Today I heard a prediction for overall upfront spending at the four biggest broadcast
networks: north of $9 billion. “And that’s even with NBC in the shit,” one of my top TV insiders explained (ignoring that NBC’s development for next fall is looking better than it has in years). So that’s why I’m told this will be the biggest upfront maybe in the history of the broadcast business. And this upbeat forecast is coming from everyone — network suits, top agents, advertising execs, financial analysts. They’re all saying that the TV biz is back and in a big way, especially among the broadcast networks. As one of my sources described, “Advertisers are hungering for broadcast network shows again.”
If this year is a feast, then last year was a famine: overall upfront spending at the Big 4 alphabet networks in the midst of the economic crisis slid 13% to only about $6.5 billion in 2009. Auto ads, pharma ads, consumer products ads, were down or disappeared entirely. Lower prices per viewer and lower overall spending were the rule with no exceptions for last year’s upfront. True, scatter market demand was unexpectedly better and therefore pricing surprisingly stronger. Still, that was seen as more of a fluke than a trend. Contrast that with this year: in late April, the Wall Street Journal headlined a story, “Upfront Market Looks Primed for an Upswing: Outlook Improves for Advance Sales of Network-TV Spots as Companies Boost Spending”. But no one even then would have predicted north of $9B. Trust me, no one.





I doubt it will be north of $9 billion. Why would it? Political advertising will cease after the November elections, and that is a major aspect of TV advertising right now. GM and Chrysler may venture back into the waters, but the reaction to GM’s Ed Whitacre’s claim of payback of all loans (basically taking money from one government loan and using it to pay back part of another) will make them gun-shy. Because the people (through the government) are the owners.
So who will be putting all that money down? When economically, things are very uncertain. I can see growth from last year. Sure. But on the margins not growth like you have never seen before. Where are incomes? Where are jobs? Where are hiring sprees?
Heck with VAT coming, consumer prices will skyrocket, pretty much killing the CW, and possibly NBC. Along with weaker studios (think about it — a tax on every level of production AND service means vastly increased prices and without vastly increased income, far less consumer disposable spending). Who will spend big bucks to reach very limited consumer spending (as opposed to overseas expansion in China and India?)
One of the reasons that Pirate Bay operates in Sweden is that high VATs make piracy of IP a way of life for consumers. They literally don’t have $15 to spare for copy of an old movie like “the Searchers” which would run you $9 at most at the local supermarket here (for now).
I agree with Nikki, it’s been NBC best development in years. No more Jay Leno crap that the idiot Zucker tried to claim was going to reinvent television. Both jeff Gaspin and Angela Bromstad seem to know what they’re doing. The same thing couldn’t be said for Ben Silverman and Jeff Zucker. Also, Kevin Reilly at Fox and Jeff Gaspin at NBC tend to be more creative than your average network suit. They both tend to take creative risks. Glee was a risk for Fox and so is Outsourced for NBC. So, with Reilly and Gaspin, the audience tends to get better shows. Stephen McPherson better look at Fox and the new brass at NBC. Most of ABC’s shows are crap.
ABC picked up the WORST pilots. Patmore and McPherson are terrible. They have no taste. Castle is a great mistake. Grey’s was a mistake that they didn’t even like. They are out of touch and assume their audience is stupid over there. ABC/Studios is even worse. They are in a coma and assume the audience has the IQ of a rabbit just like they do. They make derivative TV. ABC’s biggest hit (Modern Family) has an original voice, flawed characters and a unique situation. This is because Fox is the studio not ABC. One would think they would learn from this. But instead their development is more of the same bottom of the barrel TV crap.
Everyone is betting on big political ad spending now that the Supreme Court has said corporations can spend as much as they like in elections.
Political ad spending is not a factor on the national level. It will not have any impact on the upfronts. Where political ad spending comes into play is on the local level.
No surprises there. Internet advertising has been a pointless exercise in money wasting, and “social networks” have proved to be an oxymoron.
People who don’t want to leave their house to socialize don’t tend to buy too many things.
Long live the new era of Television!
Where’s the love for CW? Why do they only put 4 networks up there?
Don’t believe the hype, especially when it comes to broadcast. Two reasons for this:
- the more broadcast services get pumped up about budgets, the more aggressive they will become on price and the more they will overplay their hand. There are many many first run cable shows that deliver ratings comparable to broadcast, at lower CPM’s across all demos. The posturing will force agencies to reallocate dollars to cable.
- the upfront market means nothing. Only the total market has meaning. If advertisers are simply moving money from scatter to upfront without an overall annual spending gain, the marketplace is being set up for a huge fall in 2011 scatter. Don;t forget that, with cancellable options averaging 30% of annual spend, “as ordered” is never equal to “as run”…
Great news!!! What we get to look forward to is more reality shows on network t.v.! Blah, Blah, Blah!! And even if a new scripted show makes it out of the shoot, it is given a big 3 week run and if the numbers don’t work out its gone. No time to build a following to capitilize on those advertising dollars. Blah, Blah, Blah!!
The networks lost forever the baby boom market (72 million viewers, considered to be the next coming giant consumer market. Boomers gave up network t.v. once cheap reality t.v. came into being. The networks are beating this reality horse into oblivion. Where’s the consumer market? Beer commercials? I have worked as a producer in brand market t.v. commercials in 1986. There has been no brand building let alone decent spot production that supports expensive productions since 2000. AOL/Time Warner merger ruined so many t.v. and cable networks that once had dedicated viewers.
Remember that concept “Must See T.V.?” It seems to be going all to cable television now, where decent scripted program is beginning to emerge. And the ad dollars will and do follow.
LA is killing themselves and driving creatives and crews out of the area with production costs.
Quite the change from the post Writer’s Strike days where everyone was predicting the end of Pilot season and the need for Upfronts.
Thanks to Glee for giving the latest jolt of excitement for network TV.
This is bullshit. It’s posturing. The entire broadcast TV business, including the media agencies and the buyers on the brand side, rely on the upfront. If the upfront falters / fails many, many people lose their jobs. I guarantee you that Chief Procurement Officers at every major brand are scrutinizing their TV spend. And like anyone, they’re susceptible to what the press and the general industry mood tells them. So this kind of press is necessary for everyone in order for the business to work. The problem is, the business is not working. Retransmission fees, which will eventually become de facto sub fees, are the new model. And it’s not as great of a model as an artificial upfront marketplace, unfortunately.
It sucks, but the truth is a broadcast TV spend, excepting American Idol, the Super Bowl and other major live events, is not smart marketing.
The other thing that should be mentioned, is that the upfront now includes cable nets and online spending. So ‘increase’ is not so much prime-time b’cast TV, but across the entire TV and digital groups of the congloms. So, not only is it 100% artificial posturing to help the spend (and in turn the entire ad-based broadcast industry), but it’s not even specific to b’cast prime-time.
I want the media business to grow. This comment is not meant to disparage. But I’m seriously concerned about the artificial nature of the upfront marketplace. To me, it feels a lot like the shitty housing debt that Wall Street sold to China — a shitty deal that is dangerously close to collapsing.