
How great is it not to have Mother’s Day on the Sunday before Upfront Week this year but a week earlier? Let’s enjoy it as it will get pretty crazy pretty fast. There is speculation that Fox may pick up its hot comedy pilots THE NEW GIRL and FAMILY ALBUM as soon as Monday or Tuesday. Two other notes before we check out the standings at each network heading into pre-upfront week. It’s shaping up to be a bitchy development season as both pilots with “Bitch” in their titles — ABC’s GOOD CHRISTIAN BITCHES and THE BITCH AT APT. 23 – are read-hot and certain to land on the schedule (obviously with new titles). And it looks like the first major Comcast-NBC synergy move will find its way to primetime as NBC appears high on the pilot from E! star Chelsea Handler. Here is the rundown network-by-network:
With only one freshman drama, Body of Proof, having a shot at returning next season, ABC is rumored to pick up as many as 6-7 new hourlong series. And word is the network’s brass like so many of their pilots, they may have a hard time narrowing down their choices. Of the drama pilots screened today, only procedural PARTNERS, which had been cold for a while, didn’t do well. Two pilots that had been garnering mixed early reaction — Marc Cherry’s HALLELUJAH and the Count of Monte Cristo-inspired soap REVENGE — both did better today, with HALLELUJAH still drawing mixed reaction in some rooms but also getting strong approval in others. And the Phillip Noyce-directed REVENGE got solid feedback, though some question the long-term prospect of the central revenge storyline. Paranormal Activity-style thriller THE RIVER, helmed by Jaume Collet-Serra, was liked by most who call it “cool.” On the comedy side, APT. 23 was a hit, described as being laugh-out-loud funny. Two years after he directed the pilot for Modern Family, APT. 23 helmer Jason Winer has done it again. And WORK IT, the cross-dressing comedy that had been getting positive buzz in the past few days, did well today too. The UNTITLED TIM ALLEN multicamera comedy will not screen until Monday, but its buzz is so strong that it is considered a frontrunner, with some even speculating that ABC may use it to launch another comedy block, possibly on Tuesday. Also slated to screen next week are two drama pilots with solid early buzz, the magical tale ONCE UPON A TIME and 1960s airline soap PAN AM, as well as the DC drama GEORGETOWN that has been awfully quiet. Here is a recap of the rest of ABC’s pilots that have screened so far:
GOOD CHRISTIAN BITCHES – red hot.
CHARLIE’S ANGELS – a lock
IDENTITY – hot
POE – strong
Shonda Rhimes’ SCANDAL – despite mixed reaction in some rooms, continues to be in serious contention.
GRACE – not perfect, but amazing dance sequences and strong female appeal make it a contender for a Dancing With the Stars companion.
SUBURGATORY, SMOTHERED – both solid, with SUBURGATORY‘s buzz a bit stronger
BAD MOM – Everyone loves Jenna Elfman in this, mixed on the rest.
MAN UP – mixed
MY FREAKIN’ FAMILY, OTHER PEOPLE’S KIDS – don’t look good.
THE NEW GIRL screened very well and, along with FAMILY ALBUM, is considered a lock on the comedy side, with I HATE MY TEENAGE DAUGHTER close behind. Medical drama WEEKENDS AT BELLEVUE continues to gain momentum for a pickup, with the the Ethan Hawke-starring spy drama EXIT STRATEGY also strong. Graphic novel adaptation LOCKE & KEY impressed today with the way it was shot, but there are questions about its potential as a series. The project was originally developed at DreamWorks as a feature — maybe that was the way to go. There is no final word on LOCKE & KEY or ALCATRAZ, but their chances are said to be 50/50.
TAGGED, COUNCIL OF DADS - not good
TWO BROKE GIRLS screened well today as it continues to generate strong buzz on the comedy side along with HOW TO BE A GENTLEMAN. After humble beginnings, UNTITLED PETER KNIGHT keeps rising steadily thanks to a great testing, with THE ASSISTANTS faring OK in its recent screening, while VINCE UNCENSORED is pretty much written off and HOME GAME is fading.
On the drama side, the James Mangold-directed ROOKIES appears a shoo-in, with PERSON OF INTEREST continuing to gain momentum and P.I. show HAIL MARY still strong. Procedural THE REMEMBERER had a solid screening to remain in contention, while the re-cut UNTITLED SUSANNAH GRANT medical drama will screen Monday but most are already betting on it going to series. RINGER, which screened early, has been pretty quiet, while THE DOCTOR doesn’t look very good at the moment.
Not much new information from this year’s Fort Knox, which has been in lockdown under orders from Bob Greenblatt, with SMASH and PRIME SUSPECT as prime drama contenders alongside rising REM. While not locks, PLAYBOY and WONDER WOMAN remain in contention, followed on the buzz meter by another pair, Stephen Gaghan’s METRO and the fantastical GRIMM. A MANN’s WORLD and Western RECONSTRUCTION have an outside chance, while 17th PRECINCT is pretty much done.
On the comedy side, the star-studded EMILY SPIVEY pilot has finally been delivered, and we’re awaiting word on how it has been received. (Not that that’s relevant as this pilot would have to be a disaster not to go.) From the others, the two chick comedies, UNTITLED WHITNEY CUMMINGS and Chelsea Handler’s ARE YOU THERE VODKA still look good, along with BENT, UNTITLED DAN GOOR and UNTITLED KARI LIZER, while word is that LOVELIVES, BRAVE NEW WORLD and MY LIFE AS AN EXPERIMENT don’t look that good.
In today’s screening, Kevin Williamson and Andrew Miller’s pilot THE SECRET CIRCLE lived up to the hype and now firmly holds the frontrunner position with medical drama HART OF DIXIE. HEAVENLY and procedural COOPER & STONE are still behind, followed by zombie drama AWAKENING and DANNI LOWINSKI, with the latter not as bad as many think but probably not good enough to make the cut to series.
TV Editor Nellie Andreeva - tip her here.
New ‘Man Of Steel’ Television Spot #6





Again no word on Ringer???
I thought GRIMM was a lock – been hearing amazing things.Now it’s just “on the buzz meter?” GRIMM was my favorite script this season, it incorporated the fairy tales in a really unique, eerie way.
Not looking forward to any of the remakes except Prime suspect.
I want to know about Ringer, too. what’s the deal? Not testing well?
I heard Ringer had a bad screening. On a side note is ABC really gonna pick up two shows with african american female leads? While I wish that would happen it seems highly unlikely. So is Shonda’s Scandal going or the Angela Basset led Identity?
GRIMM – I was under the impression GRIMM was a lock – been hearing amazing things about that pilot. Now it’s just “on the buzz meter?”
My picks:
NBC: GRIMM, Prime Suspect
CBS: Two Broke Girls, Ringer
ABC: Good Christian Bitches, Bad Mom
FOX: Alcatraz, Exit Strategy
Was also wondering what the deal is w Ringer.
Okay, I read a draft of The New Girl and I was really looking forward to reading it having read F-buddies and thinking it was funny. However, I was a little disappointed. It was hard to finish. I’m hoping it was just a first draft. Did anyone else read it and think the same? And were changes made?
It was terrible.
C’mon, NBC… Play with us!
Give us GRIMM!!
GRIMM!!!! and Ringer. and Smash.
i really hope the Whitney Cummings pilot gets picked up!!
What about Georgetown?
Aww, sad about 17th Precinct.
sad indeed
I hope Fox picks up Locke & Key. It’ll be unique for network tv.
Disappointing to hear that Partners didn’t screen well, it’s the pilot I am most looking forward to. I still hope that it’ll get picked up to series, seems far less risky than ABC’s other drama pilots.
It might actually be fun to watch network tv again this year with all of ABCs and NBCs pilots
Has The Doctor been turned in yet? There have been a few of these pilot update posts and this one seems to be consistently left out. Any reason? I would’ve thought a show from David Nutter and Rina Mimoun would’ve had at least *something*.
i know that people post a lot of bs on here but i have “inside” info on this one…I love christine lahti but from all accounts starting with the table read she came off very unlikeable. if it gets picked up at all it will be for mid season but it looks very unlikely.
I wonder if FOX will do the same thing they did last year with there rejected (but strong) pilots and try and get them picked up by other networks. Because, I can see either (or both) Alcatraz and Locke & Key landing at a place like SyFy.
Both shows are likely well beyond Syfy’s budget level.
I think NBC should pick up Reconstruction. But put it in a cable network, send it to Sony
Alcatraz!!! :’(
Please FOX….
I hope Ringer gets picked up. I need my weekly fix of SMG.
Try some weekly Get A Life
SMASH is going to be a smash! Entertainment Weekly -” Debra Messing rocks the crap out of the pilot!”
sad that theres no Georgetown news…
I sense a catfight coming. One half touts McPhee as the standout, the other Messing. It`s a matter of time when those Smash divas will go Hulk Smash on each other for real.
Doesn’t it seem like pilots should be made available for the public to see online? It’s strange that every year Hollywood spends millions on productions that never get to have an audience. And who knows, maybe a few of them would be given new life by an online audience’s enthusiastic response.
That’s a very good point. I was working with Disney XD a little while ago and they kept talking about testing they did. And what testing meant. And this one show they had tested poorly. But because they didn’t have anything else the put it on and now it gets some of their best ratings. Instead of these focus groups it would be great for the real public to view pilots and give feedback.
I agree. Stream them for a limited time or something. The un-picked-up pilots are like the B-sides to an album in a way.
While I’m sad it’s not looking good for Paget’s new pilot, I am excited if this means she’s coming back to Criminal Minds. She’s sorely missed.
Agreed! “Criminal Minds” needs her.
NBC’s Playboy and Grimm have to go to series. Both sound fantastic!
Too bad for 17th Precinct, I was looking forward to it. Oh well. :-/
Hmmm… I wonder if “quiet” means good or bad things for Ringer.
I’m excited that most of the pilots I’m interested in (Secret Circle, The River, REM, Smash, Person of Interest, Susannah Grant Pilot) are screening so well. Can’t wait for the announcements in a little over a week.
Can’t wait for The Secret Circle. And please pick up Awakening!!
i wrote this yesterday…THE REMEMBERER is %100 getting picked up by cbs. studio and network tests were “great” and poppy montgomery as a lead tested “higher than Any female lead on a one hour series since nielsen has been doing these tests”.
WEEKENDS AT BELLEVUE only gets on if HOUSE does not come back. people who are writing that they would make good companion pieces are CRAZY. LOL. when was the last successful night of tv that had 2 medical shows back to back?
Every Thursday on ABC?
That would ABC Thursday’s with Grey’s Anatomy and Private Practice for the past three years.
i believe i said “successful”. check the numbers…PP isn’t even close to a top 20 show.
“when was the last successful night of tv that had 2 medical shows back to back?”
“Grey’s Anatomy” and “Private Practice.” So, y’know, right now. Thanks for playing, though.
Marcus Welby M.D. and Medical Center.
It’s been a while.
alcatraz looks expensive. look at the cast.
locke and key should be made into a feature film.
Honestly, except for the ‘locks’, nobody knows anything. Reports I have from agencies are completely antithetical to this liat, we’ll all just have to wait til this week and next.
I knew that pilot wouldn’t go anywhere. The title MLAAE is not appealing.
We’ll have to wait to see!