Hollywood journalist Allison Hope Weiner has an update on the Ronni Chasen murder case and emails Deadline the following details:
The Beverly Hills police held a press conference on Wednesday stating that they believe that Howard Martin Smith, a career criminal who served time in state prison, shot and killed Hollywood publicist Ronni Chasen. Police announced that lab tests revealed a preliminary match between the murder weapon presumed to have killed publicist Ronni Chasen and the gun used by Howard Smith to kill himself. (Smith committed suicide last week before he could be questioned by law enforcement.) The Beverly Hills Police stated that Smith acted alone in killing Chasen and police don’t believe the murder was a professional hit, but rather a “robbery gone bad.” The police theory is that Smith was on his bicycle and intended to rob Chasen, but she sped off after he shot her. After listening to the details of the press conference, one of my police sources familiar with the investigation questioned the credibility of the investigation and quipped, “If I’m murdered and you find my body in Beverly Hills, please drag my body to LAPD. Even if you have to leave a bloody trail.”
Q: How did the shooter come and go from the scene of the crime on a bicycle without being spotted?
A: “You can not tell me that a black man riding around on a bicycle at midnight in Beverly Hills did not get stopped at one time by the police,” notes the police source with knowledge of the investigation. According to Mapquest, the distance from the 5600 block of Santa Monica Boulevard in Los Angeles to the 800 block of Whittier Drive in Beverly Hills is almost seven miles. The source also questions why this guy who was so allegedly desperate for money bothered to bike all the way to Beverly Hills to rob someone in a car when he can do the same thing closer to home? It’s been reported that neighbors heard the gunshots, called 911, and arrived at the murder scene before Chasen took her last breath. So how did Smith manage to bike down Sunset or Whittier without being spotted by either witnesses or the police? Especially when this part of Beverly Hills has considerable traffic late at night because of its proximity to the Beverly Hills Hotel.Q: How did the shooter aim so deadly while on a bicycle?
A: My police source asks where Smith acquired his shooting expertise. It seems unlikely that he went to the shooting range given that he was having money troubles and was behind on his rent. And how did he manage to shoot so accurately while sitting on a bike? The BHPD stated that a bicycle was found at Smith’s suicide scene and it was taken into custody by the Los Angeles Police Department and will be turned over to BHPD. The fact that the bicycle is still in the LAPD’s possession makes my source wonder whether the BHPD has had an opportunity to examine whether it was even possible for the suspect to have been on his bicycle by the passenger window and shoot directly in the chest. “One would think that they’d have conducted these type of tests before the press conference,” notes the police source.Q: How did Smith manage to pick up all the shell casings at the murder scene and still get away?
A: Since no shell casings were found at the murder scene, Smith somehow managed to shoot Chasen, pick up all the shell casings, and still bike away without being seen by any witnesses. “So it’s nighttime and it’s dark and they expect me to believe this guy is going to waste time to get off his bike in a nice quiet neighborhood to go and pick up shell casings?” my police source askss. “Those things eject backward. They’re rolling all over the place. I don’t believe a streetwise guy who spent time in state prison just stood there and picked up a shell casing on Whittier boulevard and Sunset and then biked away without being noticed.” The police source also doesn’t understand why, if this was a botched robbery, Smith bothered to stay around and pick up shell casings — but didn’t bother to reach into Chasen’s broken car window and grab her purse.Q: Why did BHPD say there was a “preliminary” ballistics match?
A: The police stated that preliminary ballistics match showing the gun used to kill Ronni Chasen was the same gun used by Harold Smith to kill himself. My police source asks the public to question what constitutes a preliminary match. “Either it’s a match or it isn’t,” says the source. “There is one test. You need to think of ballistics like DNA. Either it’s your DNA or it’s not.” The source also asks why there was no discussion about where Smith got the gun or ammunition that he used to kill Chasen and himself. “Where the gun came from? How did Smith end up with the gun? Was it used in other crimes? Where did he get those hollow points from? They’re supposed to keep a record of people who buy bullets. Did they check every gun shop in the area to find out the list of who they sold hollow points to? You know they’ve got a list.”Q: Who is the tipster who contacted America’s Most Wanted?
A: The BHPD on Wednesday stated that if Smith is the shooter, then the person who tipped off America’s Most Wanted will likely get a reward. However, the police source familiar with the investigation wants to know mor. Hs it possible that this tipster knows more about the crime than he’s told police? Have police really had sufficient time to investigate the tipster and whether he had a connection to Smith?Q: Why hold a press conference when BHPD said the investigation is only “60% to 70%” complete?
A: My police source familiar with the investigation said: “I have a bad feeling that this press conference is going to end up being the defense’s opening statement at trial. The police have a lot of investigating to do before they pronounce that Smith acted alone or that he didn’t have any connection to Ronnie Chasen. They need to find out, who did Smith hang out with?”Q: If this was simply a random crime, then why did Smith shoot Chasen so many times if he didn’t even know her?
A: The police stated they believe that Ronni Chasen’s murder was a random act of violence and that Smith had no connection to her. However, my police source with knowledge of the investigation still remains unconvinced about the BHPD’s theory of the crime. “This is a not a random homicide or a robbery gone bad. This was personal,” argues the source. “You don’t have a victim of a carjacking or robbery shot multiple times. Look at the statistics. People shoot someone multiple times for maximum effect.” Although the police stated at Wednesday’s press conference that they believed Smith acted alone and that they don’t believe that Chasen’s murder was a professional hit, at least two of my police sources with some knowledge of the investigation don’t buy it. “I don’t believe that this streetwise punk who’s done time in prison agreed to kill someone without at least getting some sort of a down payment. They need to look at where Smith spent his money. When I first heard they were having this press conference, I couldn’t believe it,” adds police source. “And then I realized, ‘Wow, they’re really going to just blame it all on the dead guy.’”
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.




Nobody I’ve talked to believes the result of this investigation. And it’s not because they just ‘want the story to be better’ — it’s because the resolution defies logic from every angle, as indicated by this post.
BHPD should be ashamed for this. More holes in this case than a Brett Ratner production.
Beverly Hills Cops closed the case – I’m sure the real murderer is sipping on Mai Tai’s and feeling good that they actually got away with it. Let’s just hope they don’t have incentive to do it again like Joran van der Sloot did.
If I’m a armed robber on a bike looking for a victim and I live on Santa Monica and Western, I’m going to Hancock Park to find someone in a Mercedes, not 7 miles away on Sunset and Whittier. This is too fishy to believe. Unbelievable B.S.
Blame a Black man for the murder of a White woman? WHAAAAAAAT? Nice police work BHPD trying to cover your asses. Shocker! There is way more to this murder than what they are leading on.
Your source doesn’t even ask the most obvious question: if there was a bike left behind, was it Smith’s? And if so, how did he get back to Hollywood? Grab a bus on Sunset?
It said the bike was found at Smith’s house. Not at the scene.
I knew it. something doesn’t add up. either that guy who killed himself was setup so the BHPD can sweep this under the rug and say “Crime Solved”. do they expect us to believe that crap they are saying? RIP Ronni
More here than in days and days (and days) of LA Times coverage. Thanks.
While anything is possible, it all seems to add up to a very flimsy conclusion. I think the report I read on this site a week or two ago about Chasen somehow finding herself knowing about an art fraud was closer to the truth than what is being claimed by the BHPD.
While I agree with all the questions asked… one thing that annoyed me at about this writer, was her constantly saying… “My police source.” My experience with reporters is that if they’re saying something like “my police source, my police source with knowledge of the investigation..” usually means, “random guy off the street,” or at best, “janitor that works for the BHPD.
Don’t get me wrong, I agree with everything in the article… but it’s not like anything she wrote was revolutionary. Heck, read the comments about this case on this very sight… all these points were made… what I want, is something NEW. If this reporter has connections like she’s claiming, then get us some new information instead of the same stuff we’ve all read and thought.
Same questions crosses my mind, and I am not an investigator, but a mere writer. Is this dis-information, to convince someone else he’s not the suspect?
pretty damn good questions being posed by this source. but will answers ever come?
The police attitude was disgusting and the 2 police at the press conference should be fired. The information was incomplete and premature. We are the laughing stock of America and Ronni’s case suffers with these Keystone clown cops!
Beverly Hills PD is the second worst police department in the area. The only one worse is Burbank, and their foibles and corruption and intimidation are legendary. I don’t think BHPD is getting anyone up. I beleive this is their final conclusion.
Agreed. Too many unanswered Q’s. What about the black car/SUV that drove around Chasen’s car spotted by a personal security camera? (reported earlier by yhe Press) Also, the angle of the bullets through the window was from above – unlikely on a bike.
Very fishy.
Good work.
I live in Studio City and you can detect the rotten fish smell from this investigation clean over here.
Some higher authority needs to step in.
This is not anywhere near over.
the “higher authority” already has stepped in!!!
no shell casings = revolver
Lastly, what about the recently reported crimes with similarities elsewhere in L.A. That occurred after this shooting? There was one reported by the Press that occurred East of the city that involved multiple shots through a side window from an SUV. The victim survived. Random? Or, part of a connected scheme? My best guess, a gang initiation.
Thank you for this article. My questions exactly. This just does not add up. Too neat from the BHPD. All we need now is the neighbor lady coming forward with a letter Smith left saying he acted alone. And then we have the three act screenplay.
I don’t buy this investigation. If he was on a bike there has to be some footage of him from some time of that day/night even if he was waiting and stashed the bike in the park. Did they look for shell casings in the medians on Sunset? I think they might be incompetent.
This is such a travesty.
BHPD is nothing more than a highly paid security company…and, obviously, the citizens of Beverly Hills are not getting their money’s worth.
Nobody believes the official story.
Killers don’t ride around on bicycles.
Actually Randy, they do, all the time. Don’t know where you live but kids on bikes carry out hits all the time in all kinds of places. Happens in Philly ALL the time.
Killers also ride motorcycles (common hit squad technique all over the developing world), cars, of course, and they even walk!!
There might be alot of problems with the case, but, that was a silly, naive thing to say.
Did they positively identify the murder weapon, then? Its caliber? Because revolvers don’t eject shell casings.
I’m so sorry, my heart goes out to poor Ronni Chasen’s friends and family who are heartbroken and have to endure this Keystone Kops routine. Many commenters on DHD pointed out these very things as well. Hey, if WE can poke holes through the theory, you bet a LAWYER will…
The “explanation” from the BHPD on December 8, 2010 sounds as phony and incredible as a $3 bill. None of it adds up at all. Are we to believe that this Harold Martin Smith person rode his bike on Sunset or other roads that night from east Hollywood and nobody noticed him on Sunset Boulevard or other streets including frequent BHPD patrol and many other security service patrols?
Are we to believe that even though the BHPD was on the scene of the crime on Whittier drive within 5 minutes of the shooting that his suspect then rode his bicycle on Sunset or other roads the long distance out of Beverly Hills to the east to head back to Hollywood (or rode out to the west on Sunset Boulevard to take a very long out of the way route home)? And all this time that Smith is riding is bicycle in Beverly Hills after the police were fully aware of a murder attempt that just happened nobody saw or stopped Smith and no patrol cars encountered Smith on his bicycle?
And is there any evidence from any security cameras along the possible routes away from the scene of the crime that a man on a bicycle was ever even present in the area that night?
I am embarrassed for the BHPD. I can not believe that they would come up with such a half assed story for the public. Honestly, it is disgusting and insulting to my intelligence. As a resident I do not feel protected nor safe after all this cover up and lies. No wonder Zsa Zsa slapped one of them!