
The press conference announcement in Beijing by acclaimed director Zhang Yimou that Christian Bale will star in his Chinese period film The 13 Flowers of Nanjing is the latest piece of evidence that Bale uses his signature role as Batman as a beachhead that allows him to stretch, better than any actor who has inhabited a superhero movie role (with the possible exception of his The Prestige costar Hugh Jackman). I always felt that Michael Keaton could have better exploited his Batman perch as a way to enable good projects, but he seemed uncomfortable being defined by the role and left after two films. Keaton shows up now and then and delivers the occasional strong performance, but any ability to get movies made just by his presence vanished after his exit. Val Kilmer never got the chance to exploit the perch after replacing Keaton for one appearance in 1995′s Batman Forever, and George Clooney has spent more time than anything publicly apologizing for his turn in spandex in 1997′s Batman & Robin. Managing an acting career around iconic franchise characters is tricky stuff. Harrison Ford’s turns in Star Wars and Indiana Jones made him a top-dollar star, but it also shackled him into mostly playing stoic hero roles. Batman doesn’t seem to have created any such limitations on Bale, who made Harsh Times, The New World, Rescue Dawn, The Prestige and 3:10 to Yuma between between Batman Begins and The Dark Knight. He followed the latter film with Terminator Salvation, Public Enemies, and The Fighter. He has a real Oscar chance for his portrayal as the crack-addicted former fighter Dicky Eklund. Bale returns next year for The Dark Knight Rises, and it will be interesting to see if he bails on his Batman stronghold after that.
In 13 Flowers of Nanjing, Bale will play an American in Nanjing, China in 1937 during the Sino-Japanese war, where refugees flock to find sanctuary from the violent invasion in a church compound. The picture will begin production January 10, 2011, in both Chinese and English dialogue. Yimou is reuniting with producer Bill Kong and exec producer David Linde. They previously worked together on Yimou’s House of Flying Daggers as well as Hero. Linde’s relationship with Kong goes back to the Ang Lee-directed Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon. Kong is producing with Zhang Weiping. New Pictures and Edko Films Limited are the production companies.


Bale was great in the first one. Dark Knight not so much. Maybe because Heath Ledger took the show. IMO Bale has never been a pop star actor (if there such a phrase) or struggled with type casting. He still maintains his serious actor edge regardless of the project.
Agreed, didn’t like his Batman voice in the second batman. Seemed too forced. That said, he rocked in 3:10 to Yuma.
“I’ve been standing on one leg
for three damn years,
waiting for God to do me a favor.
And He ain’t listening.”
Perfect and timeless.
Oh, GOOD FOR YOU!!!
This comment made me burst out laughing. Thank you, I needed that.
Let’s hope that the astonishing Gong Li is also in the this new Zhang Yimou! Any news on that? She is the best underused actress in the world today, maybe by her own choice, I don’t know. And no one knows how to photograph her as well as Zhang. I can see Gong Li and Christian Bale having great chemistry.
It helps that Bale established his indie-cred and “serious” film bona-fides before jumping into blockbusters. People still talk about his iconic performance of Patrick Bateman in “American Psycho” much more than they talk about him as Batman. It also helps that Bale has been working in the film industry his entire life. I expect “American Psycho” and “The Fighter” will be his legacy, with his performances as Batman contributing more to Nolan’s legacy of classing up the traditional Hollywood popcorn flick.
Bat-geeks can argue for days over the Keaton VS Bale/”Who’s the best Batman?” question, but my money’s on Bale.
He’s actually the best Bruce Wayne, IMHO. He’s was great in both Batman Begins & The Dark Knight, so we’ll see if he makes it three in a row. My guess is that he will.
“Swear to ME!” indeed.
Agree 100%. He’s the first Bruce Wayne who acts in public like a playboy billionaire, whereas with Keaton and Kilmer, Wayne was even more morose in civilian clothes than in the suit.
I still can’t get with that “Mr Scary” voice Bale does, but, I guess that’s just me.
Another thing that works for Bale in general is that it is no longer strange to see good actors do the “popcorn movie cash-in” and then instantly transform to serious roles. Christopher Reeve for instance, was a very good actor who got typecast as Superman and none of his other movies attracted could attract the same box office.
But after Jack Nicholson’s star turn as the Joker, he returned to serious films like Blood & Wine, a Few Good Men, and comedies like As Good As It Gets. And of course, he was already a previous Oscar winner. So you started seeing more of that, as casting directors sought out established actors, and those same actors liked the paychecks that came with the big-budget flicks. We have also since seen a wealth of acclaimed British actors in the Harry Potter and LOTR movies.
Heck we’ve seen Hugh Jackman, the vicious Wolverine, singing and dancing in theater. If that don’t kill tough-guy cred, nothing will.
This sounds really interesting, great director and hopefully a great cast taking shape. Bale is also terrific in “The Fighter”, I hope he does win the Oscar.
My guess is once Nolan is done with Batman, Bale will step away. They seem to be a package deal on these films. Hopefully is number 3 is it they will stick the landing on the trilogy and walk away having set new standards for the genre.
How will Bale use his THE FIGHTER Best Supporting Actor cred? Guy has mad skills.
Sounds like it could be good. Though, it’s interesting that Christian Bale is doing another film about white refugees in China around the time of World War II, considering that his first movie, “Empire of the Sun”, was about white prisoners of war/refugees in China during World War II. Maybe he really likes China in that period of history?
In case you missed it, this picture is going to be about horrific history. The Asian Holocaust is one way to look at it. I refer you to “The Rape Of Nanking” by Iris Chan, which this picture is clearly going to owe a debt. This will not be a date movie. I assure you.
Bale has already publicly announced that he is done with Batman after The Dark Knight Rises unless Christopher Nolan has anything to say about it. I think three Batman films and a strong trilogy is enough for Bale as Batman.
The one thing the Keaton kept from his role as Bruce Wayne – He’s batshit crazy.
The batman franchises were cheesy Dreck before Nolan got a hold of it.
Bale has reeked the benefits of the franchise finally being done right.
after seeing him in the Fighter….they should save everyone some time and just hand him the oscar.
best performance of the year..
Being a fellow.. Masshole…he really nailed the accent..
G
Bale is a great actor, although the Batman films did not really stretch him. Batman Begins had a strong ensemble cast, and The Dark Knight was Heath’s show (Bale was also outshone by Eckhart). I’m hopeing in the next one Bale finally joins the party.
I’m not sure this argument holds up. Harrison Ford may have stuck more closely to his bread-and-butter “Everyman Hero” genre, but he also managed to branch out with more critical and commercial success than Bale has enjoyed (ie. Mosquito Coast; Witness; Working Girl).
The same could also be said of George Clooney, who spent much of the past decade using the Ocean’s Eleven films to offset a slew of critically acclaimed projects (ie. Michael Clayton; Syriana; Good Night and Good Luck; Up in the Air)
Yes, Bale has continued to choose films that are largely non-commercial, but that really has more to do with how he’s always operated than anything else. At the same time, his commercial attempts have either disappointed (The New World; Terminator) or found him co-starring in his own film (ie. 3:10 To Yuma; The Prestige; The Dark Knight; Public Enemies).
Thank you for pointing out the obvious that appears to have been forgotten. I really hate net-revisionist history. Errr….
Really??? You put Malick on the commercial list?
And while I agree with you that George Clooney is a champion of great projects, to me he’s more of a star than a great actor… Not that I don’t like his acting, but it always feels like variations on Clooney (I feel the same way about Harrison Ford) whereas Christian Bale has that old-school Gary Oldman ability to transform before our eyes into roles.
It may have been Malick, but it was also marketed as a commercial project. Even so, I guess it isn’t a very good example since, once again, Bale was essentially a co-star.
Anyway, it’s not a question of which acting style anyone prefers. The argument was which “superhero” actor has done a better job of balancing commercial and critical projects.
Aside from his franchise entries, just look at Ford’s choices from `81-`91: Blade Runner, Witness, Mosquito Coast, Working Girl, Frantic, Presumed Innocent, and Regarding Henry. Not only is it a more diverse selection than his typical “hero role”, but nearly all of them were both critical and commercial hits.
And unlike Bale, all of them lived or died solely by having Ford’s name on the marquee. Ford not only used his blockbuster currency to branch out, but he did so while maintaining his bankable status at a time when the star system was still very much alive.
As for Clooney, if the argument is which Batman has done the best balancing act, it’s not even close. Once he finally achieved commercial success (Ocean’s Eleven; Perfect Storm; O Brother), he almost completely changed his approach to choosing projects. The end result is that he used franchise success (Oceans) to rack up far more Oscar recognition than Bale has ever received.
Now I have nothing against Bale (and am even neutral on Clooney), but to suggest he’s done more than any other actor in the genre is absurd.
Harrison Ford is pushing seventy, yet remains the one and only choice to play Indiana Jones in the mind of the public. Can the same be said of Bale as Batman- outside of fanboy circles? The fact that were still seeing “Keaton vs. Bale” arguments- some twenty years and three Bat actors later- suggests not.
The first thought I had when reading the title to this article was how Bale used that currency to completely overhaul Terminator Salvation and the disaster that ensued from his creative control. It also didn’t help that McG was the director.
But as an actor, Bale is fantastic. First saw him in American Psycho and agree with the sentiment of it being one of his most defining roles when it’s all said and done. There are so many great moments in that movie like when he’s chasing the woman with a chainsaw and no clothes on. Or his thoughts on Phil Collins while he readies himself for a murder. Stands up to multiple viewings as well.
And for those who haven’t seen 3:10 to Yuma, I highly recommend checking it out! Crowe and Bale are terrific. Full of rich characters and it manages to be an entertaining western, how often do you find that?
This isn’t about white refugees. It’s about the nanking massacres.
Bale and Yimou, AWESOME. Yimou can show the world that he is the Kubrick of China – no bad movies from him! NONE!!!
Interesting article. Bale has done very well with the Bat franchise that turned him into a movie star, but other than one embarrassing paycheck-film (Terminator 4), Bale has picked only quality films outside of Batman. Some let him play up his movie star image of the stoic hero (3:10 to Yuma, Public Enemies) and some let him stretch as a great actor (The Fighter, Rescue Dawn, The Prestige). It also helps he has an established legacy of great performances before Batman (Empire of the Sun, American Psycho, The Machinist). Batman just put him on Hollywood’s radar as a leading man. Christopher Nolan’s brilliant direction and razor-sharp noirish scripts didn’t hurt either.
I would say two other actors have turned superhero stardom into lemonade. One is, as previously mentioned, Hugh Jackman. Jackman went from that ex-soap Aussie who was a song-and-dance man in London to a Hollywood A-lister who made bold choices (ex. The Fountain). The other is Robert Downey Jr. Sure we all knew and loved Downey. But Iron Man opening to $100 million was what turned him into a bankable movie star and why he is signed onto 50 films now. Tobey Maguire didn’t really turn into a movie star for Spidey, but it let him get movies like Brothers made, so he hasn’t squandered his spandex leverage either. But otherwise, the genre seems to be a career killer in a lot of ways.
Uh, every non-Wolverine/X-Men movie Jackman has made as a leading man has tanked, from Van Helsing to Australia to The Fountain to the TV show he produced, Viva Laughlin. The movie Wolverine itself was awful, despite the fact it did over $300 million. I’d say his super-hero currency hasn’t done him much good.
Really? Batman? I thought it was his work in his movies before The Dark Knight that established his cred. You know, American Psycho, Machinist…He WAS known before Dark Knight, I guess this just makes for a better headline?
Jonathan Chang needs to be in this film.
The Machinist?