
EXCLUSIVE: Paget Brewster will continue on CBS’ crime drama Criminal Minds next season, while new series regular Rachel Nichols won’t return. Meanwhile, co-star Thomas Gibson still doesn’t have a deal for next season, with negotiations ongoing.
I hear CBS and series’ producer ABC Studios have exercised the option they have on Brewster and opted not to pick up Nichols. As part of Brewster’s modified deal for Criminal Minds last season, which included her doing fewer episodes, she got an out to do a pilot. Brewster used the opportunity and did a pilot, NBC’s comedy My Life as an Experiment, which didn’t make the cut to series. Bewster’s pilot was in first position to Criminal Minds but ABC Studios had an option to bring the actress back to the CBS drama if the pilot didn’t go to series and has now exercised that option.
With Brewster and original cast member and fan favorite A.J. Cook returning to the crime drama alongside Kirsten Vangsness, there wasn’t much room left for Nichols, whose character Ashley Seaver was introduced last season in part to fill the void left by the departure of Cook’s JJ. As for Gibson, I hear Criminal Minds producers want him back. He got warm reception by international buyers at the L.A. Screenings this week where he appeared with other cast members of the veteran CBS crime drama. Co-star Shemar Moore, whose deal was also up at the end of this season, signed a new one earlier this month.
TV Editor Nellie Andreeva - tip her here.


I feel really bad for Rachel Nichols. She got a bad deal. She had a poorly defined character fans were pre-programmed to hate. She really never had a shot.
However, YES!!! I’m thrilled Paget will be back! Now all we need is Thomas to get re-signed and I’ll be a happy, happy fan!
i agree with you!!! ihave stopped watching the show because of part of the cast being gone but will pick it up again as it is one of my favorite shows
Yes! You’re right. Nichols got very interesting character but was poorly written. I hope they won’t simply killed her off, instead maybe offer her as a special guest actor once in awhile to streghtened and build the character.
It’s great Paget is back.Love her strong and independent character. She’s a gem!
I am so excited that Paget will be back!
That’ll be one helluva return episode since everyone thinks she’s dead.
That really does suck for RN. I hope they let her pop in once in a while, but maybe send her back to training where they got her as she’s NOT A PROFILER. That really was just unfortunately bad writing for a not so bad actress.
i argree with that and i also think her and Hotch should get together when she returns lol she never has a man in it. Plus its better if they’re all together now Jjs cumming back!!! woopwoop!!!
Totally agree! LOVE PAGET and I wish Prentiss and Hotch get together..never really liked RN..sorry
I agree!! I could see her and Hotch as an item. He needs her so he can loosen up a bit!! I will start back to watching the show now that my girls are returning!! Woohooo!!
so is it true she is coming back?! what season is it and when is she coming back??
when is there going to be a new crimminal minds
HOOORRRRAAYYY!
I am SO thrilled that all of the cast members will be returning! I did write to CBS in protest of letting “JJ”go, and again with “Emily”. I had never before written to the producers of any show, but I truly love the “Team” as it was, and will be again! Thanks CBS for making the right choice! You will be rewarded by high ratings from your very loyal Criminal Minds fan base! Can’t wait for September 22nd!!!!
I LOVE JJ always have and was crushed when she left. Then it was another rough blow when Prentiss left. I never really got into Nichols. I thought they tried too hard to replace JJ and there just is no replacing her without AJ Cook. However, Criminal Minds would not be Criminal Minds without Hotch so I sure hope he signs soon!!! Yay for the original team being back together!!! Wonder how they are writing Prentiss back in? Maybe killing Valhalla?
glad paget is back too. They should sign Gibson get rid of Montega and bring Sam Cooper to the team or get Keifer Sutherland. Just a thought
I am thrilled that both Paget Brewster and AJ Cook will be returning. Nothing against Rachel Nichols but I didn’t care for her character on the show. Now if the network can get Thomas Gibson signed, the family will be back together again.
I agree, I have been a fan for years and I don’t want Thomas to leave, he is a big part of the reason I see Criminal Minds. I am glad JJ is coming back, we missed her and Paget, well I was hoping she will come back one way or another. I did like Rachel Nichols but was a little hard to get use to her because I really liked JJ. Can’t wait till the season begins again.
I simply want Paget Brewster back.. Not the same.
the show was always better with paget brewster and a.j. cook i bet rachel nichols even knows that! the show wasnt as good with rachel nichols as it was with paget brewster and a.j. cook!! AND IF THEY EVEN TRY TO TAKE AWAY KIRSTEN VANGSNESS OR SHEMAR MOORE I AM GOING TO SCREEEEEEEEEEMMMMMMMM!!!
i like youu!
i think that your opinion is bloody amazing!
getting rid of Kirsten vangness or shemar moore is just like the end of the world honestly!
NO CRIMINAL MINDS WITHOUT THOSE TWO!
I agree. Hope the producers are listening!!!!!!!
I completely agree .. I’m sure that Nichols will go on to do great things but criminal minds is MUCH better off with Brewster, and Cook. If Gibson signs on again I think they need to bring in a romance between Emily and Aaron.
I’m so glad that Prentiss will be back. But i want to know when will Seavers story be wraped up
Its great that Brewster is back the show really lost that special feel that it had with that cast. I think if Mandy Patankin made a return visit (not permanent) to the show it would boost the ratings significantly…
Oh yes!! I love Mandy, but I also like Joe and I’ve gotten used to him. So bringing Mandy back once or twice a year would do my heart good, lol!
I’m sure Gibson will be back.
I thought the same for Lisa Edelstein on House. She was one of the reasons that show was watchable. That doesn’t seemed to have worked out.
Thomas Gibson is good on the show, but his character is completely unnecessary. In the real world, Just about anyone can fill the management role. Why should it be any different on the show?
Because he is a fan favourite and the show is dead without him…
That is what everyone said about Gideon…
Very different. Mandy Patinkin wanted to leave the show because it was too violent so he opted out, even when they offered him more money he didn’t want to stay
Please bring Paget back,she is the real deal!!!:)
Gideon wasn’t THE show like Hotch is. IN MY OPINION….
Because Criminal Minds is set in the real world yet it’s not the real world?
SHUT UP Mike I.
I’m really going to pretend you did not just say that. Do you even watch the show?
He is an amazing PROFILER; he doesn’t JUST ‘manage’ the team.
I watch the show every week. I enjoy the group dynamic, but Shemar Moore and AJ Cook are my favorites on the show. The way the jacked her around to reduce the cost of the series was reprehensible.
I have little patience for the producers playing musical chairs with the cast to save a buck.
The writing is consistently interesting. As long as the quality of the creative part of the show remains high, I will continue to tune in. People come and go (career development, promotions, desire to make more money, etc.), so the composition of a team should change over time.
Actors come and go for various reasons (some moves more mind boggling than others – Shelly Long from Cheers and David Caruso from NYPD Blue: at least he seems to have learned that lesson).
When the music stops, I will still be watching.
i luv shemar moore it wud break my heart to see him leave the show
I thought that about Kal Penn on house Kal played the role of Kutner but then agin I thought they would make a couple episodes where thirteen and chase would date
Finally, the team is back together. Great news!
YESS!!!! Best news ever – JJ & Emily are back!!!!
I know! In my opinion, they are the best two characters on TV and we need them on Criminal Minds! I screamed when I read this!!!!!
I wanted to scream too but,… kids are sleeping up stairs!!! HHHRAAAYY!!!!
Thank god!! They came to there sense!!! See later Rachel Nichols, Hello Paget Brewster!!!!!
I hope CBS heard us loud and clear. You dont just get rid of your main characters and expect that die hard fans are gonna accept that. So no more changes, lets get Thomas Gibson back now!!
It was stupid of CBS to mess with such a winning formula on Criminal Minds and then go create a spinoff (that failed). Mind you, it created a great story for Prentiss. Can’t wait to see how they bring her back.
my bet is they find ian doyle/ kill him
hopeful RIP ian doyle
Now if only Mandy Patinkin would make a cameo in the hunt for Ian Doyle…aaaah if wishes were horses!
yes, that would be great if they could work him in , even for 1 or 2 shows,
Oh thank God. The show had missed Brewster and Cook, and Nichols just wasn’t right for the tone of the show.
Makes sense to me. Rachel Nichols had a steep hill to climb in any event, and with A.J. Cook returning, she didn’t really have a chance.
[color=#fe0000]Their baaaaccckkkkk![/color] Fan Outrtage saved the day!
CR without Thomas Gibson is like a day without sunshine, Give him what he wants, he is so worth it and no can take his place.
YOU GO Nanci Hughes
Do you people read what you write before submitting your comments???….What is CR??? If you are going to abbreviate at least use the wright letters CM and “no can take his place”??? No ONE can take his place, please have some respect for yourself and just read what you write.
On the other hand I was also very upset when AJ Cook left the show and even more when they killed Emily’s character, glad they are both coming back. Did know about AJ Cook since she says it herself at the last episode but am very pleased that Emily is coming back also.
And for Mike I’s comment; Thomas Gibson is very essential to the show and hopefully will stay, and if he does not like him well he can watch something else… As far as Rachel Nichols she is a very good actress but obviously she got a raw deal with that role….
This is the best news I have heard in a long time! I kind of feel bad for Rachel Nichols but we have our Prentiss back!!! Woo, hoo!
Wahooo! …that’s all!
I fear that the network shot themselves in the foot with the changes in Criminal Minds last year, and I am in doubt that the fanbase will reward them even with the return of Brewster and Cook. If they are unable to secure the return of Gibson, this will be Crominal Minds final episodes, and I doubt it will make it to mid-season.
It sure doesn’t sound like she had any choice in the matter. So much for free will.
Free will had nothing to do with it. She has a contract with the network, end of story.
yep this is it i am done with this show to just fire Rachel like she was nothing is just so wrong to do!
Her character just wasn’t working on the show. It would be stupid to keep her around just because they wanted to be “fair” to everybody. They have to do what is right for the show or the whole thing fails and then EVERYBODY is out of a job.
It sucks, but that is showbiz and every actor and actress knows that going in.
Oh, but Paget and AJ were fired like they were nothing and you were OK with that?
Before yo jump, read the facts. Paget wasn’t fired, she was doing a pilot and had an option to come back.
Only after CBS backtracked. Did you think they were just doing her a favor?
Maybe you should read the facts, BAU Fan. Originally she WAS fired. She had a 10/13 contract, which means, if they did 13 episodes that season, she would only be in ten of them and she could do a pilot. About half-way through the season, TPTB realized they had screwed the pooch and tried to get Paget back for the full season, but Paget turned them down for “My Life as an Experiment.” So, instead, TPTB added in the “return option” if “My Life…” didn’t get picked up, so that Paget could return for season seven.
Paget wasnt fired. If you read the article, and many others, including, if I am not mistaken, a blog by Paget herself… SHE asked to be able to do the pilot for another show. The option was given when she renewed her contract, but the stipulation was if she didnt get it, they would bring her back to CM. AJ however was let go, because they, at the time, didnt see where they could write her story to give her anything more substantial. Apparently fans didnt like that idea, made ourselves heard and she is coming back, which is great. I agree that it is too bad that Rachel had to be let go, but I really didnt feel like she fit the dynamic of the team. Personally I stopped watching most of the season, because I found her character stiff and while I liked the aspect of getting the “inside view, from a victim’s perspective” I just felt that she didnt really fit with the rest of the cast… then again, I am still not sure about Rossi, so what do I know…
Uh … if you go back to the original announcements, they were firing A.J. Cook, and were reducing Brewster’s number of shows leading to her exit from the series. That’s how it was announced last summer.
By mid-year, when it was clear they had screwed up majorly, they asked Brewster to stay and do all the episodes and re-up for 11-12.
She turned this offer down for the opportunity to do a pilot.
I agree rachel did not fit and rossi fit in but so did gidian
She pretty much was nothing. They’re not going to keep an actress on who isn’t liked by the audience and frankly seemed pretty wooden. With the three main girls together again, where is she going to fit in? There isnt any room for her. Never was. Never gonna be.
They got rid of her probably because with two of the original cast members coming back:D they figured Rachel wouldn’t be able to compete. Don’t just shun the show because they got rid of her please:( Think of the other cast membersand everything. Just give season 7 a try please??(:
This is definitely exciting news.
YAY!!! Now all they have 2 do is get a contract 4 Thomas Gibson, and everything with Criminal Minds will be back 2 perfect harmony!! GO TEAM B.A.U.!!!
Now all they need to do is sign Gibson. ASAP.
Fingers crossed we don’t have another SVU situation.
I hope Gibson returns too, but if not how about Christopher Meloni taking his place?
That would be amazing
I feel so bad for Rachel. Also on the Paget return i have mixed feelings yay in a way shes returning but sad because she had imo one of the best TV Exits so in a way i feel sad there going to have to unravel all that great arch they did for Paget/Emilys Exit.
So incredibly relieved that CM is bringing back A. J. Cook and Paget Brewster. It was a huge mistake to think that both of these actresses wouldn’t be sorely missed from the show’s chemistry. When you have a super ensemble cast, you don’t shoot yourself in the foot and break it up. The young actress, Rachel Nichols, who they hired to replace AJ was not at all effective. She always seemed depressed and went around with a worried, fragile look on her face. Giving her the traumatic background of having a father as a serial murderer basically encompassed her whole character. It was a distraction from the team as a whole. Rachel Nichol’s character did not add good chemistry to the team – I found her character to be annoying. I suppose Nichols thought it made her appear more serious to look distressed and overly concerned, but it was difficult to watch her. So, it is great to hear that the producers have come to their senses; like Joe Mantegna recently said in reference to CM Producers getting rid of A.J. Cook and Paget Brewster, “If it isn’t broken, don’t fix it.” And if these same geniuses get rid of Thomas Gibson, they’re again — foolish. This is a great cast with A.J. and Paget back, so I say to CM Producers, “LEAVE THE CAST ALONE NOW (that A.J. & Paget are back).”
I totally agree with you.
I totally agree. Our whole family watches CM. Please keep it like it is now with Emily and JJ back. The team are like family and make the series work wonderfully.
This just made my day!
I am so happy that Paget Brewster is retuning to Criminal Minds!!! Emily Prentiss was, and I guess, will still be my favorite character on the show!! Though I do feel bad for Rachel Nichols… Can’t wait until Season 7!!!
YES!!!!!! Rachel Nichols got FIRED!!! Such a historic and fabulous day for Criminal Minds fan… all the petition signing has paid off…. and Paget Brewster returning to CM? I’m in AWE!!! We FINALLY have the Criminal Minds we love and know back on track!
dude prentiss was lame and jj was boring and the show was getting stale and the whole thing was not really going anywhere i felt they were overdue to shake things up and i was glad to have a break from prentiss and jj and get a new face on the screen although i am a fan of the two i figured the decision to write them off was a chance to try and find a different personality and see if it meshes well with the group and since it didnt they are fixing it seaver was not all bad she had a distinguishing personality in my opinion and i would have liked to see prentiss and jj come back but keep seaver also 8 people is not really that many for a starring cast
this is off topic but i noticed seaver is the only one with which you really noticed the lapse of time because she changed her outfits with noticeable difference in style or whatever whereas the others to me it felt like they only packed one outfit for the case
except garcia i love her crazy outfits!
Best news EVER! Paget rocks!! So glad CBS is fixing their mistakes–they just won this viewer back. Only thing left is to re-sign Thomas and everything will perfect.