
UPDATE TUESDAY 11AM: A source close to CBS stressed that the casting changes on Criminal Minds were a creative, not financial decision, and a way to “refresh a veteran drama series.” A new regular female cast member will be brought in sometime next season to fill the void that will be left by Cook’s departure.
EXCLUSIVE MONDAY 7:50PM: Heading to Season 6, CBS’ successful crime drama Criminal Minds is trimming the female portion of its cast for what I hear are financial reasons. I’m told the option of series regular A.J. Cook has not been picked up and co-star Paget Brewster is being made an offer to stay for only a reduced number of episodes next season, leaving fan favorite Kristen Vangsness as the only remaining full-time female cast member. I hear negotiations are underway with Brewster for a new deal that would keep her on the show. If she agrees, she will continue to be formally a regular but won’t appear in every episode. Talks are also ongoing with Cook to possibly appear in several episodes next season to wrap her character Jennifer Jereau’s storyline.
Among the broadcast networks, CBS has been aggressive in trying to rein in series costs, especially on its longer-running, more expensive dramas with large ensemble casts. Criminal Minds has had seven regulars as part of its core cast. Staying on are Joe Mantegna, Thomas Gibson, Shemar Moore, Matthew Gray Gubler and Vangsness. With the exception of Vangsness’ quirky nerd goddess Penelope Garcia, which has developed a strong following, the series has largely been perceived as a male-centered ensemble, with the boys getting most of the action.
Cook has been on the show since the first episode, joining after the pilot in 2005. Paget Brewster came on board nine episodes into Season 2, replacing original cast member Lola Glaudini. But aside from the Glaudini-Brewster switch and the forced replacement of original lead Mandy Patinkin with Mantegna following Patinkin’s abrupt exit after Season 2, the cast on Criminal Minds has been pretty stable, with Gibson, Moore and Vangness all on board since the pilot.
TV Editor Nellie Andreeva - tip her here.


This is the first TV show that I’ve been COMPLETELY attached to since the pilot. As a result this news hit me like a pile of bricks. I hope they take a cut and can all stay on board.
I sincerely hope this will not come to pass. If it does, I’m out – this was one of the very few shows that portrayed strong female characters without relegating them to sex kittens or love interests…wtf Ed Bernero??!
I agree! I really hate female characters in every show out there. This is the only show I actually enjoy watching with all these strong, female characters.
If it ain’t broken then don’t fix it. Criminal Minds is GREAT just like it is!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
i agree. the formula to criminal minds is a winning one, and making drastic changes would be a major mistake.it all gels well together so leave things as they are.the ratings prove that.
I love Criminal Minds, but I like it with the present cast. Why not leave well enough alone. The show is successful, as it is! I will miss Emily and J. J.
I agree! This is the first broadcastnetwork show since ER that is worth a damn. Keep ALL the characters.
AMEN! seriously i was soo mad when i found out. paget and aj are kickass characters on the show and bring it all together. ill be very upset and the show just wont be the same. they CANT get ride of them.
I love the show and the women make it a strong cast. I enjoy the input and determination of the female cast. Without them it will lack the carisma that I like.
I compleatly agree. Why should any changes be made at all? One should not mess with perfection.
Wow CBS, you have an incredible show with 1000′s of viewers, are you guys insane? Listen, the viewers are being extremely clear on what they want, why are you not listening. And just think what your sponsors who pay for advertising are going to think when no one is watching their commercials, that’s a huge amount of money being wasted sponsors. Keep the show the way it is, then everyone will be happy!!!
If that were true Adam Rodriguez would have never made it back to CSI Miami.
KEEP THE CAST AS IS …………. ITS WORKING A GREAT SHOW !
This show is GREAT ! The characters are all great in their own right. Why mess with a good thing. I say its not broken dont fix it.I have watched from day 1.
Remember K.i.S.S.
WE NEED TO ALL WRITE TO CBS ABOUT IT………..
I’m so pissed!I love this show and now this crap!Each cast member really adds something to the show,female and male,so why would anyone even begin to think of “trimming” anything?!!!!
I have just watched the seaon premiere of this show and was absolutely SHOCKED to see that they were getting rid of J.J. Why do these shows have to ruin something that is great. If they are short money, then make all of the cast members take turns at being off for 1 or 2 shows per season – after all, if the series doesn’t go because of 1 person being let go, then they all lose their job. I’d rather take a cut in pay and for the majority of these TV stars they all make too much money anyway – look at it has not giving as much money to the government! Not sure how her being let go will affect the show.
AJ’s character is fantastic! She should not have been fired. When something is not broken… leave it alone!!! This makes me so angry. A terrible mistake has been made, just you wait and see… just you wait and see….
I agree I think this is a huge mistake, leave the show alone, I hate when, the producers are morons!
I think the producers are following a code my dad used to tell me. “If it’s not broken, keep fixing it ’till it is”. And they’re fixing it real good.
They do not need to cut anyone, its perfect as it is!! (Except for them cutting JJ) I agree with many people, if its not BROKEN then DON’T fix it.Criminal minds is not broken. So don’t fix it!!
This show is awesome as it is!!!
I agree to many stupid changes can ruin a good show.
I DO NOT care for the new spin off Suspect Behavior. Criminal Minds is great the way it is!!! I agree…don’t fix it if it ain’t broke!!!! Listen to the people who watch it…. PLEASE!!!
My husband and I are in complete agreement. We have nothing against this new actress, but want the team as it was. A.J. and Ms. Prentiss were very good. We feel Emily especially is a very strong actress and a plus for the cast. Shame on the higher-ups who are also the mess-ups.
I agree I love this show. Please stop making cast changes. Although not the shows fault it took forever to get over the loss of Gideon.I really like Prentiss. I was hoping her and Hotch would get together. The show as stated is not broken. Leave it alone.
AMEN! Last year’s cast was PERFECT. I wish they would bring back Mandy Patinkink. A.J. Cook also needs to be brought back permanently! I agree…If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it!!!
i totally agree
I love Criminal Minds.
We all know about ‘Progress’ and moving ‘Forward’ but if you can , please keep the cast. I LOVE the cast- all of them. I love the chemistry between Penelope & Morgan. Love it, love it, love it. Remember “If it not broken don’t fix it. and, “leave well enough alone”.
Watch Legend of the Seeker!
The female characters are really strong in it!
Legend of the seeker got cancelled.
KEEP THE CAST AS IS …………. ITS WORKING A GREAT SHOW !
This show is GREAT ! The characters are all great in their own right. Why mess with a good thing. I say its not broken dont fix it.I have watched from day 1.
Remember K.i.S.S.
WE NEED TO ALL WRITE TO CBS ABOUT IT………..
ADAM made it back to CSI Miami that way.
repost
Stick to the books, they were better, and there was a lot more of them.
Legend of the Seeker was canceled. Nobody knows what their doing anymore.
watching “Criminal Minds” without JJ won’t be the same. I simply hate it when they change characters after so many seasons. So now that they made a major change, I will, too. Good bye JJ and Criminal Minds.
What can we “the fans” do to get JJ back. Who can we write to?
I agree, I will not be watching Criminal Minds with so many changes that has been made. It doesn’t appear that CBS cares about the viewers thoughts. It had been a great show. Don’t mess with a good thing.
I agree, I won’t be watching it either probably, because what’s the point? It’s all different and not in a good way!! Everyone’s characters are changing and it is not the same.
I am totally disappointed in you.
I agree The women on this show were powerful and great to watch without using their sex appeal. I hope they dont get rid of penelope b/c Ilove this show
you know what it is.They can get rid of the bigger salary and hire someone cheaper. Cook obviously balked at taking a pay cut and I wouldn’t be surprised if this is coming out now in the hopes she’ll cave ala jorja fox and eades from early in CSI.Because if this is true then the writers should be fired because they can’t have much creativity if they can’t write for Jareau or Prentiss
Why were the women asked to take pay cuts and not the men?
i agree 100% with men getting paycuts and i am a guy. its womens rights movement all over again. cbs get your act together. if you actually get rid of the women cast you will lose lots of viewers. mostly women but al lot of viewers
I am outraged along with the whole family. Words cannot express how I feel about losing ‘J.J.’; and now Paget is taking a huge cut? Wtf?! Keep all the men on board of course! I am just one devout fan since season one but i refuse to watch anylonger…along with many others. Gluck CBS…SO PISSED IN MASS
CBS just doesn’t want female characters on their network anymore.
Is there one NEW show in hour long starring a woman?
What is going on over there?
you should watch rizzoli and isles. great strong female characters. the season just ended, but it’ll continue to run until the new season. really great show.
I also love Rizzoli and Isles, but what has that got to do with anything? Criminal Minds is the best show on TV. Every character contributes to the dynamic in this fascinating and smart series. I surely hope this stupid move on the part of CBS does not tank the series. Who do they think they could pull in mid-season that could soften the blow? Duh-someone cheaper. STUPID!
Actually there are a number of shows now with strong female leads, Closer, Chase, Rizoli and Isles to name a few. Although I agree with everyone else, I think if a show is working why change it. It’s like the Dodgers, ever notice after they have a big season or win the play-offs they get rid of their best players everytime, it’s really odd. Maybe whomever owns the dodgers owns CBS too lol.
This does it for me. I’ve been a fan of Criminal Minds since the beginning. No more.
Garcia, JJ and Prentiss bring balance and heart to the show that will be too heavy without any one of them – let alone two.
Closer, Chase, Rizoli and Isles are all on different networks (TNT and NBC) who seem to get that you don’t have to have dangly bits to be a strong assertive character.
Give me a break, JJ was terrific. She brought her own personality and uniqueness to the show. She had great strength. Get her back, she is part of the team.
miss J J please bring her back.
I was just catching up on my recorded Criminal Minds and only just realized JJ will be gone. What a loss. I agree with the other comments about why not rotate out some of the actors a week here or there, or all take a cut. This is (was) one of the best shows on the tube.
I totally agree. What are they thinking — it seems to be so easy to get rid of the established female character and all is well…They are a draw to the series…It makes me rethink why I would want to watch something that doesn’t appreciate the team that carries it now — there is a reason we watch it. Maybe it just becomes true that television spits out the women from once they are over 30. What a shame — I know I won’t watch the series now.
Hasn’t CBS learned from the mistakes of NBC with Jay Leno every night or the horrible cast switches of of Law and Order Criminal Intent? They original CSI still has their cast — WTF Ed.
I totally agree. We strong women appreciate having strong women as front line. What is wrong CBS, have you guys totally lost it? Why not take off one of the men and pay AJ more; afterall, she has definitely helped carry the show. This is the thanks she gets???
I am beginning to understand more and more why my daughter watches so many shows on other networks. She has complained about CBS a couple years now. She has convinced me to record shows on the other networks and I am really glad now. Watching last season of them has me up to date so I can start switching if this crap keeps on.
I just watched the season premiere and “JJ” was awesome getting thru all the red tape of getting on the “emergency broadcast system. She was great convincing Billy to let Ellie go. In this one episode she played the part of a very determined woman, a very brave woman, and a loving mother. She was excellent at all three!If she goes, I go!
Me too. This is ludicrous. They are an ensemble cast and this will leave a crazy big hole. Based on her last episode it looks like the shows producers wanted to keep her and it is the network that killed her. I hope another network picks her up and CBS sees what they lost.
I didn’t start watching criminal minds until last year. My husband realized that I was really into the show,so he went and bought me all 5 episodes. I’m totally hooked. From Mandy to Garcia they are all great actors. What ever you do, just leave well enough alone. I agree with everyone post. I got my co-workers watching this show. I’m the go to person when it comes to tv shows. And by far this is one of the best shows. Do what you can to save everyone and bring JJ back!!!!! If anyone else post, please encourage the network to keep it the way it is and bring back JJ. I will hate to tell my co-workers to stop watching the show. Because if you replace anyone else. I’m OUT!!!!!!
I love the 7 cast that is what makes the show bring Emily back andJJ and don’t change the rest . everyone I know loves hodge ,rossie ,morgan reed jj, emily and garci . we the people who watches the show that way. I don’t care for the other crinmial minds at all . we all love those people give them what ever they want to keep them on
Actually, the original CSI DOESN’T have all it’s original cast….The characters Grissom (The head charrie btw), wolfe, and for a short time Sydow were gone from the show. And now they’ve also axed one of their stronger female characters from the current cast, Wendy Simms aka Liz Vassey, was dropped in the same way as A.J. So it’s not just CM that CBS is butchering up; pretty much all their high ranking dramas are losing their strong female draw-ins.
I stopped watching CSI because all the good characters are now gone. Half the time I couldn’t find it, it would be on for a few weeks, then disappear. Nothing is consistent anymore. I used to watch the reruns and the new episodes. Now they are ripping Criminal Minds up! Nothing left but those stupid reality shows.
“I sincerely hope this will not come to pass. If it does, I’m out – this was one of the very few shows that portrayed strong female characters without relegating them to sex kittens or love interests…wtf Ed Bernero??!”
Well put!
This is ludicrous!!!! The one show I religiously DVR & will not miss. They are part of this success. Don’t be idiots!
WHY! WHY!WHY! can’t you CBS execs leave the show the way it is. The actors male and female are strong and they make the show what it is and has always been, strong, riviting, intresting and very good to watch. If they want more money give it them this is one of the best shows on CBS and Television. You must have NEW excs at CBS making these changes and mixing things up. They are gonna cost CBS ratings, fans you name it they are gonna mess things up, like the dumbies at NBC removing J.Leno from his time slot. LEAVE THE DAMN CAST ALONE!
I agree leave the show alone…Love JJ…Keep her in the show..I have watched this show from day one but if you don’t keep JJ then you have lost another fan of the show…
You are ruining one of the best shows CBS has ever produced and as a female viewer it is more than interesting that only your finest female actors are being let go based on financial decisions — shame on you.
A.J. Cook and Paget Brewster are believable as FBI profilers, yet you seemed to find money in your budget for new female characters on both CM and Suspect behavior that look like barbie dolls and dumb down your once stellar show — I will no longer watch my favorite television show and have posted messages on my website, facebook, and twitter pages to other fans to boycot the show until you fix the damage the suits have done to a smart, well-written, well-directed,creative show. I’m also taking note of who your sponsors are and plan to forward the monumental criticisms of the recent decisions being posted all over the web.
For the record, I have never even thought about writing anything like this but there is so much crap being broadcast out there I couldn’t stand seeing one of the few smart shows your network has ever produced being ripped to shreds!
I say the same as many of the comments I just read!I say WHY WHY WHY WHY!Leave it alone!Why mess with something when there is nothing wrong with it at all?Strong women characters who happen to be HOT!Leave it alone!First AJ,now Paget’s character!I happen to like Paget Brewster aloooot!Now they are going to do something with her!That upsets me a great deal.CSI NY took off two female characters that I liked alot and now I don’t care for that show anymore!Now this!CBS do know what you are doing?
I AGREE 100%!LEAVE THE DAMN CAST ALONE!IT’s A GREAT SHOW!PERIOD!
This is my favorite tv program, I never miss it. Please keep JJ and Emily on the program. Why change when you have a great program. It does not make any sense to me.
I agree. Don’t you love Garcia? A female uber geek you can relate to.
Between Garcia on CM and Abby on NCIS, smart, beautiful and strong women RULE!
JJ was a welcome relief to the mostly mail cast. You will certaintly lose your female demographic including myself if AJ Cook leaves. With all the horrific things going on in this show her sweetness yet no nonscene sence of duty was a welcome relief
I have watched since day 1. Why do the women have to take the hits! CBS will lose me if they replace Cook. I love JJ’s character and she adds some logic and serenity to all the horrific things that occur.
I will stop watching the show. The other networks are all fighting for an audience for newer shows.
Get real! Lose JJ, and lose viewers and ratings!!!!!!!!!
i just want to agree with this viewer i to have watched this show since day 1. I even watch the reruns constantly on a&e and ion
tv but not any more there are plenty other shows to watch. Loose JJ
and loose other faithful watchers> Hope your ratings go down!!!!!!
Interesting observation. The frequent horror and strong emotional impact of this show is well balanced by intellectual insight, pithy quotes, righteous strength, and tenderness, or compassion. These are essential for success. I would not watch a show that depicted violence and horror without the redeeming qualities that have been evident thus far. This character and this actress are essential to making this possible.
BIG YES!!! CBS, don’t be greedy. The show has very strong following so it sure is serving you right.
I am an avid “Criminal Minds” fan. I enjoy every aspect of the show. The opening and closing quotes that draw you into emotional (psychological) elements of each show (and it’s cast members; even the predators). I have a professional background in English and in Psychology, so this show impacted me in a very profound way; however, the recent cast cuts (female characters at that) feel like a betrayal (no drama intended) to the integrity of
“Criminal Minds”; it will no longer be able to maintain the emotional/mental range that a gender-balanced team (family) maintained (for six seasons!). To quote one of my favorite blues musicians “The thrill is gone” and so is this once devoted fan.
Yes. I agree. I’m sick and tired of sex on television. Every show has to have sex kittens or a love interest brewing between co-workers. It’s annoying! Just do the story!
“songfire: I agree! I am getting tired of those shows “sex kittens or love interests” Give me “strong female characters” that has a brain.
I TOTALLY agree! I am/was an avid fan of this show. Their treatment of strong female characters was refreshing and made an important contribution to this show’s balance and success. Women were portrayed with actual common sense, but they were allowed to display their beauty without flashing skin or using their sexuality. I’m saddened that one of the most compelling treatments on TV today has been altered. Whether for creative or financial reasons, removing AJ Cook from this series was a serious misstep, and one i believe this series will live to regret. I’ve spoken with many of my peers, and the feeling seems to be fairly wide spread. In fact, we have discussed that if the timeslot on other stations provides an interesting alternative, like many CSI fans did a couple of seasons ago, we will move on.
exactly what I think too! Stop the maddess, CBS! Just stop! The show is good the way it is… GREAT with AJ Cook!
well actually Law & Order:SVU is also another show that has that. While Detective Benson (Mariska Hargitay) may go undercover as a prostitute or things of that nature, she still is held in a very strong, respected light. Though I am disapointed that the already limited action female staff is being cut. If anything more females should be added.
and A.J Cook is slated to make an apperance on an episode of Law & Order:SVU when the 12th season returns in the new year. It is scheduled to air in early 2011. You can and I suggest you read the article here.
http://www.tvguide.com/News/Cook-Criminal-Law-1026590.aspx
After last night’s episode, I probably won’t be watching anymore. No Hotch??????? I don’t like the new BLONDE. Either bring back the old cast or the show is over for me. I even watch the reruns on A & E & Ion. so theree stationns will suffer. I know just one person can’t make a difference, but it is goinng downhill fast. Don’t you care what the veiewers think? Fed up in Texas
I TOTALLY agree with EVERY word. Don’t ruin perfect!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I totally agree. I understand cuts….I work in the corporate world too, however….when you have a show that is working…and pulling all ages..and genders… WHY on earth would you mess with that….??????
I have as my husbund puts it lived to watch this awesome show from the date it started. It was hard loosing Gideon but Rossi has become a great addition. Now your telling me JJ? Have you fallen and bumped your head? Please do not take this awesome series and turn it into just another weekly program. I own every season made but as I read earlier if its not broken don’t fix it !!!
I agree leave the females alone!!!!!!!!
Keep JJ OR YOU HAVE LOST ANOTHER FAN…DO NOT LIKE THE NEW GIRL AT ALL..SHE IS NOT BELIEVABLE LIKE JJ…
well, once again tv has taken a show with a great format and tampered with it. probably no one can tell you what to do about the pay scales of your actors, but i think you will see a big difference in your audience. count one more gone. i have stopped watching the day jj left. so have many of my friends. the new girl, as i am sure you intended, is a younger, vapid version of the intelligent and compelling character of jj. so we should have been prepared for a change, right? someone younger and cheaper, with that irritating little tinny voice so many young people cultivate today. then, you will do the same with emily prentiss. well, why not, i mean she also represents an intelligent, strong woman. don’t worry though, i am sure you can find someone younger and cheaper. and really, not everyone envisions garcia as an FBI liason. ARE YOU KIDDING with that? she is an eyesore. and her relationship with morgan is too weird, but it works. get the message. they all work. now you bring in the valley girl and force it down the throats of people who looked forward to the show each week and say here. eat this. NO! you watch criminal minds now. and you can also watch that lousy spin off too. an american unit with an englishman with an irritating accent. hmmm, i don’t think so. i am 64 and have watched even bigger shows like “all in the family and kojak”, go under because they changed formats and threw people away. and by the way, i have never read anything about cutting the salaries of your males stars on criminal minds. whats up with that. frankly, i think a.j. cook and paget brewster ought to sue your asses off for sexual discriminations. what do you think about that? maybe i should get a group started on that issue. just on the grounds that you are too stupid would put me off enough never to turn you on again.
I saw some weird CM with Forrest whatever and others….(no disrespect F) What was that all about. It was like an impersonation of CM on my own PC???
I agree! I’ve watched Criminal Minds since Day 1; HATE the new spinoff — it’s just weird! Mandy Patinkin was a loss for a short while, but that’s what he does. Rossi has become part of the ensemble and now they not only take JJ off, but by killing off Prentiss make it impossible for her to come back — or is this another dream?
wont watch criminal minds because of changes, come on every one dont watch anymore until they bring back the girls,they cant ignore viewers, we are the ones who make and brake the show, sissy
The new girl with blond hair cannot hold a candle to JJ, u have just lost another viewer. I have been with u from the start and I am really lost for words that one of the best shows on TV, you cannot come to an agreement. Such a shame. Well CBS I guess I will check out the re runs on on other channels or better yet check out the Killing, Sorry u do not know a good show
I can’t stand the new blonde AT ALL either. Totally not believable.
I agree, I am not sure I like this new girl.. I am sure she is a great actress, but she is not part of the cast that I have grown to love. Like I read before.. You make many more changes I also will not keep watching…
well said….enough???
I agree, and the women that played those roles were great in them. JJ and Prentiss were great characters that were an amazing part of the team. I thought this set of characters were a perfect match. It was hard wanting to watch the show without JJ, with Prentiss gone I’m not sure I’m going to watch at all. I am amazed I ever watched it to begin with, this is not usually my type of show, but the powerful, intelligent women caught my attention. I WAS a huge fan. The show made a big mistake, hopefully they figure it out before the show hits rock bottom.
this is shit
this is completely insane!!!! WTF, someone has got to stop this!!!
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! what is CBS thinking?! Criminal Minds is my favorite show! If they cut her or more cast members, I will stop watching it! THIS IS OUTRAGEOUS ..I am just in shock.
SCREW THAT CM SPIN-OFF!
I am a devouted Criminal Minds watcher, but after hearing last nights shock about A J leaving. I’m pretty much done with the series. One of the few really good shows out there and now they are going to hose it all up. Guess I can watch reruns on TNT or A&E
We are trying. Hard.
I completely agree,dump the spin off and leave the regular Criminal Minds cast as is! I was not impressed with the spin off unveiling in the least. Criminal Minds sets a wonderful example having women who can hold their own in a male oriented field. I would hate to see that message being lost. All the characters are essential parts of the team on Criminal Minds! CBS will loose viewers if they go through with this!
Totally agree, Why mess with what works. This seems to be the trend with networks lately either they cancel the show because it cost too much to produce or they get rid of essential cast members to cut cost. Way to lose an Audience CBS! I don’t think the show will be the same without AJ and Paget. Seriously thinking about not watching this show if both characters are let go to add a new female character. I do like all the other cast members but it took me a long time to warm up to Joe Motagne as a new addition to the cast just not a fan of his. The writers can add new life to their existing characters with a new story line for them. You don’t need a new character/cast member to do that.
I love Criminal Minds.. it is my favorite show by far! I have been a loyal fan and viewer of the show since 2005, and must say that because of Paget Brewster’s character (mostly), I have recently applied to the FBI Academy. I have always been passionate about being an FBI agent, but have been motivated greatly by Brewster and her character, Emily Prentiss. I hope she stays on board… love her to pieces.
criminal mind got rid of giddion and that one lady. now they finally have a great cast and jj leaves? talk about show suicide. cbs how can you let this happen? do you not notice ratings of nbc, tnt, or abc? get a clue and do the right thing.
It’s true you finally have a great cast and you are about to cut them. Please think twice about this. They all work together very well. Better than the previous ones. I was so shocked when I saw the episode. It will truely be a disappointment. Please don’t screw a good thing up.
Get rid of AJ and Paget and they won’t have a show to replace anyone on. Come ON CBS. Thinking with your freaking heads! You have a cast that WORKS and team that WORKS and an audience who loves them! Why why why do you want to change that!
Why are Ed Bernaro, Mark Gordon, Deb Spera and CBS dumping the female element of this show? What is the deal? There must be a reason they are too embarrassed to admit. Paget Brewster is an awesome talent. She should have her own show.
Absolutely! You have a fabulous cast and making changes at this point when your audience has a rapport with every single cast member is absolute insanity. I cried last night because it was so sad. I am so disappointed in CBS. You have made a terrible mistake.
Wow.. getting rid of 2 liked characters to add a new one makes no sense. And a creative move not financial sounds like backpedeling to me. “…A new regular female cast member will be brought in sometime next season to fill the void that will be left by Cook’s departure.”… not a departure of choice but more like being pushed out… If you need any creative storylines for AJ or Paget’s characters, contact me and I’ll give you a few. Don’t let characters that people have grown to care about go.
From the multiple shows that I follow over the course of the year, CM is the only one that hasn’t let me down with regards to plots, characters, developments etc. After viewing 2 very disappointing season finales for other shows, my friends and I watched the CM finale and were exciting talking about what they were going to do next. This sort of move was not even entertained as a bad joke.
There’s plenty of potential for both these characters without turning them into sex objects
CBS you guys really need to think this over
What is CBS thinking? If they go through with these changes, then I’ll be changing the channel.
I’ll be gone too.
I bet they loose more than half their viewers.
Agree, CBS will pay for this!
My next move will be, to keep watching the repeats on A@E , once the they make the cuts that will deprive us of a fine ensemble..which attracts bot male and females viewers.
It’s been a show that put both men and women on the same level, which made it almost unique as the female of the species was not there for window dressing.But now ,they go and cut part of it’s core, of what was undeniably, a very progressive series..that is so typical.
syl.
I totally agree. WHY COULDNT THEY JUST LEAVE IT ALONE. Their a bunch of well you fill in the blanks!!
i agree, have never missed an episode but i will change channels also
I’m happy that they’re getting rid of A.J and cutting back on Paget, cuz that means more air time for the guys. And seriously, who doesn’t want to see more of Hotch, Reid and Morgan?
It could possibly mean better story lines as well since they wont have to worry about fitting in all the characters into an episode and having them say something. Heck it could mean better parts for the guys as well since now the writers will be able to focus on better stories for them. Maybe even a love interest story line for Reid?
And if the writing is better then an Emmy could be in t heir future. Plus I hated the fact that Reid didn’t get as much air time this season, which seriously pissed me off. Plus, all they need is Garcia for the comp stuff, Reid for all the mapping, Morgan for all the door busting and Hotch for all the leadership stuff. So I seriously think that this is a good move for the series and I am not at all worried.
Right on aboput the reid stuff but i like aj(jj) and i like paget(prentis) too. They should just cut the pay on everyone.
way to make female fans look like shallow twits who are only interested in watching attractive men, idiot.
Hate to tell you this, but I’m a 40 + straight women and what I want to see are intelligent shows featuring good looking MEN. Now…don’t get me wrong, I’ve gotten use to Prentiss and JJ so losing either one is like losing a family member now…HOWEVER, if the show had NEVER had them on at all, that would have been just peachy with me. HATE last season with no Reid-centric eps. THIS viewer wants smart shows with good-looking men. No, I don’t give a crap if you think I’m an idiot – you don’t pay my bills and don’t presume to tell me what women should or should not want to watch in tv shows!
I am so upset about Criminal Minds cutting A.J. Cook. Do they really think people will continue to watch the show as they one by one cut the cast members that have brought viewers back week after week? No….I can watch reruns on A&E and Ion and be perfectly happy. The show just isn’t the same with the cast changes. It’s really a shame….it used to be such a great show!
The men maybe nice to look at, but the women are really positive role models. They’re smart, funny, strong females who just happen to be attractive. Their story-lines add layers to the show and provide a various female perspectives. Also, a show doesn’t run on “pretty” alone.
You’re a friggin IDIOT, get rid of the women? it’s people like you that run CBS, NBC and ABC. Criminal minds is the best damned show on tv, why don’t you go fishing or something and SHUT THE HELL UP.
Calm. Down.
Think for a moment please.
Though I’m upset about A.J leaving and Paget possibly leaving, I remember that if I knew anything about what it takes to run a television network, I’d be running it. Since you are bashing the people that run CBS, NBC and ABC, I think it’s safe to assume you-like me- do not run these networks. So why don’t you take your own advice and “shut the hell up”.
Okay, folks need a hobbie if u have to get upset over a show!! I love it as well, so very much that i own all that has been released.But do get a new person if that will b the only change….I look forward to the show and love the charactors in a way that when new shows r introduced to us (the public), and rush to c it.So please continue to entertain us with this show and others.A devoted fan!
Lets see…Hotch is a sourpiss. Morgan IS HOT but a malewhore & I do adore Reed. If you want to see “male flesh” watch True Blood.
Wow, you think it’s because of the girls that Reid didn’t get as much airtime, um no, first of all it’s very male centered, I’ve been watching from the beginning, you need to freshen up those dvds, and also that lost Reid time did it really go to one of the girls or to one of the guys. Also people, remember when they brought that girl on for JJ’s before, um no, what does CBS writers&exects. think it’s going to fix things that yeah we’re dumping two girls, one who’s been there from the beginning permanently, but don’t worry(!) in the 6th season of this show we’re going to introduce a new female character to replace A.J. Give me a break, and this is coming from a fan of all the actors, and girl who’s 20 yrs old who’s been watching CM since the first season. Also for some reason it took less time for me to warm up to Prentiss rather than Rossi, and I wasn’t even a huge Gideon fan, if anything I’m such a huge Reid fan. Although I do love them all, I just love A.J.’s and Paget’s acting, although there’s no doubt that Shemar’s good, as well as smokin’ hot, and Hotch I love me and more each season, and Garcia is just so unique and amazing, it’s all the core 7 that make the show, come on CBS!
I suppose you are a guy who things all the stuff you mentioned are what makes the world go around. However, i am here to tell you that there are other nuances that you have missed and these nuances mising from the show will make it hollow and insufficient.
Ummmm are you out of your freakin mind…if they drop JJ who will handle the media and the children and the woman etc…and if they drop Prentiss well thats just like cutting one of a dudes nuts off!!!! now on a lighter note CBS IF YOU DROP THEM YOU WILL LOSE OVER HALF OF YOUR AUDIENCE, NOW GETCH YO HEAD OUT YOUR BUTTS AND THINK!!!!!!!!!!!! thank you:)
I agree! If Emily goes too, they may as well shut the show down. New blonde SUCKS! Why get rid of a pretty one for HER? & I Have never seen a show w/o Hotch. CBS you just ruined yet another show. The spin off won’t last either. It was bad last year! Are you running out of money? You are runninning out of veiwers!!!!!!!!
What a fool.
We don’t want a new cast member, we are happy with the cast AS IS! Don’t make the spin-off, as it has a horrible team and I will be giddy when it *does* fail. Keep AJ and Paget, they are two beautifully talented actresses. I hope for once, the big wigs of the network will listen to their fans and see that this decision is not a popular one.
Peace, Love, and Happiness to You…Sarah
“A new regular female cast member will be brought in sometime next season to fill the void that will be left by Cook’s departure.”
WHAT? How could anyone fill the void left by Cook’s departure? Answer: They can’t!
This “veteran drama” doesn’t need REFRESHING. It’s working great the way it is, and they need to focus on doing it right instead of “fixing” what isn’t broken.
Everyone is replacable. I don’t agree with making your replacements gender specific however, I have never like the character of Emily and found her a horrible replacement for Elle (Elle was tough when needed to be but showed a softer compasionate side when need be, Emily has never been convincing). Furthermore, it shouldn’t be hard to replacement for JJ, because she just kinda blends in like wallpaper, and personally I always found her acting ability minimal at best.
I don’t agree with you at all, never cared for Elle and I love Emily. I think the team was made a whole once she came on board. I think it stinks they are chopping up the cast, it’s going to cost them in ratings, which will make the show end. As in all the great shows on, the big wigs bring them down, not the actors.
WTF!
First, last night Bruno on DWTS pissed me off so bad I dont care if I ever watch that show. American Idol f**d up that show and now CRIMINAL MINDS
JJ out and possibly Emily too. I dont care if I ever watch this show again now. Everybody has to mess with perfection. I loved JJ. Can’t count on anything anymore. Well to hell with that. Time to start looking for some new ones
I just said the other day that I had no intention of getting hooked on any of the new shows because I had enough shows to watch.
Big mistake! You have taken away two of my favorite characters, JJ and Paget, and I won’t be wataching Criminal Minds any more. Take a look at some of the other shows that are being cancelled because the actors were deleted and use your common sense. I thought CBS was smarter than this. You ruined a great show.
This is horrible. First of all, I really liked Lola Glaudini, but learned to like Paget Brewster a lot. Now they want to replace both women? This is just another example of how women are disposable in Hollywood. I always liked how intelligent CM was as a show, but it’s obvious it’s just another boys club. Horrible!!
Only comment….” Not Happy about this decision if it goes down “
Criminal Minds was a show with the perfect cast, why ruin a good thing? It’s really too bad as AJ and Prentiss were two of my favorite characters. In the past the show has had temporary female replacements and it just did not work and after reading about the new changes I no longer look forward to the new season.
CBS is wrong in eliminating female role models from CRIMINAL MINDS. Women need to know that there are job opportunities in the FBI. That women can be in the investigative world as well as criminal forensics. CBS has lost it. I know I will be watching less of the shows that have decreased the roles of women.
Please don’t remove these two powerful female role models. One is a working mother and one is a strong powerful single female who is making it in a male dominated career.
I don’t want to see a show full of insensitive men.
Tam
yeah i completely agree with you!!!! they cant just take aj and paget away from the show!!!!
This is a totally stupid decision! And I believe many ppl feel the same way. I can say I will not watch the show anymore if they remove one or both of the female characters. I love Criminal Minds, but why would CBS make such a stupid move?!
Changing the cast this drastically will turn my favorite show into one that I won’t watch much at all. I enjoy having all of the girls in the show and feel they are all equally important. Don’t do it.
CBS using their own Criminal Minds show to victimize women. What? There aren’t enough unsubs to go around? Or they just want to live vicariously through their show. Narcissistic ,misogynistic sadists…for shame.
The show would just not be the same without the female characters. I for one more than likely won’t watch anymore if A.J. Cook and Paget Brewster aren’t there to speak out and catch the bad guys.
I THINK THEY ALL SHOULD STAY!Why mess with a good thing.Ihave watch the show from the beginning its a great show and the characters make it work,all of them.What is wrong with you people! take it do more with the story lines and you’ll have a long running show.
I don’t like the change of leadership. I love Shemar Moore but the show already has a great leader. I don’t understand why they want to mess things up.
I rarely watch TV – too many of the shows on network channels seem to be written in a dumbed down way – they certainly aren’t written for the average American who is intelligent enough to keep up with clues, twists in the script and spot out an occasional error or two. Having said that, I fell in love with Law & Order but gave it up entirely because of the cast changes. I watched the very first episode of Criminal Minds and was absolutely hooked. My husband liked the show but since it conflicted with American Idol, he watched that instead while I retreated to the bedroom to watch CM. I didn’t particularly like Gideon leaving and have had a lot of trouble adjusting to Rossi. He’s a great actor but it took a long time for his character to gel with the rest of the team. Prentiss, however, only took a few episodes. She made the team better and it was a smooth transition.
For the first time, I’m angry enough to sign the petition and speak out in support of a show that has a HUGE fan base and the demo group it reaches is an advertising Mecca.
CBS – the old adage suits. If it ain’t broken, don’t fix it. Leave well enough alone. You have an excellent, excellent show. Trying to substitute someone from JJ is not only ridiculous, it’s impossible and Emily Prentiss’ character is just right the way it is. Who else could hold her own with Morgan or bring out Reid’s softer side with humor and compassion.
I totally agree. Not broken, don’t fix. I mean, in one episode, J.J. takes out an unsub with her Glock, through the glass, no less, and between the eyes! In other episodes, she takes off the rock-hard edges off FBI procedure with maternal concern for her child. You don’t kill a cash cow like CM by experimenting with cast changes like removing J.J.and reducing Paget. Common sense business tells us if it makes money and sits high in the ratings, stroke and nurture it.
Yeah, what she said! Much more eloquently than I could but my sentiments exactly!
My daughter turned me on to Criminal Minds. At first, I just did not want to focus on serial killers. I was wrong! This is one of the best shows on TV. The cast members make it happen. I am really disappointed that A.J. Cook may not be back. It would be better is Mark Gordon made an effort to keep her and Paget Brewster as continuing cast members. Women are probably the largest audience and taking these ladies out or limiting their participation is “series suicide”.
I’m a huge CM fan. HATE HATE HATE hearing about AJ cook and the possibility of Paget not returning . I’ve been a loyal follower but may in fact check out the new shows like Hawaii50 and Chase and maybe consider watching the CM reruns next spring. (sigh)
NOOOOOOOOOO!!!! WTF people!!! What are you thinking!! I started watching this show because of JJ. Now you’re taking her out?? Are you kidding me?!?!?!?! COME ON!! LEAVE JJ ON, PLEASE!
im sorry but when you have the best show on tv, why do you have to mess with the chemistry. please say it isnt so you will be sorely missed JJ
I have watched this show from the very beginning and it is one of the best shows on TV. I think cutting any of the cast will take away from the show. AJ Cook is very much a needed part of the show as well as Brewster. It is refreshing to see woman have an equal parts on the show and are displayed as intelligent and strong women. I hope you keep everyone!
I have never commented before but this time I am totally ticked off. Leave AJ Cook on the show and do not cut Paget Brewster at all. They make the show as JJ and Emily along with Garcia. You guys just love to mess up a good thing, don’t you? You will lose a faithful veiwer when you do this. Better do what is right.
I have to say that Criminal Minds had…let me stress had the perfect cast. Other than the fact that there is room for Jason to come back too. JJ and Emily are needed and wanted by the fans. The people making the decisions need to listen to us. We want them back.ASAP
CBS is making a HUGE mistake. I guess they want people to stop watching for some reason. AJ Cook and Paget Brewster are an awesome comparision of how women can be strong in different ways and have an excellent chemistry with the men they work with and can hold their “man’s world”. Get rid of self centered egotistical Dereck Morgan (Sorry, I’m sure Shemar Moore’s is a nice person)and see if Scott Bakula is doing anything. I really hope CBS changes their mind, I’d hate to stop watching.
I completely disagree! DO NOT TOUCH SHEMAR MOORE/DEREK MORGAN! While I will miss JJ, I started watching for Shemar Moore and I would stop of he wasn’t there!
I do agree however that they shouldn’t have gotten rid of JJ, why mess with a great show?!? Maybe they will change their minds like CSI did with Jorja Fox….
This is the best show that we have had in a long time. It make you laugh and makes you cry and also makes you cheer. J.J. is a very strong driving force in the show and it would be a great mistake to let here get away. Without her it would not be the same show and may not be the same to watch.It would be a shame to quit watching this show.
I really dont understand why they change show when they have something great.
This is like CSI – when Grissom/Warrick left – I have not watched the show since, there is just something missing.
AJ Cook is an essential part of the show, she will be missed. I am certain that they will loose viewers – I probably wont be dedicated as I was before.
very very sad.
I agree with your comments I rarely watch CSI anymore, it just isn’t the same since. It isn’t on my must see list anymore. CSI NY brought in Sela Ward this season and I stopped watching that too. Can’t stand her, much preferred Stella character.
I wish they would reconsider doing a spinoff of CM. Why mess with a good thing. Why the big bosses always have to mess with the good shows and ruin them I’ll never know.
I have also watched CM since the first episode (and still watch reruns) and although I never liked the Elle character (Lola Glaudini) I do really like Prentis (Paget Brewster). She has become one of my favorite characters like Hotch. I would be sorry to see her leave the show. I think I would have to move on if they change too much about the show. I like that they have been injecting more humor to her character so she is not always so intense. She is becoming a more well rounded character. There is still so much they could do with her storyline. Please CBS leave CM alone. I would hate to have to give up another favorite show.
Hawaii Five O is looking better all the time so maybe that will be a new fave in place of CM if they keep messing with the chemistry of the CM team. Criminal Minds, Lie to Me and the Closer have always been on my never miss/must record/love rerun list since they first aired.
You want to cut something?…take CSI Miami off the air. I don’t care what channel it is on I CAN NOT watch the arrogant Horatio Kane character and never could stand David Caruso’s acting.
Please Please Please CBS…leave CM & Prentiss alone. Thanks.
so many tv problems always do the same thing. getting rid of cast members. when a show is doing so good ,why do they do that. i agree with the rest of you. let well enough alone the cast is perfect. pls listen.JILL
Sad, sad, sad. I see I’m not the only one who is mourning the loss of Cook on Criminal Minds. The ONLY shows I ever watched on CBS were Criminal Minds and Ghost Whisperer. Now one is gone and the other is ruined. No offense to the other fantastic cast members, but A.J. really was the glue the bound them together. CBS has lost two regular viewers just like that. Sad, sad, sad.
Pretty stupid to get rid of the females on a show that everyone loves. cast is fine the way it is. You start getting rid of poeple and changing people, the show is goign to SUCK!
I totally agree!! I hate that they are taking away Characters that devoted viewers have come to love. I am extremely upset that they are taking the strong female characters away. Do they not realize that the chemistry of the characters is what makes the show. As a female, I am offended that the females are the victims of the cuts and am undecided if I will continue to watch.
I love Criminal Minds and will continue to watch after A.J.’s departure. Her character was very likable but not necessary and did not – REALLY – add anything to the series. If they needed to cut someone – she was the one. Sorry.
I bet the ratings go down by AJ’s leaving which forces the show to bring her back. The show was perfect the way it was so why ruin a good thing. I felt the women’s parts in the show were just as important as the men. That’s what made the show so great. If you change the show too much, I won’t be able to watch anymore.
I wish they would poll viewers because JJ was one of the best characters. It will probably go on but at a loss because jjwas just a beautiful part of the show.
This is the only TV progam I enjoy watching; especially with this cast of characters. A.J. will be missed and it’s to bad under these circumstances. The TV show will not be the same; especially being replaced by someone else.
That is it for me I am done as of now Get rid of the girls your show is Toast!!!!
I enjoy watching Criminal Minds and AJ has been a very big part of this show’s success. Why take a actor out for doing a great job and now I hear they are going to replace her! This is outragious bring AJ back. We all love her character and the actor.
This is insane. Fire the people that made the stupid decision, and keep the cast intact. You just ruined a great show. Shame on you.
Cutting JJ out of Criminal Minds was criminal in and of itself. She has been a part of the “team”, but now there is a hugh void. Why do writers have to make such ridiculous changes? Bring JJ BACK!!
If they wanted to “refresh the show,” by cutting someone and adding someone new, cut the character everyone hates anyway… Do I have to say the name? We all know who I’m talking about. Cut ROSSI!!! Though he’s appeared more human last season, he’s still always been and always will be an ass IMO. How in the world could they misread their audience so badly? What a totally stupid, assanine belief, that cutting the best looking female on the show (that’s a guy’s opinion, sorry… don’t have the boobs to give a female based opinion
), and a much loved character, would be the way to go to “shake things up.” This really ticks me off.
I have watched Criminal Minds since the first episode. I think it is the most stupid reason for taking Cook off the show and reducing Paget’s role on the show. Because they are women. Why can’t these producers and writers leave a good thing alone. They also f things up.
I record all the show and watch them every weekend. I look forward to the storyline and watching all the characters. They relate to each other and make up a good team.
Just don’t understand the stupidity of CBS.
It’s not the same without A,J. The network has the money..why cant they find another alternative
. What happened to “if it ain’t broke don’t fix it”. CBS if you are listening bring JJ back!
Yes, The recent episode where J J got on the emergency broadcast system to talk to the listening serial killer about being a parent actually made me cry. (and I’m a total dude who likes the bloody stuff!) Keeping the existing ensemble is always a great move because theres always a higher element of caring for that character. If a new person did that same thing, there would be much less effect. My wife loves the show, my mom loves the show. Mess with the ladies and CBS will loose a HUGE percentage of their audience.
Why can’t they leave well enough alone. More money in the CEO’s pocket.
Why tamper with perfection? Which means, I agree with everyone else who thinks a strong female presence is not only necessary, but enjoyable. If they take A.J Cook away, I’m going away. The show was like a family, and nobody likes a divorce, but that’s exactly what’s happening. Listen to your fans– the fans that made your show so lucrative. Without us, who’s going to watch?
I think reduction of main female characters sucks, bites and blows. Criminal Minds needs the woman to help round out the cast. Once they start to mess with perfection it is usually over very soon! What a shame, I love that show.
You got rid of one of the best cast members for your audience in AJ and tonight I saw the new addition????????? You have got to be kidding. How can you justify getting rid of a cast member who played AJ for what you called “budget reasons” and replace her with another blonde who really acts like a dumb blonde? You should get rid of whoever is responsible for that decision. I was an avid watcher and enjoyed the show. Now I will never watch it again. Amazing how things work in your industry.
I agree. I’m a guy and I’ve been watching Criminal Minds since the beginning. (I also Executive Produced “The Young and The Restless” when Shemar was on the show…great guy by the way..humble, sensitive and very talented.)
Anyway, AJ Cook was one of the main reasons I watched. I loved that an attractive sexy woman could be portrayed as a strong, independent and confident character. The balance they had with these actors was perfect! Typical of the business these days. Everyone trying to “switch it up” for the sake of it. BAD and unnecessary move, CRIMINAL MINDS!
Not so sure I want to be a part of this anymore…
I have never missed a show, bought all the seasons, and now, it is a shame they cut, and are thinking of cutting another female role.
This show was perfection since Paget was added, and they are messing it up.
If this happens, you lost a fan and no more seasons ond dvd for me.
Don’t make changes to the cast – JJ & Emily add the right mix to the cast!!! I’ve been watching the shoe from day one and Crinimal Minds is one of the few shows that the charaters think with more then their body parts, but apply education and science!!! The cast of Crinimal Minds is Great!!! DON”T fix what’s not broken. I also saw the spin-off CM show and it was not near as good. Very offen spin-off shows do more damage then good. KEEP THE CAST AS IS !!!!
AJ Cook rounds out the cast just perfectly. Losing her makes me think twice about watching the show in the future. The other character replacements did not bother me, but this one is a horrible move.
What the hell is going off? Do CBS think they have an all female following for this show, & that we just want to see the boys!
Given a choice, I would much prefer Hotch was dumped last season than to loose any airtime for the girls! This is just like real life, the men always take priority. Well, this show actually revolves around JJ, Prentis AND Garcia!
Would anyone notice if Rossi was missing an episode? I doubt it! The character has no real place & Hotch’s role was very easily filled last season by Morgan – who is a much more sensitive character than either Rossi or Hotchner!
CSI just is not the same without Grissom, he was the glue that kept it together – Catherine is wonderful, but she just isn’t Grissom! Getting rid of JJ is suicidal & if you downgrade Prenties as well, there will be no real point even bothering to watch!
i have been watching every episode my favorite show leave as is if you take anyone off the show will not be the same
I am against the changes to Criminal Minds. I think the cast is perfect. I really liked Manny Patinkin and Lola Glaudini, but I like the replacements. Sometime change is good, but the cast is great the way it is. I miss AJ’s face in the new episodes, not getting used to her being gone.
I watched “Criminal Minds” last evening. I thought it was totally disgusting how this couple had problems and went around killing everybody. If this kind of trash is what people are watching, no wonder kids get the idea of killing people. Where has our society gone?
I agree with you but what can the viewing public do. Any suggestions I have already written to the show. But I just think they just want a cheaper person to play JJ’s Part on the show then they can play her less and when she starts to want as much as the men then she will be let go also..And it is to bad that they just don’t write her out of the series instead of pretending there never was a JJ. Almost all the series kill off the person they want gone so their is an ending to that part played by that particular person. They do it for all the male actors. like Gary Dourdan and Speed from CSI L.V.
I could not Believe when JJ aka Aj Cook was leaving, I loved Her ..She is one of my favourite caracters in the show. Criminal Mindsis my fave show for definite. Ever since episode 1 season 1 JJ was there. Then when she left it seemed diffrent. Then when me and my friends found out that Paget Brewster was leaving aka Emily Prentiss we were soo mad. I think that CBS has gone sexist and that they should bring the girl power back or there defo going to lose viewers.
My Opinion..Love Ireland.
I feel exactly the same way. AJ Cook brought so much to the show, someone we can relate to–I am extremely disappointed that she was cut. I’m really apprehensive that the first series I’ve been interested in in a long time is going to lose something that’s hard to put your finger on. It’s going to be hard to replicate the magnetism this team has. Please don’t mess with such a winning formula if at all possible.
I’ve been watching for about three yrs.and @ the middle of last season,I got my daughter hooked and she told her friends,not sure how many she told,but all of them are hooked.We all like A.J.and Padget also.We are Disappointed to see them leave.We feel they add structure to the show.I’m not one to write in,I just felt I should comment. Thank Dan
I, totally, agree!
I’ve been a fan since the start and you get attaced to the characters! Loads of people, that I know, are very upset wit the change, also.
I predict ratings will fall after this BAD move on CBS’ part.
Ann D.
Big mistake to take A.J and Paget out. I do not enjoy the new female …and did not enjoy Elle as much as Paget. she is not as strong and its too bad that a great cast has to be messed up.
I cannot believe that they keep taking the females off the shoe. I have been addicted to this show for years now and have become attached to all of them. I agree with a previous poster wishing they would take a pay cut and keep everyone on.
Please don’t take Emily off she is great. And bring J.J. back. I don’t like the new girl that was put on. Keep the cast all the same. I was glad when L got off I didn”t like her. If you keep takeing off the good actor’s I will not be watching criminal mind’s
any more.
I am a big Criminal Minds junkie. Not only have I never missed an episode, but I also watch all the reruns. I am extremely disappointed at the way CBS has eliminated Cook and Prentiss from the show. The new female character has no connection to any of the other cast members. Get back J.J and Prentiss or you will lose two more viewers.
It is unfortunate that corporate bureaucracy stamps its ugly head into everything including matters that are not only working but exceptionally well; as in the existing cast for Criminal Minds. Making changes just to make changes is a practice that almost always fails and only signifies practices of individuals trying to either justify their job and or an attempt to make their mark in the reigning corporate landscape. Shame on you CBS!!! If indeed these “creative changes” are made, you will not only lose my viewership but am certain they will mark the end of a show that currently receives extremely high praise and audience support!!!
Agree it’s a mistake
My family loves the character Emily Prentis and she can not be replaced.You have made her such a strong character in this show there will be a real hole if she is eliminated!! Right now you have three strong men and two strong women. That balances!!!! Please keep Paget Brewster, she is so well worth it.If not we will have to review our viewing schedual.
Sincerely, Katonni
Do not let go of Emily, especially with JJ gone. Don’t you know that us regular watchers get attached to the cast and don’t like the change. THey are a great mix and feel like a family. Don’t really like the new blonde who took JJ’s place. It appears you really don’t care what viewers want.
OMG!!! i just finished watching and i am so pissed. i cant believe they “killed her off”. so are they thinking about bringing her back at a later date or what? the show will not be the same without her. she was one tough cookie. and i will miss her greatly. i am glad that they are keeping penelope though. but emily will be missed in future episodes.
I absolutely LOVE Criminal Minds!!! But I’m tired of the casts changes…first J.J and now Emily!!! NO no no don’t do it!!!! We love the women just as much as the men!!
I think that CBS is crazy. The women are so strong that now the cast seems lopsided. AJ is deeply missed. And Paget was just written off for the time being. Garcia is good but I liked the other 2 women more. The three of them made a great cast. Lose one of the men. If they keep doing this I will quit watching. Too many men is boring!!!!!
This group works and will not be the same without the women. I’m glad ION and A&E will still have the old shows when I stop watching the new onws on CBS.
I agree with everyone to leave the cast alone. Without Emily Prentiss and J.J., I will no longer be watching this show.
Sad they are writing out the strong female roles. The show drove at least two college graduates I mentor toward a field of behavorial science –in a time when we need to push women into scientific roles. These shows do more than entertain.
This is crazy – why do they change something that people obviously like the way it is. If viewership has gone down, then ok. Prentiss was really good on that show. They did a good job of making her leave somewhat mysterious. Now, bring her back! Why would you cut JJ – she is a good member of the cast.
Pay attention to what your viewers want or I’ll be switching to another show, or reading a book.
The first mistake was to eliminate JJ. The second is the elimination of Emily Prentiss. I am sure this will be the final mistake and the demise of Criminal Minds. So sad!!!
I can’t say that this has anything to do with how women are being treated today but I do suspect this action has something to do with it. Prentiss is my favourite character on criminal minds and I know if she is completely removed from the series I will have a hard time continuing watching the show.
I’v been watching this show since day one and A. J. Cook is one of my favorite characters out of everyone. I love everyone on this show, that’s what makes it work are these characters, not replacements. It just doesn’t work that way. It won’t be as good because the characters don’t mesh like the originals.
I’ve watched Criminal Minds from the beginning and like all the cast members. It will be sad not to see Paget Brewster among them.
She was very good on the show.
Can’t believe they cut her… I love the relationship between all the characters in the cast – and I’m through with the show. If she goes, I go – just based on principal alone.
LM
I have watched this show for the last time since the cast changes (getting rid of AJ and Brewster). I know where they are going and what they are doing ($$) but it doesn’t work. I am done watching what was in my opinion one of the best shows on TV–one which I made a real effort to see. Well written and thought provoking. Dissappointing….and a stupid move by management. Be careful to take care of the goose that laid the golden egg….greed can undo success in the blink of an eye.
This is such a shocker. AJ was one that held the show together. How they could chop her is beyond me. At that moment I wasn’t sure if I would continue to watch. Then I heard they killed off Emily. Might as well close the show. Viewers are not going to watch a sinking ship. It WAS such a good show. Sorry to see it go.
Its to bad this cast of 7 friends don’t stick together like a previous cast of 6 friends. They were a packaged deal of 1, it was
1 actor with 1 pay divided equally by 6. That was phenominal!!!!
Tis is my all time FAV show,aside from third watch of course—–BUT it really SUCKS that both Prentiss and JJ are gone—-thats just WRONG!!
I CAN NOT BELIEVE THAT THE DIRECTORS, ETC. WOULD ALLOW A.J. COOK TO LEAVE THE SHOW, SHE IS THE ORIGINALS AND IF ANYONE SHOULD LEAVE GET NEW DIRECTORS WHO CAN GIVE THE PUBLIC WHAT THEY WANT.
WHY DO YOU ALWAYS TAKE SUPER SHOWS AND TEAR THEM APART?? THAT IS JUST PLAIN STUPID. YOU HAVE A WINNING SHOW, YOU SHOULD NOT MESS WITH IT.
Keep all the females on the show. My family truly loves this show with all the cast as is. Please don’t change with getting rid of Miss Cook. You will lose alot of watchers and our family will be one!!!!
My favorite cut would be Garcia’s character. I close my eyes each time she is shown. Abbie NCIS copycat? WHY depict her as a “sexpot”? Sooooooooo far from it. Gideon calls her baby girl…pleeeeeeeeease!
PLEASE LEAVE IT ALONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The show is great as is. The cast is wonderful, cut budget somewhere else!! This is one of the best shows on TV. Just as NCIS, if you start changing now, it goes out the door. You have stable actors again and we love them. Don’t start messing with them, being off a show or two is fine, don’t replace them with someone else!!!!!!!!!!!!!
They just had to make a stupid spinoff, didn’t they? This will completely ruin the show.
They had been reducing A.J. and Paget – and well, treated them like women, second-class for some time.
Lovely. They will be losing a long-time viewer, not that they care. I’m a woman, too, so they’ll care even less.
TV was just starting to get a little better, but between what was done to In Plain Sight and what is written and done every day on most every show, I would say we and society are sliding backwards.
Alexandra,” Society is sliding backwards” because of a tv show? really??
Television is a reflection of society. I am not that shallow.
Then why did you make that foolish statement in the first place?
Nitpicking, much?
Are you really that obtuse? TV shows do not exist in a vacuum. They shape and reflect our views and perceptions about society at large. Yes, Criminal Minds is *just* a tv show, but the fact that two women are being pushed out while the men stay cozy says something unfortunate about how women are treated today.
Actually, this season there was way more Paget/Prentiss than usual, and a big reduction in screen time for virtually every other character. Fans over at CBS.com (except for some of Paget’s fans) had taken to calling the show The Emily Prentiss Show. I don’t know what the real reasoning behind this is, but I don’t think it says anything about how women are treated today.
You mean like every other fan who doesn’t live and die over Matthew G. Gubler’s hair cut has been calling it The Reid Show for the last three seasons?
Reid’s character has been NECESSARILY sidelined this season due to RL injury, which may have led other characters getting more of an opportunity up front, but I really don’t see any other evidence for your point. Especially considering that a great deal of the season was basically structured around Hotch’s story arc, plus Morgan’s elevation to team leader, and Rossi more than held his own. JJ got her first character centric ep ever this season (sort of), and even Garcia got a nod for the first time in a year or two.
When you say “other characters” all I can hear is “Spencer Reid”, which may not be fair to you specifically, but can certainly be applied to many of the fans over at cbs.com.
P.S. I actually really like Reid. This may not be apparent.
Please help me understand! IF IT WORKS WHY ARE YOU CHANGING IT.
This is a good show and the character are pleasing, get AJ back and leave the rest alone.
I have been watching since First episode and may now have to go to Law and Order SUV that is on at same time.
Sincerly PJ
No! I can’t imagine not having Prentiss and JJ! If they wanted to trim costs there have got to be other ways to do it.
well, the show still has its endless supply of dead women victimized by killers with criminal minds…wait, come to think of it, so do all other CBS procedural as well.
Well of course all crime procedurals will have mostly women as victims-statistically women and children are most likely to be victims of those crimes. That doesn’t change the fact that they are cutting the roles of two regular cast members who are female.
This is awful news. I’m afraid if the show goes down to Garcia and the boys I won’t be watching anymore. I’ve loved Criminal Minds from the first episode, but without a well-rounded cast I’m done with it. No JJ, and reduced Prentiss ~ NO THANKS!
As much as I love this show, I won’t watch Criminal Minds if they’re really going to pull this crap on us fans. The reason why I started watching was because I recognized A.J. Cook from another show, and like many others I watch because of the ensemble cast – not because of “the guys.” This is crap. You just can’t toss half the cast without any forewarning or reason.
If CBS wasn’t losing so much money because they’re having less and less viewers because we all are so tired of all the news propoganda, They wouldn’t need to make cuts. AJ Cook is a rising star and worth every penny. I’ll be watching whatever show she’s on.
This is NOT cool! Like Acey said, I hope they’ll all take a cut so they can all stay. This too is hitting me hard. The show/cast won’t be the same without Paget and AJ.
I wonder if there’s anything us fans can do to stop this from happening?
Online petition here: http://www.petitiononline.com/cmwomen/petition.html
FB here: http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=125166150852209
Complain to CBS here: http://www.cbs.com/info/user_services/fb_global_form.php
yes, there is something we can do, band together and stop watching. I have been a fan since day one and I love all of the cast. I liked Gideon, but got use to Rossi quick. And I never did care for Elle, she was pscho to me. Love Emily, JJ and Garcia and the guys. I watch this show religiously, but will stop if they cut the girls.
Unacceptable, this show needs its women
I want more Prentiss not less, and you can’t just cut JJ, thats just stupid.
This better be a mistake or they just lost a viewer.
While I like the characters of Emily Prentiss, and J.J., it is the men whom I tune into watch. I will be sorry to see the girls go, but I think it can be an effective program with just the male cast members. I will still be watching so long the quality of writing remains.
aww this sucks. i hate how blatantly sexist they’re being.. hopefully this wont happen.
This news seriously broke my heart. They should just can the weak spinoff before it starts, and keep A.J. and Paget. But I guess I shouldn’t be surprised, it’s network television and I’m sure the suits could care less…
want a spin off? give us two hours of the original and split the cast between them so we get to keep everyone! The spin off was boring! TPTB haven’t even scratched the surface of these two female characters! And I’m sorry but exactly what do Rossi and big name guest stars add to the show? I love Gibson but he was overused last year and it was like watching paint dry. I’m not a huge fan of Reid but like Garcia he’s quirky. And if this cast had any integrity they would take pay cuts to keep the gang in tact( that includes Bernardo)
Why am I surprised? They are just doing what all the other networks are doing. Love this show; it’s smart and intelligent. Have really gotten into it since stumbling onto all the back to back re-runs on A&E. CBS just had to go and ruin another of my fave shows. I agree that the cast won’t be the same without the women to balance out the men, AND that TV as a whole seems to be going backwards when it comes to roles for women. BOO HISS CBS.
If they lost Montegna it would make little difference to the story lines. His character has never jelled and is as close to dead weight salary-wise as the series has. Lose him and the rest could easily stay I’ll bet.
Sadly, as much as I love Joe Montegna, I have to agree.
Same here. Rather see a hot blonde than his old goatee.
I don’t want anyone to leave, but don’t touch my Joe Mantegna.
That’s ridiculous. Joe Mantegna’s character has become a true pillar in the team. Rossi was the only one who stood by Prentiss in “Demonology” and he was the one who got Hotch through “Omnivore”. How can people not see how important he is to the team? He’s done more to make it a TEAM than Jason Gideon ever did.
Agreed.
Sadly, I agree. I love Montegna, and I’m fine with the character he plays, but he’s never stood out to me, his backstory was never as interesting as the others and I see his scenes as filler between scenes about Garcia, Reid or JJ.
It’s the TV archetype of the five man band:
Hotch is the leader, Reid the smart man, Morgan the muscle, Garcia the darkhorse, and JJ the feminine one (the “chick”). The leftover role is that of the “lancer” or the contrast to the hero of the show; Prentiss and Rossi fill pretty much the same role of the sarcastic more anger-prone member next to Hotch’s hero role.
Either one of them COULD be cut without effecting the dynamic, and the choice in this case was between the more well-known actor and the woman whose been a member of the cast longer, so of course they cut the womans role.
That said, the character who CANNOT be cut is JJ. She is INTEGRAL to the show and removing her throws the ENTIRE dynamic off. Every show needs its more sympathetic/empathetic and feminine character (not always played by a woman, to be clear) and getting rid of JJ (whose working-mother storyline still has aspects to be explored) messes up the five-man band archetype. The only thing they can do is alter someones (more than likely Garcia’s) personality so they better fit the “chick” archetype or have the “new female cast member” have the same personality traits as JJ does…which makes the firing of her completely pointless.
In this part of the thing: …the cast on Criminal Minds has been pretty stable, with Gibson, Moore and Vangness all onboard since the pilot.—Why didnt they mention Matthew? Anyway… I dont want to see anyone leave the show… If anything i think they need a new character… But why would people leave? I need questions answered!
Another thing… I think they have kind of lost some of the real power in the show… I mean in some of the more resent episodes they just havent been as… Strong. I just hope they pick back up and dont hope to see all the characters… Especially glad to her Matthew is still in it… He is my hero!
“This past season, Criminal Minds spawned a spinoff, which has been picked up to series for midseason by CBS. That series, starring Forest Whitaker, is adding a new female regular cast member”…..
Spin A.J. Cook to “Criminal Minds:Los Angeles”. She’s great!!
That would be a great idea. That episode of the FW spinoff last season was very bad. That show needs all the help it can get.
That stinks. I’ve been a fan of CM since day 1 and IMO it needs to have more than just Garcia to balance the cast chemistry. I’ve actually liked Paget and AJ on the show. I’ll stil watch it next season, but I hope Paget says no to the reduced episode offer.
Actually, this situation sounds similar to Adam Rodriguez’s deal with CSI Miami.
As shows go on, costs rise… that is a fact. The spin-off is not to blamed for this situation at all.
Yeah but none of the current Criminal Minds fans want to see the spinoff regardless!
Wow, you claim to speak for every fan of the show? Yeah, like you really know how all fans feel.
No one’s had anything positive to say about the backdoor pilot they aired in the spring – not a good sign.
Maybe if they stopped creating crap shows like the spin off they’d have more money to keep this show in its tip top form. The men? Yeah, they’re nice. But I won’t watch just for them. I’ll just go find a show to watch on a channel that isn’t being sexist.
You gotta be kidding me CBS! Cutting the cast of the show that made CM a success!? If you need money to pay the CM cast, just cancel the moronic spin off! With all the money saved on Forrest Whitaker you will be able to pay the CM cast!
I will so not watch that spin off! CBS you just didn’t kill one show but two! Way to go!
I’m sorry this is an absolute joke!! It just goes to shows how everything in this country, including our tv shows are male oriented!! No offense guys, really. But far too many shows have male leads with the women just “hanging on for the ride” so to speak.
I am a huge fan of AJ Cook, who spent most of the series being underused and ignored, so now to see them simply dump her and Paget b/c it is an all boys club…with the exception of Garcia? WTF? Here is an idea, DON’T DO THE SPIN OFF AND YOU WILL HAVE MORE MONEY!! I knew this was gonna happen when the network picked up what has got to be the worst spin off in history…and that is saying something since this is the same network that gave us CSI Miami!!!
I can tell you this…I won’t be watching next season! What I loved about this show was that the women could hang with the guys…well, not anymore apparently.
Another good show gone down the drain…sad, very, very sad. I’d say let’s write CBS and tell them we want Paget and AJ to stay and what we think but I think they stopped actually caring about their viewers a few years ago!
What if it was Page and Aj’s decision to leave? I will miss them amd I also don’t want them to go….
If this cast/cost-cutting move keeps the show on the air for a few more seasons, I’m all for it. Atleast the show still have VERY strong raitings.
No JJ. You just lost a viewer. Her and Paget are the reason I watch the show. No offense to the guys, but I watch this show because of Andrea Cook and Paget Brewster. Especially Andrea. Otherwise I will not watch your advertisers or the show. This is so sad…
Are you sure you aren’t the same guys that are trying to stop the leaking oil in the gulf of mexico? you make about as much sense…..
I agree, the pilot of the spin-off was completely underwhelming and I have no interest in seeing more. Just keep the CM as it is and dump the spin-off.