
The generational transition on Thursday continues. The 3 series that had been the anchors on the night for years, CBS’ CSI, ABC’s Grey’s Anatomy and NBC’s The Office, all hit lows last night. No great reason for concern for Grey’s (4.5/12) and The Office (3.4/9) just yet as they led their networks’ lineup by a wide margin and finished No.1 and No.3 for the night overall. But CSI (2.7/7) was the lowest-rated program on CBS last night, which featured ratings declines on the CBS and NBC and gains on Fox and CW. Since male-skewing shows were hit harder than the female-skewing ones, the baseball playoffs probably played a role, and some of the declines will probably be offset in DVR viewing.
The Big Bang Theory (4.0/13) continues to settle into its new Thursday slot. It was down 9% from last week but still absolutely dominated the 8-8:30 PM slot. But CBS has reasons for concern with $#*! My Dad Says (2.8/9). It was down 15% and held onto a so-so 70% of its Big Bang lead-in. It also finished No.1 in its time slot but by a hair, barely edging Fox’s Bones. Following CSI (2.7/7), which was down 13% for an all-time low, The Mentalist (3.0/9) was flat. It won the 10 PM slot and was the most-watched program on the night with 14.3 million. CBS tried switching CSI and The Mentalist last season when it didn’t make much of a difference. Maybe The Mentalist is now ready to take over the tentpole 9 PM position. CBS won the night in adults 18-49 and total viewers for a third consecutive week.
Second consecutive night with no good news for NBC. Community (1.7/6) was down 11%, 30 Rock (2.1/6) was down 19%, The Office (3.4/9) was down 8% for its lowest-rated fall telecast ever, and new comedy Outsourced (2.5/7) was down 11%. Community is now dipping below the level of the low-rated SNL specials in the 8 PM half-hour last fall, and 30 Rock is where Parks & Rec was a year ago. Outsourced’s retention (74%) was a little better than that for $#*! and close to what 30 Rock averaged in the slot last season (76%). No rebound for The Apprentice (1.3/4) at 10 PM. There is no chance the reality series would be able to continue much longer in the plum Thursday 10 PM slot with those Jay Leno Show-level numbers.
Following a Grey’s Anatomy rerun (1.1/4), which subbed for the recently departed My Generation, a new Grey’s (4.5/12) was down only 2% from last week but technically logged its lowest-rated fall telecast for a second consecutive week. (Vs. the series’ fast-national number last Thursday, Grey’s was actually up .1, so we have to wait for the finals to make a final call on it.). Private Practice (2.9/8) at 10 PM was up 4%, finishing neck-and-neck in the demo with The Mentalist.
Promising sign for Fox’s Thursday dramas, which had taken some beating this season: Bones (2.6/8) was up 4%, Fringe (2.0/5) up 5%.
Solid increases for freshman Nikita, moving it closer to a back-nine order. The freshman drama was up double-digits across the board from last week, including 22% week in adults 18-34 (1.1/3) and 11% in total viewers (3.0 million). Vampire Diaries was also up, 9% in total viewers (3.5 million).
TV Editor Nellie Andreeva - tip her here.


GREYS was getting 3′s last Spring, so not sure how you have them hitting lows now. Also it has the same fast national number as last week 4.5 and it ties the fast national number for this weeks GLEE and MODERN FAMILY and this show is in year 7.
The Big Bang Theory was down 9% from last week so I would not say that it “dominated” that particular time slot. Over-hyped show with Over-rated reviews. The Big Bang Theory is limited and restricted in its audience base but will never ever reach a broad based age viewership. This show does not have something for everyone.
<<<<<<<<Haters to the LEFT……..
Sherry I agree as well. “BBT” is the funniest show on TV. I love Blossom on the show. I’m betting that most TV Stations are giddy over how well it is performing since Syndication begins next FALL.
No one should be surprised that CSI bombed last night. Surely we all know how irritated and annoyed most everyone is with Vampires and Werewolves… and CSI jumps on the bandwagon a good 3(4) years WAY to freakin late. Lame.
Wow. Those are awful ratings for CSI. I tried watching, but cannot stand Laurence Fishburne on the show. And Shitner’s show is crashing too. CBS’s Thursday nights are falling apart.
Great news for Nikita fans like me. Best new shows this year are Nikita and No Ordinary Family.
Do not watch Nikita (so I’ll have to take your word for it!), but totally agree with you about Ordinary family. Truly enjoying it.
“The Incredibles,” I mean “Heroes,” I mean “No Ordinary Family” is completely derivative and a snore. Romany Malco’s talent is wasted on the show. Will somebody please give him his own show? Nikita is way better and I hope it lasts.
I’m not surprised that everything is overall down. People are loosing interest in TV shows that don’t have substance, a really story to follow. I could count the total shows I watch on one hand; none are on broadcast networks. I prefer listening to music in the dark or a night drive.
If CBS is interested in having a good hour of comedies, they’re going to have to get rid of the Shatner show. Accidentally on Purpose (which was mediocre at best) was getting less of a drop off last year coming off of HIMYM, which was not as highly rated as Big Bang is. This is only the third week and the drop off for $#*! is huge. Time to bring out your mediocre mid-season replacements, CBS! It can’t be as crappy as the Shatner fiasco.
The writing on CSI has gotten painful & lazy. Go back to the old format of 2 cases per ep. Hire better writers too.
CBS effed up when they chose Fishbird over Malkovich. Epic fail.
Another Epic Fail:
Having Justin Bieber “act” on the season premiere of “CSI.” The kid is annoying and overrated. His presence has really put a dent on the show, and so far, the show has gotten worse.
$#*! My Dad Says is just a bad series and utterly humorless.
Of course it is. It’s based on a freakin’ Twitter account! Can’t wait to see the other gem they pump out based on another Twitter account. I leave post-it’s all over the house — maybe CBS can make a show out of that.
Who CARES about the stupid “based on a Twitter account” thing? Seriously, stop blaming the shortcomings of the show on that! Every adapted project in history has source material of some kind. It doesn’t matter what the source material is, whether it’s good or bad, etc. It serves as the inspiration, and then the writers take it from there, and make it or break it based on their own skills and talents.
If you don’t like the show, blame the writers, blame the network, whatever. Don’t blame the source material.
I stand corrected, the writing is pretty awful, too, and that doesn’t help. However, the person who came up with the source material in this case is a writer and exec producer on the show, so I do kind of blame the source material. Oh, and I blame CBS.
Fine, but in this case, the source material is actually REALLY funny. Sure, it’s a Twitter feed, which is an odd format, but have you read said Twitter feed? It’s quite hilarious. There’s a reason 1.6 million people (or whatever) follow it.
Maybe Friday’s will soon be a double CSI night for CBS. CSI took a tumble last night.
Funniest BONES episode ever, and I’m not even familiar with JERSEY SHORE. Cool that Angela tried to explain the diff between doc and reality tv. Brownie points for that.
GREY’S storyline for Cristina and her ridick marriage is a big turnoff. Waiting that she wakes up and comes to her senses for good. PRACTICE is the smarter show, even if it has to suffer Scorsone’s char in order to provide crossover possiblities.
Re: CSI — BONES did the vampire thing, Criminal Minds did it, even Private Practice. The right guest stars could have made a difference.
Remember when Thursday night was must see TV on NBC? Those numbers are dismal and 30 Rock after getting shut out @ The Emmy’s is now losing large chunks of the little audience it had. I don’t even know where you begin to fix it.
Well, CSI, you kick off a longtime female cast member in favor of a new, hotter, more annoying actress. You get what you deserve.
Concerning CSI’s drop in ratings? My dvr only allows for 2 choices in competing time slots. When its between 30 rock, Fringe, and CSI? CSI loses every week at my house.
With CSI, I quit watching when William Peterson left. I realize the decision was his, but losing Grissom,and Warrick, was just too much. If they had hired someone interesting as a replacement, I would have tried to keep watching…but that didn’t happen. Except for Criminal Minds and The Mentalist, most of my shows are not on the networks.
I agree.
This article was mostly nonsense!
Gray’s was #3 for the night and The Office #7. Everything else is just spin.
I realize that CBS winning every night by wide margins makes journalists antsy to find a race somewhere but stooping to ignoring the actual results is just too much (and ageist to boot!)
CSI did actually droop a bit, losing for once to an also drooping Gray’s as both are way past their freshness date, but they essentially have the same ratings.
The office dipped below 7 million viewers much faster than last year, but its low ratings are nothing new.
Sadly the fact that journalists keep pretending it’s a hit is also nothing new.
No, chippie, you’re right. Grey’s had by far the better demo than CSI and is way more valuable than CSI’s pukey demo is. It draws a ton more advertising revenue. You don’t understand how the industry works.
Having over 360 TV series/documentaries/films in my Netflix instant streaming queue that I watch on the big screen with a PS3, who has time to watch the dreck that comes out on TV? I can’t even keep up on the DVR stuff that I did record. The landscape is changing, goodbye networks, you will not be missed.
I STILL love original CSI and I did think the Vampire/Werewolf thing was handled quite well last night. It just kills me to see headlines like this but I believe the show has suffered with Laurence Fishburne. I didn’t even know John Malkovic was a contender – I think I would have liked to see that show. Nothing personal against the Fish – obviously he’s a great actor – I just don’t think he fits this role.
Once viewers abandon a series, they rarely come back. Even with OnDemand, where you can catch up. There’s no “gotta see it” to CSI anymore. The best shows on TV are on USA, FX, AMC, TNT and even A&E, with The Glades being surprisingly good. I think “lazy” sums up CSI. BTW, the best show on TV may just be The Closer, which has good characters, strong cast, smart cases and solid writers.
I would say i am now an occasional viewer of CSI now.Once CBS started messing around with the cast the show went into decline. Basically they let Jorja Fox go during season 6 then Gary Dourdan season 7 and then William Pieterson(although he decided to go)and this season fired Liz Vassey. Once you start messing with an established cast you start alienating your true fans. Yet again CBS are doing this with Criminal Minds by firing AJ Cook and reducing Paget Brewster – again alienating their true fans and unfortunately CM will start going the same way. Fishbourne to me was never the right choice in replacing Pieterson – hollywood star who should have stuck with films imo.
I agree 100%. It really started to come apart in season 8 when Jorja and Gary left. Petersen leaving just sealed its fate.
And Fishburne just doesn’t fit in. Period.
CSI is a stinker. It’ll live through this year, but I think it will crap out next season and get dumped. Good riddance, finally!
Nbc passed on a great pilot that was new and different…0ur Show created by Larry Charles. They passed because they thought it was “too different.” What morons. They are probably not even smart enough to be kicking themselves now.
I think also part of CSI’s problem, in addition to its decline was the season opener. So interested in being able to push that Hollywood cocktail party chatter bar, they went all political. It’s just not smart to stick your finger in the eye of half of the population. If you look at the age demographics of the show, if should make common sense not to alienate conservative viewers.
But it’s hard also not to say that the second episode this year just blew chunks.
Bieber, Vampires, and Werewolves…oh my…