Luke Y Thompson is covering the Con for Deadline:
SUNDAY AM UPDATE: I think the biggest news of the Marvel Studios panel tonight is that The Punisher is now owned by Marvel Studios again, and will probably figure into a future film. I’ve learned The Punisher rights reverted to Marvel in 2009 following the release of Punisher 2. The studio has no immediate plans to develop a movie based on the franchise. Marvel Studios President Kevin Feige last night did not say when the Punisher rights reverted, or how: just that they have.
So who is The Punisher? In the comics, Frank Castle is a Vietnam veteran whose family is killed in a Mafia crossfire. Donning a black spandex costume with a skull logo, he declares war on crime and becomes a vigilante. Introduced as a Spider-Man foe in the 1970s, his popularity took off in the late 1980s, when grim and “realistic” superheroes became the norm. The Punisher is different from many superheroes in that he uses guns and has no secret identity. (He is known to be Frank Castle.) On film, he has been portrayed three times.
In 1989, Roger Corman’s New World made a movie starring Dolph Lundgren as the Punisher. He did not have the traditional costume or skull logo, but the role was a departure for Lundgren, who played the character as deranged. Initially set for a theatrical release, it wound up going direct to video, despite the character’s popularity at the time.
In 2004, with Marvel movies on the rise, The Punisher was rebooted with Thomas Jane in the lead. Jane, who is a comic book fan, and well-liked by other fans, researched the role heavily, hanging out at gun shows. John Travolta played villain Howard Saint. Though many fans liked Jane’s portrayal, the movie was still goofy and overlong, and the costume consisted mainly of a T-shirt with the skull on it.
In 2008, a sequel of sorts was made. Jane bowed out, and director Lexi Alexander was rumored to have lost control. Nonetheless, this was my favorite Punisher movie by far, with Ray Stevenson playing him as a slasher villain with guns, who defends against even worse villains. He didn’t quite get the costume, but the skull logo was still there. The movie bombed, despite being the truest adaptation to date.
While the last two were released by Lionsgate, the Punisher is fair game for future Marvel universe movies. This means you likely won’t see him as a Spider-Man foe (Sony has those rights). But you could see him fighting, say, the Hulk.
Chances are it won’t be Ray Stevenson who plays him again, even though he’s good and would likely come cheap.






Personally my favorite Punisher film would have to be the one with Thomas Jane and John Travolta. Stevenson was ok but no great Warzone was much darker and reflected more on the comic book but the Punisher with Jane was more…in depth in his revenge. Now I do agree the movies were a bust and I blame writing and the director as well as the storyboarding. So another Punisher movie won’t really be a bad thing as long as it’s done right. No one can deny the popularity in the character of Frank Castle the people will go see it weather the last three were a toatal bust or not it’s all about how they advertise it and who they put in to be the characters. Now I’m a huge Marvel fab and am very fond of The Punisher and besides the Marvel comic industy has plenty of leway on faul-ups they can let another go it doesn’t work out. Oh by the way Dolph was the worst Punisher EVER!!
The problem with the Thomas Jane version was that it took the entire film before he truly became The Punisher. Way too much time was spent establishing the character without the absolute guarantee of a sequel. Lundgren’s version was laughable. Stevenson nailed it. What was missing, though, was the War Wagon. In the comics, Frank Castle would ride around town in his modified van looking for trouble, and along the way, he would recount his activities into a “captain’s log”. Now, if folk are looking for a way to add depth to the character, there it is. he isn’t going to sit down with someone and tell them how uncertain he is about what he is doing – he tells the tape recorder. I kept waiting for that in War Zone but it never happened.
All the Punisher movies were terribly written and casted. The movies should be written in the form of james bond and bourne idenitity or even the Dark Knight series. There is no need for over the top blood or special effects. It doesnt need any comedy, just a good written drama/ action movie like the jason bourne series. The reason why fans like marvel movies is because it seems realistic. When they force unnecessary action, comedy and special effects when it comes to a character who is known for none of that it just makes it a very cheezy low quality movie. He was one of my favorite characters growing up so please i beg marvel reveal him in a quality drama/action movie.
he does what he suppose to do