Masterpiece’s Fall kicks off on Sunday, October 3 with the second series of Wallander, the Swedish detective portrayed by Kenneth Branagh, memorably described by one critic as “having the permanent mien of a recently slaughtered halibut”. British critics have found series two relentlessly gloomy, although they couldn’t find much to criticise in the acting, stories or production design. The Sunday Times called it “close to perfect” while the Telegraph called this new miniseries “top-notch”. Branagh tracks murderers across the beautifully photographed, yet roiling with evil, farm country of southern Sweden. BBC Worldwide hopes that Wallander will sell as well internationally as ITV’s Inspector Morse did, which sold to more than 200 territories. Both shows share the same confounding storylines — with the solution to the mystery pleasingly beyond the ken of most TV viewers — and the same fjord-like glacial pacing.
Sunday, October 23 sees the BBC’s acclaimed modern-day retelling of Sherlock begins for three consecutive weeks. To be honest, I couldn’t see the point of
updating the Conan Doyle stories to 21st century London, especially coming so soon after Guy Ritchie’s Sherlock Holmes being released at Christmas. After all, the Holmes character has provided the template for so many TV detectives from Horatio Caine in CSI: Miami to Doctor Gregory House (as in Holmes, geddit?) to the Beeb’s own Luther. Cor blimey guv’nor, I didn’t ‘alf call that one wrong. Sherlock, written by Doctor Who writers Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss, was the Beeb’s runaway summer hit. Jay Hunt, controller of BBC One, announced she was commissioning three more TV movies at the Edinburgh TV fest. The improbably-named Benedict Cumberbatch plays Holmes and Martin Freeman is sidekick Doctor Watson as they investigate a wave of suicides; a bomber who straps explosives to innocent people and then has them taunt Holmes with baffling mysteries; and a killer who seemingly walks through walls. Freeman has reportedly turned down starring in The Hobbit to concentrate on filming this second series – which has left MGM and New Line execs scrabbling to try and accommodate shooting the Lord of the Rings prequel around the BBC. UK culture minister Jeremy Hunt, who normally spends his time taking hefty kicks at Auntie, even praised the show as “a very good example of the BBC at its best, investing in new programming” in UK Parliament. This new BBC retelling should have plenty of time of establish itself in US viewers’ minds before Ritchie’s Baker Street sleuth returns in Christmas 2011.
Framed (Sunday, November 14) is a one-off feature-length drama starring Trevor Eve. Flooding at the National Gallery forces the curator (Eve) to return the entire collection to the disused quarry in North Wales where the paintings had been stored during the Second World War. Cue just about every fish-out-of-water cliché you can think of as the skinny moccachino-sipping metropolitan comes up against eccentric yet well-meaning yokels. Framed is an Ealing-type comedy “so warm-hearted and well-intentioned that you’d have to work hard to dislike it,” said the Times of London. The script is by Michael Winterbottom’s regular scriptwriter Frank Cottrell-Boyce, based on his own novel.
Christopher Eccleston (GI Joe) stars as John Lennon in Lennon Naked (November 21), a TV movie first shown on arts channel BBC4 over here. The TV movie goes into Lennon’s relationship with his boozy absentee father, and how Lennon replicated this distant relationship with his own son, Julian. Critics were harsh about casting Eccleston as Lennon, who, at 46 they said was too old (Lennon was approaching 30 during events depicted). The New Statesman called Eccleston “disastrous”, while the Daily Mail said the whole TV movie “just didn’t work”.


Some of us over here in USAland have already seen the Beeb’s Sherlock. It takes all three episodes to get it — and it’s worth the trip, despite a second episode that doesn’t match its bookends. Episodes 1 & 3 really break some new ground for TV storytelling for the Internet Age and writers should pay attention to them. There was a Sherlock Holmes movie in theaters? Not according to the blastings it got on Twitter!
I agree that it would be a huge mistake to dismiss this Sherlock as an unecessary remake. It somehow manages to be both faithful to the original stories and brings in something new and fresh. I found the Guy Richie Sherlock tedious and even people who liked it won’t feel like they are watching an immitation of anything with the BBC version.
I haven’t yet seen the BBC Sherlock myself beyond one or two very short promotional clips, but it’s received an immense amount of positive buzz among online genre TV fandom (and a lot of that fandom has seen it via the same channels that they get current Doctor Who episodes faster than the Beeb can officially license them into the US market).
From the glimpse I’ve had, I am not sure the Moffat/Gatiss version will be my cup of tea — but I can certainly see why people are intrigued, and not only for the erotic chemistry some parts of fandom are seeing between Holmes and Watson in this interpretation. (I hasten to note that those parts of fandom have been seeing that chemistry in Doyle’s own material for decades now, so the idea itself isn’t particularly new.)
Certainly Sherlock is a very different animal than the Ritchie project, and I see no reason why both shouldn’t prosper. (And as for Holmes imitators already on US TV, surely Simon Baker’s The Mentalist is one of the most direct copyists, given that that character relies explicitly on reading visual and behavioral cues to make Holmesian deductions of exactly the kind Doyle illustrates in the original stories.)
PBS has become so prudish over the past decade that I wonder if viewers will actually get to see John Lennon (and Yoko Ono) naked as they take their famous nude picture?
Over the past few years, PBS has simply removed nudity by editing out the “offending” frames (often making it very obvious that something has been cut out, as they did in The Last Enemy and A Room With A View). I wouldn’t be surprised if they cut the scene altogether – PBS already edits 90-minute shows like Lewis and Foyle’s War so they can add their pointless Masterpiece intro and closing.
“Christopher Eccleston (GI Joe)” Really? He was the first of the new Doctors Who (this being a BBC story and all). Using GI Joe as a credit is just hurtful.
I’ve only seen the first Sherlock program, but it was enjoyable enough to want to see the others (I could have done with less of the mobile phone texts on screen, though). Freeman definitely has a face for combining solid drama with comedic timing…
I like totally agree man.
I’ve seen the first three episodes of the modern-dress “Sherlock” and the series is both faithful to the spirit of the original stories and innovative in its reinterpretation. It’s particularly adept in updating the Holmes era to present-day England in terms of customs, technology, and attitude. Let’s see how much of that makes it across the pond by the time the show is remixed.
someone already mentioned that you chose GI Joe as the identifier for Christopher Eccleston instead Doctor Who… shame on you. That film was horrid, and he was fantastic as The Doctor.
But more to the point… if you’d actually looked for real reviews of Lennon Naked, you’d have found that nearly every one of the people who thought that Eccleston was too old *changed* their mind after actually seeing the film. He may be older than the Lennon he’s portraying, but he’s a marathon runner and is physically much younger than his chronological age… and he was brilliant in it. He looks exactly like Lennon and while not trying to mimic him, picked up many of his mannerism and was remarkable. Yes, I’ve seen it. And I’ll watch it again when PBS broadcasts it.
Personally, I think that Sherlock is an amazing show. From the minute I first saw it, I was immediately attached. It is like totally fantabulous dudes. Sherlock Holmes is awesome and brilliant! Not to mention funny. It is a shame that there is only three episodes. I vote the producers make more. CREATE MORE EPISODES!
I thought the new sherlock Holmes on PBS was great and I hope they make more episodes!!!!!
more Sherlock episodes please!!!