
The Academy Of Motion Picture Arts & Science’s official private weekend screenings for voting members are generally a must-stop for serious Oscar contenders, not only to show the films to voters all at once but also to gauge reaction both audibly during the film and by buzz in the lobby and restrooms after. After complaints about the quality of some the films shown, the Academy last year revamped the committee that chooses them and now seems much more savvy about booking movies that aren’t wasting members’ time – or so they’d like to think. While some fluff still gets screened, the cinematic menu this time of year turns to a heavy sked of Oscar prospects.
Not everything gets booked because there are basically just four slots each weekend: two matinees and two evening shows. But of the 10 pictures nominated last year, only The Blind Side, which seemed to catch even Warner Bros by surprise, did not play at one of these screenings.
In terms of this year’s Oscar contenders, it was a big weekend for Ben Affleck’s The Town (which he directed and co-wrote and stars in for Warner Bros and Legendary Pictures) which topped the weekend box office with nearly $24 million. That was a bit of a surprise, particularly for an adult-skewing drama (albeit one with a LOT of action in it). Then again, it had a 94% fresh critical rating on Rotten Tomatoes. But what was really significant awards-wise is that I hear it had a smash screening at the Academy’s Samuel Goldwyn Theatre in Beverly Hills on Saturday night. So you have a film right out of the gate among Fall releases that looks to be a serious awards prospect.
Even though the movie’s official Academy screening was skedded just as Yom Kippur was ending, the turnout was larger than normal and the response at the end very enthusiastic. A 2-time Oscar winner who frequently attends these private weekend screenings for voting members told me, “There was big loud applause at the end credits — and that’s something I rarely see at the Academy.” He went on to praise the film as easily one of the best he has seen there in some time (and, interestingly, he’s not impressed with much of the 2010 output so far). He singled out Affleck’s direction and the acting ensemble for particular kudos. Two other Academy members who saw the film at non-Academy screenings told me the same thing. So Warners could have another contender like The Town producer Graham King’s The Departed (2006) which the studio launched in early fall in low-key, almost non-existent, Oscar campaign mode and craftily rode all the way to Best Picture glory.
Never Let Me Go, Jack Goes Boating, and Catfish, also unspooled at the Academy this weekend. Upcoming films next Saturday and Sunday are Oliver Stone’s Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps, Woody Allen’s You Will Meet A Tall Dark Stranger, Legends Of The Guardian: The Owls Of Ga’Hoole, and Oscar-winner Davis Guggenheim’s education documentary Waiting For Superman.
October starts out with a biggie, The Social Network on the 2nd, and the month will also feature high profile hopefuls like Tamara Drewe, Secretariat, Conviction, Hereafter, Company Men, Let Me In, Stone, and Nowhere Boy. Mixed in are documentaries looking for attention like Inside Job, 100 Voices: A Journey Home, Sicilian Girl, and Something’s Gonna Live, although the latter two have already come and gone in local theatres.
A 2008 Tribeca Film Festival title, 2-time Oscar nominee Bill Plympton’s little known feature toon, Idiots And Angels will play on Halloween. (Perhaps hoping to drum up some buzz for a run at Animated feature?) There will also be purely commercial titles such as You Again, Easy A, Red, and Life As We Know It thrown into the mix for members who just want to go to something that isn’t overtly being “positioned” for the season.
Finally, The Girl Who Kicked The Hornet’s Nest, the third and final entry in Sweden’s Lizbeth Salander trilogy will play at the Goldwyn on October 24th. It’s significant because neither of the first two films, The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo and The Girl Who Played With Fire, screened for the Academy. Now with some Oscar buzz brewing for star Noomi Rapace, the films’ distributor Music Box clearly is seeing the value of getting her exposure in front of these voters even though the only one of the 3 pics likely eligible for an Oscar will be Dragon Tattoo since the latter two, including Hornet’s Nest, were made originally for Swedish television.
Awards Columnist Pete Hammond - tip him here.


The Town was far from Oscar worthy.. Great entertainment but not intelligent enough to be taken seriously.
well Avatar wasn’t Oscar worthy either…
I stopped going to the Academy screenings because the seats are old and uncomfortable. With most theaters now having stadium seating, it isn’t worth the cost of a movie ticket to have to dodge someone’s head sitting in the seat in front of me. The Academy needs to move into the 21st century and upgrade their facility. But I do appreciate the opportunity the screenings give for members who might not be able to see some of the films screened.
“The Town” was amazing and 100% Oscar Worthy
Rebecca Hall in The Town, best supporting actress methinks!
“There was big loud applause at the end credits — and that’s something I rarely see at the Academy.”
We hear this EVERY year from these screenings that the response was really large for certain movies and how it’s “surprising” or what have you. Every single year.
Well I still recall an Academy screening of “Everyone Says I Love You” that was interrupted at least 3 times by wild applause, and again at the end, and yet wasn’t nominated for best pic. Then again in this era of the inflated-steroided 10 noms, anything is possible.
Agree it was good entertainment with a few great acting turns. Rebecca wasn’t one of those, she was good and OK but it wasn’t a big acting step. If it holds your attention and it’s entertaining that’s a big move toward best picture.
A little bang-bang, a little romance, nice visuals and solid performances. Will it be the worst film to be nominated? No. Will it be the best? No way. But perhaps because such fare is rare (well done adult drama) folks are singing its praises a little too loudly. There are a lot of “Oscar worthy” films that get over looked, and a few subpar movies that get the nod…will I be outraged if this film gets a few awards? No, but that doesn’t mean it’s the worthiest choice.
“…not only to show the films to voters all at once but also to gauge reaction both audibly during the film and by buzz in the lobby and restrooms after.”
I’m curious, does the guy/gal who has the job of hanging out in the bathroom and gauging response “buzz” have the same chance for upward industry trajectory as does the guy/gal who starts out in the storied mailrooms? If not, I’m guessing the “bathroom-gauger” job isn’t too enviable.
The Town should remain on everyone’s radar, but I think it is a bit silly to put it in the big ten until a few others in front of it fail. But that’s just me.
Saw 100 Voices: A Journey Home in Toronto last night and was blown away. Beautiful film!
But again this goes to show you how the adult demographic is really starving for entertainment that doesn’t involve capes and alien invasions. Was it a great movie that makes you question your existence in the universe? No, but it was a story for the most part that was well told. You look at Gone Baby Gone and The Town and you actually feel like you’re in Boston. Affleck uses the locales as an extention for his characters which is extremely hard to pull off without calling attention to itself.
It wasn’t a great movie, but I definitely admire the craft that went into it. I got my money’s worth. Oscar noms for directing and supporting actors for Renner and Postlewaite I think are assured. They were fantastic. You can’t say they that they sucked.
Re “Hard to pull off without calling attention to itself.”…
That’s debatable. I think it’s kind of lame to have to put your hometown and your favorite baseball team into evvvvvvery single thing. But then I DO hate the Celtics and the Redsox, so there’s that.
At a minimum, this is a viable entry in the Best Picture: Boston category.
Come on, THE FIGHTER, whattaya got? It’s been like ten minutes since I watched a movie that discussed the myriad lore of Southie.
The Town is a tricky film to forecast oscar-wise, because it starts rather tame (especially Affleck’s performance) but builds, and builds, and builds so that by the crescendo climax, you’re so enthralled you can’t help but think, “Sure, I’d nominate it.”
If I can put District 9 on my top 10 list last year, I can start this year’s list with “The Town” at a solid #10.
The town was a high budget TV movie with cliched characters. It required a tremendous suspension of disbelief. An Academy Award? Please…
Looking like a great year for movies, with some nice surprises. The Town looks great.
Also, looking forward to Guggenheim’s education documentary Waiting For Superman. Timing could not be better with so many states now re-considering their broken, bloated education systems.
Hey leaders of the Teacher’s Union – Listening?
yeah, it’s all the teachers fault, blah, blah, blah… not the administrators who really make the difference, not the parents who are responsible for the earliest learning in a child’s life (something all experts agree has the biggest effect on future learning), not the voters who have decided to underfund education, not the politicians who put unrealistic testing in place to accompany the underfunding, and not the students themselves who often only want to be entertained and supported by their parents forever… just the evil teacher’s union.
I’m not blaming teachers, but the typical leaders of the teacher’s unions. They typically don’t have the kids or the good teacher’s interests as a priority. It’s a broken system that needs reform. Just watch (or listen to the podcast) about “The Rubber Room”. It’s crazy and inexcusable. Any idea how much the head of NJ’s teacher’s union makes? $550,000/year. Give me a break.
That said, parents need to step up as well. Our world has been transformed compared to just a few decades ago with both parents working jobs and there aren’t any 9 to 5 jobs left with Blackberries, laptops, etc.
And don’t get me started about politicians- both ends of the spectrum have failed and too many appear solely interested in getting re-elected vs making the tough choices (i.e., higher taxes and cutting spending).
Did they like ‘Never let me go’ ?
I agree with most of the responses up here. It was a great film, probably will get nominated, but should not win “Best Picture.” For those of you that say otherwise, just remember there were a couple nominations last year that were MUCH worse…
The Town is nothing more that Heat Lite. If Heat didn’t get nominated for any awards, why is The Town getting all the award buzz?
Agree, agree! Heat minus Pacino and De Niro in Boston. The 30+ crowd is begging for a decent movie. I don’t know about an Oscar but it was a decent movie.
Hey Ben, we’ve seen Good Will Hunting, and ESPN gives you plenty of face time every time they televise a Red Sox game. We know you’re from Boston and proud of it, but all that Boston in the movie was distracting. Almost as distracting as the accent, yelling, fighting, and cheering every time a Red Sox/Patriots/Celtics game is on at a sports bar.
They are getting a bit ahead of themselves – the Town is fine but not Oscar worthy.
I saw The Town this weekend and have to say that I liked it every bit as much as Heat. Affleck’s performance was very controlled and his direction was first-rate. The action was terrific, the characters were people I didn’t necessarily like, but I sure wanted to see what happened to them next and there wasn’t a single performance that wasn’t believable. I will definitely see it again and expect Renner to get an Oscar nomination at least.
This Is It! LOL
does anyone remember Shutter Island?
Nope. Probably not.
Really liked The Town. This movie would not be half of what it is without Jeremy Renner’s AWESOME performance!
The committee still doesn’t have it right. This is the Academy, and all the big films will be inviting them to premieres, lunches, parties and they have the money to do pre-nom screenings all over town for months (screenings at private screening rooms for AMPAS and guild members only).
In the past this committee had their head up their arse and made their picks based on who knows who with no regard for awards worthiness.
What this committee should pick, and they should attend a press screening before their decide (which they do not–they pick totally on word of mouth and credits), are films that don’t have the big studio budget for an awards campaigns but have award worthy: scripts, performances, crafts work. These in between films can so benefit from an official Academy Screening because these films don’t have the money for a Best Picture, full pages of “For Your Consideration”ads and 20 screenings at privates screenings rooms. To say nothing of the parties and luncheons for AMPAS members at a minimum of $100+ per person. These are the films caught between a rock and a hard place and given that they are called the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, maybe they should support that in-between distributor that doesn’t have the big bucks but has a wonderful film that is deserving of nominations in some categories.
This committee at the Academy has been broken for a long time and still is in no way fixed!!!
THE TOWN is well executed but compromised by a high level of implausibility in the central relationship between the Affleck and Hall characters. I didn’t read the source material so don’t know if that’s where the problem lies, or if it’s in the screenplay. I suspect a good deal of what was shot with Hall and Affleck didn’t make it into the final cut. Renner’s performance is fine, allowing for the stereotypical character he’s portraying. (The performance doesn’t come close to what he was able to do with what he was given in THE HURT LOCKER.) The movie is entertaining as a generic, urban crime flick, but comparisons to THE DEPARTED are insulting to all those connected with that movie. Still, with 10 Best Pic slots, decent reviews and better-than-expected opening b.o., THE TOWN is a possible nom.
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo is overrated. One word came to mind after watching this film “fiction!”
I can’t see this getting any nominations outside of Renner.
If you strip The Town to its essence, it’s a ridiculous story.
Really? A bank robber falls in love with the bank teller who can identify him? Pure Hollywood baloney.
And that massive shootout at Fenway? Pure Hollywood baloney.
It’s only a testament to Affleck and his DP that the film stayed so grounded in its sense of place that you forget how ridiculous it really is.