Anticipating an avalanche of American Idol-related questions, Fox Broadcasting’s entertainment chairman Peter Rice made an opening statement at the top of the network’s executive session. “The only thing I an tell you with absolute certainty is there are no signed deals with anyone on either side of the camera who wasn’t on the show last year,” he said, referring to judges as well as returning executive producer Nigel Lythgoe. Rice did confirm that Ellen DeGeneres met with him at the beginning of June. ”We talked about the season and her feelings about the season, the idea that she wasn’t comfortable and that it was not a good fit for her,” he said. “I tried to persuade her that it would be different in the future, but we ultimately came to an agreement. We were going to begin looking for new judges anyway, because Simon was leaving, so as that was going to play out over the summer, we came to an agreement to go to her and say: we can’t replace you, or we can move on without you. [DeGeneres is in the middle of a 2-year deal with Idol.] That’s where we got to last week. We felt confident that we could come up with a panel that didn’t include Ellen as a judge, and at the same time we knew we were coming here on Monday. We felt it was disingenuous to sit here and talk about Ellen being on Idol when we knew that wouldn’t be the case.”
The rest of the executive session resembled a ping-pong match, with reporters trying different angles to ask questions about Idol and Rice and Fox entertainment president Kevin Reilly quickly deflecting them. They refused to comment on the future of current judges Randy Jackson and Kara DioGuardi. Rice indicated that deals with the new judges are in advanced stages and an announcement will be made before the Idol auditions before the judges begin in mid-September. The plan is to make one announcement with the entire new panel, Reilly said after the session. He said he does expect Idol to remain the top-rated show on TV next season, as Idol has “an awful lot of wiggle room” in terms of ratings advantage over the rest of the pack.
Reilly and Rice also commented on the decision to hold the new Steven Spielberg/Peter Chernin adventure drama Terra Nova until next fall, with a May preview. Reilly said the reasons stemmed mostly from the scope of the project, set 85 million years ago, which requires extensive post-production as well as pre-production. He said the show is still in the process of locking up a filming location, with possibilities raging from Louisiana to Hawaii to Australia, as producers are looking for a place that would most closely stand-in for pre-historic Earth. Also, having a jump on a completed pilot loaded with all special effects months before the official series launch would help better sell the show to advertisers, Rice said.
Reilly also noted after the session that the network continues committed to dramedy The Good Guys for fall. In May, Fox ordered additional episodes from the show for fall before its summer premiere, and it hasn’t cut back the order despite low ratings so far.
During the session, Reilly said the network “is taking a beat” in late-night after canceling The Wanda Sykes Show and not making a deal with Conan O’Brien. “This season we really want to stay focused on prime time, but late-night is never off the table and we will revisit it when we find the right piece of talent.”
Reilly also was asked to address the departure from ABC of Stephen McPherson, who has been a close friend of his for the past 30 years. He admitted the news was “upsetting” to him. “All I can speak to is the depth of his character,” Reilly said. “On a personal basis, he’s a loyal and good friend, and I think people in the community know that and can speak to that. As a professional, he is not a guy who is afraid to have the courage of his convictions, and that’s resulted in some inspired programming and has made him a successful executive. It will continue to serve him well as he goes forward… I don’t know what his professional plans are but, if they entail any producing, the door will be open to him at Fox.”
RELATED: Jennifer Lopez Is New ‘Idol’ Judge; Replaces Ellen
Diane Haithman is contributing to Deadline Hollywood’ TCA coverage.
TV Editor Nellie Andreeva - tip her here.


No signed contracts yet? Good. Please rethink Lopez and Tyler. This is a disaster. Why not Connick???
Lopez will be fine. Hire Harry Connick Jr. and replace Randy with Babyface and it will be an awesome panel of judges…
When Jennifer was a mentor and did a good job:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8zG8rOKDSfs
“They refused to comment on the future of current judges Randy Jackson and Kara DioGuardi.”
…very interesting!
When the host and judges are announced for “American Idol 10″, expect judge Randy Jackson and emcee Ryan Seacrest to be among the missing.
I expect that there will be an all-new panel of judges and a new host(ess) as well.
And perhaps also some major tweaks to the format as well.
Seacrest is in the first year of 3 year, $45 million dollar contract. There is no way 19 Entertainment is going to eat that contract. Besides, he’s a very good host for the show and they need some continuity, especially with the departure of Simon.
Ryan will be back.
It is reported that Jennifer Lopez (via Benny Medina) wants perks to go along with the job, and before she signs on as a judge, FOX must give her a movie and TV deal also. I wonder if FOX thinks she is worthy enough to do that?
Ken Tucker of Entertainment Weekly posed a suggestion last week… how about just ending the show? With the lackluster season that just finished, I’m not totally opposed to this idea. I know Fox would probably never even consider it given how big a cash cow AI seems to be but as a viewer, the series has just deteriorated season after season in the past 3 years. With Simon gone, who cares, really?!
Randy Jackson
Rosie Perez
Tim Curry
There – that does it.
Or, as Tyler by way of K Tucker said – just end the show. Without a Simon like presence – Tim Curry, Piers Morgan or someone like that – it has no anchor. Lopez’s career has sagged because she is just not likeable. Either keep it going with poor judges and watch the ratings sag or just put an end to it – 10 seasons is enough isnt it?
AI can regain some of its original excitment next year – better talent and better judges – maybe a shakeup in the format, BUT, Lopez is annoying after a while. What a horrible choice. And Steven Tyler? What c’mon. They would have been better off with Randy, Kara and Connick.
I think Lopez and Tyler will not be great judges. Neither of them are amuzing at all. Uggg.
The show needs more competition and more contestants that enjoy what they are doing. I found Bowersox constant confession that she just wanted the money a bit disturbing. How about “I enjoy what I am doing”? Whenever a contestant comes across as just wanting to take our money, it spoils the competition.
I love this season 2011 American Idol .I think this is a good panel of judges . they fit well ! Don’t change it !