
The Writer’s Guild East has come out on behalf of documentary director Joe Berlinger, who last week was ordered by a Federal Judge to give Chevron more than 600 hours of footage he compiled for the documentary Crude: The Real Price of Oil. Berlinger and his attorneys have prevailed upon Judge Kaplan to stay the order until they can appeal the ruling. The issue has become a First Amendment flashpoint. Here is the WGAE statement:
“In defense of free speech and the First Amendment, the Writers Guild of America, East joins with the Independent Documentary Association (IDA) in support of documentary filmmaker Joe Berlinger and in objection to Federal Judge Lewis A. Kaplan’s recent ruling that Berlinger must turn over to the Chevron Corporation 600 hours of footage shot during the production of his documentary ‘Crude: The Real Price of Oil.’
To accede to such a demand is tantamount to a reporter being told to turn over all of his or her notes and to violate confidentiality agreements with sources. As with the members of the IDA, our WGAE members working in the documentary field ‘hold ourselves to the highest of journalistic standards in the writing, producing, and editing of our films.’ Those standards include the protection of our outtakes, script drafts, research and sources.”


As a producer, I’ve had the pleasure of working with Joe Berlinger, a brilliant documentary director. I will fully support whatever it takes to stop this court order and to protect free speech.
I will do what I can to publicize this outrage.
The Apple decision about Gizmodo’s write up of the new Iphone is in the same vein.
Liberals applauded when the courts gained control over every aspect of people’s lives, on the theory that only a Gigantic state could make things “right.” Well, this is that.
Lets get to the heart of WHY the Judge ordered as he did (link from Guardian, hopefully left enough for most DHD readers):
“Kent Robertson, a Chevron spokesman, welcomed the US ruling. “The raw footage from Crude is an objective account of what is truly occurring in the shadows of this lawsuit and we are eager to bring these events to light. Given the level of opposition to Chevron gaining access to the outtakes, we have to believe there is … damning content that was left on the cutting room floor. It’s in the interest of justice that these events are known more broadly.”
He said Berlinger may have unwittingly captured misconduct by the Ecuadorean court and the plaintiffs’ legal team. He cited a scene allegedly showing the legal team participating in a focus group with a supposedly neutral court expert – a segment included in the Sundance film festival screening but edited out of the DVD version.”
There’s been a host of lawsuits that have been overturned in Central and South American countries because plaintiffs cooked up evidence and bribed judges and so forth, after deep US corporate pockets. Chevron says the pollution found now is the result of the state owned oil company.
Suborning witnesses is a serious charge. No wonder the court ordered as it did. A film-maker has no special privileges if it is credible raw footage has proof of wrong-doing.
The whole movie seems stupid. Are film-makers going to give up film-making, which requires a lot of oil? Are Sting and Trudy Styler going to stop their lavish, helicopter enabled jet-set lifestyle? Nope.
Drill in the US, particularly ANWAR, under tight regs. You’ll get some spills and environmental degradation. But realistically, you’ll get far less pollution than in Ecuador with a state-run oil company caring only about enriching ministers and cronies. I’ve yet to see a location shoot ever powered by windmills. Or a Malibu mansion run off solar. [Ed Begley's a good guy, who walks the walk. But I can't see anyone in Hollywood besides him living his middle class lifestyle. He doesn't live in a mansion. His house is only marginally better than mine. Trudy Styler has chefs flown in by helicopter for lunch, and has a fit when staff gets pregnant.]
here’s the biggest that the Drill Baby Drill crowd never bother to consider and do not realize…
when those areas such as ANWAR are raped by oil companies that don’t give a damn about anything other than making a profit and will do anything to ensure that the profit margin is at its highest at all costs…..for the short term and the long term
there is nothing whatsoever forcing them to use that oil in America!!! nor is there anything forcing them to sell at a certain price so that suv drivers can fill up at the pump.
it’s all a farce to fool you and others into thinking that they’re being oh-so-oppressed by liberals. boo hoo!!
unless you’re so multi-millionaire who has a major company that deals with the oil industry then they give next to nothing for you. period. end of story.
there’s no clean energy strategy in this country, unlike many of the other countries in the world, because our politicians are paid off and our media doesn’t report the truth and Americans are too lazy and easily fooled by the idea that continuing to rely on oil isn’t a good idea.
it’s called progress. you know, like when the country moved from horse and carriages to steam engines and beyond…the ride may be a little bumpy at times but this is the same land that sent a man to the moon, put tv shows in a rectangular instrument that fits in the palm of your hand and develops one medical miracle (heart transplant) after another (viagra). i think we can do it.
Since when did Oil Companies (mostly non American owned)get to decide what American documentary makers get to put on film???
This isn’t just an offense against the First Amendment – it’s an offense against American Freedom!
What next – is Osama Bin Laden going to sue the FBI for trying to stop him committing terrorism???
Whiskey, I think most people realize that saying we need to reduce our dependence on oil in the near future does not change the fact that right now, it is impossible to operate without it. You are right, obviously liberal movie directors do not power their sets from windmills. It is almost impossible to engage in business without the use of some oil UNTIL our infrastructure is changed to allow that.
If meat was suddenly the only food source, I wouldn’t find it hypocritical if vegetarians ate it to stay alive. Doesn’t mean they don’t believe meat should be avoided if possible…
If Berlinger can get Dave Mustaine to cry on film– he should have no problem with the boys at Chevron.
here’s an idea, and maybe i bring it up because i do not know the exact technology to bring this off, but
i’m guessing that all the necessary legal aspects are in order as far as those interviewed on film,
then
just post ALL OF IT online.
ALL OF IT!
chevron, obviously, wants to get its hands on the footage, and then claim that it violates some kind of corporate privacy or something and keep all the probably sordid details.
why else did it bring up the suit in the first place?
so, make a copy, put it all up online. the hard-hitting edited version could still be put together and if they lose the case then give chevron footage that anyone in the world can already view.
Judging by your inane posting, I can only assume that you did NOT see Crude. Or, worse, you did and are a vile fuck who could care less that an entire group of people are being systematically poisoned. The crude sludge that is currently polluting the Amazon stems directly from Texaco. Period. Chevron Texaco makes $200 billion in profits annually. It is THEIR RESPONSIBILITY to clean up their fucking mess.