The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals unanimously affirmed summary judgment in Warner Bros’ favor on the We Are Marshall copyright infringement and breach of contract case. This is the case in which Deborah Novak and John Witek made a documentary film about the Marshall University football team and plane crash called Ashes To Glory, and then sued Warner Bros alleging that that We Are Marshall was based on their film. The decision reaffirms that historical facts are not protected by copyright, and that “the only concrete or articulable similarities between Ashes to Glory and We Are Marshall consist of unprotectible scenes a faire, and historical facts, which, like all facts, whether scientific, historical, biographical or news of the day may not be copyrighted and are part of the public domain available to every person.”
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.


What a silly lawsuit.
Ashes to Glory, which was produced for a local PBS, wasn’t much of a film. In fact–the Amazon review says the doc. was made to tie-in with the feature!
http://www.amazon.com/Marshall-University-Artist-Not-Provided/dp/B000IB0DEE
This is a GREAT decision! For a while there, I was upset that the English courts were showing us Americans how to deal with idiots who thought they could copyright history – ala the ‘Holy Blood, Holy Grail’ fools who sued Dan Brown and got righteously smacked down by the English courts. Now it’s time for American courts to show the same common sense. Artists do NOT copyright history simply because they may be the first to write about it or film it. History belongs to the world.
Raises the question: why buy/sell life rights?
Now can we please have a decision about what happens when a studio or producer turns down a writer’s fact-based script and then generates its own script based on the same elements?