U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York (SDNY) announced the launch Wednesday of “Operation In Our Sites,” a new initiative aimed at Internet counterfeiting and piracy. In the first action carried out as part of the initiative, authorities seized nine domain names of Web sites that were offering first-run movies, often within hours of their theatrical release. Seven of those sites were targeted for seizure by the SDNY. Agents from ICE’s Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) also seized assets from 15 bank, Paypal, investment and advertising accounts, and executed four residential search warrants in several states.
ICE Assistant Secretary John Morton, joined on a Los Angeles soundstage by senior representatives from major movie studios, entertainment unions and the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA), made clear that the theft of such intellectual property is a serious crime and one the U.S. government has made a priority combating. Copyrighted material is known as intellectual property (IP) under the law.
“ICE and our partners at the National Intellectual Property Rights Coordination Center are targeting pirate Web sites run by people who have no respect for creativity and innovation,” said ICE Assistant Secretary Morton, who was in Southern California to meet with the leaders of the movie industry. “We are dedicated to protecting the jobs, the income and the tax revenue that disappear when organized criminals traffic in stolen movies for their own profit.”
“Criminal copyright infringement occurs on a massive scale over the Internet, resulting in billions of dollars in losses to the U.S. economy,” said Preet Bharara, the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York, whose office handled the seizures of seven domain names Wednesday. “That translates into lost jobs and real hardships for ordinary working people. That’s why we took the actions we did. If your business model is movie piracy, your story will not have a happy ending.”
“Content theft online has become increasingly ubiquitous as technology and software improve and access to the Internet increases,” said Mike Robinson, chief of operations, content protection for the MPAA. “We are committed to working with law enforcement to get the illegal choices out of the marketplace and instead focus on continuing to offer more innovative and flexible legal options to consumers to enjoy the movies and TV shows that we all love. The American motion picture and television industry is one of our nation’s most valuable cultural and economic resources. We are grateful to ICE, the Obama Administration, and the federal agencies that have made the protection of intellectual property a priority for the United States.”
“We are facing a dramatic rise in the number of foreign and domestic Web sites that are in the business of making films and television shows – created by our members – available for illegal download or streaming,” said Kathy Garmezy, associate executive director of government and international affairs for the Directors Guild of America. “If left unchecked, this illegal activity threatens the very ability of filmmakers to both earn a living and create the content that is enjoyed by billions around the world.”
“We commend the action of ICE and the IPR Center in striking a significant blow against those who seek to profit from the copyrighted, intellectual property of others,” said Matthew D. Loeb, president of the International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees (IATSE). “Intellectual property is the basis of our modern economy. The stealing of digital content is not a victimless crime; it’s also the theft of tens of thousands of American jobs.”
The National Intellectual Property Rights Coordination Center (IPR Center), based in Virginia and managed by ICE, is directing the government’s response to a crime that is estimated to cost American industry billions of dollars and hundreds of thousands of jobs every year. Its “Operation In Our Sites” is targeting not only films and music, but other items distributed over the Internet, such as counterfeit pharmaceuticals, software, electronics, games and other products that threaten public health and safety.
The investigation involving the SDNY together with the ICE New York Special Agent in Charge and the IPR Center, resulted in the seizure of seven domain names: TVSHACK.NET, MOVIES-LINKS.TV, FILESPUMP.COM, NOW-MOVIES.COM, PLANETMOVIEZ.COM, THEPIRATECITY.ORG, and ZML.COM. In an undercover capacity, investigators downloaded various newly released movies from the Web sites and their affiliates, to identify those Web sites that were involved in the distribution of stolen content.
Also on Wednesday, as a result of a months-long operation, the IPR Center seized the domain names and Web site content of NinjaVideo.net and NinjaThis.net, both of which generated revenue from donations and advertising. These sites allowed visitors to stream or download popular television shows and movies. Over the course of the investigation, agents observed links to more than 200 movies and more than 300 television programs on the NinjaVideo site. This investigation resulted in the execution of federal search warrants for their content and domain name at servers in the United States and the Netherlands. HSI agents also executed four residential search warrants in North Carolina, New Jersey, New York and Washington. The case is ongoing.
The IPR Center has united the U.S. government agencies that combat intellectual property theft. In addition to ICE, the partners include: U.S. Customs and Border Protection; the FBI; the Department of Commerce; the Food and Drug Administration; the Postal Inspection Service; the General Services Administration, Office of the Inspector General; the Naval Criminal Investigative Service; the Defense Criminal Investigative Service; the Army Criminal Investigative Division’s Major Procurement Fraud Unit; and the Government of Mexico Tax Administrative Service.






I think it’s pretty clear that this was motivated by HULU — just look at the timing. Very Suspicious Timing. Beyond this, you can bet that this sort of thing will continue because it’s International in scope. You can clean up the US – so Big Fucking Deal! It’s like WACK-A-MOLE, new sites will pop up all over the world. Just like when the MPAA tries to shut down torrent sites (I see that The Pirate Bay is still in full operational mode).
This is the nature of the Beast- the Internet. And if the US cleans it up in Western Countries, then you can readily expect these sites to operate out of the Ukraine, Africa, West Indies, etc. It simply can’t be stopped. Unless you totally Censor the Internet, which ain’t gonna happen.
THE ANSWER TO THIS IS TO GET STEVE JOBS TO DESIGN A SITE TO SELL MOVIES & TV SHOWS, LIKE HE DID WITH APPLE MUSIC.
USING COPS, FBI, & LAWYERS IS COMPLETELY MORONIC, AS WELL AS A WASTE OF TIME. REMEMBER THE MUSIC INDUSTRY, BONEHEADS?
HIRE STEVE JOBS AND YOUR WORRIES ARE OVER! He can design a business model that WORKS – not like the other assholes that populate our business. Watch a fucking waste of time this is…
FYI, it’s copyright infringement not “stealing”. If you steal something, the original is gone. If you copy something, the original is retained. There are two well-established canons of law covering both activities which, unfortunately, the MPAA/RIAA and the current administration are conflating.
The following is coming from someone who does NOT pirate, or download pirated material:
As someone already pointed out, look at what happened with the RIAA. They tried and tried to get a handle on music piracy. They even sued thousands. So, what happened after years of their fight? They gave up.
So, find a new model, Hollywood. I would venture to guess that probably 95% of the end-users viewing your content without paying wouldn’t bother going to the movie theater anyway. MAYBE rent it at Redbox for a buck down the road.
Let’s face it – the majority of product that you in Hollywood put out is crap. What, maybe 5% of the product you put out is watchable. And out of that, 50% is worth paying full price for.
James Cameron and others are on the right track. For now, at least, 3D movies can’t be replicated. Meaning, you can’t get that experience elsewhere. It may be a gimmick, but it’s an idea. Start thinking of ways to get people in the theater seats. Incentivize.
I am not excusing the “pirates” who distribute your work – especially those who actually sell what they pirated. However, learn from the many mistakes the RIAA made. Listen to your customers. Think differently.
And for God’s sake, go back to what you used to be known for…. BE CREATIVE!!!
Well when movie tickets are $10 to $15 I can’t blame people for watching something online. Concessions are marked up by a ridiculous amount and you can’t bring your own food in. 3D movies cost up to $20 now as well. All in all, it could cost a family of 4 around a $100 to go see a 3D movie and get some snacks. That is totally unreasonable. Hollywood is dying. And its their own fault.
I just went to all these sites and yes indeed they have been seized so what happens to the people who watch the movies then?? Or do they just go after those who post the links and the sites I am so confused on movie piracy!!!
Futile. Doesn’t Homeland Security have anything ELSE to do? Like, maybe throwing out all the illegal aliens that are here taking our jobs?
By no means am I implying that I agree with piracy. That being said- I think they need to worry more about people sending spam/viruses via email (you know… third-party crap), pop up sites, people stealing credit card/bank account information and so on. There are much worse things happening on the world wide web than watching some movie made with a video camera that you can hear people coughing and talking in the background or walking in front of the movie. I’m just saying that the movies these people are watching are not the best quality and everyone knows there is nothing like actually going to the movie theater to catch a flick (even though the prices of refreshments exceed the price you pay for the ticket. Speaking of… I don’t see the theater employees going around checking peoples bags to see if they smuggled in some refreshments of their own. Do you put your bag on a machine that scans the contents before you see a movie? No. My point is – They really need to spend more time getting the big dog criminals off the web and stop sweating the smaller stuff.
Oh bother!,
Honestly this is utter crap. I can’t believe they are attempting to do this because of that pesky and crappy teenage movie that just came out — as if /those/ obsessed fans have the inteligence to google and stream a movie.
Anyway, while I am pissed off I do agree that they are doing this. However, great culture bases are also being lost. Some of these sites offer movies (form the 60′s and 80′s) that are hard to find on stores or at reasonable prices and that for obvious reasons don’t pass on TV. Yeah, yeah roll your eyes at me. It’s true . But then I also get that my futile angriness is wrong by my part *sigh* .
In the end I don’t really see what Hollywood is loosing, if we like the movie we will see it in the big screen, we get better quality, better experience and see it first. If we get home and want to see it again, why the hell can’t we?
And, yes this rant makes close to no sense. Concluding, other sites will appear and it takes more to take down movie-links.tv. Though I am still rather bothered. . .
What about youtube ?
I work in Hollywood. I benefit from the products distributed. That’s how I’m able to live. No, I’m not some Hollywood big shot. I’m what’s considered “below the line”, a regular production worker. I saw what happened to the music industry and it was the hard working “below-the-liners” who got the shaft. Not the higher-ups. Remember that the next time you think watching a pirated movie is a good idea. You’re taking away jobs from an entire industry. Pirating is much like the oil in the Gulf, except there’s no legitimate company to blame and pay for it. All those who think this is “futile”, I’d love to see your job go away because someone stole your final product…then we’ll see if you think it’s futile.
Well the last media I bought IN 10 YEARS were all 4 seasons of Farscape (sci-fi), Made in Australia, no offense but you guys in Hollywood produce crap.
And coming from an American protectionist Paleo-Republican, that means allot.
They are not LOSING any money from me.
The TV episodes I want were free to air to begin with.
If I can’t catch up on back episodes for free, then I just wont see it.
It’s as simple as that. I will never pay 39.95 to Oh Dot Hundred Dollars for DVDs that I am only going to view once. It’s just never going happen.
And the Whack-A-Mole game that the government is playing is never going to make the content I want to see unavailable.
They might be able to change WHERE I see it, but not IF I see it.
Until they stop charging me $14 for a movie in theaters, and $35 for a bluray, I’ll continue to watch shows and movies online. Until Hollywood adapts to the modern world, there will always be free online websites made available. BTW, see how effective the Feds are, tvshack simply moved sites to tvshack.cc
Good job Feds.. keep up the horrible work spending our tax dollars.
That sir is a great point.
Also another thing I found funny: So we all pretty mcuh know that distributing an artist work without a copyright is illegal which is why the feds shut sites down and persecute pirates. But one thing I found funny is that I’ve never seen an anime site be seized. Maybe I don’t know the laws regarding animes but you can pretty much watch any anime legally as long as its not licensed. BUT! their are hundreds of anime sits that allow licensed animes to be veiw for free. Maybe there is something I’m missing but I have yet to see or hear an anime sites being sized for unlawful sharing.
Jay, you’re a freeloader. You freeload. Like a mosquito or a leech you are only out for yourself. You wouldn’t pay for anything you could (illegally) get for free because you’re a selfish asshole. And no, your opinion that something is too expensive doesn’t justify your freeloading. These are luxury items we’re talking about here, not food, not water, not shelter. If you want them, you are obligated to pay for them, especially if you want similar content to be produced in the future.
He may be a freeloader, but you’re a Neo-Feudalists.
Instead of Obama’s ICE going after illegals who steal jobs from the poor and middle class, Obama’s ICE goes after illegals who steal jobs from the over payed rich Hollywood brats.
Republicans would have done the same thing, cause they too are Neo-Feudalists. We need a new political party.
Unless every country and every ISP agree to the cut out all copyright/pirate sites then then it will never end. Site hosted in different countries are hard to shut down. ISP’s who agree to ban internet access will to repeat offenders will lose that costumer to an ISP that doesnt report people. And there is virtual no legal risk to users of these sites. Over 30,000 people watched the new twilight film on the day of release. You show me 30,000 lawsuits and I’ll eat a federal agent
First, everyone believes the FBI raided these places. That’s not true. It was the ICE who usually captures illegal immigrants and deports them. What copyright infringement has to do with border patrol is beyond me. Second, they had someone to take care of:
http://www.aolnews.com/crime/article/police-illegal-immigrant-carlos-martinelly-montano-kills-sister-denise-mosier-in-drunken-driving-crash/19580015?icid
But they released them to deal with 9 illegal sites. And of all things, DISNEY started the press release for this. Look up “Operation In Our Sites” on Youtube and it’s the President talking about how this “saved jobs and American ingenuity” and blah-de-blah.
Now let’s get this straight… Carlos Montano is released to get drunk and kill a nun… All because 2 days earlier they were busting people for their servers being illegal… Which is the jurisdiction of the FBI. So obviously, this story doesn’t add up.
They not only took down the sites, but raided the homes of some of the administrators. How many agents did they use that morning? How many months and how many man hours did they spend investigating this? Is this how you want your tax dollars spent? Do you sleep better knowing that 9 less websites are providing links to videos that you can mostly see for free anyway on the major networks? Good job ICE and Homeland Security…you sacrificed one nun in order to crack down on 9 websites.
I guess we really know what to do with our money.
It’s all bullshit cuz If the movie is worth it, it will be bought legally to add to home collections. Think of it as testing it out before you buy. We don’t get refunds for bad movies and the price we pay to see a movie in a theater is out of control, and NewYork is the worst!! To top it off they have nerve to charge extra for 3-d glasses u don’t even get to keep. Not that I need to keep them, but if your recycling them why the fuck do I have to pay more. Bottom line thanks to our government fuckin up our damn economy with their lies and greed we are all broke and cannot afford to risk buying a shitty movie. Also all of these movie creators are overdoing it on the CG which means for the most part someone sat on their ass creating it. Sorry if I don’t see the full creativity in creating something on the same computers people are using to steel your movies. The point is people are getting lazy and so is the movie industry. I don’t mind some CG but not for everything. I don’t even see how you could be loosing so much money If u think about it, no more building movie sets, no more paying for someone to wear a monster costume, etc… Let’s not bring up the fact that the actors think they deserve millions of dollars for one movie or tv show. They are greedy as well and do not work any harder than a teacher who i working all year. The difference is the teachers don’t get paid enough. If actors stop working the world won’t come to an end, we will just find another form of entertainment but if the people who don’t count and don’t get paid enough stop doing their jobs you best believe it will. Listen I don’t defend it 100% but you also have to think about why people are doing it. Stop giving all the fuckin money to the rich for them to waist on nonsense and give it to the people who need it to buy TP to wipe their families ass and then maybe there might be enough left over to buy your movies.
If movie theaters were a lot cheaper, then there would be no reason to pirate movies on the internet. Why do theaters want 10 people for $11 when they could have 200 people for $2