
Here is the second-annual honor roll of the best and brightest at the broadcast upfront. First off, to all who got their pilots picked up to series — congratulations. You’re already winners. This is a list of those who took their upfront success to an extra level:
Whitney Cummings: The undisputed queen of Upfront 2011. She is behind two new comedy series that are among the highest-profile new half-hour entries next fall. She created, stars in and executive produces her eponymous comedy for NBC, which was assigned the network’s best comedy slot, following The Office. She also co-wrote on spec with Michael Patrick King the CBS comedy 2 Broke Girls, which broke records as CBS’ best-testing pilot (comedy or drama) ever. Both were the first comedy pilots to get a series order at their networks. Cummings, who also has a talk show in contention at E!, will serve as an executive producer on 2 Broke Girls but will be full-time on Whitney, which was in first position. I hope that doesn’t impact 2 Broke Girls, which King is expected to run/co-run, because the pilot indeed looks great. Honorable mention in the category of creators with multiple projects for Andrew Reich and Ted Cohen. One of their two ABC pilots, Work It, was picked up to series, while the other, Smothered, is very much in contention for midseason.
What a comeback for J.J. Abrams! After his high-profile NBC drama Undercovers went bust last fall, some questioned whether the networks will continue to bet on him. But bet they did this upfront, with both pilots he produced, CBS’ Person of Interest and Fox’s Alcatraz, going to series. Person of Interest instantly became one of the most anticipated new fall series when CBS made it its new Thursday 9 PM anchor. The network also said it was its best-testing drama pilot ever. And over at Fox, Alcatraz prevailed over several high-profile pilots to land one of only two drama series spots. Then, as icing on the cake, Abrams’ modestly rated but well-liked Fox sci-fi series Fringe got a renewal for next season, bringing the producer’s series for next season to three.

THE CREATORS/SHOWRUNNERS: With the pickup of Shonda Rhimes‘ Scandal at ABC, she will have three series solely created by her on the air next season, along with Grey’s Anatomy and spinoff Private Practice. The only other writer-producer with three shows created/co-created by him is Seth MacFarlane (Family Guy, American Dad and The Cleveland Show), and he upped the ante in a big way, with Fox announcing at its upfront the 2013 launch of a MacFarlane reboot of The Flintstones. The Vampire Diaries co-creator Kevin Williamson landed a second series co-created by him, CW’s The Secret Circle. On the showrunner front, CSI: NY‘s Pam Veasey will be running two series next season, the veteran CBS crime drama and CW’s newly picked up Ringer, starring Sarah Michelle Gellar. With Charlie Sheen successfully replaced on Two and a Half Men, which was one of the biggest stories at the upfront, Chuck Lorre will run three series for a second straight year, two of which, Men and The Big Bang Theory, he co-created.
THE PODS: It was a great upfront for several pods and independent production companies. Leading the charge are Chernin
Entertainment and DreamWorks TV with three new series apiece for next season: New Girl, Terra Nova and Allen Gregory (Chernin) and Smash, The River and Terra Nova (Dreamworks). Chernin Entertainment’s tally is expected to go up to four with the fully expected series order to the Kiefer Sutherland/Tim Kring drama Touch. Meanwhile, DreamWorks also has TNT’s upcoming Falling Skies, which was presented at the network’s upfront this week. Sarah Timberman and Carl Beverly’s Timberman/Beverly Prods. went 2-for-2, with both of their pilots, Unforgettable and A Gifted Man, going to series. Also producing two new series next season is Aaron Kaplan’s Kapital Entertainment – with Good Christian Belles and Terra Nova. Two pods, Alloy and Josh Schwartz and Stephanie Savage’s Fake Empire, added a third on-air series each this upfront. Alloy has newcomer The Secret Secret joining Gossip Girl and The Vampire Diaries at the CW, while Fake Empire is behind another new CW drama Hart of Dixie, as well as CW’s Gossip Girl and NBC’s Chuck.

THE DIRECTORS: Two veteran comedy directors, Andy Ackerman and Beth McCarthy-Miller, directed two pilots each that went to series. Ackerman helmed NBC’s Whitney and Fox’s I Hate My Teenage Daughter, while Saturday Night Live‘s McCarthy-Miller directed the pilots for ABC comedies Work It and Man Up. With the pickup of Fox’s Alcatraz, which Danny Cannon directed, he will have five series whose pilots he helmed on the air next season: the three CSI shows, Nikita and Alcatraz. Veteran comedy director James Burrows is next with four. He helmed the pilot for the hot new CBS comedy 2 Broke Girls in addition to Lorre’s Two and a Half Men, The Big Bang Theory and Mike & Molly.

THE ACTING CREATORS: In addition to Cummings, doing double duty as the creators and stars of their new series are David Hornsby (CBS’ How To Be a Gentleman), Chris Moynihan (ABC’s Man Up) and Lennon Parham and Jessica St. Clair (NBC’s BFFs)
THE SIBLINGS: Fox is becoming The Deschanel sisters network, with Zooey Deschanel poised to become the network’s breakout comedy star with her new comedy series New Girl, joining her big sister, Bones leading lady Emily Deschanel.
THE MULTITASKERS: With NBC’s Smash, the project’s executive producers Craig Zadan and Neil Meron hit a rare fourfecta of producing a broadcast, cable series (Drop Dead Diva), Broadway musical (How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying) and big studio movie (the upcoming Footloose) at the same time.
Speaking of a multitasker, Nancy Travis is in 2 pilots that got picked up to series. She is the female lead opposite Tim Allen in ABC’s Last Man Standing and was a guest star in CW’s Hart of Dixie and was prominently featured in the clip for the show screened at the network’s upfront presentation. It is not clear if she will continue to recur on the CW medical drama.
BY THE NUMBERS: Pods With Multiple Shows On the Broadcast Nets next season:
Jerry Bruckheimer – 4 (3 CSIs, The Amazing Race)
Chernin Entertainment – 4 (Terra Nova, New Girl, Allen Gregory, Touch, pending)
Alloy -3 (Gossip Girl, Vampire Diaries, Secret Circle)
Bad Robot -3 (Alcatraz, Person of Interest, Fringe)
DreamWorks -3 (Terra Nova, Smash, The River)
Fake Empire – 3 (Chuck, Gossip Girl, Hart of Dixie)
Mark Gordon Co. – 3 (Grey’s Anatomy, Private Practice, Criminal Minds)
Wonderland Sound and Vision – 3 (Chuck, Nikita, Supernatural)
Kapital Entertainment -3 (Terra Nova, Good Christian Belles)
Timberman/Beverly -2 (Unforgettable, A Gifted Man)
BLOCK PARTY: Producers who control network programming blocks
Shonda Rhimes: ABC Thursday 9-11 PM
Shane Brennan: CBS Tuesday 8-10 PM
Kevin Williamson: CW Thursday 8-10 PM
Josh Schwartz/Stephanie Savage: CW Monday 8-10 PM
McG: CW Friday 8-10 PM
Chuck Lorre: CBS Monday 9-10 PM
Seth MacFarlane: Fox Sunday 9-10 PM
TV Editor Nellie Andreeva - tip her here.


Now if only Ms. Cummings would stop lying about her age, we might be like “whoopee”.
I LOVE that she says she’s 25. The best part? When I knew her 9 years ago she was “25″ then too…
Makes sense to me. She’s 28. So 9 years ago, she was 19. Probably wanted everyone to think she was older so they’d take her seriously. Now that she’s actually older, she’s fudging it the other way to appear “youthful”.
@ oh snapple & agreed:The envy in this town is sometimes mind-boggling. The woman just landed not one but TWO frigging pilots and this is what you focus on? I doubt that would be the topic of your comments if a male comedian had landed two pilots in one season..not to mention.. everyone in Hollywood lies about their age. Get over yourselves.
Well said, Ronnie. Kudos to Whitney! I don’t care how legal she is!
what about nancy travis? she’s a regular in 2 pilots – last man standing and hart of dixie. which is her first position?
Oh, who gives a flying fart about that! I mean, really.
Whoever left that “age” comment is envious with issues. (Leave other people out of your misery.)
I only learned about Whitney Cummings recently, so no bias exists: but I am blown over by anyone who gets themselves up onstage with their own material, and tries to make everyone watching, and judging: laugh. If the performer makes them laugh, I respect them m
Try being blown away by the ones who do it well, not the ones who run around making faces and acting like cartoons.
She’s not a stand up comedian, she’s an actress playing stand up comedian.
She isn’t respected by her peers.
Meanwhile, YOU, other comedian, are respected by no one.
…(cont) I respect them more. If the comedian is a woman, I am in awe that they managed and achieved all that after months or years of flopping onstage, live–and because comedy is a boy’s club. If, like Whitney, they get their own show…! In the boys club of network TV, and the altogether impossibility of that brass ring! Especially, a unique and outspoken woman as she is! CONGRATS TO MS CUMMINGS!!! Right on!!!
(Shut up to the last commenter, who so gleefully threw an ugly wrench in. Get thee to a shrink..)
I also met Whitney about 10 years ago, and she was a really nice, down to earth person. She was 25 then also.
I’m with Dana. I know a very prominent producer who shaves ten years off his age and he’s not even in front of the camera. No one says a word about him and the rest of the boys who do it, but it’s always about the girl-bashing, isn’t it? Well, suck on this season, sexists!
She my response above to the other two bozos.
Sorry. *See*
What’s with the focus on Whitney’s age? She is the creator of 2 pilots…can we focus on that instead. Do we even ask how old the men are? Does anyone know how old Christopher Moynihan is? Do we care how old JJ Abrams is?
It was a boys club years ago.
It’s not now.
Ridiculous comment.
Yeah, it’s a totally even playing field, as evidenced by the tons of comments on the Palme d’Or news reports on Terrence Malick’s recent weight gain.
And YOU really aren’t the person who gets to judge whether comments are ridiculous.
The one fact: Whitney Cummings has two pilots on the air. Your tally, I’m assuming, is zero. And likely to stay that way.
Hey Dana, Perhaps you should put as much effort into your career as you did into your comment(s). If you did, maybe you would be working more consistently.
I find Whitney Cummings to be likable, intelligent and funny. I’ve run into her a few times at Starbucks and she’s hot guys. All these comments about age and all that — who cares? But the important thing about this post is JJ Abrams. Thank frickin God that he’s back in the right form. I’m still stinging from that Lost finale — I can’t help but think that if JJ had been more involved, it would’ve gone better. I’ve heard rumors about Alcatraz being only so-so but maybe it’s just misunderstood? I keep saying that if JJ can’t be personally involved in some capacity, then he shouldn’t do the shows. Fringe really stalled out of the starting gate. Now it’s a good show. But it took time. Quality not quantity, JJ. I love you, bro — but please, take your time….Person of Interest could be AWESOME. Can’t wait!
I think “best-testing pilot ever” is the new “number-one comedy in America”…
Agreed.
Shut the F up!
i like whitney cummings and i hope she has success in the fall. BUT, they must tweak the laugh track on ‘whitney.’ just the preview alone was troubling with that awful laugh track tagging along. maybe turn it down from 10 to 6.
Unfortunately, successful producers/writers often get shows just because of their “pods” ( notably Undercovers – which looked stupid from the original logline)
I’ve seen almost everything noted above
“2 Broke Girls” was my favourite sitcom til I saw “New Girl”
- had the time of my life.
Whitney Cummings is the undocumented Dominican short stop of comedy.
Lol! That’s amazing!
Yeah, but she hits .290 and has great range. It’s worth the risk.
Does anyone know if “Work it” is an honest attempt to portray the transgender community (A la “Pricilla”) or the centuries old routine of homophobic, cigar chomping guys who don’t know how to pee sitting down?
Option A would actually keep me from disconnecting my cable!
What about Hart Hanson with “Bones” and “The Finder” on FOX? You mentioned Emily Deschanel (as well as her sister and husband). And isn’t there a huge ad buy for the finale of Bones all over this site?
tv is where the action is. the movie industry is dying.
Movies are global, tv is local. No one worships tv stars.
Then why does our C-list ex-client get non-stop fan mail from all over Europe? Show ran forever on a lesser network, but you’d think this actor was Tom Hanks from all the gifts and letters that come in.
Much props to Shonda Rimes, still getting it done. I still don’t think people understand what she means to opening doors in the future for African American writers who actually can write more than just “Urban” projects.
Props to Kevin Williamson. He’s got such a long, rich track record and still pushes forth enough to have TWO shows on the air. Good for him!
It’s so cute that you think it could be the first one.