
EXCLUSIVE THURSDAY UPDATE: I hear that none of the three actors who screen tested for the Spartacus lead this week, Stephen Amell, Aiden Turner and Liam McIntyre, got the role. However, Starz is still holding onto McIntyre, the Australian, while the other two have been released. He may still get to be the next Spartacus, succeeding the ailing Andy Whitfield. But I hear Starz brass is considering all options for its hit series, including the possibility of ending it or bringing in someone else for the lead.
EXCLUSIVE MONDAY: Three Actors Vying For ‘Spartacus’ Lead: Stephen Amell, Aiden Turner and Liam McIntyre.The search for the new lead of Starz’s flagship drama series Spartacus: Blood and Sand, is entering its final stage, with the field narrowed down to three actors: Stephen Amell, Aiden Turner and Liam McIntyre. I hear the three are being flown to New Zealand for screen tests and to meet with the show’s cast and crew, with a final decision on who would be the next Spartacus expected as early as this week. The actor will replace original Spartacus star Andy Whitfield who dropped out in September when his cancer returned. He 

was first diagnosed with treatable Stage 1 non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma in early March when the series was in pre-production on Season 2. Whitfield’s cancer recurrence put the second season of Spartacus in limbo, leaving the series’ producers with a choice to recast the role or end the series,which put Starz on the original programming map with its highly-rated first season. Ultimately, they launched a search for a new actor to play the famous gladiator. Like Australian Whitfield was before he landed Spartacus, Canadian Amell (Closing the Ring), Brit Turner (All My Children) and Australian McIntyre (The Pacific) are relatively unknown foreign actors with chiseled looks and impressive physique. Turner is the most familiar name because of his long run on All My Children and as a contestant on ABC’s Dancing with the Stars. The Spartacus prequel, Spartacus: Gods of the Arena, is slated to launch in January.
TV Editor Nellie Andreeva - tip her here.






Oooh! Yes, yes, and yes. Done.
Dear Mr. Norton:
Goodness gracious, Graham, it’s 11:00 p.m. in London. Go to bed already!
Haha! That’s Ms. Norton to you. Not Graham, but I do enjoy the show.
Yep, Amell is my pick for sure, he is super sexxxy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Andy Whitfield is Welsh not Australian!
Exactly! I hate how they keep referring to him as ‘Australian’ he’s only lived there since 1999!
I wouldn’t mind waiting either tbh its a travesty, but maybe they could make a prequel to the prequel!
That’s sad news, no one could ever replace Andy. Why couldn’t they postpone the show a little bit longer like Breaking Bad? I wouldn’t mind waiting. I’ll still tune in but it won’t be the same.
I totally agree! No one could replace Andy, it won’t be the same! I’m ure many think the same. Andy IS Spartacus!
I’m sure that part of the decision to replace Andy was not made lightly. Andy is in a fight for his life, which is more important than out viewing pleasure!
I agree “Andy is Spartacus” but I would rather see him spend all his energy fighting & defeating his cancer and living!
I’m sure in “Spartacus” fashion he will win this fight, but he needs to concentrate on the fight.
People how selfish can you be? Andy’s life is worth way more than your “viewing pleasure” if you don’t agree then don’t watch!
no one is being selfish. everyone wants andy to make a recovery before they even think of him taking up the Spartacus role again. What people are upset about is Starz rushing out the second (and what should be) the final season without him. Id much rather wait a couple years than see a replacement. Whats he gonna say… “I am NOT SPARTACUS!!”?
Silly question, won’t Aiden Turner be a bit busy shooting The Hobbit for the next year or so, given he was named one of the dwarfs in it just the other week (with a shoot that starts in February 2011)?
When would he be able to do this other series? Does he have a clone?
It’s a different Aiden Turner. One’s the Being Human guy and doing the Hobbit. This one is the soap opera actor, and the DWTS alum.
people getting mixed up with aiden and aidan turner the irish one is the one whos in the hobbit and loadza films coming up. and the english one is in some soap. maybe they should get the irish guy instead
different guy. The guy in the Hobbit is AIDAN Turner, this guy is AIDEN Turner.
I’ll take all three please I can send u my address and credit card # right now
honestly, Amell is probably the one that looks the most like Andy Whitfield – they is all sexy but omg he’s perfect lol
I’m Spartacus!
*snort!*
Meh. Really not sure how they’re going to pull this off. I remain skeptical.
In the end I’m still very sad it didn’t work out for Andy. Perhaps they could focus the team on the prequel until he gets better? But it seems we’re past that stage now…
Wait and see then.
Whoever gets the part, he will have big sandles to fill.
They are all yummy to look at. I would say Amell most closely resembles Andy. I love this show and really hope whomever they choose can do it justice the way Andy did.
Best wishes to Andy and his family. Our thoughts are with you.
Amen to that.
No actor will be as good as Andy.
My prayers are with Andy and his family.
Hope you comeback to us soon Andy. We love and miss you!
It won’t be the same….I don’t know if I want to watch with out Andy! BOO HOO!
Just can’t fathom Spartacus played by another actor. Get well quick Andy….I love ya as the Thracian(sp)
Amell is your MAN!
My vote is Aiden Turner..
the guy has the chops and physique to “execute” this well..
Ok you think you can replace Andy Go ahead and try. See if they can fill his shoes i hope so. But Nobody is as Good as Andy Whitfield. We Love you Andy God Bless you and Your Family! Get Well soon and can’t Wait to see You Return to Your Role! God Speed to Your Quick Recovery Andy!
God this town is rough !! Best wishes to the actor they are replacing
There is no replacing Andy. Honestly, no matter what you think of the show, he did an incredible job. I think it’s a horrible decision to continue without him. I understand the producers need to do it, but it still sucks for everyone. I just hope he gets better soon and gets a ton of TV and film work. He’s a great actor.
Loves aidan turner. Great physique, gorgeous face, great actor. I don’t want an “Andy” lookalike as that would be a dishonor to Whitfield. When I heard about the recast (of which I am AGAINST) I thought of Aidan Turner right off the bat!
I’m partial to Andy and waiting for his return..if they “had” to recast why couldn’t it only be temporary till he recovers? Andy is cause for a huge part of the success of Spartacus, I think we owe it to him to wait again. There are many other stories they could expand in the mean time, I would be willing to watch if I knew the door was always open for Andy’s return…..
andy is SPARTACUS, he was great in the film “Gabreil”. i would wait longer for season 2, none of these 3 actors will pull of this role as well as Andy. if he would consent to return, as long as he beats his illness, season 2 would have great ratings. this news of his reoccurence is heartbreaking, GOD be with you andy. just wondering why wasn’t craig horner from ” Legend of the Seeker”, considered, you have Darken Rahl as the Legatus. i cant get over the idiots cancelling that show, and who cares what critics thinks? i sure as hell don’t not watch something because some of them down it, they are all ignorant. pleaase wait for andy but only if he wishes it so, later.
He has cancer. He quit the show to spend the next year of his life to battle the disease. Sadly, there’s not guarantee he will return and the producers can’t afford to keep all the other actors on the payroll indefinitely. Andy has expressed his desire to see the show continue and that’s what’s happening.
Without Andy there is no Spartacus. Going back to when he was younger was a smart move that bought them a year but that’s it. Do the right thing and wait. Hard core fans like me, out of principal, will not watch it with a replacement.
‘Nuff said
Agreed, what a low brow move after firing the guy who made it happen in the first place (Hamm). Does Starz have no other ideas? Albrecht must be desperate. Would Sopranos have continued without Gandolfini? Find some other ideas and give a proper hiatus for Andy. Not like it is season 4 with a huge audience.
As a “hard core” fan I will continue to watch until they stop making the series completely.
Andy is in a fight for his life, that takes precedence over everything else!
Maybe instead of being so selfish you should wish for the best for Andy! If you are a fan of “Spartacus Blood & Sand” you will continue to watch, if not – no major loss for the rest of us!
Do Not Want.
It is going to be so hard to replace Andy. It just might kill the show replacing him. I personally wish they would wait and hope that Andy can return but I digress.
Good luck with casting.
Liam looks perfect for the role! But I remain skeptical of anyone filling Andy’s sandles, but if anyone can bet on the AUSSIE!
McIntyre has it in the bag. If anyone can fill Andy’s shoes its Liam.
Cant wait to hear the outcome!
I hope they pick the Aussie, he is the best by far.
LIAM FOR THE WIN!!
Spunkiest & he’s Aussie. Win win situation really. If we’re going to be honest.
Wow, the UK actor’s union must have pretty loose rules on soundalike names if they’re okay with both an Aidan Turner and an Aiden Turner. Seriously confusing.
It is a sad thing for Andy. The best Spartacus look is Amell for sure. The other two guys are too cutesy for this role – Amell has it.