
As if Conan the Barbarian didn’t have a rough enough weekend finishing in fourth place with a $10.5 million gross for Lionsgate and Millennium (see Autopsy Report: LG’s Conan the Barbarian), the rights holders at Paradox Entertainment awoke to read a report that Stan Lee Media Inc is suing to recapture the rights to the Robert E. Howard-created character, reportedly based on the notion that a transfer of rights from the bankrupt company to Conan Properties constituted fraud and a breach of fiduciary duties. Paradox bought the rights from Conan Properties and owns all 800 stories and poems that Howard created. While Paradox has not been served with the suit, Paradox general counsel Fred Fierst gave the company’s position to Deadline. In a nutshell, they feel the beef has nothing to with them.
“We have not yet been served with a copy of the Stan Lee Media lawsuit so it is certainly premature to comment in detail,” Fierst wrote me. “We did however manage to review a copy of the complaint online. Frankly it was the first anyone connected with Paradox Entertainment, Inc., or its parent company Paradox Entertainment AB (collectively “Paradox”), had ever heard of the dispute between Stan Lee Media and the other defendants which it seems has been going on for ten or more years. Suffice to say that Paradox had nothing to do with Stan Lee Media and when Paradox acquired the stock of Conan Sales Co, LLC. and thereby the ownership of the Conan intellectual property over a series of transactions in 2002 and 2003 it did so for fair market value, paid in cash, and in reliance on the 2002 Federal Bankruptcy Court Order approving the return of that stock, and therefore the Conan intellectual property, from SLM to CSC. Since acquiring the Conan intellectual property Paradox has spent many hundreds of thousands of dollars perfecting its worldwide trademark and copyright registration program, and we stand firmly behind our chain of title.
“Our litigation counsel will respond to the complaint, once we are served. At this time we believe that the allegations against Paradox and its CEO are frivolous, and will most likely be dismissed on statute of limitations, and other, grounds. In the interim we don’t think it would serve any purpose for us to comment further at this time.”


Definitely a Paradox here. The movie made no money, it bombed. What is there to gain? Is Stan Lee Media going to pay off the debt of the film?
Who cares…the battle is already lost…only the dead bodies remain to be counted and the generals chosen to take the fall for the losses.
Whoa, nice quote
Ponder this on the tree of whoa.
“Tree of Whoa”?
I’m assuming that was planted by Keanu Reeves.
Oooh, Keanu the Barbarian, anyone? Now that’d be an interesting casting choice.
He grips the broadsward in his hand, marveling at its heft and weight.
CONAN
Whoa.
Joey Lawrence, actually.
Don’t forget the important detail that Howard created these stories while the “real” Conan held an axe over his head — meaning there has been a cloud over the Conan legacy from Day One.
Of course, we should probably keep in mind that said “important detail” never actually happened. Milius just made it up for the “Making of Conan” extra on the dvd.
The only area of controversy regarding the Conan rights was the ownership of Red Sonja, and that was resolved years ago.I have no idea where the hell Stan Lee Media ((which is NOT part of Marvel and had NOTHING to do with the Conan comics) thinks it has any kind of claim here.
Since 2007, Stan Lee Media (which no longer even has a Stan Lee in it) has been engaging in a range of lawsuits making over-reaching claims of IP ownership, the most ludicrous being a claim of ownership stake in characters that Lee created while on-staff with Narvel.
They keep buying tickets in the Lawsuit Lottery.
stan lee media can not seem to accept cerain realities like not having a claim to any of stan lees marvel characters sine stan himself does not own the rights they are work for hire and now claiming Parodox stole the rights to conan from them when odds are they bought the rights from howards own estate during stan lee media bankrupty. and so stan lee media contintues to prove to be nothing but a ligitous shell. instead of a normal company wanting rights it never owned in the first place.
I’m confused as to how ANYONE can claim to hold the copyright to Conan… US copyright law stipulates that copyright extends for 70 years after the death of the original writer, which in this case is 1936(+70=2006). Conan was written at a time when the laws changed and were altered several times, but it’s very unclear if the copyrights were ever renewed, but if they weren’t, 2006 is essentially the latest date that could be claimed that Paradox owns ANYTHING. They could pretend they hold the Trademark on the word “Conan” but given that it’s a common name, I have a hard time believing it would hold up in court. This judge could best do us all a favor and break Paradox’s claims AND simultaneously dismiss Stan Lee Media’s claim to any such, and declare this property what it is: In the Public Domain, just like The Invisible Man or War of the Worlds.
http://copyright.cornell.edu/resources/publicdomain.cfm
I agree with your sentiment about intellectual property rights; I think that they last too long and discourage creative innovation. But I think the Conan properties are still protected. Paradox successfully settled two lawsuits in 2009 and 2010 over the Conan rights involving published stories that were thought to be in the public domain. Paradox granted retroactive license to the publishers involved (one in the UK and one in the US) and received royalties from the publications. And, of course, Paradox granted license in the case of the most recent film. As for this latest litigation, I think it is a case of persistent frivolous lawsuits on the part of SLM Inc. Maybe if they keep trying eventually a judge will actually hear a case, and the very fact that a case goes to court will strengthen their otherwise weak claims.