – is priceless.
And if you’ve noticed, Ringo is also really funny.
Great knowledge of music, even the young audience will know him,
the older ones obviously wd be thrilled, etc..
I think he’d be great – if he’d take it.
Of course Stern was in the running you goofy guttersnipe – what in the hell are you talking about?? Sheesh
Good, The way that Stern treats his fanbase he does’nt deserve shit. I was a fan for almost 20 years then he turned into Hampton Howie. Screw him.
You are so right. Howie, who spent years laughing at the effete, typically liberal elitists who view themselves as superior to all others, became what he had scoffed at. He is no longer entertaining nor can he even pretend that he is “just one of us,” because clearly he is not and has not been for quite some time. Just a thought. HB
I agree. Howard turned so left wing it got irritating. I quit my Serius subscription, when addition to Howard taking two weeks off for every known holiday, he started taking Fridays off. If you’re going to make $100,000,000. a year damn it, work your butt off and give people what they pay for!
Howard is by far the most loyal guy out there, he gives his fan the best entertainment value you can get. Hampton Howie? wtf is that? I listen everyday he rarely mentions the hamptons
Your a dope. Sirius is $12.95 a month you chump and the show is better than ever.
dude howard’s show is so dusty and stale it’s sucks…Ive heard his stupid sex bullshit for so long…it just goes on and on and on BORING!!!!
Stern just isn’t relevent, sorry Stern fans nobody gives a shit.
he was relevant enough that he was given something like $250mm to “make” that satelite channel Princess.
Yeaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!!!!!!!
Fremantle and 19′s loss. For whatever fluke reason the world has embraced this glorified talent contest. I can only sumise that reason is Simon. There is no other entertainer outside of Howard Stern who could bring a new audience and keep the old ones.
Maybe this will finally be the end.
I agree. I think yoiu are watching the end of Idol…..Simon is happy by the way. This will make his X-Factor show number 1. Just wait and see.
i’m hearing it’s going to be a certain Oscar/Grammy/Tony/Emmy winner/celebuspawn w/ the last name Minnelli.
they need another loopy judge…
You can either say “There is a God” or the reality of having someone like Stern on board would just not help the show’s PG-13 dynamic.
MADONNA would be a great choice. She’s one of the most succesful performers in music hitory, has produced artists and could be more outspoken than Simon. Plus, they have enough money to pay her. No matter what anyone says about Paula, she added credibilty as a successful musical artist. Madonna can fill the shoes of both Paula and Simon.
Plus she has a British accent as well!
Absolutely agree on Madonna, I’d dare say it would be a Good progression for her career.
Madonna would be a great choice if it was judging orphans in 3rd world countries.
I totally agree! Madonna would be a great choice!
Excellent suggestion. I agree that Madonna would be a great replacement but she may consider the show beneath her. Madonna may fear that being a TV show personality gives the impression that she is washed up as a singer. American Idol could end up being the Hollywood Stars of this decade.
Madonna was a singer?
So sad, Howard would have saved the show and now it will fail!
Howard would have SAVED the show, did you say???
Stern is an aging foul-mouthed pervert who would have utterly destroyed it. If anyone can replace Cowell, Stern is NOT it. He ought to go crawl back under a rock with the other slimy disgusting creatures.
Spoken from someone who obviously does not listen to Howard. Stern is one of the most thought out broadcasters I have ever heard. You obviously do not listen.
It’s clear that you’ve never actually listened to Howard. He’s exactly what the show needs! The other judges, especially Ellen, are jokes.
I would bet that people like you who bad-mouth Howard have never really listened to him. He is the only honest personality and has been for a long time. He is also an extremely respectable human being who many of us would do well to emulate.
It is a shame to see how many hateful people there are that choose to falsely judge one another.
Stern is the only thing that could resurrect Idol. Probably a good thing though – I am personally sick of seeing all these cheesy kids chase their fifteen minutes.
russ,
I agree with you completely.
Stern wasn’t a good fit for the show, but Russ, are you 5 years old?
Russ,
You have no idea what you are talking about, you don’t listen to Stern and have no place discussing what you think about him… It’s just stupid. I’m sure you think this show is great, and that Ellen is awesome, she’s lame, and how is she qualified to judge music “talent” any more than Stern.
Here’s a little bit of a transcript from when the “judges” went on the Stern show that most people wouldn’t know about.
The judges from American Idol were on Howard Stern yesterday (01/21/03). They were judging some people who came to the studio to see if they had what it takes to be on AI. They did their usual and ripped pretty harshly into the singers. Finally, the last person up, “Scott” sang a bit from “Hero” (from Spider-Man).
(paraphrased)
Simon: “You’re too old to make it in this business. You’re alright, but not very good.”
Paula: “You were alright, but you lost us when you closed your eyes. You lack the ability to project and you don’t have a good presence.”
Last guy(?): “He was okay. Just okay.”
Howard:”Since you’ve already given your judgement, I can reveal that this isn’t Scott, but rather Josey Scott, who wrote and performed on the song “Hero” and is also in the band Saliva. So what does that tell you?”
Simon: “That we have absolutely no idea what we are doing.”
Howard:”Thank you, Josey. By the way, about how many singles of that song did you sell?”
Josey:”Over eight million.”
Artie Lang:”Well maybe if you opened your eyes and projected more, you could have sold nine million.”
Yeah, so as you can see from this, the whole show is a joke, and even more so now with ELLEN on it. Get over yourself. Stern Rules, one of the best interviewers of all time.
howard stern will eviscerate you with a tongue lashing you would never forget jerky. stay under your rock, noone needs to read your stupid comments.
You have it correct!
Yeah Howard will ask all the woman to show him their breasts.
I agree, he is an aging, foul-mouthed pervert. He made his star the only way he knew how and that was by selling his soul. And that is what he will be remembered by. Howard Stern is synonymous with inappropriate, degrading exploitation of damaged and hurting human beings. He climbed on the backs of broken humans to attain his questionable star status, and there is nothing good about him. Anyone who supports him is like him, and therefor needs to re-examine their own lives and moral compasses, and hopefully none of you have children.
amen russ…
stern is all about the “dumbing down” of america
I think you are dead wrong. Howard speaks the truth and is by FAR the Best interveiwer on the planet and would have brought Idol back to what it once was—I can guarntee you the Olympics would not have beat Idol with Stern on it.
Stern is such a loser… How can anyone take him seriously… He’s a ass.
pity. i’d actually watch idol if stern was on…
i agree. I never liked the show and think its perpetuating this pop culture that is upon us. If Stern was on id watch just see how many times he rolled his eyes.
The fact that this was even thrown out there is so laughable. Howard Stern is one of the biggest frauds to have ever reached the heights of media superstardom. He is the one who started these dubious rumors because if there’s one thing about Howard, it’s his egomaniacal lust for self promotion. He has this delusional belief that so many in the entertainment biz have stolen from him. The fact of the matter is that Howard’s only contribution to entertainment has been to elevate flatulence on the radio to a whole new level.
As the years have gone by, he’s been exposed for the fraud he is. For example (are there are many) he use to blast decrepit old farts marrying trophy wives and what does he do but marries one himself, not only that but one who seems to have no other function than to show up at red carpet events. Among other loathsome qualities about Howard stems from the past three years, where Artie Lange has been committing a slow, painful and painfully unfunny suicide over the airwaves, and what does Howard do? Nothing. Nada. His self destruction was radio gold, in the beady little eyes of Howie. And when Artie eviscerated his arms with a set of Ginsu knives last December (he’s been off the show and “in therapy” ever since), Howard proclaimed shock.
Anyone who pays one dollar to this solipsistic, narcissist heap of maggot-laden feces is a complete moron. Howard is finished. He’s washed up, and I expect him, on the last day of his Sirius show to pull a Johnny Rotten-at-the-last-Pistols-show-in-San Francisco-in-the-70s and laugh “Ha ha ha, ever feel like you’ve been cheated”.
I respect your opinion, but to say he is a fraud is a bit crazy. He manages to save Sirius by bringing his show there and bringing his fans along. I never listened to him on terrestrial radio because never had the time, but now he is amazing. To also say his wife does nothing is crazy. She helps out a ton with the north shore animal shelter thing. The truth is he saved Sirius and he would have saved Idol, but the stern ship sailed away and idol has sunk.
Oh wow. She donates Howard’s money to an animal shelter. Sounds like a tough job. People who think Stern is a genius shouldn’t be allowed to vote.
So Howard Stern saved Sirius? If you mean he brought along PART of his listening audience to keep the network limping along long enough to merge with XM, then I agree. His impact on their bottom line is questionable though. You may want to forget that shortly after his move, he blasted his former listeners for being too cheap to pony up the cash to pay for his program. It was truly ironic at the time since he was complaining to those who HAD payed for the service. Howard Stern is just a symptom of our less than educated society. His appeal is rooted in a sophomoric mentality that most people leave behind at an early age.
Saved Sirius? Do you have any idea how much money they lose everyday? He stuck them for $100 million, works the equivalant of about 1/2 of the year and lounges in the Hamptons with his trophy wife while Sirius slides into a cess pool of debt.
He is an unpleasnat combination of self promotion and insecurtiy. He lives off the most repugnant, base emotions and humor. Sure he has a fan base, but 95% of those “fans” are uneducated morons who would adore anyone that celibrates their disgusting preversions. Unfortunately there is no shortage of these specimens. It’s too bad, he seems to be somewhat intelligent and his desperation to raise his image above scum king is obvious (apparently playing chess helps to separate him from his slobbering faithful). And now, without the check of censors, he and his staff have gotten lazy. Rather than work to be creative they simply string together f-bombs and gutter jokes.
His attacks on Ellen were typically pathetic. The Howard opinion poll is quite transparent – those who go on his show gain his adoration and praise. Those who find his sophomorish humor and raunchy topics unpleasant and choose not to bow at the alter of this self obsessed egomaniac get ripped and degraded every chance he gets. Insecurity is such an ugly thing. Most adolescents grow out of it, Howard’s demons must go very deep, he just gets worse.
I am a lifetime subscriber to Sirius – I listen to Howard and his retarded, hillbilly wannabe clone Bubba The Love Sponge occasionally. $100 million – ridiculous, but still a better investment than the $50 million they gave the absentee big mouth Oprah.
Saved Sirius you say? Sirius has yet to make a profit and throwing away tons of money on the likes of Howard Stern certainly hasn’t helped the balance sheet.
Actually, Sirius XM just reported their first profit since the merger.
Of course he saved Sirius. By the time he uttered his first words over their satellites he had already brought in more than enough subscribers to pay for his contract. They were less than 10 percent the size of XM, yet once he came on board Sirius was able to force a merger (in reality a takeover). Finally, all you need to do is take a look at the current state of terrestrial radio
(by the way, Howard wasn’t the first to use that term, but he did bring it into mainstream usage) to see the impact he has. And for those of you who think he is a foul mouth pervert, I would submit that you have likely never listened to him or you would know that he is an intelligent, well-spoken radio personality. Sex is a small part of his show and his language is nothing beyond what you hear everyday.
He did save Sirius actually. It had only 600,000 subscribers b4 he joined and now it has more than 6 million, forcing its much larger competitor XM to even seek out a merger years back.
The company would have been GONE a long time ago if it wasnt for him.
Actually, Sirius has shown a profit as well as had almost a $1 BILLION…yes BILLION…dollar turnaround.
Stern was/is a factor for Sirius, but don’t slam Sirius when you obviously have not read any resent news for the past 2 months.
Sirius is great music, great choices, great voices, and going global w/ Liberty Media soon.
You should get the trial of Sirius, I believe you will love it.
Actually SiriusXM just posted results for their latest quarter and showed a profit.
SAVED Sirius??? He has almost bankrupt them — what were they thinking???
genius what exactly was “Howie” supposed to do huh idiot? Come on Ricky Retardo tell us. You sound like a disgruntled mongoloid that never fulfilled his life long desire to get on the air.
Ditto X 10 ~ Thank you for putting it so perfectly.
for a guy who hates Stern so much you sure know an awful lot about him.
You are so out of line it is not funny. You can kiss AI goodbye when Simon the poser leaves. Howard is KING OF ALL MEDIA something Simon or yourself are not.
You are a moron who has no clue what good entertainment is.
Wow, you bought that tripe, huh? That “king of all media” stuff? He MIGHT be the king of satellite radio, but as for “all” media? I can’t remember the last time I saw his ugly mug on TV or at the movie theaters. I can’t remember the last time I heard his annoying voice on broadcast radio.
“King of all media”? LOLOLOL BWAHHAHAHAHA HEHEHEHEHE Oh stop it hurts!!!
You are totally wrong. Stern is no fraud, you are a total idiot and have no idea what you are writing about. Do you listen to his show on Sirius??? After hearing him and his opinions you will realize his right most of the time.
Your comments are totally “out to lunch”
How do you know so much about Howard, especially from the last three years if you don’t listen. I love this!
wow, for someone who hates him so much, you sure seem to follow his every move. typical.
For someone who loaths Howard, you certainly know a great deal about him.
You’re so miss informed. Howard never said the job was offered to him. He said he had offers from a major network. The media assumed it was Idol related. He has said numerous times that he was not offered the job and that he wouldn’t take. When Ellen started talking about him in public, he then said he’d take the job just to screw with her. However, it was all in jest. He’s staying at Sirius as he has said repeatedly. The media created this non-story not him. He just played it up.
P.J. listens to Howard DAILY.
And Artie stabbed himself in the chest, dope.
I’ve listened to Howard for 20 years now and he never used to blast anyone for marrying trophy wives. He used to always say that’s what he would do if he wasn’t married already and he would talk about being jealous of those guys that can dump their wives and upgrade.
I don’t think you ever really listened to his show.
Well written!!!!
for your information, Stern was on vacation the week that these rumors began spreading, he did not talk about this until the following monday. so I fail to see how he was spreading this rumor.
who cares. There are much more important things to be worried about. The people that watch this trash represent all that is wrong with the world. Give me that money and I could do some real good with it. Don’t give it to yet another complete waste of space.
Right on Dave, these self-absorbed worshippers of filth are a waste of time. There is nothing good about Howard Stern, the only thing good about him will be his demise and the memory of him wiped from the face of the earth. And FYI, I would rather see AI off the air than to have to look at Howard Stern’s long, greasy, putrid face, perfect for him to stay on the radio,though it would give morons like his supporters a visual aid since HEARING him and his garbage isn’t enough to convince them he is a perv…but who cares some people just don’t get it and never will so why waste time and space I’m out
The bad news – difficult to find a more compeling figure to boost show’s rating
The good news – won’t have to look at two people with turkey necks – Ellen and Howard
This gave a great chuckle!!!
Good, keep doing your show on Sirius XM!! Love the show!!
eh, Idol will slip into oblivion soon.
without Paula and Simon, it’ll be just a pale comparasion of what it used to be.
$38 million to judge a karaoke contest. I will take $1 million. This show has jumped the shark. I have not watched it in 3 seasons. I would have come back for Howard. I am much happier that he is not in the running since I enjoy his sirius show daily. He would have left that to do this. Ellen really has to go. What a waste. She just sucks.
If you have not watched Idol since the third season,
how do you know Ellen is a waste? you lie!
or else you would have no opinon on the show at all!!!
I said that I have not watched it in Three Seasons. Not since season three. I watched for a few minutes the other night and had to turn it off due to Ellen. It was just so boring.
And jumped the shark is a term to describe when people are so over a show.
I don’t think you know what “jumped the shark” means.
I think you should ask bob dylan.
Regarding Bob Dylan. Hell yes! I have enjoyed his time on camera and in front of microphones for close to 50 years. Introduced to him in 1963 I have followed him ever since. Not that I am a Dylan junkie or an obsessed fan but I do consider his wit, sarcasm, dry sense of humor and his relentless attacks on all things worthy of his time would be a great addition to almost any T.V. or Radio show. Dylan still rocks!
Deeeelighted. How could this have ever been a consideration?
Thank God it won’t be that idiot Stern. I have watched every show for the past 9 years but if Perez Hilton gets it – I’m done. I wouldn’t watch it if you held a gun to my head! You need someone with industry knowledge. Ellen needs to go too.
American Idol is in trouble…. Ellen is a disaster… she adds zero to the broadcast and she isn’t even funny… she basically parrots the other judges and just repeat the same comment over and over again, sometimes in the very same 30 seconds.
Howard is the only one who could save that show next year. It will absolutely tank without a judge like Simon. He is the reason everyone tunes in, whether they want to admit it or not.
We’re new to watching Idol — last year was our first year. While Simon is our favorite, he’s not the only honest music exec to ever come down the pike. (Then again, as I type that, “honest” and “music exec” are hardly ever used in the same sentence, huh?…) It just has to be someone very knowledgeable about the industry who will be brutally honest — nothing personal. That’s the beauty of Simon — it’s not personal; if you suck, it’s his responsibility to make sure the airwaves don’t get clogged up with any more trash than is already out there.
We really like Ellen — she’s not afraid to speak her mind and disagree with the other judges, and she’s funny.
Howard would look for at least $75 mil a year and wouldn’t be able to stand the other idiots on the panel, so he has obviously declined.
The departure of Simon will be fatal to the show and especially if Mr. Stern is brought on board to replace Simon. Firstly, Stern is a boor. Secondly and most damning, he is not entertaining. His brand of entertainment is so crass and without any redemptive value that the show’s ratings would crater like an NBC drama series. Besides, it’s supposed to be a talent contest. The only thing Howard knows is the general difference between C, D and double D.
great to hear the truth about stern…
its too bad some embrace his crass, low level views and misogyngy
what a loser