
U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York (SDNY) announced the launch Wednesday of “Operation In Our Sites,” a new initiative aimed at Internet counterfeiting and piracy. In the first action carried out as part of the initiative, authorities seized nine domain names of Web sites that were offering first-run movies, often within hours of their theatrical release. Seven of those sites were targeted for seizure by the SDNY. Agents from ICE’s Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) also seized assets from 15 bank, Paypal, investment and advertising accounts, and executed four residential search warrants in several states.
ICE Assistant Secretary John Morton, joined on a Los Angeles soundstage by senior representatives from major movie studios, entertainment unions and the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA), made clear that the theft of such intellectual property is a serious crime and one the U.S. government has made a priority combating. Copyrighted material is known as intellectual property (IP) under the law.
“ICE and our partners at the National Intellectual Property Rights Coordination Center are targeting pirate Web sites run by people who have no respect for creativity and innovation,” said ICE Assistant Secretary Morton, who was in Southern California to meet with the leaders of the movie industry. “We are dedicated to protecting the jobs, the income and the tax revenue that disappear when organized criminals traffic in stolen movies for their own profit.”
“Criminal copyright infringement occurs on a massive scale over the Internet, resulting in billions of dollars in losses to the U.S. economy,” said Preet Bharara, the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York, whose office handled the seizures of seven domain names Wednesday. “That translates into lost jobs and real hardships for ordinary working people. That’s why we took the actions we did. If your business model is movie piracy, your story will not have a happy ending.”
“Content theft online has become increasingly ubiquitous as technology and software improve and access to the Internet increases,” said Mike Robinson, chief of operations, content protection for the MPAA. “We are committed to working with law enforcement to get the illegal choices out of the marketplace and instead focus on continuing to offer more innovative and flexible legal options to consumers to enjoy the movies and TV shows that we all love. The American motion picture and television industry is one of our nation’s most valuable cultural and economic resources. We are grateful to ICE, the Obama Administration, and the federal agencies that have made the protection of intellectual property a priority for the United States.”
“We are facing a dramatic rise in the number of foreign and domestic Web sites that are in the business of making films and television shows – created by our members – available for illegal download or streaming,” said Kathy Garmezy, associate executive director of government and international affairs for the Directors Guild of America. “If left unchecked, this illegal activity threatens the very ability of filmmakers to both earn a living and create the content that is enjoyed by billions around the world.”
“We commend the action of ICE and the IPR Center in striking a significant blow against those who seek to profit from the copyrighted, intellectual property of others,” said Matthew D. Loeb, president of the International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees (IATSE). “Intellectual property is the basis of our modern economy. The stealing of digital content is not a victimless crime; it’s also the theft of tens of thousands of American jobs.”
The National Intellectual Property Rights Coordination Center (IPR Center), based in Virginia and managed by ICE, is directing the government’s response to a crime that is estimated to cost American industry billions of dollars and hundreds of thousands of jobs every year. Its “Operation In Our Sites” is targeting not only films and music, but other items distributed over the Internet, such as counterfeit pharmaceuticals, software, electronics, games and other products that threaten public health and safety.
The investigation involving the SDNY together with the ICE New York Special Agent in Charge and the IPR Center, resulted in the seizure of seven domain names: TVSHACK.NET, MOVIES-LINKS.TV, FILESPUMP.COM, NOW-MOVIES.COM, PLANETMOVIEZ.COM, THEPIRATECITY.ORG, and ZML.COM. In an undercover capacity, investigators downloaded various newly released movies from the Web sites and their affiliates, to identify those Web sites that were involved in the distribution of stolen content.
Also on Wednesday, as a result of a months-long operation, the IPR Center seized the domain names and Web site content of NinjaVideo.net and NinjaThis.net, both of which generated revenue from donations and advertising. These sites allowed visitors to stream or download popular television shows and movies. Over the course of the investigation, agents observed links to more than 200 movies and more than 300 television programs on the NinjaVideo site. This investigation resulted in the execution of federal search warrants for their content and domain name at servers in the United States and the Netherlands. HSI agents also executed four residential search warrants in North Carolina, New Jersey, New York and Washington. The case is ongoing.
The IPR Center has united the U.S. government agencies that combat intellectual property theft. In addition to ICE, the partners include: U.S. Customs and Border Protection; the FBI; the Department of Commerce; the Food and Drug Administration; the Postal Inspection Service; the General Services Administration, Office of the Inspector General; the Naval Criminal Investigative Service; the Defense Criminal Investigative Service; the Army Criminal Investigative Division’s Major Procurement Fraud Unit; and the Government of Mexico Tax Administrative Service.


I thought the whole Wolverine leak debacle proved that piracy DOES NOT affect box office. Does homeland security and the relatable offices really have nothing more important to do? This is a witchhunt that will get no resluys in the long term. Once these sites go down, ten more will spring up. Hollywood, get the f*** over yourself…
Joking? You say the search will not lead to results, which might be true.
But saying that piracy doesn’t affect the box office? Clearly spurious. Who would go to the box office to watch a movie they’ve already seen? A very few, yes, due to the “theater experience”. But for the most part, logic clearly goes against you. Also your “evidence” doesn’t prove anything either way: how do you know what Wolverine would have made had it not been pirated?
to Dan: I seen Avatar first as an avi… Sorry I did. seen it twice in Imax since. It’s been 17 years since the last time I saw a movie twice in the theater. I used to see about 15-20 movies in the theater per year but since the Cheap theaters here in Toronto have gone I am down to 8-10. $240 per year is my limit.
crymeariver, I suggest that *you* go fuck yourself.
As long as people continue to steal these movies with no legal consequences, there will continue to be a culture of entitlement from younger generations when it comes to this issue. If they don’t like what Hollywood is selling, they don’t have to buy it, but that doesn’t give them the right to steal it either. If more illegal sites pop up, more should also be prosecuted. Maybe if there were actual consequences for this kind of stealing, people would think twice before doing it.
Let’s see you go work on a product, sometimes for years, and then go hand it away for free. This affects the U.S. economy, as well as Americans who depend on the industry for work, so yeah, it’s an issue the government needs to help combat.
I agree. Nobody buy anything Hollywood. They obviously don’t need money to make films now judging by how broke they claim they are. Only difference between not buying and downloading is the latter means someone actually wants to watch the show.
And if any of you entertainment industry ass lickers want to make inroads with downloaders, you gotta give up on the whole “Stealing” bullshit. Re-writing the definition to accommodate copyright laws would make millions of children unhappy on Birthdays and Christmas. Downloaders accept gifts from copyright infringers (who do break copyright laws) and you can’t steal something that doesn’t exist yet(potential profits). This whole heavy handed petty criminal brainwashing is making people apathetic to the real legal issues. Use “copyright infringment” or make up a new “you are evil if you do this” term, but the “stealing” bit doesn’t fit.
If I make my 1 legal copy of a cd (I live in Canada) and give the hard copy away. Stealing? I am sure I broke some law but everything I did was legal at the time… it’s what I didn’t do that’s got me in hot water. Did I steal because I didn’t destroy my copy or because I gave away the original? Go wiki “to steal” and find out which of those world shaking actions fits the definition.
A witchhunt, really? These people are criminals not an innocent person being accused of being a witch. And every time a murderer is arrested, more will undoubtedly pop up. Does this mean we should just stop trying and let people run amuck? No. They can and should punish these people.
And when the business is no longer profitable and no one can afford to make a film, you can go watch shitty YouTube videos or perhaps engage in your worse nightmare: read a book.
The point of all of this is to get a law in place that will allow a Cable TV like control over the internet. there will soon be virtual borders and domain Packages… Bell Canada has already publicly admitted to having the tech to make this happen…
The launching of initiatives will not stop until the net is subdued. even though their actions will have few results.
Did you fail to notice the ever declining number of movies getting made? Of course you did. You were too busy committing theft.
Shut down seven, seventy more will spring up. This is utterly futile.
…no its not, if you think about it for a second instead of repeating cliches. Sure 70 will pop, but for those 70 to survive they will have to be harder to find by agents, and if they are hard to find for professional computer savy agents, they will be harder to find for the common computer semi-competent folk, which means less people are going to find them, less will pirate. And once those 70 are found, the spiral of difficulty starts again, and even less will be able to pirate.
God bless ICE and SDNY. It’s time to handcuff these thieves and throw them in prison.
They need to start with YOUTUBE. There are so many links offering free views of first run movies.
I wonder how many of these sites were opperated “off-shore”. It’s good to see them shut down these sites that use stolen content to make advertising revenue.
I Also wonder when we’ll start hearing about their work in stoping counterfeit pharmaceuticals on line.
My question is – Why the hell aren’t they criminally charging the companies that advertise on illegal websites as well? These thieving scum are all as bad as each other.
Yea, I’d have to agree with Cryme. In fact, the more you make people pay, the less susceptible they will be to spin-offs, sequels and anything that requires any kind of backstory. Without a cheap/FREE way to catch up to something I didn’t see the first time around, I’m not paying to see the new one, and I suspect I’m not the only who feels that way.
Well, we all bow down to your feel-good reasoning. Clearly pirating benefits us all. Let’s encourage it.
At least the pirates don’t bother trying to make pathetic moral arguments for their side. Enjoy your next pirated movie; I hope you get a massive virus.
If you don’t want to pay for it, who cares whether you see it or not. Don’t try to spin it like you’re helping the industry by stealing the product. I just love the lame argument that hollywood makes bad product, so the public basically has the right to steal it. When would that ever fly in any other industry? It’d be like me saying the clothing at JC Penny is ugly, so I should be able to go and shoplift it, and then I’ll be more likely to buy some earrings or shoes to go with it when I’m there, so really, JC Penny should be thanking me for stealing from them.
We “steal” it because it’s convenient — let’s face it, why pay or try and find a movie when we can watch it on the spot. Of course if the movie blows us off our socks I know that many would buy it. AND please don’t use the argument “If piracy didn’t exist we would buy more.” that is bullshit.
We see links in these websites because we are bored or are curious about a movie, not because we want to buy it and cuddle it to pieces, even if the link is HD it’s still completely different from seeing on your tv monitor or in the cinema.
Without these websites we just wouldn’t go to the trouble of watching certain movies and would be a whole more incult. I for once wouldn’t see a quarter of the movies I saw in my entire life, I would definitely ignore most things from the 80′s and earlier that have lack of publicity and rarely pass on TV.
Besides most of these websites are streaming ones, I doubt anyone catches a virus unless they are stupid enough to click on the adds. And taking this down just means we lazy buggers will have to go to the trouble of actually downloading the movies, hello Emule.
Yeah, I know my points aren’t the most noble and honourable ones. But they’re true : free movies bring us the possibly of expanding our culture and it’s convenient.
All these sites will get back on track, some already are.
^Stupid facts but facts nonseless.
so true cry. this is where hollywood can just die on the vine and their false, over inflated sham of a accounting revenue predicative model they have tried to shove down our throats all these years. And then what? prohibit the masses from owning cameras for creating their own movies which are better than they can even conceive with their overpaid salaries utilizing reality shows as their foundation now. Copyright laws are unamerican the way they stand, thank you Sonny Bono and Disney for that charade.
Take economics 101: if we didn’t have copyright laws covering this sort of thing, then the content wouldn’t have been produced in the first place, because there would’ve been no profit motive.
No patent/copyright law = no innovation. Easy as pie
Wait, according to Hollywood “elites” capitalism is evil and represents naked greed except, of course, when they do it. Hail, hail, the revolution, free movies for the masses!
Dan that’s total bullshit. many of the most creative and artistic works have been created not for money but because the creator is truly passionate about their work. Money on the other hand is why Hollywood continually churns out remakes of movies made 10, 15, 20 years ago instead of coming up with new and “innovative” ideas. Money is why Hollywood movies all follow the same protocol designed to make the most money, and as result the movies are shallow and bland. Hollywood is afraid to be creative because that would be risky. You really think our current laws are protecting innovation, in fact the opposite is true: our current laws protect and encourage the mundane.
And…. where is the money for those creative and artistic works going to come from? You’ve proved that the scripts will still get written…. fine. And some small indie projects will still get funded by eccentric filmmakers. But for the most part, the film industry as we know it wouldn’t exist. Sure, we get some remakes out of that deal. shoot. but we also get hundreds of thousands of jobs, and billions of dollars in profits, plus billions more per year in value added to the US economy. Done.
unbelievable sss. Copyright laws are unamerican the way they stand?
Article 1, Section 8 of the Constitution states: “Congress shall have the power to… promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries” (US Const., art I. sec. 8, cl. 8.).
Thanks to this section, your intellectual property is protected by the Constitution.
If this is too complicated to understand, maybe someone will explain it to you.
Congress shall have the power to… promote the progress of science and “useful” arts, by securing for “limited times” to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries
Keyword Phrase: “Useful Arts”, most of the stuff coming from Hollywood is useless.
Another Phrase: “Limited Times”, these copywrite laws are approaching the unlimited time frame.
Finally! Let’s sue the pirates, confiscate their bank accounts, and have them steal our movies and our jobs. We can’t make movies and employ people if pirates can watch movies for free. Hopefully Viacom will win in appeal against Google for the same stuff. Youtube was built on pirating content that someone paid to create.
This is like King Canute’s men at the seashore. Its futile. The music industry tried this all the time, what did it get them?
NOTHING.
The only way to stop piracy is to make buying/viewing video online so cheap and easy that piracy is just plain inconvenient. That’s the Itunes solution. Does it mean drastically lower margins? Does it mean no pricey Blu-Ray sales, and so on? Sure.
But look at the Hulu model. There are TONS of old TV shows some folks loved. LA Dragnet being one. You’ve got Ed O’Neil playing a cop, and well. It’s already made. Why not make some more bucks out of it, instead of having it sit around earning … nothing. NBC’s “the Others” with Gabriel Macht, Bill Cobbs, and John Billingsley is not even on Hulu. It’s not earning any money.
No, Hollywood won’t earn back the margin lost by putting pirates out of business by making streaming video (free, ad-supported) or download (lower res, cheap) on the Itunes model. But it will stem some of the losses, its better than simply going after more and more off-shore, China/Russia based mobster type folks who laugh at the FBI/ICE/etc.
I ought to be able to look up something obscure on IMDB.com. Find a “watch it now free” link with ads, and a “buy now link” with a download for say, $1. You would not want to do that with say, Iron Man, but why not for old TV shows and movies older than ten years?
Hey save time and money and go to the Beverly Hills Library where you can check out SIXTY movies at any one time. What do you think is happening to those DVD’s – check out is only for two weeks.
I bet there sure is a lot of nervous swap meeters who purchased or pirated themselves new movies.
Well kids, I guess we won’t be watching Toy Story 3 tonight!
good job but theyve really gotta find a way to shut these sites down faster. like if a cop sees someone stealing from a store, or maybe the more accurate description is a bootlegger stall, he arrests them and throws their butt in jail. expedite the process and you will break up illegal movie sites.
The real scumbags in these transactions are the credit card companies and payment processors like PayPal. They pretend like they don’t know what’s going on (they do) while they make millions processing illegal transactions. Just like the banks can’t be knowing and willing facilitators of laundering drug money, credit card companies have no business enabling the wholesale looting of motion pictures and television shows.
That’s a really good point. This should be combined effort, penalizing everybody who breaks the law.
1. Shut down the sites, and throw their asses in jail.
2. Fine every single IP address that downloaded from that site. And I’m not talking 50 bucks. More like US$1000.00
3. Studios should sue the living crap out of companies that advertise on illegal sites.
4. Transaction providers should be heavily fined by the government.
How about when actual academy members see the first run movies first and sell them or “loan them out to ever Tom, Dick and Harry?? Hollywood needs to monitor its own use or piracy. Depending on how big/important you are in Hollywood you get movies sent to your place and then hold movie night without paying( contributing to the box office of their own movies).
Hollywood/New York needs to police itself better. When a Hollywood insider gets so many freebies and free passes to not paying to see the movies they want us to pay to see piracy seems only fair!
The piracy began in their own backyard and now once the horse is out they want to reign the waste and misuse in. Hollywood in bed with government to police the movie biz, Good f’inng luck- waste not want not!!
Amen. Hypocrisy in its truest form. I worked for a producer who ran a virtual DVD printing press out of the office. Even renting from Netflix for the sole purpose of duplicating and distributing to friends.
I love how people always complain about this. They were stealing. It’s a crime. Just because other people will do it when they are gone doesn’t mean they should be able to get away with it.
“Shut down seven, seventy more will spring up. This is utterly futile.”
It’s no more futile than believing some magical “New Business Model” is right around the corner.
The only companies that can successfully monetize copyright infringement are Silicon Valley aggregators and illegal piracy sites. The actual content creators who do all the work, put up all the money, and take on all the risk, will be increasingly SOL in this new, wonderful world of digital freeloading.
They said they seized movies-links.tv, but hey, I’m watching stuff on there right now.
Who’s the liar now, huh?
So they’re just taking the domain names, not the site and servers. If you do a whois search you can get the IP address of the named sites, and they are still up, and they already have a domain name. Basically it’s the same name, but more obscure .us, .cc, ending as opposed to *.com or *.net.
Those type of sites need to go if Hulu or similar legitimate streaming sites want to make a profit in subscriptions.
I just tried to go to the site…was there about 30 min ago…now there are two emblems (Federal something and warnibgs about jailtime etc… I will try what you suggest ,
Thanks
The emblems are DOJ and ICE and NIPR…looks official to me !
Thanks
I’m not saying the public has a right to steal copyrighted product, but there is no way that piracy costs hollywood billions of dollars and thousands of jobs. Just because that much in theoretical money has been pirated and viewed, doesn’t mean the public is going to view it if they have to pay for it. Its no where even close to that.
Under the law its illegal, but the feds know the numbers they are quoting aren’t even remotely accurate. The movie and television industry is just afraid of piracy and they should be.
I for one, have no intention of ever paying for even 10% of the I.P. that i may or may not watch if i can do so for free. No way in hell i’ll pay 11 even 5% of the movies that are released every year.
And listening to millionaires in the industry bitch about how piracy causes job loss of every day people in Hollywood? Thats cause you already pay the little guys nearly nothing while you pay your actors and studio execs and producers insane amounts of money. If you were so concerned with the jobs of your employees, why don’t you give up a tiny bit of that insane paycheck? Piracy or not the people enforcing these laws only care about themselves, and none of the little guys it may or may not affect care.
This is such a joke. I’m not saying it should or should not be illegal, but pirated content has barely any affect on sales. Billions of dollars? try a in the tens of millions. Just cause people watch it for free doesn’t mean they are going to pay for it. Most of what hollywood puts out is pure garbage. People will watch it for free, but they ain’t going to pay 11 dollars to see most of the trash thats in theaters.
Bunch of people who are clearly high level industry people just commented, probably because they knew it was coming and were waiting for it to hit the news. You all have a right to fight piracy as thats the law, but don’t pretend like you give a crap about the little guy losing his job because of “piracy”. They lose their job because your hollywood starlet needs a new car, and you need to buy your wife a new sailboat.
What I do not get, weren’t earnings up at an record high just recently?
Didn’t the studios learn anything about from what happened with the music biz? Look how much the RIAA’s strategies have helped the industry. It hasn’t and it’s been a disaster. The genie is out of the bottle folks and it was only a matter of time before the movie biz going to be hit. With cloud computing it’s just going to get worse. Get over it and be smart about the technology because it ain’t going away and it isn’t going to get better.
“prohibit the masses from owning cameras for creating their own movies which are better than they can even conceive with their overpaid salaries…”
What a joke! Enjoy your youtube cat videos. Hollywood mediocrity is infinitely better than the mediocrity produced by the youtube masses.
What these pirates (mostly young adults) fail to realize is that they are mortgaging their future. The reason there is no good music is because you can’t make money doing it anymore. The same will happen to film, if you can’t make a profit, how can you raise money, therefore there will be no more new movies. Indie film will most assuredly go away. And who loses out. In the end, the very people who are pirating movies now will have nothing left to steal very soon, and then they’ll have to learn to read books instead.
Oh wait, aren’t they pirating those now too? Sucks to be creative right now.
When I was young we had to go bootleg for certain movies because someone thought that black people would not like those movies. It has gotten better but for a long time movie theaters were not accessible in our area(a main city) and the ones that were around did not keep the movies for a decent period and had a suckey selection. Imax/3d outside of the science center is still 12 miles away. I think that it cuts into profit somewhat but if I have a large family or I am strapped for cash I am not going to waste gas plus the price of a movie ticket, all thou the price is not bad 5.00 it may become a burden for some. Also, before the internet there were only a handful of screener tapes, the rest were video in theatre, I actually went to the theatre to see one because the bootleg teased me but it was grainy, I was at a university in the community room and I saw a homeless man watching prince of persia, no sound, just killing time, I asked for the name and he had next to no computer knowledge and found the site yet this was my first exposure.