UPDATE: The destabilization of Lionsgate continues. Carl Icahn today took to the Internet and started a website slamming Lionsgate’s board in hopes of replacing 5 of the TV/film studio’s directors with his own rival slate. He also issued an “open letter” to shareholders pointing them there and to its 3 reports: 1) “Why change is needed at Lions Gate” (“Through the years I have seen many transgressions of corporate governance but they all pale in comparison to what has taken place during a week in mid-July 2010 at Lions Gate.”), 2) a report produced by Salem Partners investment bank about the value of Lions Gate’s film library (“and about cash flows or — better said — the lack thereof”; and 3) a report comparing Icahn’s nominees with the current directors of Lionsgate. It’s the latest maneuvering by the corporate activist/raider to convince shareholders to vote their “gold” cards for the scheduled December 14th shareholders meeting in Los Angeles. Lionsgate management wants shareholders to vote their “white” cards.
Usually, a proxy fight like this takes months of preparation and involves contacting every shareholder. But this is being done with virtually no time and little expense by Icahn, who owns 33% of Lionsgate. Icahn’s website focuses, in part, on “Which Slate is Better Qualified?” when the truth lies somewhere in-between. In fact, Icahn’s 5 candidates either don’t have showbiz experience or else were fired from their entertainment jobs. Meanwhile, Lionsgate is whispering to Hollywood that Frank Biondi, Jonathan Dolgen, Strauss Zelnick, and Jules Haimovitz were approached to run on Icahn’s slate, and they all turned him down. Hey, it’s nice to be asked, right?
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.


Icahn makes money… LGF is a money losing machine.
Easy call… I’m voting Icahn’s gold proxy.
Icahn makes money by destroying things…Icahn might make a buck if he gets control, but the shareholders are going to get a royal screwing…Mark my words.
I voted White…for Felty, Burns, Drake, et al. Ichan’s Board
slate is a disaster.
Does this have any impact on the upcoming films that Lionsgate is releasing, namely, Rabbit Hole or Buried? And the lack of news on the renewal of Mad Men?
Nope. Only impact would be to future productions that would be affected if the new board fires current studio management. If that happens, it’s just like when any studio changes leadership…only in this case the people that Icahn hires will likely be more incompetent than most studio execs…except for maybe Fox. I don’t think it’s possible to take that title from Fox.
Well, Mad Men duh, will stay with AMC unless it moves to a bigger channel and god knows the actors deserve a HUGE paycheck.
Rabbit Hole is a great film as was Buried. But …. They cut Burieds life short. Fantastic movie, possibly wrong Domestic company. Things that make you go…
Sigh.
Everyone is missing the major issues. What will Ichan do if he was the acting CEO? Will he keep the same acquisition people? Domestic Marketing people? This is their biggest issue facing the lion.
Not to split hairs, but Biondi, Dolgen, Zelnick and Haimovitz all “got fired” from their last entertainment job, too. Feltheimer got fired from his last job and probably Burns, too. Says something about this business, huh?
What/where did Haimovitz get fired from? As far as I’m concerned hes the only one whoes ego has yet to get in the way of his work ethic.
@ Jeffrey: to be fair, the last few quarters LGF lost money, it spent money fighting off Icahn & his advances. Now, I grant you, spending corporate money to fight off a competitor in order to keep your job that much longer isn’t a sound business practice for the company, but perhaps given Icahn’s history of raiding companies especially metaphorically with the toxicity that he brings with his takeover bids, perhaps the LG team don’t want to see the depressed value of the company depressed any further.
Jeffrey is right. Icahn is a billionaire who makes money. Just typically not in entertainment companies. I wouldn’t necessarily have an issue with new blood running LG, if it was in fact new blood & not “the usual suspects” whose track records are more questionable than the current LG team. The one exception is of course the former CEO, whose return could be a positive sign to get LG back on track.
In the end, we all know, as Reality Check pointed out, that the recycled CEOs & board members do little to sway positive cataclysmic changes. Growth always lies in the focus on content. Building franchises is great. Making great movies or acquiring AND pushing great films is the key. Most people haven’t seen Buried which is too bad. It wasn’t pushed & I think it was a lost opportunity.
When the focus for great content overtakes the need to defend whoever runs LG, be it current or future mgmt, that mgmt will be in charge that much longer. But as to the current team, I say give em another year, out of under the strain of the outside aggressor & see if they can turn it around. If not, then, let’s take another look.
That’s my two cents anyway…..
Best thing Lionsgate could do is get rid of Rob Melnick. He’s the most incompetent business affairs exec in hollywood. Never returns calls, has a deadly combination of arrogance and stupidity, he’s alienated everyone who has to deal with him. Talent actively stays away from Lionsgate just so they don’t have to deal with him. Getting rid of him is almost reason enough to vote for Icahn…
Carl is taking his next step to have Lion gate be his for good . for Carl has always been a shark when he has gone after something. leaving destruction in his wake after he has the thing finaly. Liongate will soon be finished and on that list.
How come Icahn’ has access to the personal PIN messages (Blackberry to Blackberry) and emails of Lionsgate. Corporate espionage anyone???
The use of the legal procedure of ‘discovery’ during the various lawsuits that have flown back and forth here. Icahn’s team has taken the time to actually read enough of the info to find some choice quotes.
Icahn is going to win. Lionsgate was winning before with my backing / support, but recently I was in LA, a person there who was personal friends of producers from Lionsgate was supposed to put me infront of them, then half way through ALL the meetings we had, he told me I must sleep with him in order to be famous and rich, and be his girlfriend. I told him to go F— himself and disconnected from this evil beast! Now I’m back in NY and since Icahn is a New Yorker, and after LA hurt me and I helped them, I’m just laying low to think things over, but since I’m here and so is Carl, he has my great blessing / energy to move him forward, and especially when I was wronged. So I can’t help any longer. I was devastated beyond belief and felt greatly insulted by the evil treatment from the people in the industry. Your loss, because you had me on your side, that was big, you guys could have had everything you wanted, but some people screwed me over willfully, intentionally, and purposefully for no justification and destroyed my work, so now you have bad karma. Once it’s been done , it’s done, you can’t take back your actions with the intent to harm a good, purehearted person! I cried for a week in devestation holed up in my hotel, God witnessed it and wiped off my tears, I got back up and went to Malibu and cleansed myself from bad energy and went home to NY! Now NY has protection because I’m here and the economy here is doing number one out of the whole country! Unusual, wouldn’t you say? I can forgive, but the evil actions can’t be erased in god’s book! Icahn will win and take over. Karma is a b—- when it comes back around! I’m not saying you guys were the ones that harmed me, but the others did! I cahn will take over hostily. God bless everyone including the fools!
Wow lady, that’s a movie script you got there, a really bad one that‘s pretty hard to take seriously. I’m guessing you’re an Icahn corporate crony trying to drag the Lionsgate name through the mud. Good luck because no one is buying your BS.
Frank Biondi, Jonathan Dolgen, Strauss Zelnick, and Jules Haimovitz are businessmen. They were smart to turn down Ichans offer. They want to remain neutral- and there isnt anything wrong with that.
If they chose sides, they’d lose no matter what. But when Ichan retires his “save” lionsgate plot, Biondi, Dolgen, Zelnick and Haimovitz will be free to do as they please.
In which case Lionsgate will mostly establish a board featurning the above players.
If being fired was a criteria than a lot of executives should retire.
I agree that the truth is somewhere in the middle on LGE but library valuations are a artifact.
Hopefully the company and its shareholders will benefit from the scrutiny.
this is a mess and a circus