EXCLUSIVE: This is why so many Hollywood creatives don’t understand the decisions of the networks and the Big Media corporations who run them. Because here’s a show that’s doing well in its primetime slot. And just a few days ago, freshman drama Blue Bloods was praised by Armando Nunez, president of CBS Studios International. “It’s perhaps not as sexy to talk about, but it has proven a success both on the network and in terms of global distribution,” he said. It tops the charts of how this season’s freshman shows have performed, with Blue Bloods sold around the world not just to tiny channels but to big ones like Sky Atlantic in the UK, Australia’s Network Ten, and Discovery Latin America.
So what do CBS and CBS Studios and its executive producer Leonard Goldberg, who also happens to be a CBS Corporation board member, do? They exit the show’s creators Mitchell Burgess and Robin Green (formerly of The Sopranos). Because I’m told Goldberg and the network think the show needs be “more procedural.” As if CBS doesn’t already have procedural shows coming out of its wazoo. And this latest firing comes nine months ago after then-showrunner Ken Sanzel exited the CBS series because of creative tensions with Tom Selleck over scripts that the actor felt were too procedural.
Of course, it’s a ridiculous conflict of interest for Goldberg to both be on the CBS Corp board and to be running one of its shows. (His official CBS bio doesn’t mention that, of course.) Not to say that Leonard isn’t a TV legend. But at first considered a long shot (“pilot #10 of 10″), Blue Bloods (then titled Reagan’s Law) made it onto the schedule in the first place because of Selleck’s stardom and Goldberg’s juice. CBS traditionally teams the limited-experience creators of its newly picked-up series with seasoned showrunners after the pilot, which is why former cop Sanzel was brought in as exec producer and showrunner. He ran Numb3rs for most of the procedural’s six-season run on CBS, and Blue Bloods even inherited the Numb3rs’ 10 PM Friday time slot. Blue Bloods is the first hour-long drama Selleck has headlined since Magnum, P.I., and the star wanted an emphasis on the characters, not the crimes. I scooped that Selleck wasn’t accepting the scripts that Sanzel had been giving him. So a standoff developed over personal vs procedural. And from the latest firings, those creative differences are still going on.
CBS, CBS Studios, Goldberg, and Selleck are all looking for a new showrunner now. ”How do you keep the network happy and Tom Selleck happy and Len Goldberg happy?” an insider today asked about the current situation. Another insider tried to make the Burgess-Green exit more palatable by claiming, “We’re thrilled with the template they set as the creators of the show, but we weren’t satisfied with the creative growth of the stories and the characters. No animosity, just our desire to get more wins on the board.” But there were enough wins that CBS moved the show from Friday, where it was averaging a healthy 12.3 million viewers, to Wednesdays at 10 PM for a four-week trial run beginning Jan. 19. It was moved back to Fridays on Feb. 11.
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.






Goldberg is a fossil…
Goldberg and Moonves believe they are creators. Arrogance plus machismo squared. They should sit down and write a pilot and prove it.
Goldberg is on the board of directors of CBS. He was appointed by Les Moonves. They are buddies. The whole endeavor is a conflict of interest. Burgess and Green are the exceedingly talented writer/producer/creators of this show.
It has succeeded despite Tom Selleck with that paunch and horrible hair dye because the premise and stories are good and the rest of the cast talented.
Who got them there? It wasn’t 60 blank pages. It was the world and characters of the show created by the Burgess and Green.
CBS is not a friendly place to work if you are talented. Creators beware of this network. Nina is spineless. Moonves is a slimeball.
This move makes no sense.
Blue Bloods is the best show running on television. The story line of solving the crime is shown with just the right amount of emphasis. But the Reagen family unit, their love and respect for each other, being shown as an American, blue collar, religious, family. Sitting down at that family table, putting all the problems aside for that brief period of time reminds me so much of how life was “back in the day”, around my grandparents’ and parents’ tables in America. It gives such a good feeling that maybe, just maybe, not all is lost in today’s America. Maybe we can get by the drugs, crime, cell phones and video games, and still have that brief period of time sitting down together as a family, all differences aside.
this show is great its actually about a functional family we could all learn from … please please leave it alone
Now if only they could do something about Tom Selleck’s jet black hair. It is very distracting and unreal!
I don’t understand why they mess with a show that is as good as this one is. It is one of the best drama shows I have seen in a long time and look forward to it each week. It is in the calibur of law and order where you see the reruns over and over and don’t mind at all.
It’s a broken system. The creators created the show. Let them continue creating the show. You wouldn’t have the show if they hadn’t created it. Just STOP. STOP THIS MADNESS. THIS DISGUSTING MADNESS. It’s one thing if BLUEBLOODS was souring in the ratings, if it weren’t garnering a solid fanbase. But this was.
And this whole thing is absurd. More procedural?! You have a bona fide television star on your series, and you want to make it less about his character and his character’s storylines? You want to basically do away with character and storylines in order for procedural poop? COME ON! The networks are a mess, we all know that, but man… awful. Awful awful.
Networks have no respect or regard for the people who give them their shows, who sweat and bleed their shows. Egotistical, uncreative, untalented suits are destroying network television, and it isn’t going to stop. For now, it’s sad… but in ten years, when people officially stop referring to NBC, CBS, ABC as “networks” because these stations are getting lost in the mix of cable, etc and people won’t even know what they are, let alone care… well, that will be a wonderful day. A show is good on tbs, tnt, usa, etc. then people will tune in. No one really cares about having to watch network shows anymore.
You’re gross, CBS.
All those cable channels you mentioned are still owned by those big media companies, so you’re just moving the goalposts unfortunately. It’s part of the game, you have to play by their rules.
I wish this were only the case with the networks, but I’ve heard of certain cable networks who are also following suit, trying to make their shows more “procedural” and in the end, losing the voice of the show.
It’s a shame, truly.
Interesting to know Selleck has this much say.
Don’t tinker with something that is working is always the best advise. Blue Bloods is good because of Tom Selleck and the love trickel down love relationship of all of the actors; and solving the crime in the show just brings all of the character that much closer together. Tom is surely the biggest draw for me; so don’t try to fix something that by pure luck you have alread made perfect.
I do believe Tom Selleck starred in Las Vegas which was also an hr long T.V series.
He appeared on the program but wasn’t the “star”, James Caan was..
Bill Clark, ex EP of NYPD Blue should join this show….what could be better for a New York City based procedural cop show!
Canceling it.
Bill Clark is the luckiest man in the business, and I’ll stand on Ed Burns’ kitchen table and say that.
How can you screw with one of the best shows on tv? Far more emotional depth than 95% of the rest of the drivel being aired. Most of the shows on network tv these days have really poor dialog and in a lot of cases are coupled with mediocre to bad acting.
Blue Bloods is in a class by itself. If Tom Selleck wants to do it a certain way then let him do it till he’s proven wrong. And in case the network doesn’t have a clue yet, they don’t have a choice. Selleck is the heart and soul of the show.
If the network decides to get cute, then I’ll be the first in line to boycott the show. Leave it the hell alone!!
Isn’t this the same network that dumped 2 females on Criminal Minds? How did that work out? (Oh, they want them back.) Are there death wishes at the $54 million man’s network. Someone once told me, if it isn’t broke don’t fix it.
You’ve got a great show going.
Friday night is perfect. The plots show inside a cop’s life. That why it’s so interesting.
sounds like karma coming back to bite tom selleck…
Yikes.
I want Blue Bloods to come back next season, mainly because I love the cast.
It could use some better writing, so maybe the change will be for the best.
After a promising pilot, there was almost zero character development, even after Sanzel left.
Open letter to Tom Selleck:
Dear Tom,
Please use some of your clout and have CBS switch “Blue Bloods” to film. This would allow actors to work the show under a SAG contract. Many actors are losing their health insurance because so many shows, like “Blue Bloods” are now under AFTRA jurisdiction, instead of SAG jurisdiction. Almost all one hour dramas were under SAG until the Unite For Strength faction took over SAG in 2009.
Thank you for reading.
Sincerely,
Larry B.
IF it is not filmed on film then what are we watching, video? Don’t think so.
Also, AFTRA jurisdiction due to filming in New York— or due you want it shot on the NY set in Hollywood? Why not just cancel the show and end all the madness!
It’s shot on RED (video). I don’t know the politics or union differences between film & video, but I will say that “Blue Bloods” is one of the best looking shows on TV right now.
As for the changes, it sounds like another case of fixing what wasn’t broken.
First of all, In America the “employee” is supposed to have the right to choose their bargaining agent or union.
AFTRA does not have jurisdiction over a “region”, such New York. If that were true “Law & Order: SVU” and “Gossip Girl” would be under AFTRA. For your information they’re both shot digitally, under SAG’s jurisdiction. SAG has jurisdiction over any TV program shot like a motion picture. AFTRA is only supposed to cover actors employed in live broadcasts .
AFTRA is now claiming that if you use a 24p digital camera, such as the RED camera, that AFTRA can “share” jurisdiction. Even though I’ve never met an actor that wants AFTRA as their bargaining agent or union. They are claiming that a TV show that is shot with a digital camera is not a motion picture or that the RED camera is not a motion picture camera I guess.
I am not saying that “Blue Bloods” does not look good. personally I think it would look even better on film. Look at “Castle”, “The Mentalist” or “Fringe”. All three of those shows are shot on film.
Ask any DP that has shot on both formats, film or digital, digital is not better, faster or cheaper..yet. Digital is also a lot more expensive to archive than film. Read “The Digital Dilemma”.
I don’t want to get into a debate, with a RED fanboy, over which format is better. I just don’t want to see actors lose their health and pension benefits because of AFTRA.
The only way that I can see out of this mess, is if actors with clout, such as Tom Selleck, insist on a SAG contracts. The only way to change jurisdiction, once a show is established, such as in this case, is to switch to film.
Damned if you aren’t the dumbest! Every new one-hour network show (with the exception of spinoffs from filmed parent shows) has been done in 24p video. Do you even *read* Nikki’s posts? You should stick to posting letters to the editor of The Daily Flyover. Your insight isn’t appreciated here.
My insight isn’t appreciated by you, but you are the person until corrected, thought that “Blue Bloods” AFTRA union jurisdiction, was determined by the fact that it is shot in New York. That’s got to be one of the dumbest things ever written on this site.
For your information, all recent spinoffs have been made using a digital cameras. It didn’t matter if the “parent” show was shot on film or not. The reason a spinoff is with the same union as the original show, is the fact that it is considered an *extension* of the original show. The characters are introduced on an episode of the original show, an example would be the most recently aired episode of Fox’s “bones”. The Fox spinoff will be called “The Finder”. Both are SAG. “Bones” was originally shot on film. “The Finder” was shot on an Arri Alexa 24p digital camera.
MOST TV shows are shooting digital now (which is why most are opting to sign contracts with AFTRA rather than SAG). The quality is so good now because of better cameras/tvs that it’s hard to tell it’s not film anymore, plus it’s a lot cheaper.
The location has NOTHING to do with signing the AFTRA contract, there are SAG movies and TV shows that shoot in New York all the time.
Oh, and responding to Larry’s post about actors losing health insurance… I’m not sure I understand the argument. I, like most actors who work regularly (or even not-so regularly), am a member of both unions, and benefits are just as available to members of either union (I currently get my benefits through AFTRA, but have gotten them from SAG in the past).
You don’t understand the argument because you are not *really* an actor, are you? AFTRA, unlike the DGA, WGA, IATSE and SAG, is not part of the MPTF network. Which is because AFTRA is not a motion picture union (or wasn’t until the wimps at UFS took over SAG).
SAG Actors have been part of MPTF network for what, 40 years? When SAG members lose their SAG insurance, they have to go outside of the Motion Picture Television Fund network. All actors that have had to switch to AFTRA insurance, have a BIG problem with that, believe me.
What about the SAG members that were about to become vested in a SAG pension, before all the new TV shows switch to the scumbag union -AFTRA? Do you think that actors don’t have a problem with THAT? Be serious.
You can’t be an actor, you are obviously just a phony AFTRA shill..
The show does lack a certain focus. I don’t know if I’d go with a more procedural approach, but give the arcs more even coverage. The youngest’s son’s arc about searching out the secret covert group his late brother was mixed up in is just laying there and when that happens his a character is just doing nothing. What a waste of a good actor. Selleck’s character needs more range. He can do more, and let’s see more with the daughter. I think they can service a story of the week while still moving forward on the arcs.
This show is sooo corny. “Why do i know you’ll do the right thing, because you’re a Reagan!”
” you wanna know why you’re the best detective, it’s because you’re a Reagan!”
Also lose the grandfather, he’s the worst actor on TV, and his teeth look awful in HD
Losing this show from the CBS lineup wouldn’t make an iota of difference to me.
It is stiff, over-acted and unbelievable.
It’s the characters, stupid. There are too many characters to have more procedural. It would just further slow the already slow pace. Not that there’s anything wrong with that. NCIS LA has procedural coming out the ying yang and it’s boring as hell.
Please don’t mess it up. I hope Selleck keeps an eye out for the show and we don’t see him going out on cases, like MacMillian and Wife.
Damn. I knew it. Now CBS is going to turn BB’s into every other cookie cutter procedural they have.
Burgess and Green are spectacular in every way. They wrote my favorite Sopranos episodes. CBS are fools. HBO, Showtime — please make a deal with them immediately.
Exactly! Mitchell Burgess and Robin Green wrote some of the best Sopranos episodes (Whitecaps!). I look forward to Blue Bloods every week because of the family dynamics that B&G write so well. What disappointing news! I look forward now to their next project.
The only reason I watch the show is for the characters. I can’t stand any of the other procedurals on CBS. I can understand CBS loves their procedurals…but try something else for a change.
So crap. It sounds like CBS is getting ready to renew Blue Bloods which I was hoping for, but it doesn’t sound like the kind of show I will want to keep watching.
“procedural” sells better in syndication. Bottom line. Goldberg’s making a business decision not a creative one. And that’s his job. Selleck’s and the writing staff are supposed to fight for story and character. Looks like the latter were doing there job ’cause now they’re gone. Select should threaten to walk with them and tip Goldberg’s hand.
Except that if the show gets cancelled after the second year and they don’t reach 100 eps because the fans don’t want another procedural, syndication won’t matter.
I like it b/c it’s not a procedural. Kinda think that’s why others like it also.
The only reason i watched it was for Tom Selleck, but much of the focus started going toward the terrible acting of Donnie Wahlberg who i couldn`t care about and even could care even less about his younger brother “the rookie cop” and Jared from The Pretender trying to get info about this “Skulls” like faction of the police dept.Tom Selleck should let this go away and go back to a great character Jessie Stone who the public cares about, Not a former boy band memeber trying to act tough or should i say “Hangin Tough”
As long as someone coming on board this show remembers that Jamie is a character and returns to his story of finding out about the “inner circle” of policemen, which was abandoned somewhere around episode two with no explanation, then I’m fine with any changes.
Yeah, the abandonment of corrupt secret police society plot line is mind boggling. It pops up once in a while, but goes nowhere.
I totally disagree with comments regarding Wahlberg being a bad actor. He’s the highlight of the show IMO.
This show is already kinda of boring. If it goes more procedural, I may bail.
Love this show and desperately want it renewed! Couldn’t disagree more about Donnie Wahlberg. He has been amazing in this show. An incredible actor! I love the family aspect of the show. I do think at times it needs better writing. There have been a few episodes that I think needed a little help. Like I said i just hope and pray for a second season!