EXCLUSIVE UPDATE 6:30 PM: We've just learned the backstory of how Ellen DeGeneres bowed out of American Idol and who will be the new judge taking her place. It's Jennifer Lopez,
whose singing and acting career has been on the skids after her recent movie failed at the box office in the spring and she was dropped by her record company Sony Music Epic Records this past winter. We hear her manager Benny Medina (whom she once fired) orchestrated the meeting with the American Idol producers a month ago, and negotiations have been ongoing ever since. We've learned a deal was closed earlier this week under the utmost secrecy. Today's news came shortly after Nigel Lythgoe returned to Idol as an executive producer. He has vowed to shake up the show's team of judges in the wake of the departure of Simon Cowell, publicly stating that he always thought a panel of three and not 4 made the most sense.
Still to be decided is who will replace Simon Cowell. Everyone associated with the show wants Elton John, but we hear he's asking for too much money and has too many touring commitments he can't get out of. (Denials That Justin Or Elton Judging 'Idol') 2ND UPDATE: Tonight, unconfirmed reports say Idol has offered Cowell's judge seat to Steven Tyler. 3RD UPDATE: And another unconfirmed report claimed judge Kara DioGuardi has been fired to bring the panel count down to just 3, not 4.
As for Ellen Degeneres, we're told she wanted off the show two months ago and complained that Idol producers "couldn’t control Cowell", one insider tells us. Least of all Cecile Frot-Coutaz, the CEO of FremantleMedia North America. "Cecile is doing X Factor with Simon, so she's in his back pocket." DeGeneres and her reps went in to to see Fox Broadcasting's Entertainment Chairman Peter Rice and Alternative TV President Mike Darnell and asked to be let out of the year left on her contract. "She's not comfortable. She's not happy. It's not been fun," Fox was told. But Rice and Darnell responded that, with Cowell leaving,
"We can't let you out now because it would be bad for our franchise. Give us a chance to figure out who we could get." In the end, all the show's producers -- Fox, Fremantle, and 19 Entertainment -- worked it out. "Peter Rice was awesome," an insider tells us. "Ellen is thrilled and relieved." We've learned that serious conversations took place between Idol and Jessica Simpson to replace Ellen. But once Jennifer Lopez was locked in this week, the DeGeneres announcement went out.
The affable daytime talk show host never seemed comfortable at the Idol judging table and was never quite accepted by the show's fans because of her lack of a music background. As Deadline first reported, her first day taping the judges' Hollywood segment was rocky -- and frankly never really improved. Simon Cowell showed up an hour and a half late for the taping. And Ellen stewed while she waited for him. She had reason: to accommodate both her talk show hosting duties and her American Idol judging duties, she had moved up her schedule so that she shot the talk show earlier in the day and then jumped in the car to go to Idol. She was on time, and Cowell was not. "Here it was the first day of taping of the Hollywood shows, and Ellen was there waiting for Simon to show up. Ellen's new to the gig and she's very organized and she made a commitment to take this on, and now she's asking herself, 'What did I get myself into?' She called Simon Cowell a prima donna. So right from the start, the chemistry isn't great," an insider told Deadline at the time. Ellen after the taping requested that Darnell "hurry up and pick" Simon's successor. Later, she publicly vetoed Howard Stern as Cowell's replacement.
As the season progressed, it wasn't uncommon for the other judges to sneer at or ignore whatever DeGeneres said, or for Ellen to look forlorn and left out. During the first weeks of the show, the former standup comedienne delivered her adulation or criticism of the contestants off the cuff. But as time went on, sources told us she began practicing in advance what she would say in order to make her remarks more funny or more music-oriented. It was in the middle of this past Idol season that chatter first surfaced that DeGeneres would only stay on the show as a judge for one season because she was so unhappy.
Her replacement JLo badly needs this high-profile boost to her flagging career. The actress had many hits with Sony Music Epic Records, so it was a shock within the recording industry when her longtime label dumped her. The contract period had ended, and Lopez had fulfilled it with her last two singles. But in February Sony then cancelled her 7th studio album titled "Love?", which was supposed to come out in April and featured production from Danja, Jim Jonsin, Darkchild, Chris n Teeb from Dropzone, and The Neptunes among others. That never-released album delayed the release of her CBS Film, The Back-Up Plan, which bombed badly at the box office, as did her performance at the American Music Awards. Deadline was told at the time Sony Music execs weren't sure who her audience is anymore. Where once she had little girls, she's been supplanted by Beyonce, Gaga, and Rhianna. There were also reports of fighting going on between Medina (who managed Madonna) and the label.
Current CEO Rob Stringer (younger brother to Sony parent company CEO Howard Stringer) had a meeting at the Four Seasons Hotel in Los Angeles with JLo during Grammy week to formalize the separation. Sony may be releasing her "Greatest Hits" album this fall. There've been rumors she's talked with Island Def Jam’s bigwig L.A. Reid to come to his label. But this is a tough time for music artists, especially those like Lopez who were once big in the biz and now are battling not only the changed economics and rampant piracy but also the moving target of today’s music fans.
4:45PM: In a move that is not unexpected, Ellen DeGeneres won't be returning as an American Idol judge next season. DeGeneres originally signed a 2-year deal when she joined the show last summer but will be making an exit after only one.
UPDATE: Here is Fox's official release:
Ellen DeGeneres has decided to bow out from her role as a judge on AMERICAN IDOL next season. DeGeneres served as a judge during the ninth season of IDOL, the No. 1 hit series on television.
“A couple months ago, I let FOX and the AMERICAN IDOL producers know that this didn’t feel like the right fit for me,” said DeGeneres. “I told them I wouldn’t leave them in a bind and that I would hold off on doing anything until they were able to figure out where they wanted to take the panel next. It was a difficult decision to make, but my work schedule became more than I bargained for. I also realized this season that while I love discovering, supporting and nurturing young talent, it was hard for me to judge people and sometimes hurt their feelings. I loved the experience working on IDOL and I am very grateful for the year I had. I am a huge fan of the show and will continue to be.”
“We love Ellen and understand and support her decision to bow out of IDOL,” said Peter Rice, Chairman of Entertainment, Fox Networks Group. “We were fortunate to receive the humor, energy and love for talent that she brought to the show.”
“It was a joy to work with Ellen,” added Mike Darnell, President of Alternative Entertainment, Fox Broadcasting Company. “She brought an incredible spirit to IDOL and was a great new addition to the team. While we’re saddened by her decision, we are very appreciative that she gave us ample notice so that we could work through it together.”
“I loved Ellen’s passion for the artists and her nurturing skills,” said IDOL creator and executive producer Simon Fuller. “She brought honesty and optimism to our judging panel and I will miss her greatly.”
“We will miss Ellen, she has been the consummate professional throughout her time on the show, and she’ll always be part of the AMERICAN IDOL family,” added Cecile Frot-Coutaz, IDOL executive producer.
AMERICAN IDOL is created and executive-produced by Simon Fuller, founder of 19 Entertainment; and executive-produced by Cecile Frot-Coutaz, CEO, FremantleMedia North America, Inc. and Ken Warwick, Executive Producer, FremantleMedia North America, Inc.


Resigned, or was she canned??
Remember that Nigel Lythgoe has returned to “Idol” as exec producer, after a couple of seasons at “So You Think You Can Dance?”.
Who they really need are Arlene Francis, Bennett Cerf and Kitty Carlyle. Why aren’t their agents on the phone and . . what? . .Really? . . .oh , never mind.
This might work; J Lo is a diva like Simon, but a marginal talent like Paula. She’s like their love child. And, she has nothing else to do it seems. This is a good sideways move for her.
J Lopez can be a credible judge. I’m excited to see her in the new season of AI. Why not Donny Osmond, too, as judge in AI to replace Simon?
Don’t let the door hit you in the ass on the way out.
i hope the door does hit her in the ass on the way out. she was clueless and is a media hyped no talent zippo.
if she was straight, we wouldnt know who she was unless we caught her at the “comedy store’ locally doing her 20 minutes of standup.
good ridance i say and it couldnt have happened to a finer ‘fella’
Holy shit…that’s crazy. Ellen was famous before she came out and famous after, why is this “fella” (which, by the way, is unnecessarily offensive and ignorantly conflates sexuality, gender, and sexuality) the target of your tirade? Do you really think that millions of people love her BECAUSE she’s a lesbian? You’re weird…
stop being so sensitive first of all, and second she has horrid stand up and the reason she came out was to boost her popularity.
Stop with the PC Politically Correct Post-modern garbage talk mixed with foul mouth language. Are you part of the hypocritical PC police that rejects free speech for conservatives/traditionalists? Go get a tattoo or something with you paycheck and shut up. It’s true, Ellen is only where’s she’s at because of political correctness, liberation theologies, new age occultism, and postmodernism (same with Obama), ideologies ruining the Western World. When one looks at Ellen, you see sad depressed eyes, with a faky smile and faky mannerisms with a manly androgenous look causing people to target her as a ‘fella.’ If androgeny is desirable for the human race, we would have all committed suicide with the Heaven’s Gate Hale Bopp cult, not laughed at SNL’s comedy skit called ‘It’s Pat,’ and pushed for the end of gender based languages like French and Hebrew.
Got bigotry?
That Ellen dude was awful. She is a no talent hack that never should have been hired in the first place.
your comment is totally offensive to lesbians…plus she had her talk show way before she came out as a lesbian…your just an immature person who is uncomfortable with his or her own sexuality, making them uncomfortable with others…plus, Ellen is hilarious which you obviously are so cold hearted that you dont get humor.
bigot!
Well I would like to see this person do a better job in fact just get a job on tv or something.Ellen is a great gal and she is out front on who she is that I love about her.She is smart funny and her personal life is her own.I sure don’t see you having a spot anywhere on tv or anywhere else as that goe’s.Ellen made the right decision by wanting out of Idol.It is not for her and she is smart enough to know that plus she is with class and doesn’t like to hurt anyone that is heart straight up…
This is good news. While I like Ellen on her show and I think she is funny, she never added anything as a judge on Idol as she knows nothing about the music business. Her comments became repetitive very quickly and I felt she took valued time away from Kara and Simon, the only two judges whom I felt continued to be valuable. I hope Nigel follows thru on his promise to hire all new judges. I don’t like Kara and Randy’s “pitchy” and “just a’ight” schtick have grown way old on me after all these years.
i believe Ellen was pushed out, based on Lythgoes’ prior comment that he would get rid of entire current slate of judges.
Howard Stern will be crowing “I told you so” on his radio show because he has been criticizing her non-musical self since she was named to the spot.
I liked Ellen, but it wasn’t ever about her. American Idol was always about Simon Cowell, and the dynamics between him and the other judges…especially Paula. It wasn’t even about the talent (or usual lack thereof). Without him it is dead. Anyway, we are in the Age of Gaga now. American Idol is history.
Howard Stern is nothing but a jerk period whatever he says never makes sense.He is just a nasty man yuck..
Best news about that show I’ve heard in years——-hoooooray! Can’t wait to see that overrate waste of space EXIT!! Yeeee-haw!
Seeing as how she has absolutely nothing to do with music, it made no sense for her to be on the program to begin with.
Im with you on this one she is a waste of skin and me and my wife quit watching idol because of her. It made no sense to put she-he on as a judge she-he doesnt know the first thing about music. she-hes gone YEEE_HAAAAAAA
Gotta admire your vast understanding of human sexuality and your willingness to flaunt your bigotry in front of the world. Best wishes to the little woman.
glad to see ellen go, stopped watching the show because she joined it. I might start watching it again. Its time for whites to stop beating themselves and to put the country right again. You don’t have to accept abnormal people as normal just because the liberal media tells you that you must. Its all right to be white, be proud of yourself. we built this country and we can fix it too. But the time is coming for elections and now is the time to vote for smart and experienced people to fix the Ills of our country not vote black people into positions of power because we feel guilty about the past. It is also time for the media to quit portraying whites as bumbling idiots while protraying blacks as strong masters of the universe. as long as the media persist down this stupid pointless path America will suffer.
Well, that’s fine. I love Ellen, but she just didn’t seem to fit in with AI.
Whether it was really Ellen’s decision or if it was Nigel’s or Fox’s, good thing someone came to their senses!
She is a classy woman!
Did you write “woman?” No, female yes, woman, no.
Cheetah06, you seem to imply that Ellen in some way does not embody femininity when, in fact, she simply may not (depending on who is judging) embody emphasized femininity. Please enlighten us on what the appropriate way for a woman to act is…she must have long hair? She must wear dresses? Perhaps a better question is, who decides?
Huh? How does that make any sense.
You’re a bigot.
Nice display of utter ignorance.
FIRST –
If the show’s producers want a new judge who will be embraced by fans, all they need to do is facilitate some sort of online forum for fans to submit names, narrow down the list to 5 and then let the fans choose the winner.
Of course the 5 whom would end up as finalists would all have to have agreed to actually be in contention in the first place.
Kind of like the way “American Idol” itself works, isn’t it?
SECOND –
Once FANS of the show choose a judge, it should not matter what the other judges think. It is not thier show. It belongs to those who watch it and therefore attract advertising. This should never be forgotten and it’s not a hard concept to get.
LAST –
Who are the “other judges” “sneering” at something Ellen said? I sure hope it’s not someone like KARA DIOGUARDI, who nearly didn’t make the cut herself. Also, shouldn’t someone like Kara, who most viewers had never even heard of before “American Idol”, actually be on the low end of the totem pole here?
Out of any of the judging panel, she seems to be the least experienced in show business.
Just sayin….
Kara was the best judge on the show ! She has a lot more experience than people know.
When Ellen came on – I stopped watching.
We’ll see who they bring in – Then I’ll decide if I’ll watch or not.
Since the majority of Idol voters are teeny-bopper girls, we might wind up with an awkward panel of judges. And their mothers would have to drive them to the studio every day.
The show has already been ruined by the skewed demographics of the audience. There are not many of us who would waste any part of our lives punching at our cell phones for hours just so we could vote 600 times for a cute boy.
Good. She never added anything to the show. It was a gimmick to hire her. Like Nigel said, you don’t break up a team and they wouldn’t renew Paula’s contract. Next they should get Ryan a (fe) partner to help him host the show. He needs a break.
*Yawn*
just what i was thinking. lol
As much as I have respect for Ellen, I am happy with the move Ellen made in regards to AMI.
I am also glad the Nigel Lythgoe is shaking things up at AMI. This is important as the show needs to renew it’s image that it has been loosing after the departure of Paula and Simon. Nigel Lythgoe did just what I would have done if I was EX-P of AMI.
I loved Ellen on Idol and will miss her! I have watched Idol every season, but now with both Simon and Ellen leaving, I may have to rethink my viewing.
I truly like Ellen DeGeneres but as she said “it wasn’t the right fit.” Personally, I think the show has become one long commercial for its sponsors and the show itself. They need to go back to the roots of the show and focus on SINGING. Idol has grown tiresome with Ryan Seacrest’s blatherings and the drawn out auditions.—I typically tune in after they’ve narrowed the field to a dozen or so. It’s amazing how little time is actually devoted to performance—Idol is supposed to be a singing competition, right? And those musical acts brought on to draw viewers are a worse fit than even Ellen as a judge. Most of them pale in comparison to even the weakest among the finalists. My suggestion: Bring in Elton John and either Paula Abdul or Sharon Osborurne to join Randy Jackson. Their likeable, funny, bitchy and interesting to watch. Plus they have industry track records.
As if I needed another reason not to tune in next season…
Any other lesbians who don’t know a thing about music wanna step in…Lindsay?
OK, homophobe, what does Ellen being a lesbian have to do with anything? I know it’s an attempt to hit a funny soundbite…but it’s meaningless except to point out her sexuality and act like it has anything to do with anything beyond a bad joke.
Greg – I’m not sure you know what the meaning of the word “homophobe” is. It did not sound like Freelols was scared of Ellen’s sexual orientation, rather a comment on how Ellen’s career is largely based on this fact. It’s also fair to say she was chosen for this peculiarity over other potential judges because Hollywood wants to show how “accepting” it is. Let’s face it, this is the reason why Hollywood pushes Ellen so much. If she had never come out, her sitcom would have been canceled long ago, and there never would have been a talkshow, Finding Nemo, or Cover Girl ads. She’d be back doing stand-up. She is a talented and funny lady, for sure. But she’s not as talented as they want you to think the is. Her disastrous season on AI showed this in spades.
No, it’s not fair to say “she was chosen for this peculiarity”. It’s bigoted and ignorant.
And her sitcom WAS canceled long ago. It failed right after she came out. Since her talk show gets enormous ratings you seem a little tone-deaf in postulating that it has something to do with her sexuality. What about you? Do you have any sexual “peculiarities” that might effect your job performance? Or is that just plain none of my business?
Hey Greg, you miss his point entirely. He doesn’t HAVE to point out her sexuality. Ellen does it for you, constantly, over and over, and this show is not the public forum for lesbianism endorsement. If Ellen would keep her trap shut, no one would know or care about her sexuality. Some of us are sick and tired of defining deviancy down. We’re tired of being told to accept the repugnant behavior as normal or else, we, the ones with morals, are the ones with a problem, because we’re intolerant. Well guess what, we aren’t on defense anymore trying not to earn the stigma of being intolerant. We are now saying, “you bet we’re intolerant of sin, and it’s you who are stigmatized by YOUR behavior.”
What does “defining deviancy down” mean?
Thank you, finally someone has said something a lot of us feel.
Thanks for saying what many of us feel.
Homophobia is the fear of homosexuals. No on fears homosexuals and certainly not Ellen.
People just don’t like being forced to view and accept them.
It’s natural and understandable.
Keep your odd sexual preferences to yourself and then you can say they don’t or shouldn’t matter
Homophobia: “irrational fear of, aversion to, or discrimination against homosexuality or homosexuals” Webster’s Dictionary.
Here let me make it clear for you, We didnt vote for Adam because of his flagrant homosexuality and we dont like Ellen either because of it.
LOL, please tell me your not this simple minded!
Her presence on the show had everything to do with her homosexuality. If she was straight, she never would have been on the show. The only thing more obvious was Obama getting a nobel prize because he was black.
Homophobe?? What a pathetic term, invented by liberals who want to tag anybody who dissagrees with homosexuality as having a medical condition (phobia). I do not fear gays, I dissagree with them. NO phobia here. Only liberals use the term, like other liberal terms that are totally misleading: Pro choice = pro kill babies,
I’m glad Ellen Degenerate is Gone, she knows nothing about music.
Ellen gave American Idol a dimension that made it a lot
more appealing. Will miss her on this show but not on the
air! Good Luck funny Lady!~
She was useless. She knows NOTHING about music. What a stupid choice it was to put her on the show.
Good riddance!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I don’t think Ellen ever fit in on this show. I think someone like Tina Turner, Aretha Franklin, Glady’s Knight, Diana Krall,Paul Simon,Jack Jones to name a few. I think someone who has come up the hard way and knows the music business should be on the panel. After all, these young artists are trying to make a path to show business and having experienced musicians or singers would be the way to go.These folks are all famous and would be a great draw to the show.
@JAZZLADY
When did Gladys Knight add an apostrophe to her name?
Of course Ellen had problems with Simon… he is a man. Ellen rejects any situation where there is a male authority figure because it makes her extremely uncomfortable due to her sexuality so she lashes out at the alpha male.
What an ignorant comment. So–all lesbians have trouble with male authority? I guess that’s how she has gotten so far in show business huh–fighting with people. Your bigotry and your immaturity are showing. And btw: any woman with half a brain would have a problem with Simon’s blatantly sexist attitude. You talk about Ellen like you know her so well. Riight.
How do you know Simon has a blatantly sexist attitude. And if you know, why didn’t Ellen know? Did she even watch the show before she decided to be on it? Why wouldn’t she have known what she was getting into? Face it. Ellen quit because it was damaging her reputation. I would read reports of what would be happening during the commercials, and the judges would be taking turns talking to the guest musical artists. Except Ellen! She never had any intention to get plugged into the music world, and only seemed to be collecting a paycheck.
And YOU talk about Simon like YOU know him so well. You do exactly what you acuse others of doing, you idiot.
No question. The only reason that talentless hag gets any work at all is because the California elites believe if they keep exposing us to diseased perverts on every show, we will accept them.
No thinks Hollywood; I like pretty women with talent and appealing personalities.
That is one of the stupidest comments ever. What about Randy?? He sure looks like a Alpha Male to me. Ellen is a true prize in the entertainment industry. As she said, it just wasn’t a good ‘fit’ for her. I care about & respect Ellen & want her to be happy in her life. We should all want & deserve that. Freud, I’m getting the impression that your insecurity about your own sexuality is bugging you. Get a grip.
Wow – did you get your psychology degree in some third-world country?
Wow, what an interesting twist. J.Lo can be an interesting addition. I see her being very charismatic but honest as well.
Yay glad Ellen is out! She was a bore on IA. She seemed uncofortable and repeated everyting the judges said. The show was a bore. I think J-Lo will do great! Stern but fair. Go J-Lo!!!!!
Another waste of time and space this story and the people involved. As the entire country, economy and culture goes down the drain we are told that these people matter. BS.
@Aunt Bee
How very true! This is the most intelligent comment on the whole issue!
One down…one to go…get rid of Kara and NOT replace the Degenerate with that hack Jennifer Lopez and you might have something here.
Good Riddance
Wow. Didn’t see that one coming.
I was so hoping for Howard Stern to replace Simon Cowell and mess with Ellen at every taping. That would have been so hilarious.
Good riddance. Didn’t watch Idol all last year because of Ellen, glad she’s gone, might watch it again next year.
She was unhappy there because she wasn’t surrounded by fawning posers willing to pretend everything was “normal”.
Another bigot here? Does the “normal” imply she is not? Must be hard being such a perfect human being. These message boards are embarrassing when they reveal how much ignorance, bigotry and mean-spiritedness is out there. Easy to judge and smear when you’re anonymous behind your computer. Let’s see you accomplish 1/10th of what she has accomplished, and how many people she helps.
WHO ARE you? I have many friends who are Lesbians. I don’t care to have YOU define what is normal – but think about this: if it were not for “normal” people – there would be no one to give birth including YOU! I feel sorry for Lesbians who have not found a lifetime partner – I have been to Lesbian weddings and divorces! I am NOT on the bandwagon – going off on people on this site that say what they think as YOU are. BTW – most Lesbians do not have a fondness for men. Get over yourself – to SOME people (unlike yourself) makeing love to a man is wonderful if you are a woman. I personally don’t like the thought of women using mechanics to fulfill sexual appetites – as apparently YOU do.
You’re a bigot. Period. OPen that small, small mind of yours.
Drudgebot Pyscho. Shouldn’t you be on freerepublic hating on everything that’s good in America? You’re on the wrong website you dimwitted slut.
Magid – I personally don’t spend any time whatsoever thinking about “women using mechanics to fulfill sexual appetites”. How come you do? And, btw, lesbians are perfectly capable of fulfilling their sexual needs without the use of “mechanics”.
JJ – you’re looking for bigots everywhere. You’ll have to explain how Rita’s comment made *any* reference to Ellen’s sexual preferences. I’m not sure you understand the meaning of the word “bigot”. You do however understand the concept of “political correctness”.
But since JJ threw down the gauntlet – is being gay “normal”? Sure, Hollywood wants you to think it is “normal”. Advocates will even argue that “some animals are gay! This proves it’s normal.” Darwin would disagree. If animals are gay, they don’t procreate. This means they get excluded from the gene pool, or rather, become victims of natural selection. So biologically, not normal. Biology and natural selection are not bigoted.
People however are different. A gay person can have a baby (though not with their partner obviously). Do I care? No. They are adults, that’s up to them. Are they happy with this lifestyle? Yes? Well that’s up to them and it’s none of my business. Is it biologically “normal” though? No. Does that matter? Not really.
Let’s see what Ellen accomplished. Comedian, actress, talking head. Hollyweird is about the least amount anyone could contribute to society. The guy flipping burgers at McDonald’s has accomplished more because at least he helps feed people. Just because people pay money to these losers doesn’t mean they’ve given anything of real value to society.
Why are people always accused of being “ignorant” if they are not pro-gay or pro gay-lobby? Ignorant of what, anyway? How it FEELS to be gay? Who gives a sh!t?
Facts: Gays are in the minority. To be normative, something has to be in the majority. Therefore, gays are outside that group. Meaning, gays are not normal. Numbers don’t lie.
Now, who is ignorant? The emotional ones or the cognitive ones?
Everything is relative, Rita. Are you unhappy pretending to be “intelligent”?
Great scoop, Nikki. It’s funny. I work at FOX and they were discussing the big announcement that’s what they called it. Guess you just ruined their plans….
hee hee hee hee
As usual, great scoop. You were first per usual!!!! Now I will get the parade of News Flashes…..you’re the best!!!!
i’ve never cared for Ellen on the show. Such a waste of money!!!
Replacing her with another non-singer, J Lopez, is another waste of money.
I stopped watching the show a few seasons back.
Not a big Ellen fan – never was – but I thought she did a great job, and I AM a musician. It gave me a new perspective on who she is and her ability to see real talent for what it is. 90% of the music-loving public don’t have a music background, either, but they know what they like. Regardless, I hope this will work out for the best for everyone involved.
Who cares?
Well, this will now be the last season of American Idol!
I actually enjoyed Ellen, thought she did pretty well. Sorry she is leaving, the show is really about Simon and his brutly honest comments/criticism so without out him look for the show to go down.
I quit watching American Idol the day that Ellen joined the show. I hate her, because it seems that her main goal in life is to constantly remind you of how lesbian she is. Who wants their kids watching that filthy mouthed excuse of a woman?
I have no opinion of Jennifer Lopez one way or the other, but at least now I can start watching the show again. Thank God! Good Riddance!
I really hate it when Drudge links here, because we get bigots like this person spewing their crap.
Hey Pete- Put on your big boy pants. Oh, I am sorry you dont have any.
@Pete. Word!
Then get off the site AND ignore the Drudge Report!
What does the Drudge Report have to do with this? Sounds like Pete is bigoted against Drudge Report viewers, and is fond of stereotyping anyone who might read it. I guess that kind of thing is only OK when Pete does it, but the rest of you, watch out!!
And you got here by reading Drudge, Right!
What’s bigoted about being Christian and not wanting to raise my kids with zero morals? Just because people want to sin and act depraved doesn’t mean that I have to accept it. I no longer accept the mantra that instead of villifying wretched behavior, I now have to be “tolerant.” Where is the tolerance for my wanting to at least make an attempt to structure my life around the will of God? Where is the tolerance for people who want their kids to practice their religion anywhere they like including school as protected by the 1st Amendment? Homosexuality is against my religion. I don’t accept it. I don’t want constant reminders in my face. The fact of the matter is that you can’t support your beliefs through common sense, religion, evolution, or in any other way, so you would prefer to live in your little bubble and not have to hear anything negative about the homosexual lifestyle. Go be gay all you want, just keep it out of my face. You want to call that bigotted, go ahead. I’m bigotted because I don’t want my kids having beastiality, pedophilia, rape, and murder pushed in their face either. That’s the only arguement you have to support homosexuality; to call anyone (which is the majority) who is sickened by it a bigot. Well Whoopty Whoo, guess what, that doesn’t work on me.
Well said, Annamaria.
Christians do not have a monopoly on morality. That is one of the insidious ways that religion promotes intolerance.
It is perfectly possible for a gay person to be just as moral and upstanding a person as you. They differ from you simply because they might not accept all of the tenets of your chosen religion. That is their right as free human beings. It does not make them wretched or sinful in their own souls and that is what counts. They can justify themselves just as you do via common sense, religion or evolution. These are not philosophical or analytical tools reserved for those who practice Christianity. They were, in fact, flourishing well before Christianity came upon the scene.
I am sure you know many more homosexuals than you think you do and I am not sure why you don’t want to be “reminded” of their existence but that is your choice. Millions and millions of Christians disagree with you. Even straight ones.
Funny, because I know millions Christians (I included) that agree with her.
Well put. Like cattle, they go where they’re told to spew their noxious fumes. Moronic bigots living in trailer parks, making love to their guns (and cousins and sisters) and smoking meth, spewing their bile on Americans who are actually creative and whose products are the only thing that both our citizens & foreigners want from America now; Drudge’s America, the bottom of the barrel and proud !
Annamaria – I find your hatred far more disquieting than Ellen’s sexuality. I would absolutely not want my children around you.
Will be interesting to see how this allows JLo to come into more prominence. The argument can be made that her movies and music is not really flopping….her latest movie is an international success [depending on how success is measured], over $75 million gross, in a year where domestically the moviegoers agenda has been to avoid repeat concepts, which is something Jennifer’s only film was all about. Her last music CD came out when she was already pregnant, which meant she had to drop promo for it. The music wasn’t all that great so the album didn’t go much of anywhere, but a return to chart-topping success is easily within the realm of possibility.
However, she was a well-liked judge when she worked on american idol last as a mentor, and she’s undeniably chameleon-like and beautiful in her looks, enough of a reason to tune in, in my books. idol is not supposed to be comedy, the concepts don’t necessarily go together. judges should be wise and quick on their feet, and most importantly brief and willing to be a side dish, and jennifer is a great side dish.
Why hasn’t anyone said it yet? JLo got the job because hispanic is in. At least for now it is. The sponsors want to appeal to the growing hispanic population.
I have always been an Idol fan, butI was very disappointed last season, when they brought Kara (Cara?) on. She was in the way for me, and she always annoyed me. I was upset when Paula wasn’t asked back. BUT I have to say, I LOVED Ellen. I was never happy with how, I felt, Kara behaved with Ellen. She refered to her as “the guys” and Kara was practically in Simon’s lap most of the time, like she was trying to stay as far away as possible from Ellen. It seemed disrespectful to me. I’m glad Ellen is out IF that’s what SHE wanted. LOVED Ellen. CAN’T stand Cara. Whatever IDOL is doing in the future, I hope Kara is gone. Because without Simon, Paula, or Ellen, I have no reason to watch anymore! (i love randy!!) Kara’s voice (to ME) is nails running down a chalkboard.
Don’t any of you people have a DVR? That’s the best way to watch AI. You can skip Kara, Ellen, and Seacrest. More and more, we skip Randy too. Kara is terrible, but unlike Ellen, she actually worked in the music industry.
Have they considered Gene Simmons to take Simon Cowells place? I think he would be the perfect ‘tough’ judge — to say the hard truth that we so appreciated about Simon Cowell that so many people hated to hear.
I believe it’s going to be real rough without Simon, essentially he made the show with his comments, I hope the show does not tank, but without Simon things won’t be the same.
Ms DeGeneres is smart. Need I say more?
Not smart enough, apparently. But what does her being smart have to do with this? Don’t keep it in – give us the rest of that thought.
Smart because she felt the direction the show was headed was not a good one. She’s smart enough to get off the Titanic while she can. There have been lots of comments about the judges, but I think it’s more about the contestants. Maybe the talent pool has dried up, and Taylor Hicks selection has rushed the down fall… just saying there’s nothing to watch without the talent on stage. Yes, the judges add spice, but it’s really all about the singing!!!
JLo?? Why do they keep foisting this no-talent on a public that clearly has no interest in her? Idol’s ratings slide will continue–I know I won’t watch it anymore.
You have a point. But Ellen was truly terrible. JLo, sadly, is an improvement. Mariah Carey would have been AWESOME! She’s actually a talented singer and she’s fun.
It’s so weird that J-Lo was about to become a hasbeen. She has sold more than 20M albums in the last decade AND had several hit films. It is just weird that suddenly her films bomb and her record label drops her. This gig will probably help her back to the top – if the label didn’t know who was her audience, now they will…if the Idol-viewers will like her, EVERYBODY will be her audience. AI is great exposure for hasbeens (Abdul etc.).
J-Lo had a good run, but let’s put her numbers in perspective. Miley Cyrus has sold 21 million albums AND had several hit films. In 3 1/2 years!!! And counting!
2 down, 2 to go. With Lythgoe back in charge, it’s only a matter of time before Randy and Kara are out the door. Now, if he’d do something to get “Seacrest out.”
Of all the potential judges discussed in the gossipsphere, no one is less interesting than J-Lo. Simon must be thrilled as AI fans will definitely be going with him to X Factor.
Stern Stern stern Stern stern Stern stern Stern stern…..
Howard Stern…
stern Stern stern Stern stern Stern stern Stern stern…..
Howard Stern..
He is available in DEC. when his Sirius contract runs out.
They can’t afford him though. Everything he knows is in the NY area.
Ellen never should have been on Idol to start with. Who cares what someone as psycho-socially messed up as her thinks about a singers capabilities anyway.
And I’m sure she’s contractually allowed to say it was her idea to leave. I know I will tune in more often with her gone.
Ellen who? American what? Nobody cares anymore. Simon is a genius.
Ellen was only part of what went wrong with this lousy season. Terrible producing (does no one at AI own a watch?) and directing (weird “Batman” angles from behind people’s heads), the series’ most mediocre talent, Cowell half asleep, and then the twin snooze-fest of Ellen & Kara. Ellen, who was only sporadically funny, not a singer, not a producer of singers, and never musically insightful. Who knew that Nigel was so important to the show? When he left, it’s like the wheels immediately began to wobble and popped right off.
this show keeps getting worse and worse each season…now that Simon AND Ellen are gone…..no sense in even watching it….the “so called stars” that you are getting to replace them are has beens that are just that…replacements…..no longer “fun” to watch!
Hey Ellen. It wasn’t fun for us, either.
Great choice. Great opportunity for JLO to reinvent herself.
I’ve never watched idol, but I always loved hearing about Paula’s meltdown’s. They are so screwed now. Without her and Simon there is no show. It’s a bore fest. The only person, that they’re too scared to hire, who might be able to resuscitate this lame show is Howard Stern. Now that would make for some interesting TV. …J.Lo is so OVER.
I want to meet you, Girl Friday. You’ve never watched the show but instinctively know that it is a “bore fest” (not that you’re wrong). All we need to keep it really, really boring is another Brit or two. I just love watching television where the Brits are the judges of what we should or shouldn’t like. They do, you realize, know much more than us… they must since they provide so many fine wastes of space as judges on varioius unentertaining shows.
It’s the accent, old bean. Makes them automatically smarter than us by 2 or 3 IQ points. Unless it’s a Cockney accent. Then they are both smarter and will steal your wallet without you noticing
Jennifer Lopez! Really… How many ships has she been on lately that has sunk? Don’t get me wrong she was good in the past, but no real longevity at all.
They only way they could save this ship is to bring back Palua. And I’m not even a Paula fan but it would bring in the viewers at least for the first season back. Paula and Sir Elton would have been interesting… Or what about Phil Collins? They might as well offered it to Yoko Ono… (I know that’s harsh)
Chris
JLo will be terrible b/c it will be all about JLo. Think Simon without the whit, British accent, or gravitas, but with a huge rump and annoying skeletor husband.
JLO hasn’t been hot since Bobby99 was en vogue.
Some people like great big a$$es. Not me, but some people.
Replace Simon with Les Grossman.
This I could go for!
My wife and I have watched every season but this last one will be the final one if that stupid low class Lopez is on the show. She insults half of the citizens everytime she opines about politics. She can take her offensive progressive, anti American attitude and stick it up her flagging a**.
do you kiss your mother with that mouth?
Nice going. You need to identify yourself so I can be sure to keep my kids away from you.
ellen really sucked.
lopez with that PR voice sucks
get somebody like donny osmond
Yeah
Great News!!!!! Ellen was terrible.
she didnt fit in at all
Me and my husband will no longer watch american idol if Jennifer Lopes will be one of the judges,shame because we had enjoyed watching AI for many seasons.
Sorry…it’s Jennifer Lopez, i even spelled her name wrong….
Why, you miss the mad artistic chops and relevance of Paula Abdul?
How can anyone criticize J-Lo if they enjoyed the show with Paula?
paula can sing! my cat sounds better than j.lo!
Jennifer is a great choice! Can’t wait to see her do her thing next season.
NNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!
I would be uncomfortable and nervous too if I didn,t know anything about a subject I was supposed to be judging. At least she was smart enough to quit.
Sorry to see Ellen go…she may have felt that she didn’t fit in because she is actually funny while the tired banter between Ryan and Simon was never funny. I enjoy the show but tend to agree that it needs a clean slate…starting with Ryan and the writers…
This year the contestants never seemed to work up a sweat or try very hard…even the attempt to get them to do something interesting by bringing in Adam Lambert as a mentor failed to get a rise out of them.
Jennifer Lopez should have stayed with Eric Gold. He made her.
Cant wait to hear what Howard Stern has to say about this.. hahaha
He’s off next week so you’ll have to wait.
He’ll definitely say he’s not doing AI.
Would have been better off taking Benny Medina instead. His ability to get great albums out of his clients is quite incredible.
It’s always seemed odd to me that the minute the label drops you, convinced you can’t sell albums anymore, they immediately put out an album of your greatest hits.
The Back up plan DID NOT BOMB BADLY — it was budgeted at 35 million and has made 80 million worldwide and it was a great romantic comedy that everyone should check out.
http://www.boxofficemojo.com/movies/?id=backupplan.htm
Why can’t they offer Simon’s seat to producer David Foster?
David doesn’t want the job.
Makes complete sense to get someone with a stalling career to revive a stalling show — but she is a lot like Paula Abdul, not in a good way
JHO… a judge? She’s not a singer but more of a performer. She’ll bring the broken English ghetto vibe to the table.
Ethan, Ethan, Ethan – “broken English ghetto” – my dtr-in-law is fluid in Ty (sp), Engish and Spanish – she is studying to become an “international” linguist – translator. She is hardly “ghetto”. Amazing – you have brought “ghetto” to thist site – in only ONE language. I respect your opinion regarding JLO – but lack of education here in this country is so sad. I would be offended but I just consider “the source.” Come on – do a little better for your non-bilingual friends and family. Remember our American English came from the King’s English and is considered ghetto by the English!
You might have a point… can we agree that Beyonce is ghetto? Have you heard her speak. Have you seen what she wears? The thug she married?
Well Ethan, who are you to declare someone or something “ghetto”? Do you even know or understand what the word means? It is easy for someone to sit behind their computer and talk “trailer-trash” speak when they have nothing but a double-wide to look forward to. I am quite sure Beyonce would inform you that she will gladly accept your description as being “ghetto” as long as trailer trash keeps buying her cd’s….how ghetto can one person get,huh,Ethan?Oh, yeah, her multi-million dollar husband and entrepreneur,
Jay-z,and Beyonce would most definately laugh in your poor face …
Since when is being bilingual a deficit? Americans are woefully behind the rest of the industrialized world in that respect. Obviously, as the poster above shows, bilingual skills are used to beat people over the head with. Kind of an ignorant response.
Ellen out wow… I said I would not watch Idol if she was made Judge and I did not turn it on not once. I don’t even know who won. I used to be a fan but I can’t take her lifestyle and the way Paula was let go. Some people actually do what they say they will do. With Ellen out maybe next season depending on who you get I might tune in who knows….
“I can’t take her lifestyle”…what the hell does that even mean? Oh, are you alluding to the fact that she’s a lesbian? In that case, you should feel a little more secure in your manhood, I mean, Jesus dude…
Rodney’s got a right to his opinion, JohnDoe. And what the heck would you know about Rodney’s manhood? Or do you just want to find out?
and JohnDoe has a right to his opinion as well. the bigots on here are clearly in the minority but they add nothing to the discussion other than a reminder that there are some truly ignorant assholes roaming the planet.
Another person who doesn’t know the meanings of the words “ignorant” and “bigot”. Talk about an asshole. I guess only Cookmeyer’s and JohnDoe’s opinions are valid? BTW Cookmeyer, I didn’t see Arrow stopping anyone from brandishing their opinion.
Why on earth do you care about her lifestyle? Why would you bother wasting your time even thinking about it? I may not be able to stand your lifestyle either but it doesn’t impact me in the slightest.
Oh I had hoped that Obama would be named a judge on Idol. He seems to prefer show biz to working for the people.
Couldn’t have that. He’d ignore the public and just pick the person he likes.
she’s-no-good
I’m glad Ellen is gone. We don’t want Elton either.
The beginning of the end for AI.
This is AWESOME!!! J Lo will be a perfect fit on the show because she knows what music is all about. It is her and her husbands life. She will be able to give some very useful and constructive input to what the contestants need to do to improve on their performances. Get Elton John or Steven Tyler in there and you will have an outstanding show with judges that actually know what they are talking about.
Very talented J-Lo in, no talent Degeneres out…yea! I get to watch Idol again. Woot-woot!!!
Awesome choice!!!
I loved Ellen’s banana analogies on Idol. Or maybe not.
I wished they replace Kara first. She is absolutely arrogant. I don’t think much of her songs. Her comments are rather lame, worse than the other judges.
Jennifer in a good replacement for Ellen. I was not aware that Ellen was so unhappy with being a judge.
Lopez is an ultra liberal, anti american, pro illegal immigrant hate monger. I will never watch Idol again.
Perfect. Politics should never be part off the show. It would give her a giant platform for her progressive idiotology.
As opposed to the ultra conservative, pseudo-American, anti-illegal immigrant hate monger that you seem to be. So much nastiness here today. Not the American way.
Wow. I’m not even a JLo fan but what a complete, nasty takedown of the woman. What is up with that? It seems nothing to do with why she was chosen as a judge on Idol. I’m thinking it had more to do with her two appearances on the show as a mentor and how suprisingly (shockingly) good she was at the job. But ladies, go ahead. Knock yourself out. Take down another successful woman.
Good choice for both of them, they need each other.
JLo? WHAT a joke.
Like I said before, Ellen may be gone because she having no fun, but it is not because she doesnt have chemistry with Simon, and it isnt because she lacks industry experience that puts off her panel members, it is because people get tired of lesbians and homos popping up and being given a platform for more undeserved visibility. She’s disgusting.
Holy jumping fuckin shitballs, when did Deadline Hollywood become a breeding ground for intolerant, arrogant neo-cons? Ellen is disgusting? Why, because she’s proud of who she is? Get over yourself, and lower the hate meter a tad, and then maybe you can join the rest of us here on Planet Earth.
Drudge linked to this article, that’s why the knuckle-draggers are here.
The American Taliban.
Pete, your ignorance is showing again. Do you even know what the Taliban does to gay people (not to mention people who just want to go to school)? You are a closed-minded bigot who doesn’t know the difference between the words “tolerance” and “acceptance”. People can be tolerant of your chosen lifestyle without having to accept it for themselves. That’s what we do in America. I don’t see anyone here advocating Ellen’s stoning or arrest for her lifestyle. So get your hyperbole under control and quit stereotyping.
“intolerant, arrogant neo-cons”
“lower the hate meter a tad”
The irony must be lost on you.
How about William Shatner to replace Simon? He was pretty good playing a judge in that Brad Paisley video.
Gee, I’m going to miss Randy’s echo…
Good move Fox. JLo will be good. She will bring back some spice to the show.
Dont you mean Mariah?……..There were also reports of fighting going on between Medina (who managed Madonna) and the label.
Ellen is way to nice for these dickheads.
Get Sammy Hagar or Gordon Ramsay.
I’m still not sure why she ever said yes! Does the woman not know how to say no? To anything! I mean she’s certainly everywhere, isn’t she? How was it important to her career to become a judge on AI? Or has her ego run amock and the woman honestly believes everything – absolutely everything – requires the Ellen touch?
Ellen is funny, kind and well-meaning. I appreciate her work on behalf of the Humane Society very much. But I am completely sick of her image. It’s called over-exposed, or more appropriately, overkill. And speaking of over-exposed and overkill don’t get me started on JLo. I’m just happy I stopped watching AI two seasons ago.
The other judges “sneered at or ignored” whatever DeGeneres said? Really? Not once all season did I see any judge-to-judge “sneering or ignoring” taking place, but if Nikke says “sneering and ignoring” took place then it must be.
Oh come on now. The real reason Ellen does not get a long with Cowell is because HE is a strong MAN. Most butch dykes like Ellen hate MEN. Especially strong confident MEN. They hate being in the presence of MEN. MEN to Butch Dykes are the ENEMY.
And Butch Dykes are VERY Political when it comes to MEN.Secretly the Ellen types will paint all MEN as PIGS who can’t be trusted when all it really comes down to is these Ellen types are frustrated they don’t have a dick and 90% of Womem enjoy MEN. Ellen types hate that.
I’m glad she’s off. Now maybe the ratings will go up.
Reread your post. I wouldn’t want to be around a “man” like you either, though I doubt you fit the normal definition you in-bred bottom feeder. And speaking of manhood, your hero that you followed here, Drudge, is a well known gay, you bigoted Idiot.
Now watch this get censored because drudge and gay was used in the same sentence, though everyone already knows. Deadline, you’re better than this right-wing tool and his moronic, in-bred readers. Why would any advertiser pay a premium for his links here when his readers spend what little they make on porn and meth anyway??
James- moronic inbred readers? You sound like a bigot. Shouldn’t you try to be more tolerant. What has this world come to when homosexuals deserve tolerance but people with morals get stereotyped. The majority of the population doesn’t support alternate chosen lifestyles unless you live in a big liberal city where peoples values don’t reflect reality.
My goodness – you seem to have some serious issues. And some profound misunderstandings.
Ellen DeGeneres really never fit in to the program.
J-Lo may make it, but Simon is going to be hard to match.
Not the right fit for Ellen? Really, how did Ellen herself come to that conclusion? No background in the music business, not even that great in the entertainment business if you ask me. I don’t really even care, I don’t like Ellen or Idol. Why did I look at this article, and why am I commenting?
Fitting since her recording career was similar to Paula’s.
JLo will be a great judge though. She was a very good mentor when she mentored Latin Night a few seasons back. She even got the awful Sanjaya to pull off a decent performance.
Now its time to fire Randy and Kara and replace them and the show is effectively rebooted.