Of all the film franchises at Lionsgate, the most financially reliable are Tyler Perry’s. Tolerate his racial stereotyping or not, he’s a money machine for the studio especially when his films star his loathesome female alter ego Madea. That is also why, after his lobbying, Lionsgate released last year’s Precious. Remember how controversial that pic was? Well, trust me: Lionsgate doesn’t begin to understand yet what a PR nightmare will surround its movie For Colored Girls Who Have Considered Suicide When the Rainbow Is Enuf because Tyler Perry is at the helm. It starts screening in 2-3 weeks now that the studio recently moved up the release date from 2011 to November 5th. Look, just my reporting last September of Perry’s plan to make the pic elicited some of Deadline’s most vicious attacks on a filmmaker.
Now I’ve learned that even Tyler’s close pal Oprah Winfrey did not want him to make the film version of the iconic 1975 play by Ntozake Shange. And that her reaction echoed the outrage of many black females along the lines of, “How dare you!” because the storyline is profoundly their story, not any man’s, and especially not his. The play is a collection of 20 poems, dealing with love, abandonment, rape, abortion, and more, told by seven different women who are identified only by color. Perry’s version has given names to the women, and is described as a poetic exploration of what is to be of color and a female in this world.
I’m told that despite her horror Oprah gave Perry “huge feedback” on the script, which Perry shot in June and July. Though he’s still finishing the film’s music, I hear Oprah and her gal pal Gayle King recently saw a rough cut and both gave Perry big props. Yes, but was Winfrey simply admiring her own handiwork or his? Perry, by enlisting Oprah’s fame and forum, ensured Precious got seen by a crossover audience. But this time I don’t think even Oprah can help him with the pic’s base. Not when there are predisposed attitudes among black women like this: “Even if Tyler Perry were just writing the script to For Colored Girls, or just directing, or just producing — even that would be too much for him to handle. He simply does not have the sensitivity, ingenuity, or abilities in any of those three capacities to do this film a sliver of the justice it deserves.” On the other hand, Lionsgate hopes controversy fills seats. Here’s the trailer:
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.


The question isn’t “Was it appropriate for a man to bring this to film?”.
The question is “Who the hell wants to go see a movie based on a thirty-five year old play?”.
A lot of people, hun. The play is not only classic but it’s be re-interpreted over an over again. That’s like asking who would have wanted to watch Chicago. lol.
Who would want to watch Chicago?
Foolish.
After last year, Perry is sure that the way to Oscar gold is to portray the wretchedness of black people. Why not? He’s been lining his pockets like a poverty pimp for years. He only got onto Precious after it won at Sundance and shunned it when they needed money. A white woman made that film
And you are right, no one has been waiting for this film.
Let’s hope it his Waterloo or at least his Pluto Nash.
the REAL QUESTION is, what has Ntozake had to say about this?? She’s being awfully quiet. Doesn’t anyone wonder how this has even come about? Doesn’t Ms. Shonge have the rights to this work?? How’d TP get it in the first place???
As I sit here reading not just this post, but many others and I am incensed because of what I see here….. a lot of” hating” going on.
So first to this post, IF NOT TYLER –THEN WHO, IF NOT NOW– THEN WHEN. This play has been around since 1977 and no one, no one, has thought it worth their time and or money or had the guts to make it into a movie. Your second question – many people go to the movies to see films from 30 or 40 years ago, ever heard of nostalgic, classic or history, wake up sweetheart. Yes, it would have been nice if a woman raised her hand to tell the story of women, but she didn’t , so does that mean our story doesn’t get told. That’s the problem with Americans, everybody always have something negative to say, but they won’t get off their behinds and do something. Was the writer of Harry Potter a real witch, did anyone complain about that. This is entertainment and people use their God given talent to do what they do. Have you? Sure, I also think that most of Perry’s movies are exploitation and his “plays” are not really worthy of being calls ‘A Play” they are more of a silly and predictable dramatization of life, but as mentioned, the man is putting people of color to work and you can’t fault him for that. I saw “Colored Girls” on Broadway and am excited to see what he’s done with it and happy that so many Black women have gotten a chance to work together and that so many other women will go and see it together and hopefully experience something they never have, young and old. I know my daughters will go to see it and will be better for it, ‘cause they weren’t around 30 years ago. You might learn something, all of you who are bitching and “hating” might learn something…… what it felt like to be a Black woman in the ‘70s and what it still feels like to be a Black, Hispanic and even White woman today; we have joy and pain, heartache, losses, and love. OR don’t go to see the movie Tyler won’t cry; go instead to see some of the JUNK that Hollywood is producing…… Sucker Punch, or Jackass 3D, or sit at home and watch The Wizard of OZ on TV… oh sorry, who wants to watch a 30 year old movie. Wake up. These stories need to be told. Have you read the newspapers recently….. stories of suicide, hatred, rape, domestic violence, it’s about time to educate and it really doesn’t matter who wrote the screen play or directed it.
Seymone, Amen, Amen. The movie really moved me and I can tell you that there were things in this movie that I’ve buried in my past that sometimes comes up to haunt me. I connected with this movie and after seeing it 6 hours ago, I’m still feeling the emotions of the movie.
Tyler, Oprah, Harper, Underwood I don’t care who brought this play to light, I’m touched and it has opened my eyes to be closer with my daughter and grandchild. The world it’s what is use to be in the 60′s and 70′s, all the evils of the world have come to light that most of us experience everyday still and are too afraid to speak out.
I love me, I love my life, I am in control of my life and no one, no one can will change or take away from ME.
So those who live in hate, continue living. When the self hate, self doubt, self abuse manifest be brave enough to tell your story for healing.
Amen – said the white, gay, man. This is exactly what I was thinking. This is an award winning play that was so important and is still relevant today. We must hear from our people’s mothers and fathers, our older sisters and our older brothers. And for everything I dislike about Tyler Perry’s comedic work, he has found an opportunity to take those already important stories and shine light upon them and in this illumination we can all reflect upon each other, with each other, for each other.
THANK YOU!! I was reading this “hata” mail also and ditto to your comments. It is time. It’s too many people/women/families in PAIN and it’s time for healing. Actually today the East End African American Museum (aka African American Museum of the East End-AAMEE)is sponsoring our 5th Annual Black Film Festival here in Southampton, NY (ya Black people live here) and one of our films will be “We Need to Talk” a conversation with the sistas (check out the trailer) produced/direcred by Janks Morton. The screenng will be followed by a Q&A lead my Janks. Like Janks and I agree but some folks aint ready….they rather…sit back in their STANK and spew nastyness..I pray for you too…that you too will one day wanna be free. IT”S TIME!!!
@ Seymone, I agree whole-heartedly & I too am amazed at all the negative comments. I did not see or know about the play, but after watching the movie, I will be educating myself about Ntozake Shange. Even if Tyler Perry had nothing to do with the movie, I would have gone to see it. These situations are still true today, as they were true long before Shange did her play & book years ago. Truth & honesty can be a tough pill to swallow. If anything is gained from the movie, I hope dialogue & position action will be reflected. What I took away from it is universal, Love Yourself, because if we truly love ourselves, we won’t get caught up in certain situations or know when to walk away when those situations arise before its too late.
I couldn’t agree more. It is always positive when someone of color gives back to their people. Although most may not like it this movie describes the lives of many people. Just because it isn’t a hot topic of discussion doesn’t mean that it’s fiction. This movie is emotional and concludes with a theme of overcoming the obstacles and problems that come your way, that even contracting H.I.V. doesn’t end your life. It’s bitter sweet.
I COMPLETELY agree with you. I don’t expect film critics to give this film high ratings. I wanted to see the film for me. I’m in my early 20′s and have come to the conclusion that if I can learn by listening, and not necessarily by experience, that’s the way to go. Exposure to films like this is not an opportunity women of color, or women period, get everyday. I appreciate the fact that Perry gave the script life, faces, and music. Like you said; if not him– then who. Many who never thought to read the script before will do it now and draw their own conclusions.
BRAVO TO SEYMONE and all who spoke up with her! The movie was AWESOME. As a poet it was truly amazing. As a woman it was deep and moving. As a black woman it was real. This story shows the struggles and sacrafices women make all in the name of love. It gives small clues as to why things are the way they are. It shows the bonds that we as women need to develop to grow. We need to learn to embrace one another and teach one another instead of hating and hurting one another for our personal gain. People dont kill the messenger(whom by the way did a wonderful job)listen to the message.
You said it all Seymone! This is art, and it should be seen. I also saw it on Broadway in the 70′s, and will see it again this week. What happened to women back then are just as shameful as what happens to women today. And yes, from a financial standpoint some people will gain. Others will have the opportunity to experience a part of history again. It may be ugly history, but there is always truth in art.
Thank you Seymone and Francine! You took the words right out of my mouth and said exactly what I was feeling as I read all the negative comments. When I saw the movie recently I wasn’t aware of all the negative views circulating about Tyler Perry’s involvment, and after seeing it, I’m certainly quite surprised by all the negativity. I absolutely loved the movie and plan to see it again soon. Who cares how long the play has been around? Love’s been around for a long time too, is that a reason to stop loving?
Seymone, in answer to your question if not Perry, then who? The answer is simple: Nzingha Stewart, the black female director originally slated to write, direct and produce the film before Perry took it from her.
I am excited about the movie. I plan to solicite other black girls to attend. I am hoping that with much gossip…and publicity… as women do…the seats will fill.
The publicity from Broke Back Mountain caused others to inquire and fill the seats.
I must commend Tyler for taking that risk. I have not seen so many black women in a movie that is not surrounded by the atrocities of the slave plantation. Excellent Characters
Tyler Perry offers a forum for each black women to “strut their stuff, exercise their talent, and show the world that we too can act.”
I JUST SAW THIS MOVIE AND IT IS A MUST SEE! IT MADE ME LAUGH, CRY…I WAS ANGRY, SCHOCKED AND FELT FOR EACH AND EVERY ONE OF THE NINE WOMEN. FORGET ABOUT THE PLAY! TYLER PERRY NOT ONLY TRANSFORMED THIS MOVIE FOR OUR TIME, BUT HAS CAPTURED THE INTENSITY AND EMOTIONS THAT MANY OF WOMEN TODAY FACE. AS MUCH AS THIS MOVIE IS IN YOUR FACE, IT WILL DEFINATLY HIT YOU HEART AND SOUL LIKE NOTHING HAS EVER!
The question is “Who the hell wants to go see a movie based on a thirty-five year old play?”.
Me. Thank you Tyler Perry. It is a movie for ALL to see. Again, Thank You Tyler Perry. Great job.
i think it was a very good idea that tyler perry made this movie..at least some one is giving recongnition to theses beautiful women who have struggled through life of love and lost…he is always looking at a womens prospective and alot of women shoot him down when they complain about how a man dont understand them well here you go….Mr. Perry he is phenomenial!
THIS PLAY HAS HAD MY THOUGHTS CHANGING SINCE I FIRST VIEWED IT IN THE LATE 70′S. I AM A FATHER OF GIRLS, RAISED BY A FATHER THAT DIDN’T ALLOW ME HIS ONLY SON TO YELL, HIT OR THREATEN MY SISTERS. I’VE KNOWN WHAT MEN THINK LIKE, I ALSO KNOW THAT WITH SOME HELP FROM A LOVING MALE ROLE MODLE, THEIR APPROACH AND VENTURE INTO THE WORLD CAN BE MADE AS SAFE AS A LIFE CAN BE FOR COLORED GIRLS IN THE 21ST CENTRY. MORE MALES NEED TO UNDERSTAND THAT THESE ARE THE WOMEN THAT WILL TEACH THEIR CHILDREN ABOUT THE WORLD, THAT DOING AS A MAN PLEASES IS NOT ALL THERE IS TO BEING A MAN. THANK YOU TYLER
I won’t speak to the larger issues referenced in this post, but that was a very effective movie trailer. I expect it would generate high levels of interest.
Perry got a lot of fine talent to make the movie in spite of the outcry that Nikke’s article exposed. That said, the trailer is a dud, the only good thing about it is the music.
Will this be the film to get Perry attention come Oscar time?
“Will this be the film to get Perry attention come Oscar time?
I think that was the plan, considering that the release date was .moved up from early 2011 to Nov 2010. The original release date would have meant waiting another year for a nomination; many people would have forgotten sbout the film by then.
Congrats to the editor for making what is almost certainly going to be another terrible movie by Perry look decent.
Seriously, the man is an abomination. I want to punch him in the face every time I see his smug mug on a screen.
We’ll see, but something like this calls for a real director like oh, I dunno… Lee Daniels or Carl Franklin, or even the lesser known Samm Styles.
I’d rather Brett Ratner direct this than Perry.
The person for the job of writing and directing should have been Kasi Lemmons. ‘Nuff said.
wow curious what are you doing to give back and plant a seed of change?
Let me preface this by saying: I can’t stand Tyler Perry. But damn it if this isn’t the first film I’d actually spend a modicum of money to see. Does Perry have artistic integrity? Maybe not, but at least he does something many others aren’t doing in this industry: giving minorities a voice in a predominantly bland conversation. Should a woman of color be telling this story? 99/100 of time I’d say yes, however, there is no one stepping up to.
Basically, there are preferred people to tell this tale, though in this current moment in history, I see no one else capable of doing so.
It’s not that no one else is incapable of doing so, just that no one else is currently doing so.
And I agree with the other poster. Regardless of what you think of Perry’s work, he does give people of color a voice in Hollywood. We need more people like that. We have diversity in our world. Why not in our entertainment?
Maybe he’s got some heretofore unknown genius type filmmaking ability that will reveal itself with the film. It’s possible. Just like it’s possible that our economy will switch back from a service economy (flipping burgers and changing bedpans) to a manufacturing and information technology economy and everyone will get jobs next year.
.
.
.
{crickets}
Nikki: First time commenting, long time reader of the blog but I think this argument is going to skew generationally. Women Oprah’s age and older actually got a chance to read the original material and see the play. For me and many younger people it was material we had heard about but not seen so this will be our first exposure to it. The trailer came out yesterday and there were many comments on Twitter #FORCOLOREDGIRLS and on Tyler’s Facebook page and if you go there you will see that based on the performances of the actresses in the movie (and their popularity in the community), many are excited to see this film and have judged it to be a “can’t wait until Nov” experience.
You can also be sure that if Oprah did put her hand in it then she will have Tyler and all of the actresses on her Farewell Season show to promote it with a full audience of women who have seen the movie and will scream about it like they just won a trip to Australia.
Ultimately, it will come down to the film itself, will he have surrounded himself with enough filmmakers and actors to make it a story worth seeing. And that decision will be made by the most part of an audience of 18-30 years who have no connection with the original story.
I still absolutely hate the fact that Tyler was allowed to touch this project, but I will say that the trailer actually doesn’t look terrible. Stellar cast, too.
I guess I’ll wait until after I see the film to lose my mind. I know Tyler Perry has good intentions, but he’s just such a talentless, recycling hack, I can’t take ot.
For Colored Girls, the play, now the movie, joins a long list of so-called works of art (Women of Brewster Place, The Color Purple and on and on) that exist for the sole purpose of showing black men as monsters. Oh, ad Precious to the heap.
If a black woman writer wants to score big, just write something about a black woman being a)raped b)beaten c) incessted (I know it’s not a word) d)ripped off financially e)destroyed psychologically. That’s it.
Look at Tyler’s work. See above. The black female as victim, not of a racist society, but as a victim of brutal, evil, sick black men. Lovely, isn’t it?
As Paul Mooney so eloquently stated: How could a black man read Precious and want to promote that as a film. More poverty porn Pushed by Tyler.
The author of For Colored Girls Ntozoke nee Paulette Williams who wrote this so-called truth, this poverty porn, is the daughter of a prominent doctor from New Jersey, elite educated, summered in Sag Harbor. Why didn’t she write about that? Because you can’t make money writing about upper class blacks.
It’s interesting that Tyler was so excited to make this work because Precious was just as retro.
There is not a single thing that Tyler has done for black people to proud of proud of. Nothing. Madea, his movies, and his TV shows are modern incarnations of Stephin Fetchit. The difference is Fetchit had no choice is what he did. He had to do the coon show. Tyler can do what he wants.
So get ready for another “po black woman gettin’ her ass beat by dis’ evil beast, excuse me, black man.” My friends joke that he’s set the race back 100 years. No, he’s set the race back 150 years. It’s sad to say, but true, no WHITE, man would create art like this today. They did in the past, Al Jolson, Amos & Andy, but not today.
Tyler gets a pass because he’s black. He has free reign to slander black people in general (see the buffoonery on those TV shows– saucer eyes, head bucking, “feets don’t fail me now”); and slander black men in his movies.
Congratulations, Tyler, creator of the Coon Cartoon. You’ve done it again.
Amen brother! Nothing but the truth was spoken here.
God I hope you’re white too, that’d be awesome.
All you did was speak the truth. Your feedback was quite insightful.
((THUNDEROUS APPLAUSE!!!!!))
Just don’t forget who greenlights this evil…
Re: “As Paul Mooney so eloquently stated: How could a black man read Precious and want to promote that as a film.”
I guess neither of you recall the nurse in that film. Since you missed it- he (black male)showed Precious and the audience an alternative archetype to her (black male) father ie. a strong, handsome, healthy, sensitive black man in a care-taking role.
“…he (black male)showed Precious and the audience an alternative archetype to her (black male) father ie. a strong, handsome, healthy, sensitive black man in a care-taking role.”
Big deal…there was also a handsome, healthy, sensitive, caring Black male nurse in “Angels in America”–and THAT character was gay. Perry hasn’t included a single GLBT character in his cinematic or TV canon (and a heterosexual male acting like a gay male in drag doesn’t count…not by the longest shot).
Honest Abe is tha man. Well put.
@Honest Abe: Was on the set of For Colored Girls and one of the main actors did tell me that there will pretty much be NO GOOD dudes in this film. Apparently (saying this because I have not seen the film), the only good guy in the film is light-skinned lol – who I met and he’s a great guy so I support him. But, overall, I know folks will have something to say about that after the movie is released.
I feel that this comment is so..off the mark, that I had to respond. The truth of the matter is that there is a disconnceted in the African American community. There are so many of our men in prison, absent from the lives of their children and disregarding their roles as men. Make no mistake, there is a disconnect. How many African American women have been victims of sexual abuse, rape, domestic volence, and used by men? The answer is TOO MANY. While this does not nigate the plight of other women, lets face facts. We are suffering as a whole. You stated that Mr. Perry has done nothing to be proud of, but you should know that you could not be more wrong. I am not a huge fan of Tyler, but I am proud of his accomplishments. I am proud that he has set a standard in that he has put actors in films, that have not been given much of a chance to play a leading role. I am proud that he has introduced talents in his plays. Do I like the whole madea thing? At first, but now it is gone too far. So I like the House of Payne? At first, but now it is no longer what it started out to be. Somewhere done the road Mr. Perry compromised. Instead of remaining the same in his spiritual walk, he began to lag, compromise and back off of standing on a strong foundation. This will become more evident if his change is not made soon. Nevertheless, your comment was, in my opinion, driven by hate that blind you to the fact of women’s plight. Should perry have made this movie? I am not sure; however, seeing that the cast are all women I am sure that he had plenty of help in the direction of the film.
Whats interesting, many AA want to believe that art depicts life events. A small percentage of that is true. A greater percentage is entertainment. Latino’s and Anglo Saxons do not do the same. They can be depicted as the worst serial killer…. pill-pusher…and are often chased and killed by the mass murderer. etc…. You will not see them in lines protesting…. as long as they have an acting job and brinking in the big bucks…..
Movies are a depiction of art. The producer can be as creative and innovative as he wants to be. He/she may not gain the interest of all….however, the faithful few can make a difference.
If you do not like the depiction of art….go to another theatre. Movies allow you to interface with another world…the world of make-believe; fact; fiction; terror, and surrealism.
The audience pay to choose what moment in time they want to be in.
JUST DONT GO…
Angry much.
Black people like you will complain no matter what is on film – I’m a filmmaker and although I don’t write films like Tyler Perry I do appreciate his work. His characters are doctors, lawyers, authors, business owners, yet Black people still scream and complain … if he was to do a hood movie with all the Black characters as drug dealers and pimps Black people will still complain….sensitive, angry Black men like yourself are still complaining about The Color Purple…get over it!
These stories and experiences were written by Black women who express their personal experiences or perspectives…unapologetically and unconcerned that your feelings are hurt. You are the same person that would probably complain about Black Gay Men in a film – - guess what THEY EXIST and it has nothing to do with YOU. The only think that would make the Black Snob Bourgeois Elite happy is if everything Black on Film was portrayed perfectly. You are the same sellouts that smile in front of whitey, hoping to get a cookie for good behaviors. Thank God for people like Tyler Perry, who knows is audience, this film will be #1 … and you will continue to be angry while life goes on. Remember WE complained about the Cosby Show and Good Times and The Jeffersons…
I’m over my Black snobs who need to really look in the mirror and find the root to why they re so scared of how we as Black people are portrayed on film…I’m tired of you “always looking to please whitey, scared of being judged” motherfugggas!
Carlton Jordan – look me up!
PS and if you had half a brain Nikki you would know this film is going to be #1 and most of the Black people, outside of the two you know will see this film.
That was funny! I love your comment. No matter what you do people will complain, I dont like all of the characters in his movies sometimes, but he has a great body of work. IDK why people are hating on TP….I can relate to all of his work as a black 32 year old woman in America. If he did my life story it would be worse than Precious probably. lol
well spoken honesty, i love it!
I’ll say this, thank God for Typer Perry, yes some of his TV shows as silly but everyone of all age and race understands what he’s trying to say what message he is delivering so what if it comes through corny comedy, do shoot the messenger, appreciate the message. as for his movie for colored girls and precious; Tyler is telling the story for those of us that never told that still carry that rape our incest in our hearts and souls, yes it does happen even today and obviously alot of people are unware of this which is why Tyler tells the story he tells. just because you don’t understand it doesn’t mean you should mock it. Tyler has the support of so many because he’s talkign about what it’s like for many of us to be black.
So Tyler Perry shouldn’t make movies about women because Oprah and an an anonymous black woman said not to? If only movies can stand on their own without the need of a faux controversy. The bigger controversy is why so few medium/big budget films don’t star minority actors still in 2010. If there were more movie choices out there besides the 3 black films a year then people would care less about this particular film. Takers and Karate Kid while not great both made money. No doubt Tyler Perry’s film will do well too. So why do black films (non gangster/drug related/fat suit) still have to prove those films can make money in this day and age. For the life of me I can’t imagine JJ Abrahms or Christopher Nolan needing to get the ok from Steve Jobs in order to make a film. Yet there is this media created perception that Perry or any other filmmaker has to get the ok from Oprah and Spike Lee to make movies about black folks.
I remember Perry’s comments regarding all Hollywood when he bashed every executive in town thus alienating himself as a filmmaker. Yes, Tyler- your films reach an audience that Hollywood isn’t able to reach. I’ll give you that. But there truly is no accounting for quality or taste with the stereotypes you create. Audiences continue to flock to your opening weekends, but they always leave outraged when the houselights come up.
I hate Tyler Perry.
But that trailer has POWER.
For those of you who say you hate Tyler Perry, do you know him enough to hold such aggression towards him? You hate a man for following his dreams in life to direct, produce, write, etc. Stop hating all of your life and spend that time constructively to pursue YOUR OWN DREAMS in life. If you don’t like his work don’t pay to see it, there are plenty of other people that write, produce, direct, etc… find those who live up to your expectations and support their work instead, it doesn’t take a genius to figure that one out.(Don’t like it….Don’t see it)
Why was such a brilliant and beautiful play even turned into a film? This work was meant for the stage.
Your comment is the first to make the most important point..or if it needed to be revived it should be as the play. The whole propose of the play will be destroyed as a movie
The trailer doesn’t look bad at all. In fact, it looks pretty decent compared to the awful melodrama-cum-comedic films on Perry’s resume. But we’ll see what unfolds when it comes out.
Movie looks interesting. Wonder what a woman might have done with the writing & direction.
I think many black women resent Perry because his movies tend to be condescending towards them. There’s also a subtle misogyny that lies beneath the surface of his films.
Did anyone see the hilarious and vicious satire the “Boondocks” cartoon did about Perry? Sheesh! That show fried Perry’s butt and served it up on a plate!
“…a subtle misogyny…”
Yeah…as subtle as a safe dropped from a 100-story building.
The playwright supported the film.
This looks good to me. It’s by far one of the best trailers I’ve seen all year. Half the people who are likely to go to see the movie probably weren’t even born yet when the play was produced on Broadway in 1977.
I don’t think Tyler Perry has anything to worry about given his track record. And with that cast? It’s probably going to be his best film ever.
KP
I dont know who these black women are who have supposedly expressed “horror” at the prospect of Perry writing and directing this adaptation of an iconic piece, but I doubt they exist in numbers large enough to impact box office revenue.
The sad truth is that this is 2010, not 1975. When I saw the play during its original run, it was with a group of girlfriends. We were bright and insightful young women on our way to college and well beyond. We cared about how we were portrayed on stage because we were brimming with pride and self-respect.
Today, black women happily embrace all manner of black male
“artists” dedicated to teaching little black boys to refer to little black girls as “b!tches” and “hos” deserving of being beaten to a pulp at will. So I doubt that women who embrace the T.I.s and Chris Browns of the world will suddenly rise up in box office revolt just because one gay guy makes a film about a group of women whose thoughts and feelings are alien to him.
The trailer looks ok (though it could have been more coherently edited) and “Colored Girls” will do fine at the box office. Black women who ravenously lap up each serving of misogynistic rap and hip hop sludge are not likely to suddenly develop a discerning, socio-political eye.
Nikki – a lot of us dont find Madea ‘loathsome’ – in our neighborhood she reminds us of a lot of those ‘neighborhood ladies’ who would tell you to shape up when Mom wasnt around.
Colored Girls’ was a product of its time and hugely popular but basically a minor play that could only have gotten stage time at the height of the feminist wave. Without a Tyler Perry it is probaby a project nobody would touch – not worth their while and not a guaranteed earner. If Oprahs reaction echoed outrage, why didnt she think it was worth doing? How dare you? Well, why didn’t YOU?
Much ado about nothing! Let’s see the d*mn movie first before giving melodramatic judgments.
Besides, no one flinched when Kathryn Bigelow directed an all-male troop in “Hurt Locker.”
Hmmmm….. not. quite. the same.
It’s interesting how you have thoroughly missed the point here. This play is beloved, and very hard to adapt, so anyone doing it would have faced a lot of opposition. Yes, Tyler Perry has a certain cache that makes him an easy target, but trust me, the controversy you are trying to stir up here is not going to change the minds of people who can’t get past him handling it. If anything, there are a lot of people who love the play enough that they will flock to see it to see the characters come to life, Oprah or not Oprah. The poems encompass every woman, not just black women, so I hope that you as a woman who I would think wants to see our stories told, will support this rather then giving in to idle gossip.
Of course, it is impossible to tell from a disjointed trailer like that one what the finished film will be, but here’s the thing….
That’s a good trailer. I’d go see that film. And I’m a white guy in his 40s, not the target audience I suppose. But it’s an effective trailer; it caught my attention and made me want to see more.
Now, if Medea shows up in one frame, I am outta there, but otherwise, let’s see what the film is actually like before we start shaping the usual Deadline Readers balls of poo to fling at it.
As an African-American, I often cringe at the simplistic storylines in his films that so often are full of stereotypes; that being said, this film, based on a classic, will be profitable.
The trailer is good. The movie has excellent and well known actors in the Afr-Am community that will save his mediocre script, which i read, and there has been a lot of publicity surrounding this adaption. Yes, his tv shows are horrendous and the Madea movies are appalling (in my opinion), but one cannot deny that he knows his niche and makes profitable content…and THAT is the bottom line. He has the work ethic to consistently churn out material and if we are purchasing it, then i cant knock his hustle, even if i can knock his garbage.
I was scared as hell to see TP go near this project. Until I saw this trailer. Now I’m about 30% less afraid!
I still think he should have passed the director’s chair over to Gina Prince Blythewood. She would have nailed this!