WGAW Board Members Chip Johannessen and Patric Verrone have issued a strongly worded message of support the Comcast writers wanting WGA representation:
To Our Fellow Members,
“If the Writers Guild didn’t exist, we’d have to invent it.” — Legendary Hollywood executive Sid Sheinberg said that back in 1988
when he was president of Universal Studios. Mr. Sheinberg didn’t say it out of some great love of the Guild. The fact is we were on strike at the time and, if there had been some way to do without us, any self-respecting studio head would have jumped at the chance. But Mr. Sheinberg understood the role that our Guild, and all the other guilds and unions, play in this industry. A role that Universal’s latest owner, Comcast, seems not to understand.
Hollywood runs on a talented pool of what is essentially freelance labor. The guilds, every bit as much as the companies, make this talent pool possible by ensuring two things: First, that when you work, you’ll be fairly compensated. And second, that your pension and health benefits follow you from job to job. Projects and shows come and go, but fair compensation and portable benefits ensure that talented people remain. This guild-based ecosystem works to everyone’s advantage, including the companies. It makes our industry possible. Because talented people won’t follow their dreams here if, after 20 years of working, they’ve got nothing to show for it. And without the talent pool, everything dries up.
Universal’s new owners don’t get that. Despite what Comcast promised when it was under the microscope of federal merger hearings, it is now clear that they’re not interested in maintaining Hollywood’s union environment. What they’re interested in is the same kind of foot-dragging, strong-arm tactics and deceit they’ve deployed against every effort to unionize elsewhere. Comcast spokespeople dutifully recite that employees should have the freedom to choose whether to be in a union – that, after all, is the law – but official corporate policy is more frankly expressed in their anti-union training manual: “Comcast does not feel union representation is in the best interest of its employees, customers, or shareholders.” That may be what Comcast feels, but the writers of the Comcast Entertainment Group feel differently. They have signed cards, and voted, and petitioned Comcast to accept representation by the WGA. It’s time for Comcast to say yes.
Comcast is now in “the club” – that group of multinational conglomerates (CBS, Disney/ABC, Paramount, Fox, Sony, and MGM) who negotiate together. Comcast may not be there by name – it will almost certainly still speak through familiar NBC/Universal labor executives – but its mistaken approach will most certainly be felt. And its approach is to destroy the unions that, as much as the companies, make this industry work. What Comcast wants is to come in and freeload off what others have built. What it wants is to be able to take advantage of the talent pool without contributing. Comcast thinks it can pull a sleight of hand, labeling some of its writers “Comcast,” and so non-union, when across the hall there is NBC. That may be the way they built the cable company with the worst customer satisfaction ratings in America, but we can’t let it be the way they behave here. None of us can.
As WGAW members we are committed to supporting and welcoming the Comcast writers who are fighting for WGA representation. As WGAW board members, it is our obligation to rally our fellow writers to join in that support. With what’s at stake and considering the way Comcast is behaving, our task should be an easy one and we know we can count you in. Sid Sheinberg saw this industry’s need to invent our Guild; Comcast sees only a need to destroy it.
Chip Johannessen
Patric M. Verrone
Members, Board of Directors
Writers Guild of America, West
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.



GO UNIONS!!!! YOOU NEED TO STAND UP TO THE GREEDY CORPORATE EXECUTIVES!!!! STOP THE CORPORATIONS NOW.
you nreed to simplify your argument… if you really have one ?
Um, yes it’s a simple argument. Unions mean that you’re not negotiating alone. You have others behind you. And what’s the MINIMUM you can be paid is what’s at stake. Not how much you can make, but what’s the LEAST you can make. Can you survive on what you will be paid? Can you eat? Can you get medical care, if you need it? It’s called decency.
You are actually incorrect. By creating an artificial salary floor that great writers and crap writers adhere alike, you are limiting the upward movement of the top of your union. Now, why would any organization differentiate between the middle writers, they won’t, which means they will be paid based on the floor. Therefore, what this does is prop up the low writers and artificially cap the high writers.
Now, everyone understands the health insurance and pension part of it, but that system is so f*ed up in this country that it has to be this way. However, without a union, its all a matter of supply and demand. Where the amount you earn is based on your skills. The studios need your talent, this is a fact, they can’t do it themselves and because of this there is always a demand. Your union is keeping your wages down if you work on a hit show.
Your argument is based on common economic theory – supply and demand. Unfortunately, we exist in a world of many suppliers and only a few demanders – i.e. a many writers competing for work at only a few studios. This same argument explains why McDonalds rather than farmers set the price for potatoes.
In such a case, it is very easy for the few demanders (studios) to get together and decide on a price. Even if there were only a few writers, they would not be able to demand huge fees because there are only a few places to sell their wares.
The studios can set a low price and it is then in their best interest to maintain that low price. Without more competition for the script, there is no force that can drive the price higher.
America once railed against monopoly, and yet now it pervades.
I appreciate the rational argument response, however, your example falls short. Even though their are only a “few” production companies and they set the rate they are willing to pay, if that rate is too low they won’t get talented writers. This obviously doesn’t work if 3 out of 6 companies are unionized.
However, I will use this as an easy example. Henry Ford (racist, nutjob) but great industrialist paid higher wages then other factories so he could get the best workers. By paying higher, he would have his pick of the talent. Then the next highest wage company would get seconds, and so on. (This was when there were factories in the US, before obscene wages, healthcare and worker rights got out of control)
I am not an advocate of corrupt, closeminded “executives” getting paid huge sums of money for failing. I am an advocate for living in a society where when people take chances risk their own money and come up with an idea, they should be rewarded. Workers are just that workers.
Now, being a great writer is a fantastic gift, and the fact of the matter remains, the union system put in place enables inferior writers to maintain steady jobs, instead of rewarding the truly innovative writers with great dialouge and new stories. This is not just about the WGA, but unions as a whole.
During the industrial revolution, unions has a purpose, since people were dying and getting injured left and right. Now, with workers compensation and a hopeful fix in the healthcare system to detach it from employer based and make it individual based, there would be no need for unions at all.
Ziggy said, “Even though their are only a “few” production companies and they set the rate they are willing to pay, if that rate is too low they won’t get talented writers.”
Um, have you been to the movies or looks at programming on cable lately?
I’d say a lot of untalented writers are already getting employed by lowest common denominator suits budget conscious of the cost of a writer compared to the costs of production values and on-screen talent.
What a great letter. There’s nothing worse than new leadership who has no idea how this business is run to come in and try to set everyone back decades.
Amen, Patric and Chip. Comcast needs to listen to its writers: They want WGA membership. Give it to them. It will benefit Comcast and its shareholders as well as the writers.
By the way, why were Patric and Chip the only board members to sign this letter? The failure of the current Guild leadership to organize WGA members around this important issue is disappointing.
Ashley Gable
You know things are bad for your profession when a hack like Chip is chosen to lead you.
Yes, let’s stop those corporations. If only the U. S. Government ran all the businesses.
What have you got against representative democracy? Government of, by, and for the people!
These goshdarn unions are bankrupting the poor studios. When will people realize that all the great ideas, concepts and writing come from studio executives and shareholders and not from these so called union writers.
Its a fact that all the films nominated for writing this year were written by studio executives who have been forced to take fake names to placate the writers unions, I only wish that some news organization like fox news or glen Beck would blow the lid off this and those greedy union thugs
Studio execs and shareholders have all the new concepts and ideas and they do the writing? Really?
Unions are destroying this country by making America much less competitive
Riddle me this, Jean. Germany has one of the highest rates of union employment in the world. About a third of their workers are directly represented by unions, and those union collective bargaining agreements cover over 90% of all jobs there (source: germanculture.com.)
Yet despite the overwhelming prevalence of unions there, Germany is kicking the United State’s ass economically. Germany’s joblessness has fallen to an 18-year low. They’re actually facing a shortage of skilled labor (source: Bloomberg News, 2/1/2011.)\
In Germany, labor is a partner in industry. In the U.S., labor is a just a cog in the machinery, ready to be outsourced or exploited at a moment’s notice.
And families in Germany don’t go bankrupt due to a serious illness. The horror!
Shame on you Shawn. Positive results are no reason to back something. You should rely more on corporate support and religious arguments masquerading as free market principles.
You and your pesky facts!
Yeah, because the US was sooooooo uncompetitive in the 1950s at the height of unionization.
I’m not pro-union, but I’m not completely anti-union either. But in the 1950s we had the advantage of the rest of the developed world being crushed by WWII.
Oh Dear. What a marvelously simplistic and wrong idea. Let me guess . . . .tea party??
Fox news is great, you have no idea how true it is. Those greedy union scumbags forced me to buy a off the lot Porsche for my daughter nunu’s birthday instead of having one custom made due to their royalty demands.
My poor nunu was devastated and will no longer text me. Even my poor wife has been affected, instead of shredding those wrinkled and dirty 100 dollar bills, she has to use them as cash like a common poor person.
Oh my god, what a bunch of entitled whiners.
Of course they do. It’s the psycho-Right war on unions which is class war on ALL middle and lower class. They are trying to divide Americans with lie upon lie.
However, 75k showing up in WI, protests in OH and we have awakened the sleeping giant. The oligarch reign will end soon. They will be thrown out, by force, if necessary.
Remember Egypt.
gee, i wonder if the Koch Brothers (or as they should be known the real life version of “Trading Places” Duke Brothers) will show Comcast the way.
the multi-billionaires are behind the Wisconsin governor’s union busting and who knows what else?
i guess money is only supposed to be in the hands of a chosen few, kind of like merry ol’ England with knights and peasants.
Interesting that MGM is mentioned in there, particularly as they just dismissed all their Union workers.
comcast needs to focus on all the illegal downloads happening on their network 1st – and most of all TRY NOT TO FIX WHATS NOT BROKEN – UNION STRONG!
This is an extremely well-written letter, which makes a lot of sense considering the source. The first two comments, however, appear to have been written by borderline illiterates.
More importantly, go writers!
Having worked for this duplicitous company long before the Universal takeover, this doesn’t surprise me in the least. It’s the same anti-Union stance they’ve taken on their terrible reality shows for years, and now they’re trying to run Universal the same way. Shame on them.
We can only hope they succeed. Unions are corrupt organizations by their very structure, since everything is run by favoritism and patronage, and honest whistle-blowers are ruthlessly punished and driven out. If a society has good educational opportunities, & numerous jobs available to create competition for talented workers, unions are as useful as a buggy whip.
See here’s the thing about this dipshit point of view. We don’t have to imagine what life would be like without unions since we have HISTORY BOOKS! Everything, and I mean literally everything in modern life got better the stronger the labor movement in this country and around the world got. Standard of living, income, property ownership and education all increased after the labor movement. All those things have also gotten worse or at best stagnated as the labor movement has ebbed under relentless pressure from corporations.
You obviously don’t know jack about economics, business and labor or you would recognize that a dynamic labor movement is the key to “good educational opportunities, & numerous jobs available to create competition for talented workers”. All of those things come from a thriving middle class that helps creates revenue to build the infrastructure needed to sustain a modern economy and provides the consumer spending that drives it.
So if you’re so certain that a country without union labor is so much more desirable, please emigrate to Haiti or Indonesia or some other semi-developed shithole and go to work for one of the thriving industries paying the few dollars a day that someone of your obvious intellect would be able to negotiate with the sweatshop owners in a more “merit-based society”.
As a writer currently scripting shows for
Comcast I strongly urge the company to honor the commitments it made to the unions during the last year.
I have no insight on whether unions in this industry are good or bad. I don’t know Comcast’s view of unions. But I worked at Comcast within their main technical division.
Let’s just say their culture isn’t warm and fuzzy. And they are frugal. You mess up? You are shown the door. That’s life at Comcast.
Comcast profited by underpaying workers, denying works rights and taking advatage of customers. NBC Universal will fail if they adopt this strategy as they move forward. It’s not legal, it’s offensive to Americans and it won’t be tolerated by workers.
Wasn’t there another letter that was actually signed by writers on NBC shows that fall under the WGA agreement? Those NBC writers need to go public with their support.
those same writers are worrying about their own jobs right now – can’t expect them to stick their necks out and call attention to themselves.
if you were a writer for NBC would you want your name publicly known? Didn’t think so.
It’s no surprise that Comcast continues down a destructive, dishonest path. I hate to see this company have to learn the hard way. On the other hand, I look forward to losing executives and management who have abused their positions, been greedy and won’t be needed soon.
If the WGA wants to stop this, they need to sue the studios as monopolies. Until then, they are all talk and will get bitch slapped.
All the WGA is asking is for Comcast to come to the bargaining table to work out an agreement. Everyone on both sides knows 97% of Comast Writers have already done the research and decided they want to go guild.
You are TRUELY MISINFORMED
Well put, Chip and Patric! I’m happy the guild’s leadership spoke up on this one. The companies will always make excuses and it’s important to stand up and call their greed for what it is.