
UPDATED WITH MORE OF YOUR SUGGESTIONS: Given how long the odds are for having a pilot picked up to series on a broadcast network, every year most people who have worked on pilots have a bad upfront. Some have a good upfront. And then, a selected few have a great upfront. Here are the overachievers this year:
James Burrows: He is the master of the multi-camera format. Only
three new multi-camera series were picked up for fall, all directed by Burrows: Mike & Molly and $#! My Dad Says on CBS and Better Together on ABC.
Craig Silverstein: The writer-producer is behind two new series. He created/executive produced the CW’s Nikita, which he will also run, and he also co-wrote and is executive producing Fox’s Terra Nova.
The Russo Brothers: The duo also achieved a perfect record this pilot season: Both pilots they directed, ABC’s Happy Endings and Fox’s Running Wilde, went to series. Anthony and Joe Russo will be executive producing three series next season, Endings, Wilde and NBC’s Community whose pilot they also directed.
David Nutter, aka the Pilot Whisperer: He kept his unbelievable streak alive with NBC’s Chase, his 16th consecutive pilot to go to series.
Chuck Lorre, Shonda Rhimes and Carol Mendelsohn: With the pickups of Lorre’s Mike & Molly at CBS and Rhimes’ Off The Map at ABC, the two will have three series on the air next season, sharing honors with Seth MacFarlane, who also has three shows. But that has been topped by CSI maven Carol Mendelsohn who executive produces the newly picked up CBS drama The Defenders as well as the three CSI series. (There is still room to grow for all: Norman Lear had five shows on the air in 1977)
Matt Nix and Shawn Ryan: A strong upfront for the two writer-producers who already have cable series: USA’s Burn Notice and FX’s upcoming Terriers, respectively. Nix’s Fox dramedy The Good Guys, which was slated as a summer series, landed on the fall schedule. And Ryan’s pilot Ride-Along also wowed ‘em at Fox to snag one of only two drama pilot-to-series pickups at the network.
J.J. Abrams, Alex Kurtzman and Roberto Orci: The Fringe creators used a divide-and conquer strategy, returning to TV development with two separate pilots, Undercovers (Abrams) and Hawaii Five-O (Kurtzman and Orci). Both pilots went to series, keeping the trio’s perfect pilot-to-series record intact.
Scott Silveri and Shana Goldberg-Meehan: The married former Friends executive producers landed series orders for their pilots about couples: Goldberg-Meehan’s Better Together was picked up at ABC, Silveri and Jon Pollack’s Perfect Couples was ordered by NBC. And they accomplished that while preparing for the pending birth of their baby.
Beginner’s luck: Several newcomers to pilot season struck gold. Nick Wauters, whose prior TV writing experience included a total of 3 produced series episodes, is behind NBC’s highest-profile new drama series The Event after producer Steve Stark, in his first year as an independent producer, took an old spec script by Wauters to NBC. Young writer David Caspe had sold several feature comedy pitches but had zero TV experience. That changed this year when his Happy Endings became one of the best-liked comedy pilots and landed a series order by ABC. British writer Kelly Marcel was close to making a deal with a U.K broadcaster for a show set in pre-historic times to when producer Aaron Kaplan convinced her to bring the project to the US. He paired her with Silverstein to write together Terra Nova based on her idea. A few months after the launch of Working Title TV, the company landed a Thursday night series on NBC’s Love Bites.
Honorable mention for non-writing producers who landed multiple new series:
Jamie Tarses: She had three broadcast pilots, Mr. Sunshine and Happy Endings at ABC and Mad Love at CBS. Mr. Sunshine and Happy Endings were picked up to series, while Mad Love is still in serious consideration for midseason. (Tarses also recently landed a series order at TNT for Franklin & Bash, which was formally unveiled at the cable network’s upfront presentation this week.)
Bruckheimer TV: The company went 2-for-2 at the upfronts as both of its pilots, Chase at NBC and The Whole Truth received series orders. Three of the company’s existing series, Cold Case, Miami Medical and The Forgotten, were cancelled, but Bruckheimer TV still remains the top pod with six series on the air. McG’s Wonderland is second with four, Nikita, Chuck, Human Target and Supernatural.
DreamWorks TV: The company is behind two of the highest-profile series presented at the upfronts: Terra Nova on Fox and Fallen Skies on TNT.
Did I miss anyone? I’ll add the best suggestions to the list.
TV Editor Nellie Andreeva - tip her here.




So the only pilot that Burrows directed that did NOT get picked up was OPEN BOOKS? That’s not surprising. Some scripts are so atrocious that even the best directors can’t save them.
Where’s the love to Dave Caspe! You congratulate the producer and director but not the writer? He has the same pilot percentage as David Nutter!!!!!
NICK WAUTERS – THE EVENT
Our agency’s biggest client finally getting some love! Love it!
Eh, what this more proves to me is once you’re in the club you get more opportunities than anyone else. Not that any of these people aren’t talented hard workers. But there are probably 50 better pilots than anything picked up this year sitting on the shelves because they had no-names under “written by” so nobody paid attention them. That’s just the way it goes.
A good script is a good script. All of these people were “no names” at one point. Talent rises.
Give me a break. And ABC is in huge trouble. They don’t know what they’re doing over there. The network and studio are over their heads.
But they now have three medical shows from Shonda!!!
Jesus as if a year of unemployment didn’t make me want to slit my wrists already.
(puts on fake smile, grits teeth) congratulations guys! You’re all an inspiration!
Has Bruckheimer EVER produced a pilot that didn’t get picked up? Nutter directed, but the Chase producer is on quite the Nutter-esque streak himself.
Everyone of Bruckheimer’s pilots have been picked up.
He has over 20 pilots that are officially dead.
He is very talented, but not everything he does turns to gold. Correct me if I’m wrong, but wasn’t he the guy behind E-Ring on NBC? I believe it was around 2005 in the Kevin Reilly at NBC era. The show was awful and was cancelled after just a few airings. Just saying.
With all due respect,no matter how crucial Craig Silverstein is to NIKITA, he can hardly be called the “creator” of a remake.
Surely British writer Kelly Marcel deserves a nod?
Never had a show in the U.S. then comes out with a little idea for a show called Terra Nova; pitches it and BANG! and it goes straight to series…
how’s that for left field?
why isn’t she working on the show then?
she is in first position on her other pilot for Showtime
How many tv series has David E Kelley created that have been picked up? It should atleast give him an honorable mention.
He’s had a ton of pilots the last few years that have NOT been picked up. This is his first since, uh, Wedding Bells.
The only pilot of his not to be picked up in the last few years was Legally Mad. Prior to that he started the Life on Mars remake but left/forced out to work on the final season on Boston Legal
JJ Abrams for Undercovers.
Peter Lenkov.Hawaii 5o.
True about Kelly Marcel. One to watch.
re: aaron kaplan… he is 8th on a long list of Executive Producers and a “financial interest” means he manages two guys who created the show.
he could go on to do amazing things, but i think put him on this list is jumping the gun just a tad.
This is not an exciting fall schedule, so thanks for showing the blame falls on the usual suspects.
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,and you know this because?
Aaaaah, if only they had listened to you!
NBC had a really strong development season with pilots The Event, Chase and Undercovers. I think NBC might improve in the ratings and beat ABC. ABC is in serious trouble. Their pilots are awful and NBC could be in 3rd place. I expect the ratings for NBC to go up next fall because their development season was their best in years and ABC’s was appallingly bad.
You HAVE to be joking. NBC’s slate is beyond bland. Except for their show about outsourcing, which is offensive to many. Can you imagine Middle America – or the Coasts, for that matter – tuning in to a COMEDY about all their jobs that disappeared? I can’t.
Chase sounds Extremely bland. Same with the rest. You must work for NBC.
Even Nikki said that NBC’s development was the strongest its been in years. It’s thanks to shows like Chase, Undercovers and The Event. Chase looks like a USA show like Burn Notice. Same thing with Undercovers.
He wants to work at NBC. Right now he picks up Zucker’s dry cleaning. It’
s a position with real growth potential …
I do not work for NBC and I agree Outsourced looks bad, but this is their best development season in a long time. Many people in the business and many who post here agree that NBC has the best development season out of all the networks. It sounds like you have this hatred for NBC and will bash them whenever they get the chance.
If only a few of the new NBC shows become hits, NBC will be competitive with all of the networks again.
Tommy Schlamme – Add him to the list with Parenthood last year and Mr. Sunshine this year. He’s got a great track record.
Parenthood was Ron Howard’s, Brian Grazer’s and Jason Katims production, not Tommy Schlamme.
Tommy directed Parenthood. And he directed Mr. Sunshine.
Aaron Kaplan knows how to play the game. Nasty–Yeah–Nasty boys–he’s a nasty boy!
Good for him. The guy beat most of you lemmings at your own game. He’s a winner. Go Kap!
Now the rest of you go back to Coco.
Thank you.
Turn down the suction, Nellie.
A good year for Bob Broder
The rich get richer, no doubt about it. Talent rises, but luck is also a big piece of it.
Broder deserves all the credit and those who play poker and know him as T F Broder
actually jimmy directed 2 pilots this season that weren’t picked up….open books and nathan vs. nurture
Jimmy and his crew deserve all the best because they are a team of elite professionals that believe in loyalty all the way…
What about Steve Stark? The guy has two recent series pickups… The Event at NBC and Facing Kate at USA. And he’s a pure class act. One of the nicest guys in this town.
What about Kyle Killen and his show Lone Star (formerly Midland) on Fox.
All of those Multi-Camera pilots will bomb. Remember “Back to You”?
NBC’s development is the strongest its been in years. The only one I didn’t like was Outsourced. It will not atract audiences and was not funny. But, the 3 big dramas, The Event, Undercovers and Chase look like they could be huge hits. Undercovers and and Chase look like Burn Notice, which is very USA. I think NBC should be doing USA style shows.
Hate to say it but now the networks are doing what the film studios have been doing lately: only greenlighting projects that are remakes, reboots, or created by a recognizable name. To be a relatively new writer penning original material for film OR television right now is to effectively be unemployed. It’s tragic. And it’s all due to executives being scared to take a “risk” on NEW material and/or writers and instead falling back on what’s easy, no matter how poor it may be. Shame.