MONDAY UPDATE: The film director pleaded guilty in Los Angeles federal court to lying during the Pellicano investigation. John McTiernan entered the plea to two counts of making false statements to the FBI and one count of perjury for lying to a federal judge while trying to withdraw a guilty plea. He faces up to a year in prison when he’s sentenced October 4th before the same judge he lied to.
SUNDAY PM: The Predator reboot debuted this weekend. But at 9 AM Monday, the director of the original goes on trial. John McTiernan is charged with lying to the FBI and to a federal judge in connection with the Anthony Pellicano wiretapping and racketeering case. But McTiernan, who also helmed Die Hard, The Hunt for Red October, and The Thomas Crown Affair remake, But here’s the problem: McTiernan is appearing for trial tomorrow before the same judge he allegedly lied to. In June, McTiernan lost a bid to suppress evidence in the case. U.S. District Judge Dale Fischer denied McTiernan’s request to exclude a telephone conversation Pellicano recorded in which he and McTiernan discussed wiretapping Charles Roven, a producer of the 2002 movie Rollerball that was also directed by McTiernan.
This case has quite a history. The 59-year-old director pleaded guilty in 2006 to lying to FBI agents about paying Pellicano $50,000 to wiretap Roven’s phone. Fischer sentenced McTiernan in 2007 to 4 months in prison after denying his motion to withdraw his guilty plea. But the U.S. Court of Appeals in San Francisco in 2008 said McTiernan should get a new hearing on whether he could withdraw his plea. So last year he was allowed to withdraw his guilty plea because his previous lawyer hadn’t told him he could have tried to suppress the incriminating recording as evidence. Pellicano, the one-time Hollywood private eye, was sentenced to 15 years in prison for running a criminal enterprise.
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.


Pellicano is the fall guy for a corrupt tinseltown. Ending the investigation at him instead of going up the food chain of who he was working for is proof of Hollywood and Federal corruption
I’m sorry – doesn’t this conviction show that the investigation DID include who he was working for?
Okay. Here’s the scoop. You never have to talk to the FBI. It is never required. The only thing that can make you talk at all in a criminal matter is a properly served subpoena to appear in a courtroom before a judge or a properly served subpoena to appear before a Grand Jury. Even then you can assert your Fifth Amendment right to remain silent. Only a judge can force you to speak if s/he rules there are no issues or questions that would incriminate you or lead to evidence that could incriminate you.
HOWEVER, if you stupidly choose to talk to the FBI then YOU CANNOT LIE. PERIOD. Huge caveat: Since you never know what the FBI or prosecutors believe is the truth (even if it is not the truth) you can never be certain that even if you tell the turth that they won’t turn around and claim you lied.
Okay? Got it? Lesson learned?
Back to Nikki’s entertaining enlightenment.
And, Nikki, I don’t even know what the issues are but I am sick of the sexist crap from some quarters and I am Team Nikki.
Perhaps the single most useful post every shared on this site. Sincerely, I thank you.
Kathleen…
Excellent post! I dunno if you’re a lawyer, but I like to get my legal advice from anonymous people on the web. So where’s your blog?
how come Hollywood hasn’t made a movie about Pellicano?
I heard one was in development at Universal. Any updates?
Universal would have the inside track – Wasn’t it Ronnie Meyer who kept visiting him in prison?
It’s difficult to have a development meeting over wiretaps instead of Skype.
How many offices around Los Angeles are still bugged?
yeh, where is a pellicano movie? this case gripped tinseltown for years and years but no one has done a movie about it? oh wait…it’s not a comic book yet.
No actors will take the parts of Ovitz, Fields or Grey!
REALLY? U had to bug a producer’s office? Geez – get a f*#@!g clue about life and move on. Shame on all of U in this town for pulling those kind of tactics in the name of…Hollywood?
Maybe one day Hollywood honchos will stop acting like characters in their own stupid movies…
Too bad for McTiernan that he didn’t just drug a 13 year old and take advantage of her, then flee jurisdiction for decades. He’d be in better shape.
Darth Pellicano should have auditioned for a Star Wars villian when he had the chance(s) he’s got that Sith thing down cold.
Hollywood needs to get over Rollerball and let this man get back to kicking ass. McTiernan is a national treasure. As a fan for over twenty years, it has pained me to see him dealing with this situation for so long. Here’s hoping that he receives a short sentence and gets back to what he does best.
FREE MCTIERNAN
Miles, I’m with you on this one.
McTiernan is one of the greatest living director.
We need more movies from him.
FREE MCTIERNAN
(tee-shirts anyone?)
Let’s see now … “Yes, I lied. And I DID hire Anthony Pellicano to illegally wiretap Chuck Roven when we did ‘Rollerball’ in 2002.”
“Okay, I know that I admitted I lied, but I was drinking … I was jetlagged and … and … oh yeah, I had bad attorneys. So, I want a do-over.”
“Alright, alright … I got new attorneys and couldn’t get the wiretap evidence thrown out that showed I lied about Chuck Roven … so I guess I’ll plead guilty to lying.”
“Okay, I KNOW I pleaded guilty AGAIN to lying, but the ‘questions’ were unfair because the FBI already knew the answers … and I didn’t know that they already knew the answers so I lied … I mean … no, not lied, I mean I was jetlagged, drinking, had bad attorneys … and, uh, did I mention ambushed? Didn’t mention that one, yet? Okay, I was ambushed into lying. No, I mean, I didn’t LIE … oh wait, I already said I lied? Okay, I lied BUT I was ambushed.”
“Oh, and I want it on the record that I have never even HEARD of Chuck Roven.”
Talk about being entangled in a web of lies.
Anita Busch – you are a true hero. “The mouse that roared”. Pellicano and his celebrity clients thought they were above the law as well as untouchable. But you would not be scared to silence – despite tremendous personal and professional sacrifice. It’s people like you who guard the truth, no matter what, that are true heroes.
If he knows whats good for him, he’ll take the rap, and quietly (dutifully)do the time.
When he gets out I am quite sure he will have many lucrative deals offered to him for the remainder of his career… those not being named as clients of Pellicano will be so very grateful…
This is gotcha justice at its worst. McTiernan gets an after-hours 5 minute phonecall from a man who identifies himself over the phone as an FBI agent, but who can verify who he is over the phone. Betcha McTiernan gets hundreds of phone calls from reporters, stalkers, crazy fans, etc. and has developed an easy, breezy diplomatic way of handling them. Why should you give personal info to a voice over the phone. Would you? This little five minute phone call has resulted in a brilliant man, who didn’t have a political bone in his body, being persecuted for a flip answer to a gotcha question. American justice should be better and bigger and more moral than this.
Yeah, except this “brilliant man” hired a total scumbag to put illegal wiretaps on the phones of the guy who was producing his movie. And then he lied to the FBI when he was asked about his relationship with Pellicano. (He’s admitted he knew he was talking to a real FBI agent; so much for your theory.) And then, to make it even worse, he committed perjury and lied to the judge in court, which he’s also now admitted. Who the heck cares if he’s political? He’s a criminal. Gotcha? You bet they did.
ok so he lied. big deal. slap on the wrist. up to one year sounds really harsh. they got pellicano why are they going after mcT??? the FBI needs rules too. bad lawyers is a very excusable excuse.
Take a look at the first comment to this article. Answer your question?