
EXCLUSIVE: Fairly Legal creator Michael Sardo has stepped down as executive producer and showrunner of the USA Network dramedy. Former Pushing Daisies executive producer Peter Ocko has been tapped as the new exec producer/showrunner on the series for its upcoming second season.
The changeover is part of USA’s plan for creative changes on Fairly Legal going into Season 2. When USA recently renewed the freshman series, the network’s co-president Jeff Wachtel indicated that the decision was based on the show’s appealing star, Sarah Shahi, and its potential but noted that there is room for improvement. “We think there is a creative and audience upside to the show,” Wachtel said back then. “Not every first season is the best, and we think it is a show that can do better.” While a solid performer — Fairly Legal launched as the top new cable drama of the year in adults 18-49 and has averaged a 4.6 million total viewers in Live+7 — the legal dramedy was not a breakout hit like most of USA’s recent series. Fairly Legal producer Universal Cable Prods is currently negotiating with Sardo about a potential future role on the show. Sardo is behind another high-profile UCP project — he is the creator/executive producer of the studio’s pilot Normal (formerly untitled Michael Sardo) for Lifetime. The drama pilot starring Carrie-Anne Moss is in contention for a series pickup at the cable network, with Sardo set to executive produce. (Additionally, Sardo serves as an exec producer on America’s Smartest Kids, a realty show in development at USA/UCP sibling Syfy).
On Fairly Legal, Ocko will serve as executive producer alongside Steve Stark. The show centers on mediator Kate Reed (Shahi). Its co-stars are Michael Trucco, Virginia Williams and Baron Vaughn. Ocko most recently served as a co-executive producer on NBC’s The Office this past season.
TV Editor Nellie Andreeva - tip her here.


Ocko goes from the Office to Fairly Legal… Hum! Curious to see which direction the show goes… More comedy perhaps? Sarah is a real talent tho… easy on the eyes..
Great choice USA network. Pushing Daisies was a great show. Now I’m known i’m going to start season 1 this summer.
Pete is a great guy and a quality show runner. Congrats to all!
Pete Ocko is a bully who tried to pull a coup at Pushing Daisies the likes of which are still discussed. The guy practically got in bed with McPherson behind the backs of his fellow producers. I love that he leads with that credit now, amazing. He’s calculating, ruthless and shameless.
Every writer/producer who works with him should be very careful.
I really enjoy Sarah Shahi’s character and her assistant Leo. The boyfriend storyline needs to go somewhere or go away, and they need to decide whether the step mother is going to be completely irrational like she was in the season finale or merely complex like she was most of the rest of the season.
A big bummer for the creator, but probably the right move. The show was terrible from Episode 1 despite an obvious potential TV star as the lead.
The show is horrible, but Ms. Shashi is a delight as long as the script isn’t trying to force her to be cute or funny. It will last season 2 but that’s it. They can’t make it more drama because the nature if the show doesn’t lend itself to it – no one really discovers anything as the crux of most shows; it’s just a bunch of emotional whining and compromise and that doesn’t make for 48 more shows you want to watch. They can’t go more comedy because… Well, nothing and no one in the show is funny. S2 would need a major overhaul to be sustainable.
How can they replace the guy that CREATED the show? Sad for him.
I concur with all. Keeping Shahi on the air was the right move. Now just improve the show to match her.
They should just scrap it, and do a third season of Life. I liked her in that role a lot more than neurotic arguing chick that lives on a boat. Complete waste of talent.
I would never have made it past one episode were it not for the charm of Sarah Shahi, but the whole show needs to be retooled.
Jumping into the middle of arguments by strangers may seem cute to whatever idiot writes the show, but it would get her shot or a beat down at the very least.
Virtually everything about the show is annoying:
- The adversarial relationship with the step mother is annoying.
- Being late to everything is annoying.
- The assistant is annoying.
- The ex-husband is annoying.
- The clients getting mad and storming out all the time is annoying.
Get rid of the baggage, focus more on the cases, and let her develop a real social life.
Just do whatever it takes to keep Sarah on the screen!
Sarah Shahi is terrific. Perhaps they should develop more of the role of the Judge, played by Gerald McRaney from Major Dad?