
These are nowhere near as disturbing as the True Blood stars’ recent bloody nude Rolling Stone cover that still haunts me, but TV watchdog group the Parents Television Council is stirring things up this morning with its outrage over the racy photo shoot of the stars from Fox’s Glee in the upcoming issue of GQ, which it called a “near-pornographic display.” “It is disturbing that GQ, which is explicitly written for adult men, is sexualizing the actresses who play high school-aged characters on Glee in this way. It borders on pedophilia,” said PTC President Tim Winter.
“Sadly, this is just the latest example of the overt sexualization of young girls in entertainment.” With Glee slotted to air after the Super Bowl in January, I can actually see Fox’s point in popularizing the show among men. Remember Jimmy Kimmel’s zinger at the upfronts about the move? “Apparently, they are trying to set a new Guinness World
record for the most 43-year-old drunk guys saying ‘What the f**k is this?’ all at once.” Yes, the pictures are crossing a line and I find them distasteful, but frankly so are most magazine photos these days as publications scramble to make money. And despite playing teens, the Glee actors are all adults (Dianna Agron and Lea Michele are 24, Cory Monteith is 28). GQ editor-in-chief Jim Nelson released a statement defending the shoot: “The Parents Television Council must not be watching much TV these days and should learn to divide reality from fantasy. As often happens in Hollywood, these ‘kids’ are in their twenties. Cory Montieth’s almost 30! I think they’re old enough to do what they want.”
UPDATE THURSDAY AM: Glee‘s Dianna Agron, who was far more modest in her photos than co-star Lea Michele, weighed in on the controversy in a very personal post on her blog last night. Here is an excerpt:
In the land of Madonna, Britney, Miley, Gossip Girl, other public figures and shows that have pushed the envelope and challenged the levels of comfort in their viewers and fans…we are not the first. Now, in perpetuating the type of images that evoke these kind of emotions, I am sorry. If you are hurt or these photos make you uncomfortable, it was never our intention. And if your eight-year-old has a copy of our GQ cover in hand, again I am sorry. But I would have to ask, how on earth did it get there?… I understand that in today’s world of advanced technology, the internet, our kids can be subject to very adult material at the click of a button. But there are parental locks, and ways to get around this. I am twenty-four years old. I have been a pretty tame and easy-going girl my whole life. Nobody is perfect, and these photos do not represent who I am… Glee is a show that represents the underdogs, which is a feeling I have embraced much of my own life, and to those viewers, the photos in GQ don’t give them that same feeling. I understand completely… For GQ, they asked us to play very heightened versions of our school characters. A ‘Hit Me Baby One More Time’ version. At the time, it wasn’t my favorite idea, but I did not walk away…I’m moving forward from this one, and after today, putting it to rest… These aren’t photos I am going to frame and put on my desk, but hey, nor are any of the photos I take for magazines.
TV Editor Nellie Andreeva - tip her here.



Well – DUH!!!! not that shocking since this is an 8 pm show that had girl on girl action last week.
So it would have been appropriate for 8 PM is was girl on boy action, but suddenly girl on girl makes it inappropriate for the same time slot?
Girl on Girl is cool for 8 however “scissoring” is not
wrong… “scissoring” is WAY cool.
‘scissor me timbers!’ – “mrs.” garrison
Scissor me timbers!
They had scissoring? I need to start watching this show.
I was wondering where all the bigots came from then I realized the story is on Drudge Report. So don’t worry normal people, Hollywood has not gone Hateful and joined the Klan. The Klan is just visiting from the keyboard of their double wide trailer.
Hey drudge readers time to vote republican so they can send all the good paying blue collar jobs to china and cut you out of the middle class. Now go off to Walmart you are late for work.
BTW Parent Television Council is just a right wing wacko cover group like the bigot who hides behind “Jesus” James Dobson and Focus on Family. Isn’t it always strange even going back to slavery and the civil rights movement fundamentalist Christians have always been on the side proven evil by history.
Beware of Christian fundamentalists they are our American Taliban. I’m gonna subscribe to GQ just to support the Glee issue. Those who agree it is on Amazon for a dollar an issue.
because homosexuality is wrong. personally, i think tv shows have gone too far as it is with the language, sex and violence. even with commercials for viagra, etc. showing during the day/early evening should be removed.
LOVE and agree with you comment!
Come out of the closet already Dave. You’re not fooling me.
Screw you. There’s nothing wrong with the show being at 8pm. And if you believe Kurt’s storylines are “wrong” for 8pm, you should reexamine your beliefs and life experiences.
Why be judgmental about others being judgmental, Tyler? A more tolerant response would be “whatever, dude”. But we are all so firm about our own values that our feigned tolerance only reaches those who agree with us.
Everyone does what is right in their own eyes. But the results will tell how wise that is.
There is One who will examine all our beliefs and life experiences and will be the final, eternal judge. Life is not a game. I am really sad for you.
I totally agree with you. We are living in a terrible time when “anything” goes….meaning sickos are portrayed as the “norm”. It’s a true shame.
We are becoming Sodom and Gomorrah. Eventually, God will have had enough and we’ll all suffer his justified wrath. The world today is full of disgusting perverts and they want to be glorified for it. Satan is the master of deception, and cloaking his evil under something ‘innocent’ or ‘pretty’ is the best deception of all. Stupid people will never get it.
Yes Kerry, ignorant people really will never get it. There is no god and the best deception of all was the bible.
Luckily, you can change the channel or turn the set off. Don’t try to tell me or anyone else what’s appropriate.
I think you should learn the rules of written English.
You sound like my 85 year-old aunt. The social wars are over. The liberals won.
And this is why parents can’t watch prime time television with their children anymore. What a shameful disgrace!
Ah yes, the libs won. Get ready for a big change in November, Bucko.
Big bull patties.
Massive liberal funerals are scheduled for 3 Nov 2010 with all the few remaining libs to be planted 2 years later.
Won what? The right to watch porn, the right to do anything you want, the right to be as sleazy as you want? Yeah, that’s really something to be proud of winning………………..there really isn’t a war over that, you can have all of it you want, just remember, we told you so when it catches up with you.
Why, in your day, women didn’t dare to vote or show their ankles!
What a bunch of Puritans here .
You are right, why not have them fully nude? Or have them having sex with animals? (sarcasm off)
There are those who believe people are more than just our base biological actions. And certainly over sexualizing children is still considered sick. Hopefully we won’t devolve so much as a culture that that becomes acceptable.
everyone is entitled to their opinion – no matter how dumb it may be.
Have a great – albeit mindless – day.
I was wondering where all the bigots came from then I realized the story is on Drudge Report. So don’t worry normal people, Hollywood has not gone Hateful and joined the Klan. The Klan is just visiting from the keyboard of their double wide trailer.
Hey drudge readers time to vote republican so they can send all the good paying blue collar jobs to china and cut you out of the middle class. Now go off to Walmart you are late for work.
BTW Parent Television Council is just a right wing wacko cover group like the bigot who hides behind “Jesus” James Dobson and Focus on Family. Isn’t it always strange even going back to slavery and the civil rights movement fundamentalist Christians have always been on the side proven evil by history.
Beware of Christian fundamentalists they are our American Taliban. I’m gonna subscribe to GQ just to support the Glee issue. Those who agree it is on Amazon for a dollar an issue.
Timothy James,
The main reason our jobs are being sent over seas is that the Democrats tax and regulate large and small buisness to the point that they can not keep their doors open if they stay in this country.
The Democrats have had controll of the House and Senate since Jan 2007. they have controlled the purse strings and they have led us to oblivion. They can not keep printing money, taxing to death those of us that work for a living and spend more then they take in. Eventually the whole system will collapse.
The problem with Socialism is that you eventually run out of other people’s money….
Keep drinking your Kool Aid and watch as the House and Senate return to sanity after this November’s election. Revolution via the ballot box, it is the American way.
Go to hell.
That’s right….girl on girl action at 8:00 pm is VERY inappropriate for a network telecast…
When I was a kid, 8PM meant you could watch the Fonz tell someone to “sit on it” AAAAYYYYYY!!!!
the fonz saying “sit on it” to guys has a whole new meaning now that we know he is gay
The photos of Lea Michelle are especially disturbing. Hit show, extraordinary singing talent, and she’s still so desperate for attention that she’s doing crotch shots and licking lollipops? At what point can she afford some dignity?
Incidentally both of the actresses demeaning themselves in these pics have more talent than the marginal Cory Montieth. Too bad they don’t have enough self respect.
You suck just like the fat spanish waiter.
The waiter wasn’t perfect, but he deserves respect. Not sure what’s more appalling: these young actresses whoring themselves out like C-list Maxim tarts, or LFC in the relegation zone.
You’re drunk again, aren’t you? I see why you were kicked off the debate team.
The US media has a long history of aggrandizing marginal males at the cost of impressive females.
Remember the age group we are talking about here. This show is targeted to kids and some self control would be nice. By the way when you want electric do you put a male plug into a female socket or do you just try to attach to male plugs together? I don’t personally have anything against Gays but it is not a normal life style and it would be nice if Gays would act appropriately in public with a little decorum – your life style is repugnant.
The first season included a knocked up Chastity Club president, drug use, allegations of a teacher molesting students. It is obviously NOT targeted to kids.
just because they had inappropriate material on the show doesnt mean it wasn’t targeted at kids – actually its the opposite. They were targeting kids with inappropriate material.
You’d have no problem if a guy and a girl were doing the same thing. Get over yourself.
Ma’am,
Gays will act “appropriately” in public when all straights do as well.
Mamabear,
Your generalization of everyone you see as ‘homosexual’ is insulting. My parents taught me to comport myself in a polite manner public-wise and I do. Even if I didn’t, there is no constitutional right to not be offended. If there were, Christians would have been out of my hair years ago.
You’re on the wrong side of history. Switch teams or shut the hell up.
Thanks!
You are as ignorant as they come. Gay people are just as normal as straight people, get used to it. And you obviously know nothing about gay sex. Your ignorance is showing, please off yourself promptly and renew the gene pool.
“By the way when you want electric do you put a male plug into a female socket or do you just try to attach to male plugs together?”
-Hey Mamabear,
Did you ever think about who created the names for “male” plugs and “female” sockets, or do you always generalize all your thinking before using such ridiculous analogies to perpetuate your small minded thinking?
Neither is appropriate but the glorification of homosexuality is more inappropriate.
When television had “real” Standards & Practices and movies had a Hays board, this type of shenanigan would be verboten, and I think it’s about time.
IMHO when these folks do anything gay and I mean anything, it gets an “R” and it is never, ever, never shown on network television.
And certainly nothing sexual is directed at or near an underage actor or an underage character.
But that’s just me.
YES!
They didn’t say it was inappropriate; they said it wasn’t surprising. I think Dianna offered a very suitable response in saying they aren’t the first, all intentions aside.
yup, pretty much.
Huh? Pedophile is an adult attracted to a child. While these actors are under 21, they are not children.
Actually they are 24, 24 and 28 according to the post-
Hmmm…simulated sex with an “of age” (18+) actress *portraying* an *underage character* probably crosses the gray line into illegality…
In this regard, I trust the judgment of (ahem) Hustler Corp (their dubious business after all) – their magazine is called “Barely *Legal*” – not “Slightly *Illegal*”.
Any porn going through the US Mail alleging to show “underage” girls (portrayed by 18+’ers)?
I don’t think so.
If Hustler doesn’t know where the legal line is, I don’t think anybody does…
I’d say that, based on the sheer number of 80′s sex comedies set in high school (Porky’s, etc..), there’s nothing illegal about showing 20-somethings pretending to be teenagers.
Uh, no it doesn’t cross the line into illegality. In overturning part of the “Child Pornography Prevention Act of 1996,” the Supreme Court has said that it would be unconstitutional to make it a crime to use young-looking adults and present them as children. Try reading a book sometime.
Dennis’s point is correct – people working to protect children from exploitation (like myself) feel like we’re being kicked in the teeth when Hollywood produces soft-pornographic images like these, because we cannot prevent actual pedophiles from producing similar images. As far as the law is concerned, it is currently legal to produce/simulate/fake images of “children” performing lewd and lascivious acts – so-called “legitimate” imagery like the GLEE photos only support the arguments (or, more factually, cloud the judgement of the jury) when we get these pedophiles in court.
The saddest part is this kind of imagery has such a large audience. Ergo, there’s a little bit of a pedophile in almost every 30-40ish American male…
I think the only actor on “Glee” under 21 is Chris Colfer. I think you meant to say the actors play characters under 21.
They’re all over the age of 21 …
while the actors are young adults, they are playing high school students under the age of 18. Not an appropriate photoshoot.
Yup! the girls are telling our girls it’s ok to be a SLOT.
Try doing your job as a parent rather than leaving it up to your TV.
I agree we should be doing our job as a parent. Don’t let your kids watch this stuff. That doesn’t mean we cant raise hell when it is put on public airways though. It’s no different than if Hustler decided to send out a free edition every month to every family in the US. They may not want it, but it gets delivered anyway.
Side note: without material like this and its predecessors, there would be a lot less teen pregnancy in our country. Is teen pregnancy good for society?
Yes Rick,
Until television was invented, there was no such thing as teen pregnancy.
Ok, Boys and Girls, The government has been mixing things where a lot of things are illegal whebn they should not be illegal.
The interest is there, but the interest ois not for little girla =s which isa SICK at best and there is no best,
The few photos has nothiing to do with children,,, God, I nebe=ver thoufght I’d ever say anything like that,
How about some typing lessons there? i cant even begin to understand this post.
If you raise your kids right, they’ll be able to make their own choices on television. I have an 18 year old sister and she doesnt care to watch shows with overly sexual themes. It’s just how she was raised…
I absolutely despise anyone telling me or anyone else what they can and cannot do. Live your own life on your high horse and let me live mine. I might even end up like you on my own accord, but being forced not to do or watch something only makes me wanna do it more.
You said, “I absolutely despise anyone telling me or anyone else what they can and cannot do.”
Then you told us to, “Live your own life on your own high horse and let me live mine.”
Didn’t YOU just tell ME what to do? So, do you despise yourself? Don’t feel bad. We can’t avoid moral judgements. No one is morally autonomous. The true debate is over which morals we should follow.
I work with sex-offenders. This is no joke. It doesn’t take much to trigger these folks,men and women. This doesn’t offend me it scares me. Watch the miovie Network and see if this has not happend.
The photoshoot in it of itself should be treated like any fantasy inspiring lure for those who have a preference to it. It should not be given any more credit or hate as those involved are well past 20 years old. Last I checked, this is still a free country where adults are free to make conscious decisions for their personal actions.
What people should be scared are those sex-offenders who attribute their social degeneracy on an external stimuli… That is utter equine manure. It offends me that someone can blame a picture, a store front, or even how a woman dress for their indecent behavior. Take some personal responsibility! If you don’t want to go to jail, then don’t do something that would land you there! They should institute public flogging… but that’s another argument…
No, dumbass, pedophilia is an adult’s sexual attraction to a PRE-PUBESCENT child.
Scissor me timbers!
These are the same right wing wackos who accused Abercrombie of being child pornographers. Ugh Christians who would rather see a gunshot than a boob.
Hey look everybody! The official God hater showed up! Everybody make room for this miserable guy to go around hurling baseless ignorant insults at anyone who has a moral compass grounded in something other than themselves!
Hey, Dave, why don’t you chillax and leave people with a different opinion alone? Free speech, remember? jamesthuter isn’t asking anyone to make room for him, and as for saying ‘look everybody’, you’d be waiting a long time for someone who cares about you shouting someone down for being a ‘God hater’.
Anyway, these people are right-wing. And they over-react to everything. They are never happy unless they have something to whine about. James is right: they would rather see a gunshot than a boob.
Not cool man. Not cool.
Because someone needs to stand up to these repressive, fundamentalist bullies, that’s why. I’ll bet Diana apologised because she was feeling pressured or intimidated. And how could the GQ Glee photos possibly border on paedophilia? Crazy stuff like this makes me think some people are never happy unless they have something to whinge about.
Which is NOT COOL.
Uh, James, it’s liberals that are trying to outlaw heterosexuality by constantly pushing their GAY agenda on to every single show out there. Sorry, but I’m conservative and I enjoy looking at hot girls with nice asses. I guess it’s liberal re-education camp for me.
I couldnt agree more. I myself am a conservative, and believe it or not, just did a topless scene in a film… It’s 2010. times have changed. Yes i am not too proud of doing my topless scene, but honestly, i had a GREAT TIME and felt very liberated in being able to do that. So anyways, personal views are personal views, it’s not fair to categorize people by their political or religion views. I myself, thought this was not disturbing to the audience but TACKY AND UNNECESSARY. That is all. They prob lost a lot of fans and viewers because of this.
Look how much leg Lea is showing, this is not nice For Glee.
Look people, personal morality is irrelevant for public television. Its personal morality, not universally agreed upon, so if you don’t agree with what is on go back to Amish country and knit. Then you never have to be offended by the rest of us evil heathens.
Bull.
First, PBS is public television, it gets gov’t money, and therefore it should absolutely be subject to Standards and Practices.
Second, ABC/CBS/NBC/FOX are broadcast networks, and should be subject to Standards & Practices for that reason.
Third, I think the minor cable networks should voluntarily self-regulate.
HBO, Showtime, Cinemas, The Movie Channel, and all the other titty channels are fine, personally I think they are way too fixated on the gay at this point in time, but let the viewers and the ratings help them decide what they should do.
Evil heathens-you say that in jest, but you’ve never been more truthful. I’m so sad for you.
Not entirely in jest, don’t be sad for me. Be sad for all the children who god let starve to death today, pray for people dying in a godless world. This is a debate over the morality of public television in a culture of ‘sex sells’. These actors and actresses are all of age so personal morality is irrelevant, its their bodies. Next as for standards, again if you don’t like the show turn on something you do. If you are rabidly moral you won’t watch this stuff anyway.
Another Hollywood trash program, there must be more to life than just sex that sells, where is the storyline here? Hollywood needs to have a wake-up call, programs use to have substance now its just trash sex.
In their 20′s or not, these “kids” are perceived as kids by those watching it. Stupid move, GQ.
you degrade women. your message to young girls is shameful.
Uh, wendy… Exactly how many ‘young girls’ read GQ?
Straight men that don’t dig into high school musicals will not be pulled along by this campaign. FOX needs to realize its core audience and deliver to them, rather than pandering to a lost demographic.
Exactly.
What is Fox’s core demographic? Are you confusing Fox News Channel with Fox by chance? Fox has never been “conservative”in nature. A fact that Fox News Channel devotees should take notice of and realize that maybe, just maybe, Fox News Channel only cares about finding a niche and exploiting it for all it can rather leading a conservative movement as you may think.
@Hmmbaby–
Intelligent thought will get you no where with liberals. Shame on you!
Just as insightful thought will get you nowhere with conservatives.
Like they say… If you are 20 and conservative you have no heart… 40 and liberal you have no brain.
I don’t think they meant Fox’s demographic, I believe they were referring to Glee’s specific demographic, obviously. This isn’t a discussion about conservatives vs liberals or politics, but rather the core audience of the show. While the show touches on some adult themes, it is still geared toward the “High School Musical” crowd, which is tweens, teens, and young adults, not middle aged men. This photo shoot could have been done far more tastefully, but the line was crossed. Besides the fact that Lea Michelle looks so unnatural and forced it almost make me uncomfortable to look at her face.
Her face?
I’d say GQ has a hit / high newstand sales with this issue. Lots of attention, something GQ needs and knew they would get with the pics. Who is the photographer I wonder? Pictures are what hey are and they are good. The “sexy schoolgirl” pose/dress is one of the oldest and most common costumes/styles/stereotypes and always will be. Well done GQ & photog.
Terry Richardson. I know someone who quit their job because it would have meant looking at his pictures for a prolonged period of time.
No joke.
How does this “layout” (as it were) help with GQ’s core audience of male homosexual clothes horses?
Mr. Murdoch
Total frickin hypocrisy to say the least. From your tabloid journalism newspapers-to your right wing Fox Network/Glenn Beck and BA BA O’Reily-to this crotch shot of a high school girl. You are clearly the center of the circle that is marked
“Who Gives A Sh*t” “Let me hear the sound of Ca-Ching.
BTD
Well, in fact it isn’t hypocritical because Murdoch is in it for one thing and one thing only … money and lots of it. Murdoch has even said more than once he would have launched a liberal news channel if there had been the same money in it. The people running the show could care less about anything but the cash. If there were enough money in it for full frontal nudity at 10pm they’d find a way to do it. (As an aside, I think the outrage over this photo shoot is utterly ridiculous. America needs to grow up).
you sir are a complete idiot
Murdoch owns GQ? Didn’t know that.
The blonde hair girl has a huge movie coming out soon right? Nikki posted the trailer a few weeks ago. Can you say hello PR?
I Am Number Four. Good heat on that one.
I love the shows and the photo’s. I’m a 52 year old female, so not the demographic they are looking for. The actors are adults, not children. Luv the sexy photo’s and although I’ve never purchased GQ, I may go out and get a copy just to support the Glee actors!
what part of disgusting do you people not get??? the people saying this is ok is what’s wrong with this country – no morals…
taking pictures of under-age girls looking like slutty prostitutes… absolutely disgusting and demoralizing to women.. I feel really bad for little girls these days… all this pressure to grow up to be nothing but a boy toy.
really heartbreaking..
Apparently you can’t read. There are no underage girls involved in this photoshoot.
It’s not that they ARE underage it’s that they APPEAR to be – every week during primetime and even in this photo shoot. GQ is sensationalizing the “appearance” of two very popular television actresses who play underaged girls the show. Call it what it is – soft porn.
I agree with you completely. They are potraying high school (underage) girls.
Look again. That picture is of a bunch of high schoolers. I don’t care if the people are actually fifty, they are MEANT to be highschoolers. Real high school kids are meant to look at them and see them as peers. What if they have a brother and sister having a relationship on the show? Is that not inappropriate? They’re not really brother and sister, but they are still portrayed as such.
“what part of disgusting do you people not get???”
That part which leads you to the bizarre judgement that sexy photos of beautiful women in their twenties are disgusting. Do you put pantaloons on the legs of your Queen Anne table as Queen Victoria did?
sexy photos? Really?? Do you have any kids….no I don’t wear pantaloons but I don’t spread my legs open for any Tom Dick or Harry to take a look either….
The Victorians did not put clothing on furniture limbs. But the moderns like to think they did.
I rarely bother to intrude in such inane and sophomoric discussions, but it is worth noting that this the show is about imaginary people doing and saying things written for them by others with the goal of making money.
Actors and actresses are simply people pretending to be somebody else for a living, and just because a 40 year old or even a 24 year old pretends to be a minor, doesn’t change the reality that they really and truly aren’t.
What they want is attention, publicity, fame, money, and to be the center of their own little universe, populated by dedicated and doofy sycophants.
Pixels of color aren’t real people either, by the way…
…its all in your filthy imaginations ; )
>Pixels of color aren’t real people either, by the way…
The correct term is “African American pixels”.
Anyway, if you don’t like a TV show, don’t watch it. Problem solved.
Personally I think religion is a far worse problem than TV. Religion corrodes the intellect and wastes scarce neurons on rubbish like the invisible sky daddy and combustible shrubberies. I’d recommend the government go in and shut the churches down, except I’m not a meddling busybody that wants to control what everyone does with their time.
Holy cow. These people do realize that the actors are NOT jailbait, right? You know how many guys have GFs/Wives/Spouses who throw on the cheerleading outfit now and again? Come on. They are ADULTS. The SHOW is a fiction. They are NOT high schoolers. Anyone with a brain can figure that out.
Not in the show, dimwit.
“Borders on pedophilia”? Congratulations on just making your point laughable. Both of the girls in the photo shoot are in their mid-twenties.
Perhaps an explanation, Michael: “Borders on pedophilia” because the characters on the show are in high school. It is against the law – and rightfully so – for adults to have sex with minors, for adults to show pornography or sexual images to minors, and the like. Photo shoots of TV characters who are of high school age promotes to high school age children that this is appropriate dress and photos for their age group. It is not. Their physical bodies aren’t even entirely developed until their early 20s, much less their intellects, which is why we have laws in place protecting them from adults who pursue them sexually. It doesn’t matter the actual ages of the actors or actresses. This should be an obvious point.
“It doesn’t matter the actual ages of the actors or actresses.”
What? Since when?
What is pedophilia? Do you know? If you did, you’d realize the actors/actresses aren’t anywhere near being children, in fact, they’re adults.
Oh wait, you do realize that… you just can’t comprehend why people who are in their 20s don’t act like they’re in their teens when the cameras aren’t rolling…
The cameras were rolling, or in this case shooting.
Nit-wit!
What? They are in there mid twenties. Not in dispute. If you think kids are not sexual beings by then, you either grew up in a black hole or another era, and you definitely haven’t seen the crap on TV like “Teen Mom” etc.
The laws are in place to prevent minors from being duped into sexual acts they are not ready for by adults. Statutory rape is real, and it can be used to really hurt young people.
But in this case, these were ADULTS, who have AGENTS and ADVISORS, were paid for the shoot, which was NOT porn, just tarty photos, and they were advised as to the content.
The “obvious” point is that they are adults who decide what to do with their own bodies.
Actually, the age of the actresses is the only thing that does matter if we’re talking about “bordering on pedophilia.”
Your point appears to be that teens might get the wrong idea about their clothing, which is an entirely separate point.
I’m personally surprised how much attention this is getting, especially since Lea Michele has participated in racy photo shoots before. And Britney Spears did the same thing to greater effect in the “Baby One More Time” video when she was actually underage (sixteen)…twelve years ago.
“Their physical bodies aren’t even entirely developed until their early 20s, much less their intellects”
If your posts are any guide, clearly some folk’s intellect never fully develops.
By the way, and this is going to make you head explode….did you know it actually is legal in many states for adults to have sex with those who are in high school and under 18? Heck, some high schoolers are actually adults too, being 18.
I just figured out that Drudge has a link to this story and THAT’S where all these Victorians came from. Please, people, go discuss this topic at your mega-church on Sunday. No one else here is shocked.
But they are not posing as girls in their 20′s they are posing as young teenagers!
As if I needed another reason to stop watching Glee this season other than a total lack of anything resembling a story, increasingly worse musical numbers, and the drudgery of being repeatedly beaten over the head with platitude after platitude.
It’s a shame that a show with so much going for it has fallen so fast. I’ll be surprised if it makes very far beyond this season.
You’ll be surprised if a super successful show that TONS of people watch despite your personal tastes in television will make it very far? Hmmm… Getcha Head Checked, son!
I think pictures are great. I thought the girl on girl wasn’t as big of a deal as they made it out to be. They didn’t make out, the one girl just ‘kissed’ the other girls neck while they talked… and yeah she said scissoring. But if it were 10 years ago, I wouldn’t have caught the reference at all. I only know what it is because A) Im older and B) southpark did it… literally.
TriggaMike,
I have noticed that you tend to like alot of bad shows. Glee is an interesting premise and their musical numbers are great (most of the time), but come on, there is absolutely no story in any of the episodes. It went from being something different to being something very preachy. It does not have a long shelf life. It is not as groundbreaking as shows like Mad Men and Breaking Bad, where there are ACTUAL storylines.
Clearly you have no concept of what people actually watch on TV. Have you not noticed that most of the trashy TV shows stick around MUCH longer than things with intelligence behind them? Yes, Mad Men and Breaking Bad to well because they are on Cable Networks that are geared towards a different audience. Basic television networks can’t cater towards those crowds. Shows like Kings, Jericho, Studio 60, etc… that had really involved story lines get cancelled because people are forced to watch weekly and their brains actively have to work to stay involved and understand. Shows like CSI, Glee, Law and Order… you dont have to watch weekly to be able to grasp the episodes you watch. They allow you to sit back and get lost for an hour each week without having to have memory recall.
I never said I watch Glee, I referred to a scene that was brought up that I was able to watch and see for myself what the big crisis was… and it wasn’t. Also, this is the third post I’ve ever written, so who are you to judge my Television watching habits? Can I not be happy that Chuck – albeit a silly little show that I do enjoy – got a full season 4? Im hoping they can wrap up the series this year. And as far as Chase, I and 115 of my closest friends make the show. So yeah, Im happy that our team has a job for the rest of the season. Whereas rude people like yourself enjoy pushing your opinion on the rest of the world acting as if a show you don’t like affects your life in some way, when you dont realize it affects 100+ hard working people more so. So Get off my case, ass.
You hit the nail on the head. I don’t even DVR the show anymore. Too bad it left its winning formula after only a couple of seasons.
Uh, it’s only 3 or 4 eps into its second season. I’m guessing you’ve never watched.
It’s in its 3rd Season, so right back at ya.
Um, no it’s not. It just air season 2 episode 4.
We stopped DVR’ing it last week and so did 3 other people I know. Creatively, the show just isn’t what it was in season 1 and 2. Too bad, it was one of our favorite shows.
I guess we are not watching the same show but IMHO it’s the best show on TV right now bar none. The ratings are matching the all-time highs and it’s one of the few shows that I don’t erase from the DVR after I’m done. To each their own and I will never argue about tastes but this show is trending up not down.
“Creatively, the show just isn’t what it was in season 1 and 2.”
Guys, if you’re going to hate on a show, just disagree with it in principle. “Glee” JUST began its second season. THIS is how people can tell you’re not even watching it.
I completly agree…this will have a negative impact on the show. The cast is already making apologies.
It’s too bad that it’s nearly impossible for an actress to have a career without channeling her inner slut, but these are the times we live in. I am with Jimmy Kimmel that the chances of growing the straight adult male audience is roughly zero. I think the real sadness of these photos is that young girls who admire the show will think this is what it takes to be cool and popular.
Completely agree! Also they are posing as their characters not as their adult selves, notice the clothes and set? Our girls and boys are growing up influenced by these types of images and anyone who thinks that’s a positive should have their head examined!
How many young (high school age) girls do you know that actually read GQ?
All of these actors are well into their 20s. The fact that they play high schoolers on a tv show in no way makes this “border on pedophilia.” Give me a break.
But are they really posing as th 20something they are?
I mean the setting and the (sexy) schoolgirl clothes and even the love triangle poses imply actually that they’re posing in-character.
This shoot is not sold on the reality of them being adults but on the fantasy of the girls being Lolitas – sexually available underage teenagers. I don’t know if I would go as far as the PTC but it’s sleazy as heck.
That’s not hypocrisy, Murdoch is smart enough to go where the money is… It’s called “business”. I’m sure Murdoch was really impressed by your holier than though rant though, it’s probably a lot more entertaining to read while having lunch cooked by a private chef, while traversing the globe in a private jet.
wonder if the “quality of the show’s writing” will also go down. true blood’s PR stunt only opened it up to criticism of a a very poor convoluted & embarrassing finale that was made even more laughable with the RS cover.
i realize alot is about being campy but either you are trying to make “serious” tv or not. dont respond to those who dont like your show by saying “its more than just blood and sex” and then do a PR campaign that is about “blood & sex”. just stick to providing solid and suspenseful serial TV episodes.
same goes for glee. hopefully it doesnt start sucking ass now that is cast feels it should be doing PR campaigns about how hot their “asses” are…either your about the talent or your not.
Hahaaa!! Agreed
IF YOU DONT LIKE IT-DONT WATCH IT!
I don’t like it so I don’t watch, only losers who miss high school tune in.
Well we won’t have to worry about ratehr we choose to watch it or not. This action will be their demise.
so everyone in support of “young” actors and actresses portraying high school students in a non-reality world (but some can’t identify what is/isn’t reality) displaying behaviour that is racy and edgy is ok with their 16 yr old daughter coming home pregnant or their daughter/son coming home with a sexually transmitted disease? where do you think kids learn disfunctional behaviour at? home? OTHER KIDS??!!! way to go you proud moms and dads who see nothing wrong with the continued degredation of public behaviour!!!
Saying that the photos borderline “pedophilia” is just a way for the jerkoffs at the Parent Television Council to get attention by using a shocking word.
The photo shoot is inappropriate. These look like takes from a Playboy, sans the nudity. An 8pm show should never have sexual content (girl-on-girl or girl-on-boy or boy-on-boy), but look at the comments here. Most of you seem to have missed the point, that this type of content belongs nowhere on primetime TV, but it is so common these days that we are desensitized to it. The poses themselves belong only in sexual magazines, whether they are clothed or not. No matter how much one may argue, celebrities have a responsibility to not promote sexualized images. I realize sex and all things related sells, but give me a break. Children do not need to idolize celebrities who have trouble dressing or acting appropriately – and this goes for all of them, Brittany, Mylie, etc. The almighty dollar is more important than the innocence of their fans. Sickening, and the Council is right to be alarmed at this, for a show that airs at 8pm, right smack in the middle of primetime, whose largest following are high school age kids.
“Takes from playboy, sans the nudity”
Translation, not pedophilia, not sexually explicit. Suggestive…sure.
How is this any different than what Elvis or the Doors did during prime time TV on the Ed Sullivan show?
Life is too short to waste it watching “Glee.”
And even though “They are ADULTS . . . The SHOW is a fiction . . . They are NOT high schoolers,” I doubt many of the high schoolers (and a surprising number of adults) who waste time watching “Glee” can figure that out.
Thus, shows like “Glee” set examples that too often will be emulated by actual, non-adult high schoolers (If we didn’t believe that TV potentially alters behavior, no body would spend a dime on any TV advertising)
Why is it that we continue to put up with corrosive role models and unnecessary sexualization of our youth in the media?
Reality TV wouldn’t have grown so big if scripted shows hadn’t offended so many viewers by struggling to promote irresponsible behaviors and controversial “platitudes.”
As for cultural rot-in-print like GQ . . . we keep ‘em in the Men’s room at work in case we run out of TP . . . .
Kudos to PTC for “calling out” GQ and the irresponsible floozies of “Glee”(who really aren’t that “hot,” BTW).
I’m most offended by Lea Michele’s morbidly obese ego. And now GQ just fed it 12 cheeseburgers.
Previous Glee Fan, you are a moron. It’s the hottest thing on TV and on iTunes.
If you hate it so much and think it has fallen so fast, then stop watching and go back to watching your reruns of Beverly Hills 90210 on Soapnet.
Loserrrrrrrrr.
face it folks, girl on girl, boy on boy, those sexual orientations are perverse. do what you want with your fragile lives but trying to normalize sexual perversion is radical and not normal human behavior. Gay lifestyle is abnormal and oh so “edgey”
The correct spelling is “edgy”. Why don’t you stop watching Fox News and read a book for once. Maybe then you’ll be able to pick up on how to spell correctly. Hick.
Yeah, waicool, jeez! Coming from someone with a name like yours, which is obviously supposed to be ‘way cool’. Not cool, man, not cool. You just sound like the Mad Monk dude in Assassin’s Creed or someone.
“pedophilia” means before puberty. People are so F’in stupid. While 18 might be the legal age, many states its 17 and other civilized countries 16 and 15. In the United States legal is usually 17 or 18. The point in learn what a word means.
how about pederasty and ephebophilia then? go figure. what a bunch of semantic bullshit…
so now we make the legal for adults & teenagers 15 to have consenual sex? pathetic. how much underage sex is enough? more underage sex more STD and so on, but by the looks of most posters on this thread nobody gives a damn. ok let the flood gets open and then bitch how expensive medical insurance is.
again…pathetic.
oh and just because glee is popular doesnt make this whole PR stunt right. wrong is wrong no matter who does it.
Theses actors are portraying ninth and tenth graders on the show so again it’s kind of perverted. Not that there is anything wrong with that. But they’re is no ambiguity they are playing high schoolers(aka underage) so when ‘in character’ don’t act like s**ts and be role models for teens.
The PTC is a horrible organization full of zealots and whackjobs. I stopped taking them seriously a long, long time ago. They’re a joke.
so why comment on their “zealous” and “whacy” comments then?
just curious…?