Diane Haithman is contributing to Deadline’s coverage of TCA.
Because they are introducing a show about men into the traditionally female-skewing ABC primetime lineup, the producers and performers of Man Up! were called upon to spend much of their time addressing reporters at TCA today about what it means — or doesn’t mean — to be a man in America in 2011. The show stars Christopher Moynihan (also the creator and one of the executive producers), Mather Zickel and Dan Fogler (Tony winner for his role in The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee) as three confused guys in their late 30s who would love to grow up if they could only figure out how.
One reporter went so far as to ask that, in a new season that includes many of what the network has been calling “female empowerment” shows, if Man Up! might actually be a show about male emasculation. Fogler thinks not. “[It] reflects what’s going on with people right now in society,” he said. “I feel very close to my character, Kenny — I have a lot of friends out there who will watch … that’s me up there, man … I think they’ll dig it. I don’t think the show is about men being emasculated; [it’s about men] finding themselves.” Moynihan joked that the three, being actors, “are soft guys already … face it, I have a lot of product in my hair.” On a more serious note, he called current thirtysomethings “the generation that has not been made to do anything” and has had the luxury of a volunteer army rather than having to “man up” and face the draft.
Cast member Teri Polo cited Susan Faludi’s book Backlash: The Undeclared War Against American Women as having a lot to say about today’s confusion of gender roles. “Our generation of men aren’t quite sure. Should I mow the lawn, honey? Should I not mow the lawn? What do you want me to do?” she said. Producer Victor Fresco, at age 53 somewhat older than the characters in the show, pointed out that TV men have been searching for what it means to be a man since The Honeymooners. Still, he acknowledged that today’s technological society has changed the concept of work for both men and women. “Life hasn’t gotten easier, it’s just gotten different … something’s gone wrong,” he said.
After the session, Moynihan and Fresco were asked whether the recent cancellation of AMC’s critically acclaimed but low-rated Men of a Certain Age might represent a bad omen for “man” shows. Although he acknowledged that there might be “something in the ether” about examining men’s issues right now, Moynihan thinks his new show stands on different turf. “Those characters are 10 years older — they have more serious problems,” he said.
Fresco pointed out that CBS has had a big success with male-skewing shows, proving that the male audience is in fact out there. “I don’t think there’s any trend,” he said. “[Men of a Certain Age] was a great show; the cancellation was probably a matter of economics.”


Men of A Certain Age was on TNT not AMC
does anyone proof or copy-edit these posts? men of a certain age wasn’t on AMC…
Best thing about MAN UP is it’s not WORK IT.
The cancellation was due to low ratings. It was sampled and eroded. The same will happen with “Man Up!” which doesn’t have as strong a cast and is last to the party. There have been other, better pilots with this same theme including one with a matching title, right down to the exclamation point. “Two & a Half Men” offered more insight into the male psyche. Then again, so did “Home Alone.” They should have made “In the Company of Men” into a series, not this “Revenge of the Nerds” set in suburbia. The critics weren’t impressed.
Classic case of why Hollywood is such an inefficient town. Dumb idiot agent assistant just fully agreeing and passing on his boss’s opinion without thinking for himself. Anyone else remember that Good Will Hunting scene in the bar where the ponytailed Harvard d-bag tries to use Gordon Wood’s opinion as his own?
I find it disgusting that Moynihan has used the horrible losses of our fighting men and women and the current public exposure of a volunteer army maimed and murdered overseas to pitch a pathetic TV show about the wimp that he is.
Yeah, that was his intent. Moron.
Here here, Ed! This and Tim Allen’s show won’t probably last even a month and then we’ll have the pleasure of another hour of Dancing with the Stars to eat up ABC’s schedule. Yippee!
This show sounds absolutely abominable. I can’t believe they think even for a second that any men AT ALL will watch this anti-male piece of crap.
It’s not anti-male. Just anti-funny.
Even if this show winds up being good fun I cannot get over how lame the title is, a la Cougartown which I finally caught up with and have enjoyed. The explanation makes me want to skip this show altogether, and I usually do watch all the new pilots when they air.
Moynihan is an idiot for his volunteer army comparison or that the draft was in any way masculine (I could give a list of notable people who had deferments). The people who ‘manned up’ and did it either believed in what they were doing or had no choice based on class, which even in a volunteer army has not changed much who is in at all (except that now there are women). This whole post-modern take on thirtysomethings with gender roles seems offensive to thirtysomethings and I am not even a thirtysomething. How about you just say, masculine is Don Draper and is there man on TV that is anything like Don Draper? As said before, thank goodness there are actually better insights and themes that come out of television that are better than what this appears to be.
Yeah, should I watch this show, honey? Do you not want me to watch this show, honey? Teri Polo, the best thing you ever did was pose naked in Playboy. This show sounds stupid. Maybe now men will see that we have become a laughing stock. F this show.
The League on FX deals with the “issues of childish 30something men” and already has 2 seasons and is hilarious.
I saw the pilot episode of Man Up at a friend’s house and it was 10 times more funny than any of the comments above.