UPDATE: The feds released info today that FBI and IRS agents this week arrested and charged 18 people who now face fraud and money laundering charges relating to a telemarketing “boiler room” scam that solicited $25 million in so-called investments in indie films with false promises of up to 1,000% returns. The scam was run in Southern California and Florida. While some of the movies were actually produced, the indictments allege that the defendants lied, gave half-truths and concealed material facts from investors around the nation.
A former CIA agent who ran a Burbank movie company called Q Media Assets has already pleaded guilty to conspiracy, mail fraud, and tax charges in relation to the fraudulent boiler rooms. Also fingered are the activities of Cinamour Entertainment LLC, which allegedly bilked investors who put money into independent motion pictures called From Mexico With Love and Red Water: 2012. It follows the May 2009 apparent suicide of Glen Hartford, the 45-year-old chairman-CEO-founder of Cinamour Entertainment.
The charged defendants and other telemarketers cold-called investors from “lead lists” and solicited investments with false claims, such as that 93% of investor money would be used to produce and promote the films, and that investors would receive returns up to 1,000%. According to the indictment, the telemarketers failed to disclose that they would receive commissions when, in fact, often more than 1/3 of the investments went into their pockets. Little more than 1/3 of investor funds were used to actually produce and promote From Mexico With Love.
During the course of the Cinamour scheme – which the indictment alleges ran from early 2004 through May 2009 – the defendants collected approximately $15 million for From Mexico With Love from about 450 victim-investors. The movie cost about $5 million to produce and generated approximately $550,000 in its theatrical release in October 2009. The defendants raised about $2.7 million for the Red Water movie from about 100 victim-investors, but essentially none of the money was used to produce the film, which was never made.
The second indictment alleges that telemarketers for Q Media Assets LLC fraudulently raised funds for films called Eye of the Dolphin and its sequel, Way of the Dolphin (which was later called Beneath the Blue). Telemarkers associated with Q Media also bought “lead lists” from the same San Clemente company that sold lists to the Cinamour telemarketers. As in the Cinamour case, telemarketers seeking investments in the Dolphin movies allegedly “made material misrepresentations, told material half-truths, and concealed material facts, when speaking to investors,” specifically concealing information about commissions and promising returns of up to 1,000%.
The defendants in the Q Media case raised approximately $5 million for Eye of the Dolphin and about $4 million for Way of the Dolphin from about 250 investors. “Eye of the Dolphin” made about $70,000 in ticket sales in its theatrical release, while “Way of the Dolphin” went straight to video.
The 45-count Cinamour indictment charges a dozen defendants: Daniel Toll, 56, of Encino, who was president of Cinamour; Joel Lee Craft Jr., 41, of San Clemente, who was the CEO of the San Clemente-based American Information Strategies Inc which sold investor lead lists to telemarketing operations that solicited investors through telephone cold calls; James Lloyd, 47, of Lake Arrowhead who operated his own boiler room that raised money for Cinamour and Q Media; Paul Baker, 50, of Palm Springs, who operated his own boiler room under the name Independent Essentials that raised funds for Cinamour; Bart Douglas Slanaker, 48, of Panorama City; Allen Bruce Agler, 54, of Canyon County; Albert Greenhouse, 58, of Delrey Beach, Florida; DeLitha Jones-Floyd, 54, of Lancaster; Brian Emmanuel Ellis, 35, of Saugus; Daniel Morabito, 31, of Redondo Beach; David Nelson, 40, of Eagle Rock; and Daryll Van Snowden, 40, formerly of Chatsworth and now of West Hollywood.
All 12 defendants are charged in a conspiracy count, as well as in several of the 15 mail fraud counts, nine wire fraud counts and 13 sale of unregistered securities counts that are alleged in the indictment. Additionally, Craft, Toll and Floyd are each named in at least one of five money laundering counts. The indictment also charges Slanaker with two counts of tax evasion.
The 33-count Q Media indictment charges nine defendants, including Lloyd, Agler, Craft and Morabito. The indictment additionally charges: Robert Keskemety, 56, of Hallandale Beach, Florida; Jady Laurence Herrmann, 34, of Lake Arrowhead; Joseph McCarthy, 37, of Boynton Beach; Matthew Bryan Wellman-Mackin, 30, of Manhattan Beach; and Robert Ramirez, 44, of Sunland.
All nine defendants in the Q Media case, including those also charged in the Cinamour case, face charges of conspiracy, mail fraud, wire fraud and sale of unregistered securities. Lloyd is also charged in this indictment with two counts of money laundering. Craft is also charged in this indictment with two counts of tax evasion.
The charge of conspiracy carries a statutory maximum penalty of five years in federal prison or custody. The wire fraud and mail charges have a maximum possible sentence of 20 years. The money laundering counts alleged in the indictment carry maximum statutory penalties of 10 years. The charge of sale of unregistered securities has a maximum possible sentence of five years. And the tax evasion charges have a maximum possible sentence of five years.
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.


The moral of the story kids? Always hang up on telemarketing calls!
The FBI should also go after the guys at Nu Image and Screen Media.
There are so many of these sleezy AFM companies that need a thorough investigation.
Anyone remember Unapix? It was run by Robert Baruc. The Wall Street Journal said he wasted hundreds of thousands of dollars as the company was going bankrupt. He never paid any of the filmmakers what they were owed. My own company lost $500,000 with Mr. Baruc.
So what happened? He simply formed another company, Screen Media, and became successful doing the same scam over again.
This is the way of Scams like this. They get closed down by one Agency, and then pop up under another pseudonym months or even years later.
PT Barnum ad it right. And this sort of shenanigans doesn’t help those of us trolling for funds legitimately.
FBI. What a love/hate relationship. Love when they go after crooked organizations, hate it when the violate individual rights.
My ex could not be talked out of investing $60k. I feel sorry for him and hope the basturds get the max.
These guys burned a few hundred.
Alpine Pictures has burned tens of thousands in the last 20 years. In the US and Overseas. They should really be taken down but no one seems to be able to nail them. They have the classic boiler room callers. Now they have changed their name again and they are ripping off more folks on the pretense of making kids entertainment. THey are the scum of the earth. The friggin Carroll brothers.
A former CIA agent moves into the movie business while pulling off white collar crimes … seems like a cross between CHAOS and WHITE COLLAR. Is there a pilot in the works?
A boiler room film finance pilot? Boring!
just like a film based on the creation of Facebook. Oh wait….that was awesome. Take the blinders off and think outside your little box.
OK, I’ll be creative and think outside my little box if you’ll be brave and try thinking outside your anonymity.
I believe this story was called “The Producers”
Across between CHAOS and WHITE COLAR pilot? Can I invest and get in on it?
Chaos – early 1930′s mafia anarchy conspiracy theory types! That is very good point to make Zombie… where is the TWIST (like how did they pull this off!)! We need to know how the US got into that bogus industry in the first place = I have never heard of an investment scam based around moview = why bother? (I am glad they did sack it I have watched some really terrible movies (like above) yet they claim to be “winners” on the title = never judge a book by its cover and DVDz)
White Collar = YES! Business based on lies = criminal
Chaos ? = current system. lol which allows for something like this exist for more than 6 months! wow wow
I was thinking the same thing, except I was seeing a Burn Notice/White Collar mix. Nice
I thought the same thing. This is a movie script in the making!
i invested 10 grand into red water 2012.
what the hell am i gonna tell my wife..
That they call it risking capital for a reason. No investment is a sure thing,
If someone told you otherwise, and you believed it… I have some swamp land in Montana I’d like to sell you.
Be truthful. Come clean with your wife. If losing $10,000 ruins your marriage, then there were other underlying reasons for your wife to not trust your judgement.
There’s swampland in Montana?!
The good news is she probably already knows you’re an idiot.
@ JJ and Anonymous
You two really believe the comment from ‘ssucker’ isn’t a joke?
Steen – you really believe JJ and Anonymous are serious in their answer?
Find out when ‘Glengarry Glen Ross 2: Indie-Cent’ hits theaters (we’re hoping!) in May 2013.
After Whales of August, Glengarry Glen Ross has to be one of the most boring, featureless films of all time. Pointless and devoid of any real entertainment value. If there is a “2″ it will be a snozer, as well. Which means the self-important elitist snobs known as critics will love it, and it will be a bomb with people who watch movies to be entertained.
I would wait till the FBI contacts you regarding the issue = what are you going to tell now? anything really factual as of yet. I think you will recover your money = unless this whole scam happens to be ALSO bankrupt! (it appears this happens alot in these situations)
As an indy producer who is on the phone raising $ constantly, this really complicates getting a film financed, as investors are simply afraid – of course, I always try to work with people I know well. Absolutely, use IRS Section 181 to deduct investment.
Out raising $$ for you independent movies are you??? Without a doubt you are violating a number of federal and state laws not to mention trying to sell unregistered securities. Does anyone know one person who ever made money or even got their principle back on a movie investment. It is always a most outrageous scam. For the most part Independent film makers outside of Opie Taylor and the other legits are nothing but pie in the sky idiots that think they can actually tell a story on film and get bought out for millions. Like I say, Idiots, using other people’s money on a pipe dream.
You are right Ms LeCure. I’m an attorney and have represented several indies when the SEC has descended on them. All it takes is one investor making one complaint. There’s not much I can do except attempt to negotiate jail time, fines and forfeiture. Their lives become a living hell with a lifetime of living with a felon label. Their lives are ruined all because they were sucked into believing that it was easy to make a film and sell it for a ton of money. You stand a better chance of standing in a barn blindfolded with at 22 rifle and hitting a fly with one shot than successfully making, distributing and profiting a feature film. The film business it totally controlled by the big boys and the big boys are more ruthless than Osama Bin Laden and the other muslim terrorists. Even if an indie makes an excellent film, all the money will be taken from them and there’s virtually nothing they can do.
If all you do is negotiate jail time aren’t they wasting money with you? Other then a scare tactic to get indies to pay you for little, what’s your point? There are plenty of orgs and assoc. that have the info you need to follow IRS guidelines and set up the paperwork. You can make money releasing a movie. Maybe not retire money, but enough to live on. The hardest part is making a movie worth watching. The rest is just necessary paperwork.
This post sounds like the rant of a frustrated, unsuccessful filmmaker than an attorney in the business of defending artists.If that were the case, then no one outside of Hollywood would attempt making a movie. And yet…according to AFM and other orgs, more films are made worldwide that are independent than there are studio films. And like any business, if you only make one, then you haven’t got a prayer. It’s a numbers game and you don’t need the big boys anymore.
You are ABSOLUTELY CORRECT!
Seems like the defrauded investors now own all the films in question; I’d rerelease them all in theaters, using the publicity from the arrests to generate new ticket sales, especially overseas. Would be funny if the investors made a mint selling these movies after all. Yikes, the titles sound like the fake movie titles in the awards scene in “The Bodyguard.” “And the winner is ‘Lonely Fight for Love’!”
Sorry bout that! Look i’m a black horror film maker. Don’t take what u did too hard! Yes she will be mad! but like everything that u do in life, it’s a risk. If u want it, u will go after it! If u want some extra funds to give her and the family that “boost” for a fun’ner life. U are gonna have to give up that little piece of tail that takes u closer to the goal. Pull her into the investing thing, trust each other. Plus someting I learned in CA. Stick with the true independent film makers, that way! They get to full the dream and U get to learn what it takes to do the invester thing. Stop looking at the glits and get with the thing that is INDIE film making and the steps. Don’t run down the hill, WALK! Look in her eyes and tell her…..I made a judgement call and it was bad! I made it doing the guy thing and it was a mis-stake! Then call ur sibling a nd get it from them! LOL! Don’t let mom and dad find out!
Keep it INDIE and build it INDIE!
It takes time, everything is not 1000% LOL! Make a good product and do the foot work, it’s worth it. You already took the first step. YOU BELIEVED in the PROJECT! Someone willbe BLESSED with UR interest in their dream!….Try it again! Real INDIE!
Huh…
Looks like I’ve been going about this whole “raising money to make stuff” thing the wrong way…
If I’d have known it was that easy to raise tons of money from cold-calling, it’d be a whole different story…
Oh my gosh! 1000% return! Why, that sounds too good to be – - um . . .
The real life version of “The Producers”. See, there’s not an original idea out there, not even in the real world.
This may not be the right time, but I really do have a movie idea that’s never been done! seriously. And I need some money. Anyone interested? Post and I’ll call.
Ok, If any of you guys that worked in the boiler room are reading this Lets do it again! But this time disclose the commissions and let me actually make the movie! If you guys can raise this kind of capital… Well, Lets do it! we just wont break any rules this time.
Paul,
Me, too, I’ve got a great, unique film. Lets do it!!
You have an idea but no script! Wow, and you’re too lazy to write it like the rest of those suckers; you wanna get paid for your great idea up front!
Nothing screams “I’m a dumb ass” more than selling an “idea” instead of an actual script. When you’re starting out you write a script. Plain and simple. Yes, Spielberg can sell “an idea.” You are not Spielberg.
So shut up and write.
…And they sold the story for $5m
Lucky for me a couple of agents from the Delphi Bureau, Fox Bialystock and Dana Bloom, warned me away from that CIA guy. But they tell me Broadway plays are a great investment…
Ha ha seriously. We’ve been going after legit money, how stupid of us.
I think its all a mess, good bad its all mashed together in some way because we still have 6 banks or whatever running the world based out the US – I think these types of situations show how much is “really” going on behind the scenes = like boilers rooms off skype? yea one call is hard enough to make..
It’s like Dante’s Inferno. There’s basically 9 levels of stupidity a person has to travel through in order to be victimized by this. That’s just pathetic.
1. Having a traditional landline. Why? It’s 2011. Waste of money.
2. Having one but not being on the ‘Do Not Call’ registry. I know $0.00 seems like a lot, but trust me the fee is worth it.
3. Allowing telemarketers to call but not having caller ID to screen them.
4. Having caller ID, but answering blocked and unknown numbers anyways.
5. Answering but not hanging up the moment you realize it’s a telemarketer.
6. Staying on but not taking over the conversation to politely decline and say goodbye.
7. Letting a cold call telemarketer control a conversation and listen to his pitch.
8. Believing anything they say, let alone ridiculous promises of 1000% return.
9. Actually giving money to a stranger who randomly called your house.
So I’m having a hard time feeling bad for anyone who fell for this shit.
that made my day. thank you for that post
Ditto.
You’ve probably never invested on a large scale in stocks or commodities. Those call lists are made up from accounts and profiles on investors that are made and sold by established and reputable brokerage firms. Opting out is in the finest of fine print, and being on the do not call registry doesn’t mean anything. I worked for a commodities broker in Beverly Hills some years ago, and we called people from those same lists; most of the numbers we dialed were cell numbers, not land lines, and the people we called didn’t hang up. They were used to taking calls and pitches on potential investments just like agents are used to taking calls and pitches on scripts. Thing is, pitching a butterfly flip on oil futures against steel with a potential return of anywhere between 5% and 1000% is like pitching a stake in a movie with a potential return of the same thing… The people who invest aren’t suckers, they know how to read a contract, and they lose money all the time. They also make money all the time. But if they put money into a venture where 60% of the investment goes to “overhead,” you better believe they’re going to find out, and there’s going to be a federal investigation soon enough. Case in point.
John V. Karavitis That’s an amazing post, Jared. I’m guessing that you have some experience working in such situations? Were yuou a broker in a previous job? You sound like you have a lot of experience and potential material at your fingertips. Have you ever considered writing a book about your experiences? It might give people a chance to learn more about these kinds of scams, and thus give them more strength to “Just say no”. Or are you saying that, even given any experience that these people might have, they STILL fall for these scams? How could that be? I would expect that anyone this experienced in getting into investment deals would know enough to do their due diligence. Also, Hollywood isn’t the kind of place where you can keep a secret for long, yes? John V. Karavitis
No, I worked for a broker. Briefly. Not enough material in my limited experience to cover in a book, but I can tell you it was the most fantastically boring job I’ve ever had. You wanna learn about scams, just learn how to read a contract. When the guy pitching you says you’ll make your money back guaranteed, and the contract says you acknowledge you might lose your investment and you promise not to hold the seller liable, congratulations, that’s Wynn you walk away.
Regarding your last question, I think Hollywood is exactly the sort of place where secrets are kept for a very, very long time.
Excuse me, do you know what ‘lead lists’ are? Obviously not from your post. And by the way, a landline won’t go out when the power does or when the cell signals do. Just an FYI for ya.
Traditional land = YES for sure. I just had a terrible emergency occur a weekend ago and the Flipping modem was not working no cell service either (my own fault but I know this happens to the elders loured into doing the VIOP systems.. they lose the modem they have no phone service..
WE COULD HAVE ISSUES = LANDLINE WORKS WITH ANY CORDED DEVICE! I AM GLAD SOMEONE SUGGESTED THIS BECAUSE PEOPLE HAVE NO CLUE WHATS ITS LIKE TO LOSE CABLE/POWER AND NEED YOUR PHONE!
BACK TO LAND LINE FOR ME = ITS MORE SECURE AS WELL – SKYPE IS LIKE A NIGHTMARE AT TIMES THANKGOD I DONT DEPEND ON IT!
Hmmm… land line or brain cancer? Let me think…
Sorry, those of us with kids (or even not) keep the landline for safety reasons. A cell phone is NOT the same with 911.
Thanks from me as well…
I won’t name the person, but one of those in the first indictment sold me a car he said he bought at auction but he had an entire scam going buying and selling cats without ever taking ownership. Happy to see him caught scamming people. Justice!
Buying and selling ‘cats’ without ever taking ownership? Sounds fascinating!
I kept waiting to see David Bergstein’s name come up in that article.
Me too! (Perhaps they just haven’t found how he’s connected through a dummy corp yet.)
Thank you for this.
In related news, Q Media is leaving WME and signing at CAA.
I would like to the meet the person who thought the cast of FROM MEXICO WITH LOVE would return 1% let alone %1000 on the money. Who are these people and how do they have enough money to invest in a film? I need to meet these rich, dumb idiots.
Don’t be too hard on the investors. Savvy people recognize a Z-list cast (screams direct to video), but then it ‘could’ be actually really good and a breakout hit, though rare. But one thing you always check on, when investing in a film is “WHO is starring in it?”
If it’s a movie with George Clooney, Jula Roberts, Tom Hanks, Brad Pitt and directed by Christopher Nolan and only costs 5 Million … SIGN ME UP !!!
Anything else, research what the project is carefully. But BOILER ROOMS are high pressure sales rooms for a reason. They want to force you to make a decision without the time to think about it.
You wrote: They want to force you to make a decision without the time to think about it.
My comment: Regardless of the previous posts, I would consider anyone investing money strickly on the word of a telemarketer, especially one that promised guaranteed returns. They may want to force me, but I will either hang up, or tell them I need to read the contract first and make a decision. If they cannot wait, too bad, no deal.
Paraphraasing the saying: sheep begets wolves.
Get a real education, don’t lose your money in these scams.
Gracias! I was hoping someone would key into this!
We’re adding a little something to this month’s sales contest. As you all know, first prize is a Cadillac Eldorado. Anybody want to see second prize?
Second prize is a set of steak knives.
Third prize is you’re fired.
Watched “Eye of the Dolphin” with the kids on Netflix streaming a year or two ago…actually a half-decent movie with heart. Go figure.
Now we definitely know it was a scam. Hollywood doesn’t do that on purpose very often.
Agreed. Those victim/investors should get sentenced for being such schmucks
Imagine the additional layers to “Glenngary Glen Ross” if the guys were fighting over and cold-calling the leads to investors in indie films instead of FL real estate…
…sounds like a re-boot to me!
Damn.
Where can I get $25 million?
I’ll at least put some all of the money on-screen.
Start making those calls D. ….they`re still out there. Have, “Hooray For Hollywood” playing in the background.
See, that’s where they went wrong. You’re supposed to actually MAKE the movies, but then you keep inventing expenses so you never have to pay out anything. THAT makes it legal.
Thank you Buddy, your comment made my day. Most insightful remark I’ve seen here in a long time.
We have a winner.
Reading this, I wondered what actually was the difference between what these guys did verses the “traditional” means of funding movies, especially independent ones.
But, if the movies had made money, who would be complaining?
Big promises to get money for a risky investment in the entertainment biz is SOP.
And, if the flick fails, you’re SOL.
FADE IN-
INT. A MOTEL ROOM. DAY.
BERNIE CONGO is on his cellphone talking to a prospective INVESTOR, selling HARD.
BERNIE CONGO
(conspiratorially)
Mrs. Landers, it’s as sure a thing as STAR WARS. The original one, not the crappy sequel-prequel-schlock. (beat) Right! Seed money for a sure fire hit! Your investor ment of 100,000 dollars could make you a millionairesse in two years (much quieter) if all things go as expected. (beat) You can transfer it into our film fund immediately. Great! I’ll email you a contract and you can sign it electronically. Good as gold! Yes, your name will be into the titles as “co-executive producer”… (jokingly) unless you prefer “Continuity Girl”! (chuckles) Excellent! You are one smart lady! Call me anytime. Yes, the title will be “BIG MONEY”! How can it lose? Everybody loves money, right! Good night, dear!
Bernie Congo hangs up and falls back onto the motel bed, LAUGHING.
BERNIE CONGO (CON’T)
Cha-frikkin;-ching!
Get Shorty covered all this w/style
There was already a movie called “Boiler Room”
FYI: As a rule of thumb ROI’s for equity investors are 25%. So why would anyone be stupid enough to think you could get 1,000% ROI?
because NOBODY has learned from the Bernie Madoff Scandal…. Because GREED makes people stupid
Good reference with the boiler room! IT was a movie and far from real. These boiler rooms destroy the integrity of a good call to get business. This type of stuff should be shut down because its hurts everyone! We have security issues now = cant trust our local movie studio – gimme a break! (this is a scam of massive proportions = bottom line
lol ROI is 25%. That’s conservative. ROI is relative to risk and timing. A week ago, I saw a ROI of 187% in 3 or 4 days on one equity investment.
Maybe the sequel should be called “Eye’s An Idiot”.
I worked on Beneath the Blue and Eye of the Dolphin and the guy the FBI convicted is not a crook, he put all the money into the movies. they have name actors and were real productions. He is not living the hi-life like others who were convicted. I think some had Malibu homes keeping most of the money. He lives in a small apartment and really wants to make a good movie that will make money.
There is a difference between the guys getting (and skimming) the money and the people on the crew who ACTUALLY MAKE the movies. Those are the little people, who are just trying to make their vision. The people who were ripping investors off certainly were NOT the people actually making the film.
For the record, I once worked on a film in which the scumbag execs skimmed 2/3rds of the money earmarked for the movie to their own pockets. It wasn’t the filmmaker’s fault that they had to make a movie with a third of the money they were promised.
The filmmakers themselves are VICTIMS as well, since their projects were tainted by events that happened far ABOVE their sphere of influence.